Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 15/09/2021 00:32

mustlovegin

Interesting. You probably didn't read my earlier post on this it's a long thread.

Essentially and having talked a lot with friends I think that having a spiritual urge, for want of a better term. Is for some a part of who they are and for others it isn't. The feeling there must be something, a higher power, a meaning, maybe some kind of life after death.

Some people just feel that and some don't. One particular friend and I have talked a lot about it and we just can't understand having that feeling/ not having it if it's not how we are!

I do think that being raised in a mainstream religion is no bad thing. People then have an exposure to it and may feel comfy with it, switch to one that suits their outlook better etc. If no experience then it's alien. And much harder to access if it's what you want/ need irrespective of the actual faith.

That's no reason to have it in schools though if parents have a faith they will refer to it at home/ pray/ follow certain holidays and practices/ engage in festivals (which are usually upheld by many who are not practicing) and of course go to church.

We are a Christian society and country and it is present all over the place all the time. Sometimes so much that it's just 'normal'.

So yes having exposure to a religion and feeling it's somewhere you are welcome as it were is good.

No need to do it in schools.

And not everyone has that vacant place by any means.

mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 00:19

It's a very sensitive topic for many, understandably. I wish we had the solution.

I'd better go to bed now Wink

mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 00:15

I've never encountered antipathy towards them

Except on MN Grin

mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 00:13

The taking space in the vacant place in minds is interesting. Could you expand on that?

This is just my opinion, and many will not agree. But I think almost everyone needs a belief system to hold on to in life. When you take away religion (any faith) you are leaving a vacant space for something to take its place (be it a cult, 'worshipping' of an individual, an ideology, literally anything).

Not everything is a valid replacement unfortunately, but the replacement will be done (and will sometimes be detrimental)

NiceGerbil · 15/09/2021 00:05

'Partly that's why I think it's not appropriate to argue that entry criteria in this case amounts to 'discrimination' as per the OP. There needs to be an element of 'safe space' in religious schools, otherwise, how long will it be before anything is up for challenge by those who wanted to get in 'because little X;s friend goes there' but resent religion and actually wished it gone.'

I think this is a bit hyperbolic tbh.

CofE is pretty uncontroversial. We are a Christian country officially. That's I think the majority religious schools. Nothing to get excited about. Births weddings deaths still for most across the country just a standard. I've never encountered antipathy towards them.

No parent would apply for schools when their child is a toddler because their friend goes there. If they totally oppose the ethos. If it's a good school maybe but I can't see that anyone would go against all their beliefs to get their child into a school that clearly states it's religious ethos as they all do round here. And then attack them. The school will say erm what go away. The parent would look like a twat and it would be obvious they'd lied to get in. Can't see it happening here anyway.

And I don't get the safe space thing.

For Jewish and Muslim (and other?) schools yes. Is that the ones you mean? I can't see that mainstream branches of Christianity need a safe space surely? Or are you thinking NI or similar areas with sectarian issues?

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:56

The taking space in the vacant place in minds is interesting. Could you expand on that?

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:56

'This is a very difficult question. There is obviously a need to change with the times and organised religions are no exception. But where do you draw the line to prevent core beliefs and traditions being eroded until there isn't much left? It takes a lot of (collective, in this case) bravery and clarity of mind to achieve the right balance. I agree that it seems to have made it worse and left (mostly western) society at the mercy of opportunists wanting to take a vacant place in people's minds.'

I totally get that. This is why the orthodox church has so many flavours and also in non RC Christianity in England.

Change disagreement schism.

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/09/2021 23:51

It's interesting to note that the Catholic school near me are the most foul mouthed disgusting kids as opposed to the state school which seems very well behaved.

Why do you find that "interesting" @Againstmachine?

mustlovegin · 14/09/2021 23:51

I mean that was what I got from info supplied and it was clear that was the focus

Yes, maybe I went off on a tangent and started to think more in general about the impact of 'changes' in religions Smile

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:47

I mean that was what I got from info supplied and it was clear that was the focus

In the UK at least where I live the RC churches are thriving due to loads of RC people from Eastern European countries and to a lesser extent but still material, parts of Africa.

When I was a child the majority of RC congregation was from Ireland/ Italy.

It's always been a major religion here which is why so many schools.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:42

The Rc changes were about increasing global communion and from that perspective were extremely successful indeed.

mustlovegin · 14/09/2021 23:41

That is again just your experience though. Not a general truth for all children

Yes, I know this.

Also by 'abolished' I meant PPs who said religious schools should be banned

mustlovegin · 14/09/2021 23:39

It was a mistake or a coincidence that society changed and a falling away happened at the same time, they achieved the opposite of what they planned

This is a very difficult question. There is obviously a need to change with the times and organised religions are no exception. But where do you draw the line to prevent core beliefs and traditions being eroded until there isn't much left? It takes a lot of (collective, in this case) bravery and clarity of mind to achieve the right balance. I agree that it seems to have made it worse and left (mostly western) society at the mercy of opportunists wanting to take a vacant place in people's minds.

Partly that's why I think it's not appropriate to argue that entry criteria in this case amounts to 'discrimination' as per the OP. There needs to be an element of 'safe space' in religious schools, otherwise, how long will it be before anything is up for challenge by those who wanted to get in 'because little X;s friend goes there' but resent religion and actually wished it gone.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:28

@mustlovegin

Trying to remember. I went to an RC primary as did most of my friends

RC educated family here. For me also single sex. I will always be immensely grateful to that school. Nuns were no-nonsense and had their heads screwed on. I never saw teachers being lazy like someone mentioned upthread. Most of my classmates went to university and there were very few who were from 'privileged' backgrounds.

(Any) religion is also very helpful when the going gets tough in life and I wish every child/person could have this to resort to. It's very upsetting when people want it to be abolished in the name of 'tolerance' and 'civilisation'

I don't remember anyone saying religion should be abolished! That's your take on the thread?

I'm pleased that you had a good school experience and your faith has assisted you when things were difficult.

That is again just your experience though. Not a general truth for all children.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:22

High CofE might be a fit.

The stances on these massive topics that are so contraversial in RC then won't come up iyswim. You are free to have whatever beliefs you have on those topics yourself. With no religious controversy etc bringing questions from others or trying to start 'debates'.

mustlovegin · 14/09/2021 23:21

Trying to remember. I went to an RC primary as did most of my friends

RC educated family here. For me also single sex. I will always be immensely grateful to that school. Nuns were no-nonsense and had their heads screwed on. I never saw teachers being lazy like someone mentioned upthread. Most of my classmates went to university and there were very few who were from 'privileged' backgrounds.

(Any) religion is also very helpful when the going gets tough in life and I wish every child/person could have this to resort to. It's very upsetting when people want it to be abolished in the name of 'tolerance' and 'civilisation'

newfriend05 · 14/09/2021 23:14

No OP , it's about choice .. if you want the end of Church schools .. what about private schools and grammar schools ..

Againstmachine · 14/09/2021 23:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 14/09/2021 23:10

That's why I am pro choice, I value the life and health of women so would rather they access safe intervention I also respect their right to not share the same beliefs as everyone else. I think abortion is a disposable thing, I have kept my opinion to myself when friends told me they had abortions, eventually it did put me off them though, if they would so that to their own child they are capable of doing terrible things to others, so I watched and their behavior over time revealed them to be so selfish for us to carry on.

I doubt I would get along with JRM either.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:10

If you don't like jrm style RC then high CofE might be worth attending a service.

It really depends on which parts of RC belief are important to you. Transubstantiation being a big one.

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:06

Maybe if you moved to an area where the language of children at the faith school was not generally English. It would help?

Because you won't know whether they're swearing or not Grin

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/09/2021 23:05

There's something very disturbing to me about parents forcing religion onto their children.

What do you mean "forcing" @Maryjane3227?Confused Do you consider parents who give vegetables with every meal "forcing"? What about those who make their children do sport or music practice? Is that "forcing"?

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:05

Will abolishing all faith schools stop this widespread issue of horrible nasty sweary children?!

Is that a balanced view given your view is based on one school?

NiceGerbil · 14/09/2021 23:03

@SunIsBehindGreySky

Are there any RC branches (probably wouldn't be allowed to call themselves RC) that kept the original ways?.

Yes, they are annoyed because that's where all the young people go with big families and smart dress, it's growing apparently where as the 1960/70s version is dying mostly attendance is old people. I have seem people attend the English mass in their PJs and jeans.

Though when I heard that Jacob Rhys Mogg was that type of Catholic it put me off.

Jrm is definitely old school. 100% against abortion for ANY reason. Pretty sure contraception as there were news stories when found out to be involved in a company that makes contraception amongst other things).

The fact he proudly says he's never changed a nappy. Even though has many children (although one would be bad enough) tells you everything you need to know. I mean probably nannies do it but it's the being proud of it. Nasty piece of work. Oh and the any circs at all is also awful as with no caveats it would include saving mother life at any stage of pregnancy.

Againstmachine · 14/09/2021 23:02

And as I said before religious schools need. To be abolished no place in modern society