Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
Just10moreminutesplease · 13/09/2021 03:20

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@Just10moreminutesplease - Jewish kids are taught about other religions (in some Jewish schools but perhaps not all). However they are taught most about Judaism. While that wouldn’t suit your kid (presumably as an atheist or agnostic) it would suit Jewish families. So I think it’s best to have schools for everyone including Jewish people not just for you or indeed me.[/quote]
But this is exactly where we don’t agree. I don’t believe it is right to teach children primarily about one religion at school, from a viewpoint that this religion is the ‘right’ one. As far as I can see this is divisive and I believe society is a better place when people see that we are all more similar than we are different.

Not only that but school, in my opinion, should be reserved as a place where children are free to learn and grow through none biased education. And that’s because I think a child’s right to make their own decisions is more important than their parent’s wish to see them educated in a specific faith.

You are wrong to assume I’m not religious by the way. Believing that schools should be secular does not say anything about my personal religious beliefs.

sashh · 13/09/2021 03:18

They shouldn't exist.

They can also discriminate in their staff selection and promotion.

They change their entry criteria to get the 'right' kids in, RC schools used to not have many ESOL kids, until Polish people started to move tot he UK, suddenly you not only had to be baptised but baptised ASAP after birth and within a year of birth.

Then there is what is taught, as well, outside the RE classes, the language(s) taught, the history or the perspective of history, some subjects may not be available at all and others might be compulsory (Yes I am bitter about spending 3 years learning to cook and clean).

Faith schools also may offer counselling or pastoral care that is faith based. In VI form a student made the mistake of telling a teacher she thought she was pregnant, she was told if she was she could have the baby and stay in VI form but if she had an abortion she had to leave.

I totally understand people wanting their children to share their faith but I think that could be accommodated, maybe have secular schools across the board but with a half or even a full day once a week where children can attend a religious school or the school could provide religious instruction.

I think study of world religions should be a secular subject.

But state religious schools are inspected (more rigorously IMO than secular) and required to comply with certain standards.

Ofsted inspect all schools but faith schools have a separate inspection of their RE done by a member of that faith.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 03:09

@NiceGerbil - I have no idea of any 50% Jewish school or how suitable it is for anyone. What I did say was that it makes sense for a Jewish school to select Jewish children over other children as that’s what it’s there for. Of course Jewish state schools must offer places to children of all religions and cannot select unless oversubscribed

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 03:06

@onlychildhamster - legally it’s practice. Ultra orthodox schools can ask you live a certain way and some do (no tv etc.). But they cannot (whether state or private) demand the children are halachically Jewish. So if you and your family chose to live that lifestyle you could send your child to those schools. I have nieces and nephews and cousins in those schools. But I wouldn’t choose them for my dds because they’re not right for them. But I have no problem with them as long as they are keeping up to standards (and in fact many ultra orthodox schools are very good academically).

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 03:03

You believe that my 50% Jewish school that had no noticeable religious affiliation had an unsuitable education?

Ok.

PurpleOkapi · 13/09/2021 03:03

What agenda? As someone else pointed out upthread, this is only an issue if the school has to turn away a child of the faith it's intended to serve in order to accommodate a child not of that faith. Teaching non-Jews about Judaism or anything else isn't the purpose of Jewish schools. Teaching Jews about Judaism is. A religious Jewish school shouldn't have to turn away Jews who want to attend just to accept non-Jews who don't even want to attend a Jewish school, it's just that (according to you) there's no non-Jewish school nearby. If you're correct about that, the problem is the lack of secular schools. That problem is neither the fault nor the responsibility of any religious school, because they aren't the ones in charge of building them. The non-Jews not admitted to the Jewish school can go wherever the Jews you think they should have supplanted would have gone if your preferred policy was actually the rule.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 03:00

@Just10moreminutesplease - Jewish kids are taught about other religions (in some Jewish schools but perhaps not all). However they are taught most about Judaism. While that wouldn’t suit your kid (presumably as an atheist or agnostic) it would suit Jewish families. So I think it’s best to have schools for everyone including Jewish people not just for you or indeed me.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:55

@NiceGerbil - not really. Basically children of one particular religion are going to a more suitable school and others are going to another more suitable school. There is no discrimination

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 02:55

@CayrolBaaaskin well I think their criteria is orthodox Jewish children. As I converted in the Liberal denomination, I can't join an orthodox synagogue! Or have an orthodox rabbi sign off on whether I keep kosher or shomer shabbat. I once asked my MIL if the rabbi was willing to sign off everyone who asked and she said she didn't think so, he had to have a reasonable belief that you were frum. So that rules out all the Jews who drive to shul.

But anyway it's not my ethos either :) and DH attended a Chabad primary school and they only taught in Yiddish. No English or Maths. They are now Ofsted regulated but classified as 'inadequate'.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:54

@NiceGerbil - I am not not concerned about religious schools in that I think all of them are great. I am not concerned about the existence of them in general because many are very good and the government have standards to enforce on them the same as any other school. If some of them are not up to scratch it doesn’t mean we should ban all religious schools any more than we should ban all schools of a few are failing their ofstead inspection.

If there genuinely aren’t enough places of course more should be provided by the government but as we have already established that is nothing to do with religious schools.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:53

In areas where it's predominantly faith primaries and most schools are over subscribed. The result is children not of those faiths and ticking certain boxes in terms of adherence etc. Are discriminated against. By having a place only miles away.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:51

I have massive issues with faith schools full stop esp that get state funding.

I am concerned about the reports going back years about what some schools are teaching and how.

I cannot see how that is not ok.

The fact that those children are s different faith/ a different group of the religion, so ignore that is not a position I'm going to adopt.

And my list put that way down anyway so why the focus on this in particular.

Just10moreminutesplease · 13/09/2021 02:48

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@Just10moreminutesplease - the view that religion should not be taught in schools is not a view I share. Not is it a view that the vast majority of Jews in the Uk share (I can only talk of my own religion). For us our schools are an important community hub. As I said though our religion has a lot of learning needed - practically it would be difficult if not impossible for me to teach all that at home.

As I said I think religious state schools are an important part of diversity and tolerance. Of course they should be inspected and teach within limits. But I think it’s a great thing we have such schools and I hope we can continue to have them.[/quote]
It’s not that I don’t think religion should be taught in schools. I think children should be taught about all world religions in a none biased way so that they, hopefully, grow up to be tolerant and are free to make up their own minds about their religious beliefs.

I think we’ll just have to agree to disagree on this one.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:47

@onlychildhamster - any school (including charedi) cannot bar non Jews. Only have religious criteria for entry. I have many family who send kids to ultra religious schools- wouldn’t dream of it myself as it’s not my ethos but they couldn’t bar dds if they met the practice criteria.

There are of course illegal religious schools in Stamford hill and other places that are teaching only religion in Yiddish. But that’s not what op is about (nor do I agree with such - kids should get a good standard of secular education IMO).

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:43

Hold on

So schools catering to Christian/ Jewish closed groups are off the agenda? Why?

And I posted my list of other issues with faith schools upthread. I have many, this is only one.

PurpleOkapi · 13/09/2021 02:42

@NiceGerbil

'it's the parents' prerogative to limit their children's exposure to those whose faiths and behaviour they disagree with. '

???

There seems to be a strong focus on animosity etc here.

The fact is that in some areas if you're not the right religion then there are no local primary schools that will take you.

How is that ok?

Many secular parents wouldn't want their children attending a religious school because they don't want their children to be taught those beliefs. For religious parents, the same is true in reverse. Animosity may play some role for some people on both sides, but for the most part, wanting to raise your child with a particular set of beliefs and values doesn't indicate animosity towards those who believe differently.

If there's not a secular school available in some areas, that's definitely a problem, but it's the government's problem and the government's responsibility to solve it. Telling religious schools that they have to admit non-religious students doesn't solve it, because those children still have no option but to attend a religious school. Effectively forcing students to attend religious schools when their parents would prefer a secular school would be no less of a problem.

A proper solution would be to give parents a real choice between secular and religious schools, but that would require the local government to build and fund more secular schools. Personally, and again picking religions at random, I don't think it's appropriate to tell a Muslim student that they have to go to a Catholic school if they want to go to school at all. Whether the Catholic school admits them or not is a separate issue, because even if it did, that situation would still be unacceptable. Supposing it were actually happening, of course, because I don't entirely believe you that it is. All children should have the option of attending a non-religious school.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:42

Not being concerned about religious schools is the same as not being concerned about any schools.

There have been issues raised over and over and little action.

If it's your thing to trust to the govt to act etc then that's up to you.

I feel differently.

That's all there is to it.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:41

@onlychildhamster - I agree re child not smarter because go to school with more academic children. But unfortunately many don’t agree

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 02:40

@NiceGerbil JFS, Jcoss and Yavneh are not closed. They are Ofsted regulated, they teach the national curriculum, they have many non Jewish teachers (Jcoss principal isn't Jewish, I think), the children do their GCSEs and A levels- a higher than average percentage go onto Oxbridge. There is a distinction between them and the haredi schools.

Most people in the mainstream Jewish community disagree in some part with the educational practices of haredi schools. But no non Jewish parent would even want to send their child to a school that teaches very little English or maths so the fact that they don't allow non Jews is a moot point.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:39

@NiceGerbil - not an issue with religious schools at all then

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 02:38

@NiceGerbil - I have no idea what is going on at the schools you refer to or what or where they are. But state religious schools are inspected (more rigorously IMO than secular) and required to comply with certain standards. So I’m not concerned about all religious schools. If there are issues with religious (or non religious) schools, they should of course be dealt with. But if it’s just prejudice, that’s something wla

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:36

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@NiceGerbil - is not ok for there not to be a school place. But is that really the case? Or is it just not a desirable school place?[/quote]
I mean no place at all.

Moelwynbach · 13/09/2021 02:34

I attended a standard county primary school in a fairly white area of Manchester mainly Christian families (that was just the demograph of the area) my high school was very obviously C of E but had people of all faiths and none. Much more multi cultural in my opinion and a much more cohesive learning experience than my none religious primary, my sixth form was also very multilingual and Catholic.
I don't think the issue is about the religious exclusion as a stand alone issue its about restrictive admission policies. Schools should be free to be faith schools but not to restrict their pupils due to their faith. I wholeheartedly believe my secondary school experience was formative fir the better.

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 02:32

@CayrolBaaaskin I understand the desperation of parents who perhaps don't have a good local secular state school and therefore want a place at the local faith school which has good results- be it Jewish, Christian etc. But the reality is that if a school has good results because of structural reasons i.e. smart children choosing Jewish school over prestigious non Jewish schools, your child is not going to be any smarter just because he or she shares a school with such children!

I do agree Jewish schools are meant for Jewish children. This could be out of date as my husband was in JFS over 10 years ago but a significant amount of the school day was spent on Hebrew and Jewish studies. At hasmonean, it was as much as 30%. Also the post GCSE Israel trip was a big milestone, almost all children would participate as it is heavily subsidized by the Israeli government and you are only eligible if you have a Jewish parent, I think. Non Jewish children would be excluded from it. In some jewish schools, a lot of children's friendships are centred around synagogue friendships, family friends etc, connections you would only have if you were Jewish. I know my DH and his sisters found it harder socially as their mum was a orthodox convert so they knew less people. I cannot imagine how it would be like for a non Jew.

The thing is I agree in principle that faith schools should be open to everyone who is willing to learn more about the religion but Jewish schools are very different to Christian schools (as someone who has only studied at Christian schools). It is much more tribal (for lack of a better word), Jewish education takes up far more time, Jewish rituals and customs are much more complicated (I lived for 3 years in an orthodox household and it probably took me over a year to grasp the basics). It is just not accessible to the average non Jew.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 02:31

@CayrolBaaaskin

I don’t know what you mean *@NiceGerbil*. What is the issue with these “sects”? Ultimately if anyone practices those religions they can go to the school. That’s the law. No need to be halachically Jewish to go to Jewish school- you need a certificate saying your child has attended the requisite number of times. So if you want your child to go to a Jewish sects school - send them along to the services.
So you're not aware of the issues with state and private schools over the years with closed religious communities?

I find it really worrying and have done for years.

One closed Christian sect is very local and the children used to go state and then when technology moved on they opened their own school.

Wtf is going on there? I have no idea and I doubt the council does. This bothers me a lot.

Also the issues with some schools state and private for a closed Jewish community.

Things which are in immediate vicinity are understandably a focus.

This is a more general conversation though surely.