Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
YouMeandtheSpew · 13/09/2021 21:16

OP just out of interest what are the school’s admissions criteria? Where does church attendance/faith come in the priority list?

Zolrets · 13/09/2021 21:12

Humanists can set up schools in areas where there is no secular school available

They wouldn’t, for the reasons they state, plus why should they? There is, as a pp, explained, no such thing as a ‘secular school’ as by definition, it would be illegal to not perform an act of daily worship. The fact is, ‘set up your own school’ is a crazy, inefficient and divisive solution that is no solution at all. Also secular isn’t interchangeable with humanist, secular means not having any connection with religion.
It’s also not interchangeable with atheist either.

Againstmachine · 13/09/2021 21:09

Why not?
No child should be indoctrinated into a religion, if that happens at home it's out of people's control.

But schools should not facilitate such things.

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 21:03

But no child should go to a faith school

Why not?

Namenic · 13/09/2021 20:58

Humanists can set up schools in areas where there is no secular school available.

Zolrets · 13/09/2021 20:53

I think lots of people on Mumsnet live in urban areas where there are lots of schools in a reasonable distance. Where I am is more rural with very few schools so when an oversubscribed community school is taken over by a religious academy chain and reserves 30% of places for those of their faith, surely there is problem to be seen? No? It’s a reduction of choice. And yes, the GP analogy is spot on and the history similar to the foundation of schools.

And to whoever claimed there are humanist schools - no there are not. Not in the Uk. The humanist society says the reason is this ‘Because Humanists UK campaigns positively for integrated inclusive schools for children of all faiths and none. It would be no less ethically unsound and socially divisive to set up overtly humanist schools in a pluralistic society than it is to set up religious schools’

StripeyDeckchair · 13/09/2021 20:49

I don't think that the state should fund faith schools. Its outrageous that a priest, not an education professional, gets a say in whether a child goes to a school or not.

Have we learned nothing from the wars and conflicts around the world in the name of religion?
Education should be religion free, if your religion is that important then send your children for religious education after school/at the weekend.

Namenic · 13/09/2021 20:34

Jay smith and Errol - would Sunday assembly style stuff count in the worship assembly category? That would indeed be unfair if secularists and humanist couldn’t set up their own academies as state schools.

Againstmachine · 13/09/2021 20:27

Faith schools shouldn't exist in my opinion, obviously it's not a matter of dismantling them over night. But no child should go to a faith school.

Graunaile2017 · 13/09/2021 20:22

Maybe some facts to go with some of the anecdotes

Faith schools - RC and C of E , don't get extra money from the Church.
Also they will happily take children of different faiths or no faith, if there is room, and they must give a priority to and SEND kids.

Catholic schools serve more diverse and disadvantaged communities reflecting the multicultural nature of Catholics in England, many of whom come from the new and old migrant communities.
18.8% of pupils at Catholic primary schools live in the most deprived areas compared with 13.5% nationally. 16.5% of pupils at Catholic secondary schools live in the most deprived areas compared with 11.3% nationally.

40% of pupils in Catholic primary schools are from ethnic minority backgrounds compared with 32% nationally.

www.catholiceducation.org.uk/about-us/faqs

Brainwave89 · 13/09/2021 20:14

Faith schools often owe their success to the support of people of faith and the strong ethos built over many years. It is quite possible to develop and seek funding for a humanist school, indeed there are I believe one or two. Faith schools often welcome people of different faiths or none, but I see nothing wrong with them giving priority to people who will share their ethos.

storminborehamwood · 13/09/2021 20:06

@mustlovegin

How do you explain that to a 4 year old?

There are many tough facts that you will need to explain during his lifetime, this is no different

'Sorry, love, I know I tell you that we live in a country where we try to treat people fairly, but that doesn't apply to getting into school.'

It might be true, but it doesn't make it right.

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 20:02

How do you explain that to a 4 year old?

There are many tough facts that you will need to explain during his lifetime, this is no different

storminborehamwood · 13/09/2021 19:49

Some strong views on this, then!

The comparison with a faith NHS GP is an interesting one. It got me thinking about faith public transport, too!

For those asking, I think it's unfair that my son can't go to our closest primary like his friend next door because it is CofE and we're not. How do you explain that to a 4 year old?

The fact it is a higher performing school makes it feel worse, but that's our problem, not his.

I would be genuinely interested to see what would happen if the law changed. Would state faith schools go private? I think it's more likely they would incorporate faith-based teaching into before and after school activities, paid for as an extra, which I'd be fine with.

I don't live in Borehamwood btw.

OP posts:
Bucanarab · 13/09/2021 19:12

To misquote Superintendent Chamlers

"A prayer! A prayer in a public school! God has no place within these walls, just like facts have no place in organised religion!"

AlexaShutUp · 13/09/2021 18:59

@Poppitt58

It’s grammar schools that screw up the school system in my local area. Kids should just get the nearest school to their house. No application. Just the nearest one.
Yep, I would get rid of grammar schools too. And single sex schools for that matter. I would like all state education to be truly comprehensive.
AlexaShutUp · 13/09/2021 18:57

@mustlovegin

Even if all faith schools were privately funded, people would still argue that they if they were not admitted because they did not belong to that religion, it was discrimination Hmm
Nonsense. I couldn't give a toss if people want to send their children to fee paying religious schools. I have zero interest in sending my child to a faith school, so why would I choose to pay for it.

The problem is that religious families have more state funded options open to them than non religious families. How is that fair?

If we are going to continue to allow faith schools to discriminate, then I would like to see non-faith schools prioritising children from families which are not religious. However, that would result in fury in our area, as the religious parents typically pick the outstanding non-religious schools as their first choices while assuming that they have a god-given right to the faith schools as a reasonably acceptable back-up plan. As tax payer, I want my child to have the same rights within the state education system as any other child in my area. If I have to pay more tax in order to compensate for the paltry contribution that is actually made by the Church to our local faith school, then so be it.

Ionlydomassiveones · 13/09/2021 18:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Poppitt58 · 13/09/2021 18:13

It’s grammar schools that screw up the school system in my local area. Kids should just get the nearest school to their house. No application. Just the nearest one.

woodhill · 13/09/2021 18:10

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@Travielkapelka indeed, op seems to be from Borehamwood where the religious schools she is referring to are Jewish. There are two state secondary schools, one Jewish, one not. The Jewish school was set up by the Jewish community and over the last couple of decades many Jewish families moved to Borehamwood so their child could go there. The Jewish school has some of the best academics in the country and a more middle class student body than the non-denominational school. But that is really pretty much entirely because it is a Jewish school (otherwise no reason to think it would be any different from the non-denominational state school).

I think what concerns me about these types of threads is that there is lack of tolerance to people who are different from you. In op's case, its jewish people. In other cases it might be catholics or other christian groups.

There are plenty school places in Borehamwood but in schools not as academic or middle class as the jewish school. So many in Borehamwood and elsewhere are angry at the local jewish community having better schools. But the schools would be just the same as the non-denominational school that op could easily send her child to if it wasn't a Jewish school. So you can't have the education offered by a Jewish school by saying it should be abolished It doesn't make sense.

I think its great in the UK that we are tolerant and open minded enough to provide partially state funded religious schools (which as I said must keep to certain standards and teach certain secular matters). These schools serve our diverse communities. If there aren't enough school places, of course there should be more. But that's not an argument to abolish good schools which serve a community that you happen to not be part of.

Its nothing like a GPs surgery. Also noone is being denied entry because of religion but children of a particular religion can be given priority for a school of that religion. Which entirely makes sense! If religious state schools are undersubscribed, they must let anyone in and many do.

I have family in Borehamwood and they have faced some hostility from non jewish neighbours accusing them of putting up house prices, having shops that they (the neighbours) don't want to shop in, having their own schools funded by the taxpayer (apparently Jews taxes don't count) and having everything "their way". Its can be frightening to Jewish people as this low level anti-semitism can lead to worse behaviour as we all know.[/quote]
Imagine saying that about a different religionConfused

Sounds awful for the Jewish people there

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 17:57

I don't want to send my children to a religious school but it has a knock on effect. I have already explained that because my two closest schools wouldn't take my kids, I have to look further afield and then the good secular schools wouldn't take my kids either because we're further away.. so I get stuck with a terrible religious school (religious parents often avoiding it in favour of the ones close to my house) or a secular school a long way away. And that's not even as bad as @Rannva's situation.

I also - even though it wouldn't have been my first preference - do understand and think it's reasonable to want to send your kids to a school that is very close by even if it's religious and you're not. Especially for working parents, that can be really useful. All I think is that everyone should get the same level of choice or religions can at least pay for their own schools

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 17:49

13% of the population regularly worship, 37% of primaries are faith schools. So more non religious tax payers funding religious schools

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 17:42

And I agree with PP that a lot of taxpayers are religious anyway

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 17:41

Rannva I understand your situation if there is no other option where you live. But often people have two or more options and they still choose the religious school as it's better but don't want to bother with religion, or despise said religion, mock it, etc. I've seen countless threads on MN, it's disgusting

Rannva · 13/09/2021 17:37

@mustlovegin

This topic has been done to death OP. You seem to want to send your DC to a faith school and benefit from all the advantages but not bother with them adopting that religion? That's taking the P**S, surely
They're taxpayer funded.

In a town of 22 schools my 'heathen' children are only allowed to appy to one - how is that fair?