Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?

413 replies

storminborehamwood · 12/09/2021 23:37

Most people accept that you can't discriminate against someone for their religion. So why can faith schools do it when it comes to kids getting a place?

AIBU to think state-funded faith schools should be forced to remove religious criteria from applications?

I know state-funded faith schools get extra funding from religion and that supposedly justifies giving priority to kids with religious ties.

I just can't understand why it's illegal to mark someone down for a job application based on their religion, but it's okay to do it for a school application.

OP posts:
Willow19C · 13/09/2021 15:53

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

Its nothing like a GPs surgery.

It's not that a faith school is identical in every way to running a religious NHS GP surgery. It's that when taken in the context of all the many, many state-funded services people can expect to receive in a modern diverse liberal democracy (schools, police, prisons, waste disposal, child protection, national security, hospitals, driving tests, etc.) state faith schools are a weird outlier, because the majority of services in the majority of liberal democracies are provided in a secular manner — not "atheist" or "humanist" but secular, that is, provided without religious influence or favour, for the benefit of people of all faiths.

You spend 20 mins at the GPs (for a lot of people - not very often). You nip in to see a doctor, then leave. Hopefully less than once a month. Even being chronically ill, I don't spend spend too long at the doctors.

You spend 35+ hours a week at a religious school, actively practicing a religion.

Not the same type of place at all.

AlexaShutUp · 13/09/2021 15:43

@jackstini

Well unless you all want your taxes to go up massively so that the government can purchase all the land & schools that are owned by different faith groups (approx 7000) and cover all the extra funding - this is not going to go away!

The CofE in particular were one of the main proponents of starting schools and getting children into education - they accounted for more than 2/3 of schools in Victorian times and donated the buildings and the land

All faith schools are open to all, if they are not oversubscribed with applicants of that religions, but it does make some sense that people who practice that faith, want their children schooled in that religion and pay towards that school get priority.

Surely if you are not religious, you would prefer a non-denominational school anyway - the issue is that there are not enough good non-denominational schools - but that is down to government, not religions!

I wouldn't actually mind paying more taxes if it meant that we could get rid of state funded religious schools. I don't think state education should discriminate.

I would absolutely prefer my child to go to a non-religious school, and in fact, she did. However, I fundamentally object to the fact that religious families have more choices with regard to school than families who are not religious, because of the way in which the system is structured.

In my area, the best local secondary school is not religious but it is very heavily oversubscribed. The second best option is a Catholic school, which prioritises Catholics, then other Christians, then other faiths above none. I know lots of religious families who had the excellent non-religious school as a first choice, followed by the Catholic school as a back-up. Clearly, getting their kids into the best possible school was their priority, over and above having a religious education per se. Why on earth should those families have had more options than we did for our dd, just because of their religious beliefs?

If they had been pushed to the bottom of the queue in the non-religious school, while non-religious pupils were prioritised, then I would agree that it's fair for them to get priority at the faith school. As things stand, they just have more options all round - equal opportunities at the first choice of school but a massive advantage at the back-up option. Not fair.

State funded schools should not be segregated on the basis of religion full stop. If parents want a religious education, then they should either pay for it themselves or persuade their religious bodies to fund it. Taxpayer funding should give equal opportunities to all children.

CheltenhamLady · 13/09/2021 15:36

Faith schools are not fully state funded, and even if they were, being of a faith wouldn't absolve any parent from paying the taxes that fund education.

Why shouldn't the children of those who want them educated in a faith school also have state funding?

I don't see a problem with faith schools personally. All of them accept those of different faiths or none if places remain after those the school was set up to admit have been accommodated.

YouMeandtheSpew · 13/09/2021 15:30

I’ve screenshotted our local CofE school’s admissions criteria. The faith-related criteria are numbers 10 and 11 (so a long way down the list). Basically they only use those criteria when considering out-of-area applications and I don’t think that’s unreasonable at all. But I do see a problem with children being refused entry to schools they live next to on faith grounds.

To think faith schools should be forced to change their application process?
onlychildhamster · 13/09/2021 15:30

CofE gave up being Christian a while back in my opinion. I gather Charles plans to quit Christianity for some new faith, a woke universal morale code, so this is what the CofE is preparing for, a mash up of ideologies, defender of faths he will be. The new state religion will be the international woke ideologies and a kind of mash up with Christianity etc.

Sorry this is a very weird statement. I can't even begin to unpick this....

jackstini · 13/09/2021 15:29

Well unless you all want your taxes to go up massively so that the government can purchase all the land & schools that are owned by different faith groups (approx 7000) and cover all the extra funding - this is not going to go away!

The CofE in particular were one of the main proponents of starting schools and getting children into education - they accounted for more than 2/3 of schools in Victorian times and donated the buildings and the land

All faith schools are open to all, if they are not oversubscribed with applicants of that religions, but it does make some sense that people who practice that faith, want their children schooled in that religion and pay towards that school get priority.

Surely if you are not religious, you would prefer a non-denominational school anyway - the issue is that there are not enough good non-denominational schools - but that is down to government, not religions!

SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 15:23

CofE gave up being Christian a while back in my opinion. I gather Charles plans to quit Christianity for some new faith, a woke universal morale code, so this is what the CofE is preparing for, a mash up of ideologies, defender of faths he will be. The new state religion will be the international woke ideologies and a kind of mash up with Christianity etc.

shinynewapple21 · 13/09/2021 15:16

Where I live (Midlands) the CofE area diocese is encouraging schools to remove the church attendance criteria from applications process. Schools will remain Christian in character but inclusive to all .

Deletesystem33 · 13/09/2021 15:14

I don't know a Christian who hasn't lost and regained their faith many times. I have known many an atheist or woke person who will refuse to entertain that they may be wrong, I have yet to meet one who isn't obnoxious, insulting and superior about their beliefs unlike agnostics or people of various Faith's who seem to have a level of respect for others beliefs I have yet to experience with an atheist or woke person.

That's more insulting and obnoxious than anything an atheists has said on this thread.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 13/09/2021 15:09

A non-religious school shouldn't be "pushing" atheism any more than a non-religious tollbooth or a non-religious planning committee or a non-religious mental health day centre or any other non-religious service should be pushing atheism.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 15:03

Taking religion out of their state schools don't seem to have made the USA a secular utopia of tolerance.

I gather many now homeschool because there are certain ideologies taught and some removal of family rights that are causing conflicts between state and families and parents and children.

Am I the only one who finds it offensive when PPs refer to religious teaching as brainwashing? Yet pushing their own atheist beliefs on children is apparently fine?

I don't know a Christian who hasn't lost and regained their faith many times. I have known many an atheist or woke person who will refuse to entertain that they may be wrong, I have yet to meet one who isn't obnoxious, insulting and superior about their beliefs unlike agnostics or people of various Faith's who seem to have a level of respect for others beliefs I have yet to experience with an atheist or woke person.

habibibibi · 13/09/2021 14:56

@Babdoc

Am I the only one who finds it offensive when PPs refer to religious teaching as brainwashing? Yet pushing their own atheist beliefs on children is apparently fine? And why should children be left to somehow discover a religious belief on their own? Do you also advocate leaving them to discover maths and literacy unaided? For those of us who are practising Christians, our faith affects our entire approach to life. It is not something we and our children just do for an hour on Sundays, and should be made to ignore during the school week. I am sure this is true of other religions, too.
But how do you know your religious belief is the right one? How do you know its not Hinduism or shamanism?
MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 14:51

While faith schools (in England) are free to have an admissions policy that gives priority to children based on faith, if I recall correctly they are not actually allowed to exclusively give places to that faith if they receive applicants from other faiths who meet the other admissions criteria.

This is true but the admissions criteria can be:

  1. Looked after Catholic children
  2. Catholic children
  3. Catholic siblings
  4. Orthodox
  5. Other Christian denominations
  6. Other religions
  7. Other siblings
  8. Distance

That's what I have most commonly seen for Catholic schools - some CofE schools can be a bit better. But it's not hard to see how many years no one gets in on the basis of distance. The Catholic schools around here won't even give you sibling preference if you somehow make it in under distance so you run the risk of being stuck.

BubbleCoffee · 13/09/2021 14:36

....and UK law still requires that all state schools have a daily act of worship, broadly Christian in character.

How often does this still occur in practice?

MattyGroves · 13/09/2021 14:30

Did you actually apply though or speak to the schools or did you just assume that because you aren't religious your children wouldn't get in?

Looked at their admissions stats, spoke to the schools. Total no go. Most London religious schools seem to have basically zero non religious pupils. We were literally a stone's throw from one and still wouldn't have got in.

We moved house to an area with more secular schools. The Catholic schools in our area even put looked after children who aren't religious below anyone from anywhere who is religious. I am sure Jesus would approve.

FrangipaniBlue · 13/09/2021 14:21

@MattyGroves

Where we were previously in London, our two closest schools were CofE. The next furthest was an excellent secular school. We wouldn't get into the CofE ones because we aren't religious. We were too far from the secular one. So our kids would have ended up at a school further away still while parents drove their kids to the school just over the road from our house. Sensible? Fair? Basically religious parents get a wider choice of schools.

I also just don't see why the state should fund religious schools anyway - parents can teach their children about religion on their own time without excluding other children from their closest school.

Did you actually apply though or speak to the schools or did you just assume that because you aren't religious your children wouldn't get in?
FrangipaniBlue · 13/09/2021 14:19

While faith schools (in England) are free to have an admissions policy that gives priority to children based on faith, if I recall correctly they are not actually allowed to exclusively give places to that faith if they receive applicants from other faiths who meet the other admissions criteria.

A lot of people don't know about this though and therefore don't bother applying, so faith schools generally don't receive very many applications from other faiths.

There's nothing to stop you still applying to a faith school, especially if you meet the other admissions criteria such as living close by.

We aren't Catholic but my DS got a place at an over subscribed RC primary school.

Inspectors often take a dim view of schools who give places to children from the last admissions criteria over those who meet the first criteria, where the only difference is faith.

Balonzette · 13/09/2021 13:49

Absolutely ridiculous statement.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 13/09/2021 13:25

Its nothing like a GPs surgery.

It's not that a faith school is identical in every way to running a religious NHS GP surgery. It's that when taken in the context of all the many, many state-funded services people can expect to receive in a modern diverse liberal democracy (schools, police, prisons, waste disposal, child protection, national security, hospitals, driving tests, etc.) state faith schools are a weird outlier, because the majority of services in the majority of liberal democracies are provided in a secular manner — not "atheist" or "humanist" but secular, that is, provided without religious influence or favour, for the benefit of people of all faiths.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/09/2021 12:09

@Namenic

Well they can set up their own schools with that ethos then Errol - so it can be open to everyone but no religious assembly/specifically religious teaching from a belief point of view? If they are popular, then people will be attracted and they can set up more. I guess it’s the academy system that we have…

And I guess it’s down to what the electorate want.

Actually, they can't.
Jaysmith71 · 13/09/2021 11:47

....and UK law still requires that all state schools have a daily act of worship, broadly Christian in character.

Jaysmith71 · 13/09/2021 11:46

Atheists, Humanists etc can set up their own fee-paying schools, but that's not the point. In the UK they cannot establish voluntary-aided faith schools with the advantages that status confers. Tried and been turned down.

Namenic · 13/09/2021 11:43

Well they can set up their own schools with that ethos then Errol - so it can be open to everyone but no religious assembly/specifically religious teaching from a belief point of view? If they are popular, then people will be attracted and they can set up more. I guess it’s the academy system that we have…

And I guess it’s down to what the electorate want.

randomsabreuse · 13/09/2021 11:40

To an extent any school that requires parents to do something other than fill in the basic forms will get better results!

ErrolTheDragon · 13/09/2021 11:35

@Namenic

Atheists and humanists can set up their own schools with their own ethos. I guess historically the schools were church schools and then got funded by state. I guess the state could pay for all of it and the electorate could decide what types of schools they want…

Maybe the govt should fund schools with lower grades better and give proportionally more help and funding to those schools which take on previously excluded children or children who have difficulties which need extra support.

The flaw in that argument is that the ethos of humanists tends to favour fair and equal access to education with no discrimination or privilege. Setting up their own schools would be counter to this.
Swipe left for the next trending thread