Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
home2012 · 13/09/2021 07:03

All religious schools should be banned. It's ridiculous in this day and age. Teach your kids your religion at home

Matilda82 · 13/09/2021 07:01

So why repeat it @willow19c? I've heard this said before by parents using faith schools. It's insulting to those of us who do care very much , but just happen not to have been born into a specific religion. It's a bit tricky to rock up to church and start playing the faith game if you've never attended before or aren't christened. I just can't bear the smug attitude that eminates from some parents who use faith schools. When DS got into his school and some found out we weren't Catholic they actually complained to the school as they thought we had commited fraud to get in. Hmm never mind our son has SEN and the school had specific facilities for him. Small minded people.

Iamnotthe1 · 13/09/2021 06:54

Many schools with links to religions don't receive additional funding. This is especially true of CofE schools, which is why there are two types (Voluntarily Aided and Voluntarily Controlled).

However, the church often owns the land the school is built on and sometimes the buildings themselves. After all, it was the church that first set up and ran many of those schools. Unless the Government/council was prepared to buy control of the land (and buildings), they couldn't change the admissions criteria.

In reality, for most schools, the religious priority accounts for very few pupils. In ours, it's usually a quarter or less of the intake each year. However, if you ask in the community, they would tell you that you can't get in unless you go to church. It's not true but it is their perception.

Willow19C · 13/09/2021 06:52

[quote Matilda82]@willow19c no, someone turning up to church regulary does not make them a better parent. By and large it's someone bought up in X religion who 'rediscovers' their faith when their first child is born and are playing the system as they believe faith is best. The schools are self selective.

I know a woman whose son went to a well regarded RC school in the area. She was terribly smug and 'we are in the club and you aren't' . Not very Christian. DS got a place as he has an EHCP despite us not being Catholic. She was Shock when I told her which demonstrates everything wrong with this divisive, excluding system and the motives of many involved. .Religion should not be part of the school day, it should be a family matter. I really don't see why anyone needs to practice a faith at school. You can pray at home.[/quote]
I was just quoting a teacher I know, I don't think it. I don't attend church.

Matilda82 · 13/09/2021 06:51

@willow19c no, someone turning up to church regulary does not make them a better parent. By and large it's someone bought up in X religion who 'rediscovers' their faith when their first child is born and are playing the system as they believe faith is best. The schools are self selective.

I know a woman whose son went to a well regarded RC school in the area. She was terribly smug and 'we are in the club and you aren't' . Not very Christian. DS got a place as he has an EHCP despite us not being Catholic. She was Shock when I told her which demonstrates everything wrong with this divisive, excluding system and the motives of many involved. .Religion should not be part of the school day, it should be a family matter. I really don't see why anyone needs to practice a faith at school. You can pray at home.

Iwonder08 · 13/09/2021 06:35

It is disgraceful. If a school is tax funded it shouldn't use church membership as an admission criteria.

Willow19C · 13/09/2021 06:31

So many typos, sorry, it's 6.30am!

Willow19C · 13/09/2021 06:31

I've read through this thread and it seems like most people don't understand that at a religious school, you actively practice the relation on a daily basis and this is why they are open only to children of that religion.

It isn't comparable to a Christian only GP practice Hmm

I went to a Christian school as my family are Christians. We had to pray in the morning, took part in church services, the religious lessons were more catered around bible study, had a Chapel to attend, took communion.

I'm not religious now, but if you're living a very Christian lifestyle, your life can revolve around your faith and that is why my school was like that.

I don't think it would have been suitable for a child of no religion, or a Muslim or Jew to be sat in communion with me.

I don't think it would be enjoyable either!

But for the most part, I don't think the schools aren't letting your children in to be horrible and discriminatory. I think they just want to practice their beliefs without your non religious child taking a place.

I also remember a teacher telling me that Christian parents who had the discipline to attend church every Sunday (we were only allowed to miss 2 Sundays a year to get into my school) were seen as better families to have at the school, because they would push their children harder, be more committed to school events, stuff like that!

I won't be sending my daughter to a religious school, just as a side note. We're not a religious family, I don't want her having to sit through church services if she doesn't want to.

Numbersixtyeight · 13/09/2021 06:30

I agree that there is no perfect system. Every system is problematic.

Hercisback · 13/09/2021 06:15

Names out of a hat would be fairer.

How does this work in practical terms though?

I understand in inner city oversubscribed areas it might work. What happens if your name comes out in a school 3 miles away and 60 mins on public transport, when you have a school over the road? That's crazy and not helpful for anyone.

There's no perfect system.

Sirzy · 13/09/2021 06:05

If faith schools stopped being able to prioritise students from that faith then the funding that comes for the school from the religion wokld soon be stopped so it would have a negative impact overall.

Personally I am no fan of faith schools and even though I am C of E actively avoided faith school for ds when selecting his school. But I don’t think the school system would be any better if we changed the admission criteria for them.

Knittingupastorm · 13/09/2021 06:03

People can meet with people who share their own beliefs, should political parties let anyone who doesn't share their views in as members in order to be inclusive?

Ridiculous comparison that isn’t relevant to state schools. I don’t share the Tory party views but could, right now, go onto their website, pay my £25 and I’d be a member. No check on my views.
And besides, being a member of a political party is optional, kids have to be educated.

I totally agree with the OP.

Numbersixtyeight · 13/09/2021 05:53

You could also argue that the criteria of nearest to a school discriminates against those on lower incomes. Names out of a hat would be fairer.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 13/09/2021 04:13

[quote onlychildhamster]@ClumpingBambooIsALie so it's not comparable to the GP surgery given that the religious aspect which isn't the state's responsibility is funded by the parents/community.[/quote]
I was quite careful to specify that the extra religious stuff I invented (monk coming in to pray once a week) was separately funded.

No analogy is going to be perfect, but I think analogy is the only way to express to those who are used to it just how anomalous the state-funded faith school system is. What would you think if your nearest NHS GP wouldn't take you because you're of the wrong religion?

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 04:11

@Hoowhoowho or you can look at it the other way and see that even if faith schools are selective, they are much more accessible than grammar schools (which select based on academic ability) or private schools (based on family income). Attending a religious service is free after all.

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 04:07

@ClumpingBambooIsALie so it's not comparable to the GP surgery given that the religious aspect which isn't the state's responsibility is funded by the parents/community.

Hoowhoowho · 13/09/2021 04:03

It’s discriminatory because

As an example, there may be 1000 school places in an area, if 500 of those places are in religious schools and 800 of the potential pupils come from secular families or families of religions not represented by those schools (the vast majority of U.K. religious schools are C of E or Catholic) then schools are being paid to teach kids in a religion their family does not subscribe to. This is obviously unacceptable

There is a huge barrier for entry to many, particularly oversubscribed religious schools l, ie regular attendance at religious services. This therefore includes families who can ‘fake religion’ but excludes families who whether due to language barriers, substance misuse, mental illness or other vulnerabilities cannot play the system. They could be committed to the particular faith but life means they won’t be attending a service weekly or 42 times a year or whatever the system is. Basically faith schools exclude the most socially vulnerable.
This therefore particular in areas where most schools are religious puts an unfair burden on surrounding ‘secular’ schools as they will have more children who need a lot of support and it turns faith schools into elite institutions for ‘families like us’. If you want that pay privately.

The only argument for keeping religious schools is the complex history of school funding in the U.K. Churches own and maintain school buildings throughout the country and despite overall this being a relatively small financial contribution to the education of the pupils. To buy or replace all these schools, particularly in rural areas where they are often very undersubscribed would be a massive financial burden for the state.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 13/09/2021 03:59

[quote onlychildhamster]@ClumpingBambooIsALie not sure how it is like at other faith schools but UK government only pays for chol (secular) studies at Jewish schools. Parents have to pay for Kodesh (religious education).[/quote]
And?

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 03:56

@ClumpingBambooIsALie not sure how it is like at other faith schools but UK government only pays for chol (secular) studies at Jewish schools. Parents have to pay for Kodesh (religious education).

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 13/09/2021 03:51

I'm imagining the reaction I'd get if I were somehow able to set up a faith NHS GP practice, built on land owned by a local religious group that also gave my practice a bit of extra funding on the side, say, for a monk to come in once a week and say prayers for the sick, but getting the majority of its funding from the state. By putting some extra prove-your-religion admin barriers in the way, I'd be filtering out not just people who have the wrong religion, but also people who find it more difficult to jump through admin hoops. Filtering out those patients might well mean my patients need fewer health services on average, so the patients I do accept will get a less-stretched service. This is totally justified, apparently, because some people want a GP service that will reinforce and conform to their religious beliefs — obviously, it's totally unreasonable to expect religious people to use a generic GP who provides services to everyone, and get their religious health-related concerns (prayers, religious guidance, rituals etc.) dealt with at their own community-funded religious institutions. Even if I'm the closest NHS GP practice to you, you might have to walk past my surgery to get to the one you're allowed to register at, the one that takes all the people who can't jump those hoops. Perhaps you'd prefer not to use my surgery anyway, because you'd rather not have a particular religious slant to your healthcare. But that doesn't mean that it's okay that you have to trudge past the nearby state-funded faith GP, with your dicky hip and your COPD, to get to the more distant, more stretched GP that a) will accept you and b) won't be pushing religion at you.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 03:33

@QueenFreesia2021 - hear hear. It’s about choice.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 03:31

@Just10moreminutesplease - I don’t know that Jewish schools necessarily teach children that theirs is the “right” religion. But they teach them about the religion. Which is important to Jewish parents. I don’t think it’s about right and wrong though- I’m Jewish but I don’t think other religions are “wrong”. I’m happy to be tolerant towards them ans would hope to get same in return

RedHelenB · 13/09/2021 03:30

@Missgemini

I think we should be trying to improve the other schools that aren't doing so well, instead of being annoyed at the religious schools. Why do we think religious schools do better though?
Because they have children in them whose parents are more invested in their education mainly. On the whole they have less children in FSM.
QueenFreesia2021 · 13/09/2021 03:29

How is it discriminatory?

If you do not believe in the religion being taught within the school why on earth would you want your child to go there? And why on earth would they want the complications of lots of children sitting out of lessons etc?

My children go to a non denominational PS and will go to a non denominational HS.

But why should all schools be non denominational / secular? Surely it is about choice.

There are plenty of other secular schools for those who don’t subscribe to a particular religion, or for those who don’t want that to be such a big part of their child’s school day.

I’m not bitter that there are catholic schools locally that my DC could not attend - we are not catholic so why would I want them to attend?

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 03:27

@sashh - that only applies to very narrow definition of teaching of the actual religion and it still has to abide by “British values” etc. the type of thing you mentioned should not be present in any school (faod religious schools can’t discriminate re staff etc).