Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:30

Also @NiceGerbil - that’s a lack of school places rather than anything to do with religious schools

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:29

@NiceGerbil - is not ok for there not to be a school place. But is that really the case? Or is it just not a desirable school place?

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:27

@PurpleOkapi - state religious schools cannot select on the basis of religion unless they are oversubscribed. So if there are not Jewish children to fill all places for a Jewish school, anyone must be allowed to attend.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:26

'it's the parents' prerogative to limit their children's exposure to those whose faiths and behaviour they disagree with. '

???

There seems to be a strong focus on animosity etc here.

The fact is that in some areas if you're not the right religion then there are no local primary schools that will take you.

How is that ok?

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:20

To clarify I mean I don’t have an issue with selection of an appropriate school on the basis of religion. Not that some people are being excluded but that the most appropriate people for a religious school are those who practice that religion

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:16

@onlychildhamster - I agree in part why Jewish schools get better marks. But the reason many Jewish parents want their children to go to Jewish schools is as you say kosher food, holidays, anti semitism and Jewish education.

Jewish schools are for kids who practice the Jewish religion unless there are spare places. I don’t see an issue with that

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 02:09

@NiceGerbil yep my DH's Alma mater. I know a young lady from my shul who got accepted recently, her mum isn't Jewish but dad is, is considered Jewish by my synagogue as she grew up in the faith. She chose JFS over Jcoss because she felt JFS was more academic.

I personally prefer jcoss tbh which accepts non Jewish children /JFS has changed 4 headmasters in 7 years even though the results are good but Jcoss is catching up even though it's a young school.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:08

I don’t know what you mean @NiceGerbil. What is the issue with these “sects”? Ultimately if anyone practices those religions they can go to the school. That’s the law. No need to be halachically Jewish to go to Jewish school- you need a certificate saying your child has attended the requisite number of times. So if you want your child to go to a Jewish sects school - send them along to the services.

PurpleOkapi · 13/09/2021 02:08

@NiceGerbil

I don't think money is irrelevant, because if no one's getting more of it because of their faith, then no one's being treated unfairly here.

As for the other things, are you talking about a school that refuses to allow students from other faiths full stop, and would rather have empty seats? Or are you talking about an oversubscribed school giving priority to members of its own faith? Those are two very different situations. I think most people here are talking about the latter.

But even for the former, while it's not something I would personally choose, it's the parents' prerogative to limit their children's exposure to those whose faiths and behaviour they disagree with. If you hold certain values, it's much harder to instill those in young children when many of their classmates are openly saying or doing the opposite and telling them that it's fine. This is the same reason many parents choose not to send their children to academically-superior religious schools whose teachings they don't agree with - they don't want their children being taught beliefs and values they don't agree with. And that's fine, just like it's fine for religious parents to prefer religious schools.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:06

@NiceGerbil - all religious schools (jfs case indeed) must only select on the basis of something the child or parents do. Not what they are. So it must be about practice not birth.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:03

There are issues with schools of all faiths.

My comments earlier apply to all.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:03

@Just10moreminutesplease - the view that religion should not be taught in schools is not a view I share. Not is it a view that the vast majority of Jews in the Uk share (I can only talk of my own religion). For us our schools are an important community hub. As I said though our religion has a lot of learning needed - practically it would be difficult if not impossible for me to teach all that at home.

As I said I think religious state schools are an important part of diversity and tolerance. Of course they should be inspected and teach within limits. But I think it’s a great thing we have such schools and I hope we can continue to have them.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:03

'The thing with Jewish schools in the UK is that now they are not able to discriminate against children of mothers who underwent non orthodox conversions. '

Court case jfs right?

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:01

Local closed Christian and Jewish sects.

Your extremism comment was strange and unhelpful.

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 02:00

The thing with Jewish schools in the UK is that now they are not able to discriminate against children of mothers who underwent non orthodox conversions. So now the criteria is attendance at X number of services (which anyone can attend). This is because the Jewishness of a child is determined by their birth- traditionally, you would determine someone's Jewishness by their parents' ketubah/marriage certificate but of course not all Jews would have this- there are Jews who only have a civil marriage and there are Jews who married in a masorti/reform ceremony (so their ketubah is not recognized by the orthodox). However, despite this, I have never heard of any non Jews trying to 'game the system' and getting their child into a Jewish school. I heard of children of reform converts (kids from my synagogue) attending a less religious Jewish school like JFS. I imagine Yavneh would be similar as they employ the same criteria. The more religious Jewish schools are able to filter out the less religious children and indeed the reform converts because they ask for a letter from an orthodox rabbis certifying you keep kosher (which many Jews in the UK do not strictly keep even if they belong to an orthodox synagogue).

Also as someone whose husband and sisters-in-law have exclusively attended Jewish schools, the reason for the good results in Jewish schools is private tuition. Yes middle class kids in any desirable comprehensive have the same tuition, but almost all children who get into a grammar school would choose the grammar school over the comprehensive. Many Jewish parents would choose the Jewish school over the private/grammar school, due to reasons like kosher food, antisemitism, Jewish holidays etc. So you get a lot of kids who belong at the top schools in the country at the Jewish school and this drags up the average mark.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:58

@NiceGerbil - hmm I suppose maybe I think she in borehamwood because her user name is @storminborehamwood.

What is your issue with these sects schools? Extremism in Muslim schools in Birmingham was something reported in media.

Just10moreminutesplease · 13/09/2021 01:55

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@Just10moreminutesplease -Jewish people want their children educated in our religion. It’s a fairly involved religion so lots of education needed. I consider many Jews to be in “their right mind” regardless of their wish to educate their children in religious schools.

Just to correct you too, I personally know Muslim kids in Jewish schools which are under subscribed. Jewish people are not as a general rule bigoted (of course some are same as any other people).[/quote]
I’m sure people of all religions want their children to learn about their faith. I just don’t think school is the place for it.

Surely it’s better for children to grow and learn together rather than be separated based on their families’ beliefs?

Thanks for clearing that up for me. In my area it is only Christian schools which have a significant number of children from other regions applying (studied this as part of my degree but sadly only based on local data). Unfortunately this just means more children than I initially thought are growing up seeing themselves as ‘other’ to the religion they are primarily exposed to in school.

I don’t believe any collective of people are “as a general rule bigoted” (though obviously there will be individuals in every religion who are so).

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:55

Also just to be clear- my dds go to a religious school. I a progressive Jew and moved to a very specific area to ensure we were in catchment and that they could get the Jewish education I wanted. It’s something I want them educated on. It’s key for me that they learn about our religion that they learn Hebrew and that they celebrate our holidays and don’t grow up feeling weird or different.

I want that for other religions too. Of course I agree that there are basics that religious schools should comply with but there are standards in the Uk and inspections.

I think allowing people to practice and be educated in their own religions is just the basics of tolerance. I am absolutely supportive of it.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:49

?

Extremism? What the hell?

Where did that come from?!

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:48

OP doesn't give any indication like that whatsoever.

OP has only posted once and I can't see at all how it can be interpreted in meaning Jewish schools and borehamwood.

The vast majority of religious schools in UK are Christian.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:48

@NiceGerbil - great. I don’t know what widely reported issues you are referring to. Do you mean extremism?

Generally Jewish languages and education is likely not to be all that interesting to non Jews. And it’s a lot of work to learn Hebrew etc. But it works for many (eg lots of Muslim families find kosher food advantageous, etc).

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:43

@NiceGerbil - the ops op is clearly about Jewish schools if she is talking about borehamwood (which I think she might be….). Anyway intolerance to the Jewish religion is not that different from intolerance to other religions (although there are obv some differences).

Don’t like religion- don’t send your kid to a religious school. Many people do, hence why religious schools are so popular. We pay taxes too. We are just as entitled to schools that meet our needs

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:42

' It’s a fairly involved religion so lots of education needed. '

Again I would raise the widely reported issues in some faith schools around this.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:41

My school was maybe 50% Jewish and 30% Asian.

No problems at all.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 01:38

@Just10moreminutesplease -Jewish people want their children educated in our religion. It’s a fairly involved religion so lots of education needed. I consider many Jews to be in “their right mind” regardless of their wish to educate their children in religious schools.

Just to correct you too, I personally know Muslim kids in Jewish schools which are under subscribed. Jewish people are not as a general rule bigoted (of course some are same as any other people).