Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
sashh · 13/09/2021 09:35

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@sashh - that only applies to very narrow definition of teaching of the actual religion and it still has to abide by “British values” etc. the type of thing you mentioned should not be present in any school (faod religious schools can’t discriminate re staff etc).[/quote]
Oh look a school recruiting this week for a 'Practicing Catholic'

www.tes.com/jobs/vacancy/headteacher-manchester-1484599

And another

www.tes.com/jobs/vacancy/headteacher-medway-1485049

And some advice on when schools can legally discriminate on the grounds of religion.

neu.org.uk/advice/religion-or-belief-discrimination

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 09:34

@Travielkapelka indeed, op seems to be from Borehamwood where the religious schools she is referring to are Jewish. There are two state secondary schools, one Jewish, one not. The Jewish school was set up by the Jewish community and over the last couple of decades many Jewish families moved to Borehamwood so their child could go there. The Jewish school has some of the best academics in the country and a more middle class student body than the non-denominational school. But that is really pretty much entirely because it is a Jewish school (otherwise no reason to think it would be any different from the non-denominational state school).

I think what concerns me about these types of threads is that there is lack of tolerance to people who are different from you. In op's case, its jewish people. In other cases it might be catholics or other christian groups.

There are plenty school places in Borehamwood but in schools not as academic or middle class as the jewish school. So many in Borehamwood and elsewhere are angry at the local jewish community having better schools. But the schools would be just the same as the non-denominational school that op could easily send her child to if it wasn't a Jewish school. So you can't have the education offered by a Jewish school by saying it should be abolished It doesn't make sense.

I think its great in the UK that we are tolerant and open minded enough to provide partially state funded religious schools (which as I said must keep to certain standards and teach certain secular matters). These schools serve our diverse communities. If there aren't enough school places, of course there should be more. But that's not an argument to abolish good schools which serve a community that you happen to not be part of.

Its nothing like a GPs surgery. Also noone is being denied entry because of religion but children of a particular religion can be given priority for a school of that religion. Which entirely makes sense! If religious state schools are undersubscribed, they must let anyone in and many do.

I have family in Borehamwood and they have faced some hostility from non jewish neighbours accusing them of putting up house prices, having shops that they (the neighbours) don't want to shop in, having their own schools funded by the taxpayer (apparently Jews taxes don't count) and having everything "their way". Its can be frightening to Jewish people as this low level anti-semitism can lead to worse behaviour as we all know.

onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 09:26

State funded education should be secular imo. If you want your children to have a religious education, send them to Sunday school, yeshiva, madrasa or whatever the relevant equivalent is.

The reality is that this would never happen in the UK. We have a monarchy and our Queen is the head of the CofE.

There would always be C of E schools as schools are an important part of how faith is transferred to the next generation. So if there are C of E schools, why can't other religions have their own schools.

Btw in America, no faith schools are state funded. Evangelical Christian, Catholic and Jewish parents pay crippling amounts for each child to attend their respective faith school. I don't think their society is more secular/inclusive than ours. In fact it is a nightmare for an atheist. When a religious school receives no state funding, there is no incentive for it to progress in line with what secular society values. JFS could have rejected state funding after the Supreme Court upheld its decision that it had to accept the children of Reform/Masorti/Liberal converts. But it didn't because it probably recognized that UK Jewish parents were probably not willing to pay fees and thus it needed state funding to remain open. And JCOss (UK's first cross communal school and which actively tries to build relationships with other faiths and also accepts non Jewish children) was also opened with state funding because there was no non Orthodox Jewish state school at the same time so it is a step in the right direction to make Jewish state education more inclusive & diverse.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/09/2021 08:58

I have also never understood why it's ok to discriminate against kids on the basis of what religion they are, but not for a job (except in very limited circumstances).

Not even what religion the child is - no four year olds has chosen their religion. Also, faith schools can discriminate when it comes to employment - I'm not really sure if they're meant to, but we knew a teacher who found it hard to get a job in our area (oversupplied with CofE and RC schools) as many wanted a reference from his vicar or priest.Hmm. Lovely 'ethos' there.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 13/09/2021 08:30

OP I agree with every word you said. I have also never understood why it's ok to discriminate against kids on the basis of what religion they are, but not for a job (except in very limited circumstances).

In my view all faith schools should be opened up to everyone. You can still have the ethos, but it's very unfair to stop someone coming who lives in the same street.

There's so much hate for grammar schools but at least the kids get in because they are bright, not because their parents go to church or synagogue or temple or whatever. Even if they are tutored, they need the raw intelligence.

I also think faith schools can be very divisive.

LakieLady · 13/09/2021 08:11

@NiceGerbil

'it's the parents' prerogative to limit their children's exposure to those whose faiths and behaviour they disagree with. '

???

There seems to be a strong focus on animosity etc here.

The fact is that in some areas if you're not the right religion then there are no local primary schools that will take you.

How is that ok?

Is that because local non-faith schools are oversubscribed, @NiceGerbil, or because there aren't any?

Due to a combination of a change in demographic and new building, there was a massive increase in the number of under-5s here a few years ago. Rather than enlarge existing schools, the LEA opted to add a whole new form of entry at one primary, and the only one that had sufficient space to have temporary classrooms was a CofE school on the very edge of town. So a lot people who want a non-faith education for their children can't get one.

Over the years, siblings have joined the school and its massive now. There are so many children going there from outside the immediate area that the traffic at each end of the school day is horrendous, and the roads around the school are gridlocked.

Meanwhile, a former special school site, close to the town centre and convenient for most of the town, has been left to rot for years.

Travielkapelka · 13/09/2021 07:51

The reason I think that Jewish schools have dominated this conversation is because the OP sounds like she’s from Borehamwood which houses 2 secondary schools, one of which is secular and had a poor Ofsted recently and has some real issues and the other is one of the top state comprehensives in the country which happens to be Jewish and outperforms the majority of private schools. I can see that local non Jewish parents who would like a local school find it unfair that they might be excluded from the school.

Having said that, the school has an affiliated primary school which is a free school. A proportion for places are given for religion and the rest are allocated on distance. Whilst the distance places are mainly taken up by Jewish child whose parents probably moved to the area to get places there are also non Jewish children in the school who got distance places.

malificent7 · 13/09/2021 07:50

Why anyone would want to send their kids to these brain washing establishments is beyond me but if you value academic achievement above all else then crack on!

dworky · 13/09/2021 07:50

There shouldn't be faith schools.
School is a place of education not indoctrination.

Pottedpalm · 13/09/2021 07:38

Application *

Pottedpalm · 13/09/2021 07:37

Out of interest, what has been the impact of the virus on entrance criteria? Pre pandemic I noticed children at Mass getting a booklet signed by the priest each week, prior to school applicstoon. Then churches were closed.

Had the weekly attendance requirement been dropped?

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 07:37

Where we were previously in London, our two closest schools were CofE. The next furthest was an excellent secular school. We wouldn't get into the CofE ones because we aren't religious. We were too far from the secular one. So our kids would have ended up at a school further away still while parents drove their kids to the school just over the road from our house. Sensible? Fair? Basically religious parents get a wider choice of schools.

I also just don't see why the state should fund religious schools anyway - parents can teach their children about religion on their own time without excluding other children from their closest school.

LakieLady · 13/09/2021 07:36

@Just10moreminutesplease

I think it’s crazy that religious schools exist at all.

Who in their right mind would want children divided up by religion instead of learning together?

And yeah, I know plenty on none Christians apply for catholic and CofE schools. But they are still majority Christian and reinforce the idea that Christian is the ‘default’ (and I’m not sure there are very many none Muslim children at Islamic schools or none Jewish children at Jewish schools? Though happy to be corrected if I’m wrong).

Surely if your religion is so important you can just teach your children about it at home?

Totally agree.

State funded education should be secular imo. If you want your children to have a religious education, send them to Sunday school, yeshiva, madrasa or whatever the relevant equivalent is.

Where I live, there are 5 primaries, 2 are CofE, 1 RC. It's harder to get your child into a non-faith primary than in a faith one, esp as one of the CofE schools is much larger than any of the other schools.

Sirzy · 13/09/2021 07:31

But then you didn’t feel strongly enough about how awful church schools where for independent thinking when you decided to send your children too one? Your rather contradicting yourself in your post.

You have shown that even with a catholic education both you and your children have been able to make your own opinions on things so why do you think others won’t be able to? Even if they go along with the family line while primary school age that doesn’t mean they aren’t going to make their own decision ultimately and obviously that decision may be that they do believe in that religion.

Walkingwounded · 13/09/2021 07:29

I find religious schools highly divisive.

Surely if we want to teach tolerance and openness in society then kids of all faiths should be educated together?

Autumngoldleaf · 13/09/2021 07:27

Sirzy,

My huge "thing" is like my df who was a tribal Liverpool Labour supporter who never ever shoved it down my neck.. Or brain washed me to follow labour.. He pushed independently thinking and question everything.

That was his thing.. Question everything.

That's also mine, I see people in rl and even in here who for instance seem brain washed to follow a political party, our parents have such a strong influence over us...

So we used to try to take the dc to church when they were little but the priest at that time was not only quite intolerant of any noise or movement he was also anti abortion and all that. So we stopped going.

Our dc have never had religion pushed or presented at home as what we do.

Conversations at home has never been soley around religion so they have not had that double layer of pushing.

BubbleCoffee · 13/09/2021 07:25

All state schools must follow the national curriculum whether they're faith schools or not. It's mandatory to learn objectively about various different beliefs.

Autumngoldleaf · 13/09/2021 07:22

I support all different kinds of school because I don't believe one size fits all...

The difference between faith school and independent or grammar for me isn't the entry criteria, it's the brain washing aspect which removes the opportunity for free choice and independent thought.

To a degree, dd tells me loads of dc don't believe in God but they are being pushed by parents m

Sirzy · 13/09/2021 07:21

Surely the fact your children where able to make that decision for themselves shows that even when they are in a system which pushes it they are capable of independent thought?

knitnerd90 · 13/09/2021 07:21

Bit weird to focus so much on Jewish schools in this thread as they are really not responsible for that many places even in Borehamwood.

The Jewish schools in North London/Herts are oversubscribed so non-Jews don't get admitted. In Ilford they are not so there are non-Jewish students at King Solomon. As for the chareidi sector, most of those schools are not state funded.

My dc would have gone to JFS most likely if we had stayed in London. On the one hand, I never totally liked the way faith schools are funded; on the other, English state schools aren't properly secular either. London Jewish schools do have good teaching, but they also tend to have a very low proportion of children on free school meals, i.e. very middle class intake.

Autumngoldleaf · 13/09/2021 07:19

To be honest my dc are in Catholic school, I initially chose it because I am a lapsed catholic, my own schools were rather mild on pushing the religion, and I like the moral ethos.

However the experience has rather put me off, the political head pushing it, it's almost felt like brain washing.

What chance to dc have with independence thought if parents and the school pushes the religious aspect so hard?

It's brain washing. Every person is born free and equal, we can show them different things, we should never ever force or push it.

At around age 8 years both dc said they don't believe and I didn't say yay or ney except that I respect what they feel and support it but be discreet at school.

BubbleCoffee · 13/09/2021 07:19

How many people are against faith schools but pro independent schools?

Is selection by parents' ability to pay fees really any better?

BubbleCoffee · 13/09/2021 07:16

I agree it's farcical to have a system where parents have to turn up at church for a few years in order to get their children into a particular school. I don't think Jesus was too keen on hypocrisy. Having said that, are also many C of E schools, both primary and secondary, which don't have a religious requirement for entry.

Confrontayshunme · 13/09/2021 07:14

I wholeheartedly agree, which is why our Christian family and friends were surprised when we opted for the closer, non-Christian school. If you are a faith school, your funding should come from your local diocese or faith community (do Muslims have the equivalent of dioceses?).

x2boys · 13/09/2021 07:11

I always think mumsnet is extremely hypocritical about faith school, most of the uk doesnt have Grammar school, s, but the general consensus on mumsnet is that they are great for those that are lucky enough to have them and lucky enough to have super duper intelligent children to pass the 11+so they are happy enough for the tax payers to fund their kids but not kids in faith schools
How about we improve education across all schools so all kids get an equal chance?