Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 22:59

I would be guessing they didn't when my friends were at secondary they also only got rhythm method as contraception and a v strong anti abortion message.

I would imagine it hasn't changed but I imagine depends massively on the school? And maybe the make up of children in terms of background.

Againstmachine · 14/09/2021 22:57

Ok they tend to be vile nasty kids who the world owes them something.

And yeah your language in public reflects on you.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 22:56

Are there any RC branches (probably wouldn't be allowed to call themselves RC) that kept the original ways?.

Yes, they are annoyed because that's where all the young people go with big families and smart dress, it's growing apparently where as the 1960/70s version is dying mostly attendance is old people. I have seem people attend the English mass in their PJs and jeans.

Though when I heard that Jacob Rhys Mogg was that type of Catholic it put me off.

Mlhactive · 14/09/2021 22:55

Do Catholic schools still refuse to teach about same sex relationships and contraception in sex ed or has that changed?

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 22:55

Your point is that based on two schools near you, you believe that children who go to faith schools are not nice kids?

Sorry I can't work the last bit out cos of typo.

I went to an RC primary and a school which didn't have any religion or prayers or Christian ethos (like many even though daily worship is the law).

I swear like a trooper.

What is the reason for by bad language in terms of religion in my education?

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 14/09/2021 22:52

Couldn't agree more OP. I'm an atheist but brought up Catholic. Went to Catholic schools. Live in a northern city that is VERY heavily dominated by faith schools- there are very few non-denominational state schools here both at primary and senior level.

I have three children and their "choice" of senior school will basically come down to whichever of the crappiest local schools is undersubscribed when they go. It blows my mind how my children will be bottom of any admission criteria within the city simply because I'm letting them get to an age where they either choose their faith or none rather than indoctrinate them into one or pretend to have a faith simply to be further up the admissions criteria.

How it's legal to discriminate against those who have no faith is crazy- that said I think having religious schools of any kind shouldn't be allowed. Religion should be taught from a more objective stance or as part of phase/ history/ politics/ law when relevant rather than to validate one particular doctrine. Further knowledge of a child's religion should come from family/ their place of worship...

Againstmachine · 14/09/2021 22:51

Against that's 2 schools! I don't understand what your observation adds to the conversation?

That faith schools don't out nice kids

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 22:48

In the end the change around missions and adapting to local cultures etc was very successful though wasn't it.

Are there any RC branches (probably wouldn't be allowed to call themselves RC) that kept the original ways?

In the end I'm by nature I think just not spiritual as it were.
My view on the RC church is one thing. I have loads of RC friends and was raised that way. I don't see differences in belief between individuals in terms of which religion should be a barrier. I mean in terms of different views on the actions/ line of the organisation. If very different views on key matters then you're unlikely to be friends in the first place.

I suppose in the end I think people understand/ are more comfortable with things that are different to them more if they have had exposure to them.

DD school has a wide variety of different faiths and the friendship groups mix all around. And so it becomes people, individuals rather than the unknown.

Just my view.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 22:45

www.reuters.com/world/europe/pope-francis-renews-curbs-latin-mass-rebuff-conservatives-2021-07-16/

So I probably never attended the type of mass my grandparents did, my parents can not remember if I was baptized in English or Latin.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 22:41

I have never been to an extraordinary mass, apparently I am too late, the Pope has cancelled it.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 22:40

Bizarrely I've been to CofE 'high church' services and there were looking bits in Latin, loads of regalia, formality. Swinging smoke things (sorry don't know name).

Asked a few people my mum said oh they're more Catholic than the Catholics!
If you felt that was a part of your worship then maybe that would be worth attending a service although obv many many differences so sorry if that suggestion is not one I should have made.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 22:36

I didn't know about nuns and standard clothing. My guess (but may be wrong) is that differs around the world. Dunno.

Last time I saw a nun was when I was walking home from work and tripped and really hurt my knees- massive scrapes blood etc. Someone put a hand out to help me up and it was a nun in habit. Hauled me up I was surprised how strong she was! That was 2006 (remember as week before my wedding!).

She would have been from my old school I imagine- the convent has gone now I imagine most/all no longer with us.

So you can't spot a nun. Well I never.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 22:30

NiceGerbil

I am slowly trying to understand myself.

I have asked older people they say they can't remember, from what I can make out it was started with implementation in the early 1970s, they changes the old rite and Latin was replaced with English, the priest turned to the congregation and they left the alter at the back, communion in the hand was what we were taught and they brought in a wood alter as Luther wanted.

It was a mistake or a coincidence that society changed and a falling away happened at the same time, they achieved the opposite of what they planned.

You would have been taught in Junior school by nuns the way you were, now what nuns there are left wear standard clothing.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 22:20

Against that's 2 schools! I don't understand what your observation adds to the conversation?

Maryjane3227 · 14/09/2021 22:19

Faith schools aren't always better. I worked in one that went into special measures and got shut down.
Not all families who send their kids to faith schools follow the faith in reality, a lot of lies. It's all a bit farcical. Buying into an illusion, on both sides.
I train teachers now and some of the lamest, laziest trainees I tried to help ended up securing jobs at faith schools. Possibly because they too Know how to put on an act. A posh voice helps too.

If we are ever to strive for integration and equality, faith schools need to go. There's something very disturbing to me about parents forcing religion onto their children.
I actually believe religious affiliation should be something a child chooses at 18 or over.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 22:19

Thank you that's really interesting.

My read is essentially that they wanted to expand the congregation globally and to achieve that they moved away from language and ritual that might be seen as intimidating/ confusing / unwelcoming (in modern parlance not 'accessible') and softened their stance on some major areas.

Is that right?

Againstmachine · 14/09/2021 22:15

It's interesting to note that the Catholic school near me are the most foul mouthed disgusting kids as opposed to the state school which seems very well behaved.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 22:11

NiceGerbil

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Vatican_Council

You can use this as a starting point.

My understanding is that it went "live" in various countries and places at different times and in incremental steps. Some say it basically turned the RC church into what Matin Luther wanted all along.

I have always believed, though I have doubts every so often for a few days and always return, I had the unusual situation of the only athiest parent around in childhood, refused to attend my First holy communion etc, spent time doing impressions of people in church and laughing at everyone for believing etc.

I totally get it some people just don't believe and some just do.

KihoBebiluPute · 14/09/2021 22:02

Yabu.

Church schools existed long before the state decided to provide universal education. The government negotiated with the church in good faith to incorporate existing church schools into the new state education system, with that negotiation including the agreement that church schools could select on faith grounds.

Parents have the responsibility to ensure their child receives an education, they don't have to use any specific school, a variety of school types exist which have a variety of levels of popularity in relation to places available. Schools with religious entry criteria are often very popular because they have better overall results than other schools, but they are also popular because some parents particularly want their children educated in an environment that upholds the values of their faith. We have freedom of religion and that is ok.

The problem isn't the criteria. The problem is that there are insufficient places at good schools, and insufficient good schools that aren't religious in character. You can't fix the problem by changing the character of the good schools by stopping them from doing what they do.

You are advocating reneging on a contract, effectively stripping the church of their legitimate assets to coopt them for secular education, depriving religious parents of their right to educate their children in line with their religion, instead of requiring the state to provide sufficient places at secular schools that are of equivalent quality to the religious schools. That's the wrong solution, based on a misunderstanding of the problem.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 21:34

I never believed even when little. I do think there's an element of some people having an inside thing towards spirituality for want of a better word. Many raised with no religion seek out a belief system that meets their needs in terms of things like values, level of formality, their feeling there is something else unknowable, community and so on.

And others just don't have that.

Have had some really interesting conversations with friends about it! Friendly but totally unable to even imagine feeling like the other one!

This is a massive diversion though sorry.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 21:29

What sort of year?

Trying to remember. I went to an RC primary as did most of my friends. Mine had nuns and there was 1 hour religious assembly every morning. Also had to be silent in lunch room. Didn't go to secondary RC but loads of friends did.

What were the changes and when-ish? Really interested. Trying to remember how many friends parents were adherents rather than practicing.

I'm nearly 50.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 21:18

RC schools are mainly full of children of those who are culturally RC iyswim.

I think most people are like that now. I remember a time when it was different. I don't know if times just changed, some say it was Vatican II. It all started changing as I was a child. Then the fist institutions the scouts and RC church started to be exposed, that out many of us off, then it was followed by the BBC, NHS and just about every institution going. Then some things happened, I never left God, I left the church and have returned, I know it's dying, I know I am unpopular to take this turn when others move further away and get annoyed at us for not joining them and sharing their beliefs.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 21:11

Round here due to the situation with locality most schools are faith etc. It's not about being devout/ faithful to the religion etc for the vast majority.

RC schools are mainly full of children of those who are culturally RC iyswim. All the schools are good it's about how can I get my child into one that won't screw my commute by sending me off in the wrong direction every morning at rush hour. That my parents can get to without masses of grief.

Loads of people look up the criteria when they're pregnant of local schools and think ok what can I do to increase my chances of getting something that won't make our daily lives an utter sod.

Loads of churches massive load of parents (usually mum) with children aged 0- 4.

I know many don't like it and I understand why but that's the reality.

If the schools could look into parents head and see their strength of belief and their actual thoughts. I'd bet on the schools being pretty much empty.

Can't comment on anything other than RC and CofE on that point.

That's what is actually going on. Which must piss off those who do have strong faith. But what can be done? Play the game or have a really difficult years juggling. Arranging with work to start late. That sort of stuff.

The reason it happens is because of the very high proportion of faith schools. And if they didn't do it. The schools would struggle to get pupils. Unless they start shipping them in from other areas? Which would be even worse!

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 21:05

I went to a religious school my children did not, they are adults, they would rather have gone to the religious school and I regret my decision also, they plan to send their children to religious schools.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 21:03

it means a school that in this area will be bloody ages to get to when there are multiple schools in walking distance. And children being brought in from further away. I think that walking to school is brilliant. Reducing pollution is great. And this Criss crossing and time to go further is no good for pollution congestion the children etc etc