Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 11:26

@Hoowhoowho If C of E voluntarily makes its schools private, then we can begin to talk about Catholic/Jewish schools doing the same. But we both know that would never happen.

Hoowhoowho · 13/09/2021 11:14

I’d also abolish grammar schools personally but they are only based in some limited areas already.

Private schools are not state funded (although their charitable status should be abolished) and people can spend their money how they like. I don’t think we can abolish all advantage but state money shouldn’t be funding religious education.

The state provides a service for its benefit, the education of children. It doesn’t fund Steiner schools (as a rule) or Montessori or democratic schools, if I don’t agree with the National curriculum then I can home educate or privately educate. Religious parents can do the same.

Hoowhoowho · 13/09/2021 11:08

If course religious parents should raise their children within their religion. It would be hypocritical not to do so. However religion should stay out of state funded schools. In many rural areas there will be no schools within a reasonable distance which are not religious. This isn’t a case of families wanting to get into the oversubscribed religious school but of simply having no option but to attend a religious school many of which are undersubscribed.

Even in cities, in a London borough, 30% of the school places may be in religious schools. Most of those schools will be C of E or Catholic but maybe 10% of pupils are active members of those religions and the rest actively practice another religion or are from secular families. This means children will be forced to take school places in religious schools they do not want. Also means little Johnny from the atheist family gets to go to crappy religious school two miles away rather than good local religious school while little Janey who is religious and lives next door to crappy religious school instead gets priority over Johnny and travels to good religious school. So Johnny is hit two ways travels two miles to get a religious education he doesn’t want.

The simplest thing would be for parents to educate their children in their religion on their own time or for religious organisations to fund independent schools for children whose parents want them to have a religious education.

Bananarama21 · 13/09/2021 10:50

C of E schools get more funding than Catholic schools they have to make up the short fall. The whole point in Catholic schools is the religious ethos they carry within their school journery throughout the school, having their holy communion, attend M
mass within the school, celebrating religious events so of course they their faith should be a priority in regards to a Catholic school in order to facilitate that, not have children who don't practice the faith. They tend to be the better performing schools because of the ethos they stand by or they are in my area. Children can still apply but priority goes to faith, siblings in the school and catchment area, alot of people apply for the Catholic schools as they are popular.

Namenic · 13/09/2021 10:49

Atheists and humanists can set up their own schools with their own ethos. I guess historically the schools were church schools and then got funded by state. I guess the state could pay for all of it and the electorate could decide what types of schools they want…

Maybe the govt should fund schools with lower grades better and give proportionally more help and funding to those schools which take on previously excluded children or children who have difficulties which need extra support.

Deletesystem33 · 13/09/2021 10:31

@Babdoc

Am I the only one who finds it offensive when PPs refer to religious teaching as brainwashing? Yet pushing their own atheist beliefs on children is apparently fine? And why should children be left to somehow discover a religious belief on their own? Do you also advocate leaving them to discover maths and literacy unaided? For those of us who are practising Christians, our faith affects our entire approach to life. It is not something we and our children just do for an hour on Sundays, and should be made to ignore during the school week. I am sure this is true of other religions, too.
Atheists beliefs? You mean like, not teaching children that God is real?

You've said some pretty offensive things about atheists in the past.

severusvape · 13/09/2021 10:29

If schools give parents hoops to jump through to get into that school then parents will jump through them. The parents that do, tend to be much more invested in their child’s education.
Parents are a crucial factor in child success, it is this that makes a difference in faith schools in my opinion, so many like minded parents.

Behaviour in catholic schools tends to be much better, in my experience, and this has a big impact in secondary schools.

You could argue about grammar schools. Those that are financially able can afford to pay for a load of tutoring which discriminates against those who can’t.
Or any private schools, why should those with more money get a better education that those who don’t? There is discrimination everywhere.

Doubledoorsontogarden · 13/09/2021 10:26

Most state funded schools don’t receive full funding from the government. They do fund raising and parents are asked to pay monthly into the fund.

Sirzy · 13/09/2021 10:24

I think when children are young they will always be guided by the beliefs of their parents, not just on religion but on most life issues. The key as far as I am concerned is ensuring they have the skills needed to discuss things and make up their own mind as they get older. Ds was christened as a baby, by the time he was about 8 he was sure he didn’t believe in any gods and at 11 that is very much his firm view BUT I have made sure that he understands just as we respect his views he has to make sure he respects the views of others.

x2boys · 13/09/2021 10:18

@Babdoc

Am I the only one who finds it offensive when PPs refer to religious teaching as brainwashing? Yet pushing their own atheist beliefs on children is apparently fine? And why should children be left to somehow discover a religious belief on their own? Do you also advocate leaving them to discover maths and literacy unaided? For those of us who are practising Christians, our faith affects our entire approach to life. It is not something we and our children just do for an hour on Sundays, and should be made to ignore during the school week. I am sure this is true of other religions, too.
Good point, my son has always gone to Catholic school, s and now says hes atheist so hardly brainwashed, i have also brought him to beleive in whatever he chooses as long as he appreciates others have different beliefs to him.
Babdoc · 13/09/2021 10:09

Am I the only one who finds it offensive when PPs refer to religious teaching as brainwashing? Yet pushing their own atheist beliefs on children is apparently fine?
And why should children be left to somehow discover a religious belief on their own?
Do you also advocate leaving them to discover maths and literacy unaided?
For those of us who are practising Christians, our faith affects our entire approach to life. It is not something we and our children just do for an hour on Sundays, and should be made to ignore during the school week. I am sure this is true of other religions, too.

YouMeandtheSpew · 13/09/2021 10:06

I can’t speak for other faith schools but my son should be going to the local CofE school.

I think that faith (well, more specifically, attendance at one of two local churches) is either 9th or 10th on the list of factors they’ll take into account. From memory the priority list is ‘looked after children’ (ie children in care), then children of staff who fill a ‘hard to fill’ position at the school, then children for whom the school is the closest school who have a sibling there already, then children for whom it’s the closest school, then children for whom it’s not the closest school but who have a sibling there, and a couple more that I can’t remember before you get to church attendance.

In other words, faith only used to differentiate if they’ve got spaces left after awarding school spaces to all the children who are actually eligible for proper reasons. A kid who lives next to the school won’t miss out on a place because a kid from 5 miles away attends the local church. And that seems fair to me.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 09:57

@onlychildhamster - also agree re. USA. Taking religion out of their state schools don't seem to have made the USA a secular utopia of tolerance.

DreamerHutton · 13/09/2021 09:55

YANBU OP. But see also entrance exams, catchment areas and parent paid for uniforms or transport. Until every child can go to whichever school they/their guardians choose for them, there will be a way to game the system or discriminate against children.

SandyY2K · 13/09/2021 09:52

I disagree.

I'm Catholic and my kids went to Catholic schools, as did I. I personally wouldn't want them to attend a school of another faith, so I have no issue with it.

It's right that priority is given to those who are of the faith, then spare spaces can go to others.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 09:52

@onlychildhamster - lol there is definitely a love hate relationship with Borehamwood with many in the Jewish community! Boring wood, etc. But last time I visited its really looking better.

Agree with your post though - noone is saying all the Londoners are putting up house prices in the home countries,etc.

In Borehamwood a some of the non jewish population are blaming the jews in part because they seem foreign to them and in their mind less entitled to things. For example, England flags in houses next to Jewish facilities and draped over the Eruv wire. As if it were mutually exclusive to be jewish and English.

Jaysmith71 · 13/09/2021 09:48

Faith Schools in England and Wales are an accident of history. The CofE ran the first free primary schools in the 19th century, and by 1944 they were still a power in the land, joined by the RCs, who gained great kudos with the wartime govt when the Archbishop of Westminster went full-on fire & brimstone in favour of bombing Germany into the dust, no doubt in a spirit of Christian Love.

Coming at a time when you had several CofE bishops banned from the airwaves for their lilly-livered just war homilies, this was an, er, godsend to Winston and Co, so they were in his good books for the 44 Act.

Then enter Blair, who saw the Christian hegemony was unsustainable and decided he could co-opt other faiths rather than go secular, which was why he sided with the Sikh mob that tried to burn down the Birmigham Rep.

Should be abolished, more accurately all made voluntary controlled and told to go independent if they refuse, but won't happen.

Everydayimhuffling · 13/09/2021 09:47

I don't think there should be state funded religious schools at all. If I take your premise that they should exist then it's totally reasonable for them to include criteria for that religion.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 09:47

I don't see why we can't continue to have a variety of state schools for a variety of children. No reason all schools should be secular because some people are secular any more than all schools should be jewish because some people are jewish. A mix of schools to suit communities is the best way imo.

JustLyra · 13/09/2021 09:45

@Missgemini

I think we should be trying to improve the other schools that aren't doing so well, instead of being annoyed at the religious schools. Why do we think religious schools do better though?
They’re often better funded. Not always, but often.
onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 09:45

I have family in Borehamwood and they have faced some hostility from non jewish neighbours accusing them of putting up house prices, having shops that they (the neighbours) don't want to shop in, having their own schools funded by the taxpayer (apparently Jews taxes don't count) and having everything "their way". Its can be frightening to Jewish people as this low level anti-semitism can lead to worse behaviour as we all know.

When I was looking to buy in 2019, the first place I went to was borehamwood because I heard that was where all the young jewish couples were settling in. We bought in london eventually though cos DH prefers London. I suspect his sister made aliyah partly to avoid living in borehamwood!

But young families to the Home Counties is very normal thing nowadays and is almost expected. However, non Jews have the whole of Kent, Surrey, Bucks, Berkshire and even further afield to move to. Jews only seem to have borehamwood esp Jews with families in Golders Green/Hendon/other parts of north london. A lot of Surrey and Bucks Schools probably do have a very middle class, ex londoner demographic too, its what happens when a london terrace is over a million so people with a healthy budget often make the decision to move further afield. But unlike other groups, rich and poor Jews tend to move together as we need certain economies of scale to run our shops and schools and have a decent number of synagogues. I have hardly seen a mumsnet thread that says- help all the londoners are taking up spaces in my local school- which garners a lot of support. In fact so many mumsnet threads involved moving out of London! Well Jews move out of london too, they just don't have a whole list of destinations to pick from.

sashh · 13/09/2021 09:44

@BubbleCoffee

All state schools must follow the national curriculum whether they're faith schools or not. It's mandatory to learn objectively about various different beliefs.
Academies don't and the only mandatory bit is that children learn about 1 other faith.
CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 09:43

@sashh - the link you posted actually says they cant discriminate. But faith schools may take into account if staff conduct is in accordance with the ethos of the school (provided that their selection otherwise complies with discrimination law). So I don't see the problem. If you're not a catholic, why do you want to teach catholic RE anyway?

EatYourVegetables · 13/09/2021 09:42

I think there should be no faith schools to begin with Smile Children who choose to get religious education can do that in Sunday school / after school clubs.

CayrolBaaaskin · 13/09/2021 09:40

@onlychildhamster actually state funding doesnt make any difference - private schools are equally subject to the equality act when it comes to admissions. JFS's policy refusing children on the basis of who their mother were fell foul of the Race Relations Act (now the Equality Act). It would be equally subject to that Act if it were a private school.

The JFS case (and others) set out that it must be something the child (preferably) or family do (ie practice of religion) not what they are or how they were born.