Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:35

It's not about Jewish schools!

It's about faith schools full stop.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:33

Just to be clear @NiceGerbil - no one is saying it’s a problem for non Jewish kids to be at Jewish schools (and indeed it’s relatively common in Uk in areas where not so many Jews as in borehamwood). But the issue is if people are not supportive of a school’s Jewish ethos but want to send their kid there because the kids at that school do well academically. That tends to be bad for the school.

Also @SusieBob - us Jews are taxpayers too. We have no less (and no more) right to schools than you do.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/09/2021 01:33

Why do we think religious schools do better though?

It's only some religious schools which do better, you know. My area has far more 'Christian' faith schools than proportionate to the numbers of regular churchgoers. Some do well, are oversubscribed so can apply selection. Parents undergo that mysterious preschool or year 5 epiphany and start attending church. The school prospers by having more kids with parents who are invested in their education.
Other schools faith schools are undersubscribed ... they can't apply selection. Their supposed ethos doesn't seem to make any impact on their ratings.

So a parent who lives near the first school who can't or won't attend church to secure a place for their child may find the child gets allocated a place in the second school. Fantastic.Hmm

YANBU OP. Discriminating against someone because of their religion (or lack thereof is wrong. Discriminating against a child because of the religion (or faked religiosity) of their parent is outrageous.

Just10moreminutesplease · 13/09/2021 01:33

I think it’s crazy that religious schools exist at all.

Who in their right mind would want children divided up by religion instead of learning together?

And yeah, I know plenty on none Christians apply for catholic and CofE schools. But they are still majority Christian and reinforce the idea that Christian is the ‘default’ (and I’m not sure there are very many none Muslim children at Islamic schools or none Jewish children at Jewish schools? Though happy to be corrected if I’m wrong).

Surely if your religion is so important you can just teach your children about it at home?

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:33

What is the problem with schools having students from a range of religions?

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:32

A closed Christian sect and a closed Jewish sect that are both fairly local.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:30

It's not about money.

It's about all the stuff I put upthread.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:28

I'd rather think about the more general points raised tbh.

If a Jewish school is undersubscribed then non Jewish children will get a place. If it's taken then the parents will have made that decision.

Same as a non RC parent sending a child to an RC school where the religious side and beliefs are key.

On the general points that I put above though. What do you think?

PurpleOkapi · 13/09/2021 01:26

I'm picking religions at random here for the sake of simplicity:

The Catholic children who attend Catholic school would still have to be educated somewhere, probably at state expense, if that Catholic school didn't exist or if it didn't have room for them because it was filled with Protestants, Muslims, Jews, etc. So long as the state isn't giving the Catholic school any more money per student than it gives secular schools, I don't see the problem. It's not costing taxpayers any extra.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:24

Also @NiceGerbil - what do you mean by “certain sects”? Do you mean Jewish sects? Or other religions? Or are you talking about catholic schools in NI, etc?

Generally religious schools are supervised pretty strongly for “British values” (well those of non Christian religions are). I think that’s fine and schools should have certain basic matters they teach kids. But that’s not the same as just saying all religious schools = bad.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:19

@NiceGerbil - re the Jewish holidays questions presumably because it’s inconvenient for non Jewish people to be off for Jewish holidays as they will have to work. They are scattered throughout the year. Re the kosher food, lots of Jewish schools have “milchig “ kitchen so no meat. Some people not of the Jewish religion are intolerant of that. Not everyone of course. But Jewish rules don’t necessarily suit lots of non Jews and so they can get angry and upset because they think that these things shouldn’t be done in state schools. That they should only be for “secular” (they mean Christian secular) types.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:13

Ok so it's a local issue with certain dynamics. That's fair enough.

My comments in general still stand though.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:12

So basically people want the Jewish schools with the good marks to admit their children and to be exactly like a Jewish school but not Jewish. That way they don’t have to send their kids to the actual non denominational school. Like they would like the local kosher shops to be waitrose so they don’t have to shop at tesco.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:05

@NiceGerbil - my post just got deleted so don’t propose to retype but basically there is a a fair bit of low level anti semitism in borehamwood. Some non Jewish locals blame Jews for high house prices and because there are many shops and businesses to suit the Jewish population that they don’t like (eg kosher food shops). There are Jewish schools that are oversubscribed in borehamwood which are good even great schools but non denominational schools that are undersubscribed. So plenty of places in schools but the best schools are Jewish and lots of Jews want entry.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:00

@CayrolBaaaskin

Also *@storminborehamwood* no one is “marking your kid down” because they don’t have priority for a Jewish school. A Jewish school is the most appropriate place for a Jewish child. Sounds like a non denominational school may be the best place for your child.
What about the issues over the years with state funded schools for children who are members of certain sects?
NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 00:57

Out of interest why would a person in general not be happy with their child eating kosher food, having time off for Jewish holidays instead of Christian?

If there are not enough applicants from Jewish families then non Jewish children will get places. That's an automatic problem?

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 00:54

Also @storminborehamwood no one is “marking your kid down” because they don’t have priority for a Jewish school. A Jewish school is the most appropriate place for a Jewish child. Sounds like a non denominational school may be the best place for your child.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 00:53

Because if you're not Jewish or RC or c of E and for many meeting certain religious criteria.

Then there's no option at all within a reasonable distance.

That's discriminatory due to religion.

I don't know the situation in borehamwood in terms of what options there are locally etc.

As a general point though in some areas it is a problem because so many schools have faith criteria and schools are oversubscribed. Most years there are can't remember. 100s of children with no school place at all.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 00:47

@storminborehamwood - Jewish schools in borehamwood won’t let your non Jewish kid in? And now even though you don’t practice the Jewish religion (legal criteria to get into Jewish school) you think your child should get in anyway? And what happens then when you don’t want your child to attend Jewish services, to eat kosher and so on.

There are state schools in borehamwood which were set up and part funded by the Jewish community in order to educate Jewish children in their religion and allow them to eat kosher food and celebrate their holidays. If there is space, because they are state schools, they will admit non Jewish children. But there usually isn’t space.

I don’t see any problem at all that there are state funded schools that are there to fulfill local community needs. Like Jewish schools in borehamwood. I think that it’s right that schools for people of the Jewish religion are allowed to select people of the Jewish religion to attend. It makes sense.

You may wish your child to go to a Jewish school when you don’t practice that religion because they tend to get good academic results. But it’s absolutely not unfair that they are able to select Jewish kids for priority entry when that’s the purpose of the school.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 00:47

Missgemini

It's not 'annoyance'. That trivialises the issues imo.

My thoughts- it would be good to know if you think any of these are issues and what could be done?

There are squillions of faith schools that receive govt funding round here. C of E, Jewish, RC.

In my locality there are more faith primary schools than non. (Noting that all schools have a duty for Christian stuff. Many ignore it but it's the law. Schools can apply to have the legally required act of daily worship changed to a different religion but I don't think none is ok. Not checked for a while though)

So in practice loads of children are essentially barred from their nearby schools and end up with long journeys. Schools round here are oversubscribed mainly.

In the past there has been trouble with illegal questions being asked/ donations. This area was in the press for being really bad.

That I hope was clamped down on but there's still the point that meeting criteria is a proxy for certain things. Because it involves being able to do something regularly and often for years. Parents who have various things in their situations are way less likely to be able to meet that.

Schools that don't put sibling high up on criteria are a nightmare for parents.

Issues in faith schools for some that follow a more fundamentalist branch have been flagged for big problems many times but nothing seems to be done as there's a reluctance to interfere.

Aside from all that I also have concerns about private schools for certain sects.

TooBigForMyBoots · 13/09/2021 00:46

Is there a shortage of school places where you are?

nanbread · 13/09/2021 00:44

@Missgemini

I think we should be trying to improve the other schools that aren't doing so well, instead of being annoyed at the religious schools. Why do we think religious schools do better though?
I agree that other schools should be better, but these things are connected.

The faith school has extra funding from the church = can pay for better things = better results.

Also, this is a sweeping generalisation but religious families are more likely to be family oriented with both parents involved, possibly stricter parents too, so better behaved kids.

If the ambitious parents / parents who give a shit (and aren't phased by lying) fake being religious to get into the school, then they are taken out of the other secondaries' pool of students, and this has a negative impact on those schools.

TooBigForMyBoots · 13/09/2021 00:40

What's happened @storminborehamwood?Brew

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 13/09/2021 00:36

We're not in an area with faith schools as an issue. Faith schools that include religion really shouldn't be part of the state system. They should be additional to it.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 00:31

Susie sadly some private schools for certain groups are what most people would see as terrible for the children.