Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
ummymummy · 14/09/2021 21:01

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@NiceGerbil - hmm I suppose maybe I think she in borehamwood because her user name is @storminborehamwood.

What is your issue with these sects schools? Extremism in Muslim schools in Birmingham was something reported in media.[/quote]
A quick opportunity to paint Muslims in a bad light and use the "extremism" word eh? Several Jewish schools have also been investigated in the media incase you were oblivious

Also love how @NiceGerbil called you out on the random strange statement but you conveniently ignored Wink

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 21:00

@SunIsBehindGreySky

NiceGerbil

I think I can understand the way you look at the situation. You see a school, you see resources being wasted.

Others see the world though a different lens they start with for example God first, then family and work outward, their church and it's school are attached. Then they see people wanting to dismantle what's there rather than understand why it's there and leave it alone, as these schools do well.

That's not how I see it at all!

Can you say why you got to that conclusion.

The school is teaching children. That's what it's there for. In what way is that wasting resources?

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 20:58

I don't like faith schools in general because they are

Discriminatory and round here leave some families with nothing nearby even though there's loads of schools.

I do not believe that religious practice and school should be mixed as per Lisa Simpson Smile who put the argument well!

I do think it's divisive not to have children segregated due to religious belief of parents. Not going to school with other faiths reduces exposure and IME it's true that mixing and being friends with children who are not the same in whatever way is beneficial.

The entry criteria are often very strict round here which does end up being selective for families with certain set ups/ situations.

The ones that put siblings way down list are making life really difficult for some parents and the reason I suppose is to limit the siblings of the occasional child who gets in outside religious criteria. I think that's really poor.

Probably more!

However.

It's not changing anytime I will see as church land, buildings etc make it impossible.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 20:57

NiceGerbil

I think I can understand the way you look at the situation. You see a school, you see resources being wasted.

Others see the world though a different lens they start with for example God first, then family and work outward, their church and it's school are attached. Then they see people wanting to dismantle what's there rather than understand why it's there and leave it alone, as these schools do well.

EstherMumsnet · 14/09/2021 20:53

Just coming on to remind people to be civil to each other. Thanks, as you were!

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 20:49

My area is (and this is about primary for most and both for other points).

Very densely populated

Really lucky to live in an area where the vast majority of schools esp primary are good.

A very high proportion of faith schools of branches of Christian schools locally and branches of Christian and Jewish schools in wider area.

The faith schools in general DO tend to have the faith as a core part of the school ethos. Worship, learning about the religion and what is in the texts as a faith thing (IE on top of re learning about). Lighter or heavier sure. But a core thing. Teachers who are practicing are preferred if possible.

A history of illegal things happening with selection which was in the news a few years back - questions on forms that were not allowed, asking for donations etc.

Some schools being in the news for essentially ignoring national curriculum and teaching religion, girls and boys different things, that sort of stuff. This crops up over and over. I hope it's been addressed now.

From one sect opening their own school when mainstream education officer the years could not meet their practices (no computers, television, news etc). What happened to those children? That community used to be about the place they just... Vanished. How can those children possibly be getting an education in line with national curriculum? What are they being taught? Yes they are out of state system but... It bothers me. I was at school with children from that group to 6th form and I mean who knows? Maybe it's fine? Hope so.

The density of faith schools meaning that for those who are not the right faith/ have ticked the right boxes, it means a school that in this area will be bloody ages to get to when there are multiple schools in walking distance. And children being brought in from further away. I think that walking to school is brilliant. Reducing pollution is great. And this Criss crossing and time to go further is no good for pollution congestion the children etc etc. That's probably less of a big deal for others but it's a really good time to chat etc walking and exercise rather than going in back of car. Some use bus or tube obv but it just feels a silly way of organising things.

So that's where I'm coming from.

Silverswirl · 14/09/2021 20:42

@Just10moreminutesplease

I think it’s crazy that religious schools exist at all.

Who in their right mind would want children divided up by religion instead of learning together?

And yeah, I know plenty on none Christians apply for catholic and CofE schools. But they are still majority Christian and reinforce the idea that Christian is the ‘default’ (and I’m not sure there are very many none Muslim children at Islamic schools or none Jewish children at Jewish schools? Though happy to be corrected if I’m wrong).

Surely if your religion is so important you can just teach your children about it at home?

Because if you are Christian for example and worship at a cofe church, the teachings of Christ should be in your day to day life (and in the day to day school life) of a child. You would prefer your child to be taught by Christian teachers for example, to attend mass or Christian assembly every day. Say prayers 3 times a day at school. Have a Vicar regularly visit the school and a chapel room for your child to go to when they please if needed during the day. You would want god entwined into daily life, not just taught at home or on a Sunday at church!
Cutabove · 14/09/2021 20:35

@SunIsBehindGreySky

Objectors to faith schools also ignore the fact that faith schools are often good because of the faith aspect. DSs school was incredibly strict - lots of throes rules that MN bitch about - but it's one of the reason s it was so good. Take away the faith side and it's not going to be the same.

I am not politically right wing, I do like to listen to people and what the American republicans complaints are - that the Democrats have started to move to the Republican states because they don't actually like living with the reality of their ideology in action, they then try to change the republican states as if somehow things will be better this time, they seem to have zero respect for the fact that Republicans don't want them bringing a failed ideology (in their opinion and I can't blame them saying this as the democrats don't want to live in their Utopia themselves) and ruining the states Republicans are content with.

Which Qanon commentator told you that?
Cutabove · 14/09/2021 20:34

So sorry if this is not relevant or anything

That ship has wrong since failed.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 20:31

9 pages to read! Did a couple but don't have time for all sorry. Only came back because saw my name on threads I'm on.

So sorry if this is not relevant or anything.

Problems with this conversation when it comes to it as things so different in different areas, naturally all posters are talking of their local area / experiences/ friends experiences etc.

I know from loads of threads that the difference in things like over subscription, proportion of faith schools/ what faiths any faith schools are/ distances / results/ how religious the faith schools actually are/ strictness of entry criteria/ and amount of children getting first second etc choice or no place at all varies enormously.

So I think this will always be at cross purposes which doesn't help.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 20:18

Ok then stick with 50% Jewish.

Same point. Was their education inappropriate. Hmm.

Not caught up by the way since last posted massive thread.

Might have s try.

FortVictoria · 14/09/2021 19:10

@NiceGerbil

My school was maybe 50% Jewish and 30% Asian.

No problems at all.

This is conflating ethnicity with religion. They’re two completely separate things.
TooBigForMyBoots · 14/09/2021 18:56

You need to think of the word 'religion' in wider terms. Politics, gender issues, climate change, veganism and a host of other topics are being treated as 'religions' nowadays and people are being indoctrinated, yes

No I don't. I know what "religion" means @mustlovegin. It is a specific word. It doesn't mean "belief" in whatever.Hmm

flippertyop · 14/09/2021 18:47

storminborehamwood I haven't read the full thread, but I have contributed to many similar threads in the past. The short answer is yanbu.

There are people campaigning to change faith school admissions - see the Fair admissions Campaign here: fairadmissions.org.uk/.

Unlike some other groups, they don't campaign to abolish faith schools, but only to make it illegal for them to use faith-based admissions criteria.

What??? The whole point of a faith school is to help indoctrinate into the faith. How on earth can you ever have faith schools with non faith based admissions criteria - what on earth would be the point

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 17:57

Objectors to faith schools also ignore the fact that faith schools are often good because of the faith aspect. DSs school was incredibly strict - lots of throes rules that MN bitch about - but it's one of the reason s it was so good. Take away the faith side and it's not going to be the same.

I am not politically right wing, I do like to listen to people and what the American republicans complaints are - that the Democrats have started to move to the Republican states because they don't actually like living with the reality of their ideology in action, they then try to change the republican states as if somehow things will be better this time, they seem to have zero respect for the fact that Republicans don't want them bringing a failed ideology (in their opinion and I can't blame them saying this as the democrats don't want to live in their Utopia themselves) and ruining the states Republicans are content with.

woodhill · 14/09/2021 17:43

@AnneElliott

I don't disagree with faith schools (DS went to an RC primary). I do see the issue for families who are not religious but either want to get their kids into local food schools and can't, or are frustrated that there are fewer non religious schools to send their DC to.

I don't understand however while faith schools are such an issue for MN when selection by wealth - either by paying for private education or buying an expensive house in a very tiny catchment is seen as more acceptable? Faith schools are much more accessible than either of those.

And the one DS went to was much more racially diverse and had more SEN than local non faith schools.

The churches own the building and land his primary is on and therefore buying them off the church is going to be a problem. MN posters often ignore the fact that faith schools existed well before secular schools as they were charities to educate the poor who couldn't afford to pay to educate their children.

Objectors to faith schools also ignore the fact that faith schools are often good because of the faith aspect. DSs school was incredibly strict - lots of throes rules that MN bitch about - but it's one of the reason s it was so good. Take away the faith side and it's not going to be the same.

Well said and this is the tradition of the UK
SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 17:09

I never heard of transhumanism until someone linked to shouty Alex, he mentioned it during a rant about someone called Yaniv wanting their Johnson touched to wax their balls in Canada, other than that I have not watched him.

The Economist journalist Helen Joyce has a book discussing one of the individuals in IT pushing it all, fascinating stuff.

www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-9988677/Amazon-brings-palm-swiping-technology-concert-venue.html

BrassyLocks · 14/09/2021 16:59

@Deletesystem33
You seem to think things like veganism and "climate change" count as religion and that people worship some random headteacher in the same way people worship a god. You're just making it up as you go along.

You're the one making things up. I never said anything about veganism or climate change or headteachers, lol.

Cutabove · 14/09/2021 16:17

@mustlovegin

You make as little sense on that thread as you do on this one

She is hinting at the issues rather than being explicit. Try and pay attention and it's very clear.

I had not seen everything written together like this, and it's quite shocking actually

I am paying attention, it's clear as mud. And irrelevant to the thread.
Cutabove · 14/09/2021 16:16

@SunIsBehindGreySky

Your posts certainly show you may think you are a cut above others, and if you don't understand then it's everyone else's fault entirely, not your fault in any way, insult and put others down tactics. Grin

Cutabove

Wait, so do I not understand because I'm arrogant, or because I don't want to?

And jts a bit rich for you to accuse others of being insulting.

mustlovegin · 14/09/2021 16:12

Unlike some other groups, they don't campaign to abolish faith schools, but only to make it illegal for them to use faith-based admissions criteria

On what basis? More encroaching then? Going by a lot of these threads on MN (not seen so much of this IRL), many who are non-religious but get admitted tend to be intolerant, mock religion and treat it as a nuisance. It will never work out.

Religious groups can 'campaign' too, you know?

AnneElliott · 14/09/2021 16:10

I don't disagree with faith schools (DS went to an RC primary). I do see the issue for families who are not religious but either want to get their kids into local food schools and can't, or are frustrated that there are fewer non religious schools to send their DC to.

I don't understand however while faith schools are such an issue for MN when selection by wealth - either by paying for private education or buying an expensive house in a very tiny catchment is seen as more acceptable? Faith schools are much more accessible than either of those.

And the one DS went to was much more racially diverse and had more SEN than local non faith schools.

The churches own the building and land his primary is on and therefore buying them off the church is going to be a problem. MN posters often ignore the fact that faith schools existed well before secular schools as they were charities to educate the poor who couldn't afford to pay to educate their children.

Objectors to faith schools also ignore the fact that faith schools are often good because of the faith aspect. DSs school was incredibly strict - lots of throes rules that MN bitch about - but it's one of the reason s it was so good. Take away the faith side and it's not going to be the same.

mustlovegin · 14/09/2021 16:06

You make as little sense on that thread as you do on this one

She is hinting at the issues rather than being explicit. Try and pay attention and it's very clear.

I had not seen everything written together like this, and it's quite shocking actually

myndabit · 14/09/2021 15:56

@storminborehamwood I haven't read the full thread, but I have contributed to many similar threads in the past. The short answer is yanbu.

There are people campaigning to change faith school admissions - see the Fair admissions Campaign here: fairadmissions.org.uk/.

Unlike some other groups, they don't campaign to abolish faith schools, but only to make it illegal for them to use faith-based admissions criteria.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 15:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.