Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
Ozanj · 14/09/2021 09:11

@BubbleCoffee

It’s grammar schools that screw up the school system in my local area. Kids should just get the nearest school to their house

That would just mean that the well-off families access the naice school in the leafy area where they live, and the less well off in the deprived area get the 'rough' school with low aspirations. With grammars, while the system isn't perfect, some of the brightest but poorest children will have the chance of a place, so there's actually more social mobility.

In true grammars yes. But most of them are private selective schools using the grammar name.
Ozanj · 14/09/2021 09:09

The local (outstanding) Hindu school is so oversubscribed with Hindus that they now require a letter from a priest saying the child and their family follow all Hindu traditions, speak an Indian language (excluding English), and follow a vegetarian diet at home. So it excludes most Hindus too.

Nc123 · 14/09/2021 08:55

@storminborehamwood

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

The point of faith schools is to educate children in that faith. What on earth would be the point of them taking people from outside the faith at the same or higher rate than believers? There would literally be no point. They are there primarily to serve the children of that faith, so those children will have priority.

Under certain circumstances it is permissible to specify religion, gender etc on a job advert. Provided you can demonstrate that it’s essential and why, it doesn’t count as discrimination.

Like previous posters I agree that your anger is misplaced. We need to work out why religious schools tend to do better and are therefore more sought after by non-believers.

BubbleCoffee · 14/09/2021 08:42

It’s grammar schools that screw up the school system in my local area. Kids should just get the nearest school to their house

That would just mean that the well-off families access the naice school in the leafy area where they live, and the less well off in the deprived area get the 'rough' school with low aspirations. With grammars, while the system isn't perfect, some of the brightest but poorest children will have the chance of a place, so there's actually more social mobility.

flippertyop · 14/09/2021 07:52

Non denominational is Christian but not specific to one of the denominations ie mixed Anglican and Catholic. Perhaps you should have looked into it more!!

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 07:29

Hitler was an atheist vegetarian, I recall the Russian revolution lot etc were athiests too.

Have we learned nothing from the wars and conflicts around the world in the name of religion?

LobsterNapkin · 14/09/2021 02:02

"Non denominational" turns out to be very denominational most of the time, with Christian prayers in the morning and everything about Christmas and Easter. Christians are the majority in this country so I'm not complaining but at the same time why on earth shouldn't my child be able to have the same experience - colouring in pics of his holidays and learning about his cultural traditions - just like yours do?

Almost always the term denomination means different types of Christianity, not different religions altogether. I think there is some fudging going on where it's presented as the latter.

The difficulty with religions with quite small numbers in one place is always going to be that you won't usually have enough people to run a school. I think it's a significant factor in why some families in that situation will choose to live in a larger city where there is more scope. I've been in the situation myself where the type of education I wanted for my kids simply wasn't available, so the options were finding the best available match or home education.

I t's not entirely dissimilar to other compromises made by living in a less populated area - worse emergency services, poor internet, fewer job options. All things we could say we should have equal access to, but practically we don't.

LobsterNapkin · 14/09/2021 01:28

There are basically two directions you can look at any rights question. There is the idea that parents have the right to apply to any school they like. Or the idea that parents have the right to have their children receive a certain kind of education in line with their values, be it a Catholic, Muslim, Humanist, or Steiner type school.

Schools like this don't function if the parents aren't largely bought in. The only real alternate is a one size fits all approach where the state decides what the lowest common denominator is in terms of values and epistemic assumptions. Because as much as people might like to think there is such a thing as neutral, secular education, there isn't. All education presupposes a certain way of thinking about the material and moral world.

It's easy enough to be happy with the state making the decision when you are more or less happy with what the state decides about these things, and say everyone else should be on board with it as well. When all of a sudden someone finds a conflict with their views, though, they tend to be very quick to feel that as parents they should have a greater degree of input in their children's education. Even if they are not rich and able to fund it privately.

FightingtheFoo · 14/09/2021 00:38

Sorry, my rhetorical question absolutely not directed at @CayrolBaaaskin but at the OP.

FightingtheFoo · 14/09/2021 00:38

@CayrolBaaaskin

Also just to be clear- my dds go to a religious school. I a progressive Jew and moved to a very specific area to ensure we were in catchment and that they could get the Jewish education I wanted. It’s something I want them educated on. It’s key for me that they learn about our religion that they learn Hebrew and that they celebrate our holidays and don’t grow up feeling weird or different.

I want that for other religions too. Of course I agree that there are basics that religious schools should comply with but there are standards in the Uk and inspections.

I think allowing people to practice and be educated in their own religions is just the basics of tolerance. I am absolutely supportive of it.

I did the same for my DC after sending them to what I thought was anon-denominational nursery where they spent all of a December learning about Christmas (with 1 afternoon on Divali and 1 on Hannukkah) and my DC came home asking if we were going to have ham for dinner. That was the end of that.

"Non denominational" turns out to be very denominational most of the time, with Christian prayers in the morning and everything about Christmas and Easter. Christians are the majority in this country so I'm not complaining but at the same time why on earth shouldn't my child be able to have the same experience - colouring in pics of his holidays and learning about his cultural traditions - just like yours do?

alexdgr8 · 14/09/2021 00:19

Autumn, i think going to a catholic church and finding that the priest is anti-abortion, would not be such a rare circumstance.

tilder · 13/09/2021 22:38

Given the schools are under subscribed, faith is not a condition for entry.

The RE lessons are a little skewed. 'we believe this'. Followed by lots on Christianity. Then the occasional 'some people think this'.

tilder · 13/09/2021 22:34

@flippertyop

But why would you want your child to go to a religious school when you are not religious ?
No choice. We live rurally.

Catchment school. 1.7 miles. CofE.
Next school. 5 miles. CofE.
Next.6 miles. Catholic.

The closest none religious school is more than 10 miles. Odds on getting into that school when its oversubscribed (it's in the local town) and all schools between us and it (rural schools) are undersubscribed? Zero.

knitnerd90 · 13/09/2021 22:30

Yes -- the villages where the only primary is a faith school are a bigger problem. Though in some of them, faith is less of a consideration for entry. One of DH's cousins was in that situation; they're not C of E, but they got in. And of course there's Northern Ireland too.

The USA is interesting because the point of keeping religion outside of school was partly to protect religion. The Catholics were afraid that if it were taught in school it would make people less likely to send to Catholic school. In return, Protestants who were prejudiced against Catholics passed laws to ban any state funding of religion. In practice, as you'd expect, the atmosphere varies quite a lot depending on place. In New York City, they get off for the major Jewish holidays, Eid, and Lunar New Year as well as Easter and Christmas.

In Canada several provinces have separate state-funded Catholic boards. (Ontario is notorious because they fund Catholics but no one else.) But the regular boards are truly secular.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/09/2021 22:20

@flippertyop

But why would you want your child to go to a religious school when you are not religious ?
If you live in a village and the village school happens to be an faith one, that's one very common reason. Tough luck on you if it's a popular oversubscribed one.
NeverDropYourMoonCup · 13/09/2021 22:17

Of course, once that extra funding from the churches goes and they stop being involved in education (or shift over to private as many grammar schools did at the start of the comprehensive system), there are all those venture capitalists and Toby Young to run the schools instead. Maybe. Education for profit. They might just close altogether instead, putting more pressure on the standard non religious schools instead.

AlexaShutUp · 13/09/2021 22:16

@flippertyop

But why would you want your child to go to a religious school when you are not religious ?
Several people have already answered this. 🙄
flippertyop · 13/09/2021 22:11

But why would you want your child to go to a religious school when you are not religious ?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 13/09/2021 22:07

Maybe they were just lucky, but my dd and SiL are not at all religious and didn’t pretend to be, but still got places for Gdcs at a highly regarded C of E primary. They were within the catchment area though.

Plumtree391 · 13/09/2021 21:59

@LemonFantaGin

My son goes to a 'state funded faith school' and he is of no religion, there are also many other religions, not related to the 'schools religion' they are one of the best schools in the area, and faith does not determine your place at the school, many people will not apply because of the attached faith.
Faith schools have been taking children with no faith background for a long time now.

I know people whose kids went to faith schools and were then awarded grammar school places. I've no idea why they are, on the whole, better than non faith.

My view is, as long as the children are happy.

storminborehamwood · 13/09/2021 21:58

@YouMeandtheSpew

OP just out of interest what are the school’s admissions criteria? Where does church attendance/faith come in the priority list?
Admission criteria, highest to lowest priority

1st Looked after children
2nd to 7th Attend CofE church :- ranked by frequency and sibling
8th to 11th Attend other Christian church
12th to 13th Practise other faith (non-Christian)
14th Proximity to school

We're 14th and places never get to 14th.

OP posts:
tilder · 13/09/2021 21:52

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

I'm imagining the reaction I'd get if I were somehow able to set up a faith NHS GP practice, built on land owned by a local religious group that also gave my practice a bit of extra funding on the side, say, for a monk to come in once a week and say prayers for the sick, but getting the majority of its funding from the state. By putting some extra prove-your-religion admin barriers in the way, I'd be filtering out not just people who have the wrong religion, but also people who find it more difficult to jump through admin hoops. Filtering out those patients might well mean my patients need fewer health services on average, so the patients I do accept will get a less-stretched service. This is totally justified, apparently, because some people want a GP service that will reinforce and conform to their religious beliefs — obviously, it's totally unreasonable to expect religious people to use a generic GP who provides services to everyone, and get their religious health-related concerns (prayers, religious guidance, rituals etc.) dealt with at their own community-funded religious institutions. Even if I'm the closest NHS GP practice to you, you might have to walk past my surgery to get to the one you're allowed to register at, the one that takes all the people who can't jump those hoops. Perhaps you'd prefer not to use my surgery anyway, because you'd rather not have a particular religious slant to your healthcare. But that doesn't mean that it's okay that you have to trudge past the nearby state-funded faith GP, with your dicky hip and your COPD, to get to the more distant, more stretched GP that a) will accept you and b) won't be pushing religion at you.
Love this.

Now sure how discriminating against children is seen as a religious thing to do but still.

YouMeandtheSpew · 13/09/2021 21:42

Sure, but I think there’s a massive distinction between a) a child being denied entry to their closest school whilst children from much further away get a place purely on the basis of faith, and b) schools using faith to differentiate between applications after admitting all children who are eligible based on SEND/children of staff/sibling attendance/distance from the school.

(Distance from the school is arguably an unfair criterion too, but that’s a whole other discussion).

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 13/09/2021 21:19

There are plenty of religious secularists, people who have a personal faith but who think that religion shouldn't come into public life except insofar as it informs individuals' opinions and actions (for example, everyone gets a vote, and is free to choose how to vote based on their religious opinions or otherwise, but churches don't get to have extra representatives over and above the representatives elected by popular vote).

Zolrets · 13/09/2021 21:19

As far as I’m concerned I object to the fact it is there at all, be it third, fifth or tenth. It is discrimination.