Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trying to relax when TTC is shit advice

114 replies

postingfortraffichere · 12/09/2021 22:26

I hear so many people say this. 'Just relax' it happened for us as soon as we started to 'relax'.

Now I understand the sentiment behind it but I really don't know how people think I can just 'forget' that it's the tww and forget to remember ovulation and keep alcohol intake low etc.

It's just annoying advice.

Did anyone not 'relax' and still manage to conceive? Because I find 'forgetting about it' impossible.

OP posts:
randomsabreuse · 13/09/2021 10:52

Relax is the wrong word but there's an element of of trying to control things you can control and not trying to control things you can't.

You can control your diet, sleep, alcohol consumption but trying to control your partner is a recipe for stress! Likewise work/life will happen - DH broke his arm right after we started TTC and I was initially so cross we'd have to delay until he was healed (would not admit this in real life) and had to make myself move on from being angry with the situation to something more constructive and be less of selfish person about it!

CounsellorTroi · 13/09/2021 10:51

I always think we wouldn’t need the pill if stress could really stop you getting pregnant!

Jeds55 · 13/09/2021 10:48

Totally agree with all, such pointless and infuriating 'advice'. If it's got to the stage that you're discussing ttc with friend/doctor/consultant you're obviously further along in the process than you thought you'd be and already quite unrelaxed about it.
Total bollocks, we've been on a long ttc journey. Now pregnant with second and also had the 'you should be grateful with dd' and 'relax' after 4 mc when stressed in early pregnancy. People talk shite.

BabyLeaf · 13/09/2021 10:46

Of course it's shit advice. There is some evidence that stress can reduce fertility, but it's not like you can turn stress off. Wanting a baby and the process of trying for one, waiting to see if it'll happen, dealing with the uncertainty, months passing by without a positive test, possibly dealing with losses, IS inherently stressful, and being told to relax about it is about as helpful as telling someone who's upset to 'calm down'.

People conceive through rape, during wars, during natural disasters, while being held captive.

The most annoying is the anecdotes about someone's friend who was incredibly stressed about TTC, somehow stopped stressing about it, and then magically fell pregnant. Pure confirmation bias.

I don't mind it SO much if someone is giving actual practical advice, for example an alternative mindset to consider, but the whole 'try to relax' thing is insulting.

Here's a personal anecdote: I was incredibly unrelaxed about TTC, I was really concerned about having only one tube and stage IV endometriosis. From the get go I had zero chill about getting pregnant, used OPKs from day one, had scheduled sex around ovulation, took prenatals, used a tracking app. And got pregnant immediately. I was the opposite of relaxed, I wanted a baby yesterday and was desperately worried in case it wouldn't happen for me. None of what was going on in my mind mattered, conceiving is most of the time absolute pure luck, you can get the sperm to where the egg is at the right time (which isn't doable for everyone) but the rest is up to chance. People who like to talk about how relaxing and a positive mindset helps tend to believe that they can somehow will themselves into a pregnancy and have more control over it than they actually do. It's comforting. More comforting than recognising that it's pot luck whether you end up with a baby or your friend doesn't.

LincolnshireLassInLondon · 13/09/2021 10:46

I hear you, OP! It is infuriating advice and it's never said to the man, which makes it yet more infuriating.

I am now going to be really annoying myself and give unsolicited (but hopefully helpful) advice... check out BFN podcast on Spotify. They have lots of funny things to say about "just relax" and "you can always adopt" advice and also some genuinely useful stuff about looking after yourself whilst TTC.

Good luck!

YouMeandtheSpew · 13/09/2021 10:38

It’s such a cliche - up there on the bingo card of ‘shit things to say to a person who’s struggling to conceive’, along with ‘you can always just adopt!’ (Because adoption just involves going to the baby shop and picking one you like).

CounsellorTroi · 13/09/2021 10:34

Yes it is infuriating advice. For the first year I was ttc I didn’t worry about it. I knew it could take a while and was sure it would happen eventually. Except it didn’t. We went on loads of nice holidays too.

FrangipanFlower · 13/09/2021 10:04

Oh I’ve forgotten what my SIL said to me - she’d done some course in hypnotherapy and was touting one of her ‘services’ as helping women with fertility issues. Apparently I wasn’t getting pregnant because I didn’t want a baby yet deep down.

brokenbiscuitsx · 13/09/2021 09:26

I agree OP it’s shot advice. As well as making it sound easy, like something that just happens as soon as you ‘relax’ it also has a sense of blame. You’re not relaxing it’s your fault!

It’s up there with a comment I received from someone who was all about manifesting their future (you can manifest anything into your life apparently!) apparently I couldn’t be manifesting this enough 🤬

InTheNightWeWillWish · 13/09/2021 09:24

The idea that tracking ovulation and your cycles introduces stress is true for some women. For some women, they feel they need the control. My periods were regular until we decided to TTC, then they decided to just do whatever they wanted. Not tracking in that situation was more stressful than not knowing when to expect my period and doing (negative) pregnancy test after pregnancy test. I was able to spot that temping wasn’t for me and wasn’t helping me and I stopped that after two months. However, using OPKs from month 2 helped me feel as in control of the situation as I could.

I did actually get pregnant on the month I stopped using OPKs but it wasn’t because I was relaxed. I had no idea when my period was due and even though I’d been paying attention to my body during ovulation for months, I didn’t see the usual signs of ovulation that month. I was stressed because I thought I hadn’t ovulated at all, had no idea when my period would decide to show up. As a result, I was a raging bitch for the whole month because I was so angry my body had just decided to go off the rails for no apparent reason when we wanted to TTC. Maybe you should just try being a complete bitch and telling everyone to fuck off for a month? Wink None of the advice worked for us the month I got pregnant - we had very little sex (roughly every 5-7 days), we had also both introduced alcohol back into our diets after doing dry January. Fingers crossed you get a BFP soon.

Mumoblue · 13/09/2021 09:20

A woman at work told me “Oh it’ll happen just when you stop trying!” - I wanted to snap at her “Do you know how babies are made?? How would it happen if I stopped trying?!”

It took me 3 years and 2 early losses to get my son and if it’s taught me anything it’s taught me to be QUIETLY supportive of anyone trying, and to not make assumptions.

Frazzled2207 · 13/09/2021 09:20

It is totally useless. However. anecdotally for me it worked.
Dc1 took 2 years to conceive, lots and lots of stress and various further investigations etc

When it came to dc2 we stopped using contraception but weren’t actively “trying” at all-
assumed it wouldn’t happen for years. Two weeks later….

user1471462428 · 13/09/2021 09:16

@Avenueofcherryblossom I used to point that out to the people telling me to relax… I eventually got pregnant after surgical intervention but I heard all kinds of bullshit before including from a GP that infertility is a mental health issue. I got unbelievably dismissed and lost a lot of confidence in health professionals as a result.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 13/09/2021 08:45

I think there's a difference between a couple who've been "trying" for two minutes before the woman (usually) whips out ovulation charts, thermometers, put the bloke on a green juice regime etc etc, and those who aren't pregnant after a year or more of regular sex. The trouble is we often don't know which is which in casual conversation, so best not to wade in to other people's love lives.

BelieveInRainbows · 13/09/2021 08:42

It took me a year to get pregnant, then I miscarried twice in a row. I already had 2 children so what I got most was to "appreciate what you already have" as if I didn't Hmm Wanting a 3rd child was the absolute worst thing in the world apparently.
The advice to relax and enjoy lots of sex was unhelpful too because we both have pretty shit sex drives, I ovulate around day 21 of a 34 day cycle and we'd be exhausted by the time that rolled around if we did it every other day! We'd do it 3 times in my window and honestly that was us done for the month most of the time.
I temped, I tracked ovulation, I peed on sticks galore from 8DPO. I would have loved to relax but I was consumed with having another baby and the miscarriages only heightened that feeling. The obsessing worked eventually, 18 months later and I'm 13 weeks pregnant.
Not being able to relax won't stop you from conceiving, it's probably better for your mental health but it's definitely easier said than done.

Avenueofcherryblossom · 13/09/2021 08:40

Trigger warning

I had the try to relax advice. If you have to relax to get pregnant why do victims of rape and sexual assault get pregnant? Why are women in war torn countries and refugee camps getting pregnant?

‘Try to relax’ is the most ridiculous advice. As for ‘everything happens for a reason’ no one would say that to someone whose child had just died or whose partner had a terminal illness so why is it okay to say to people (women) struggling to conceive or with miscarriage?

As it happened male infertility was the problem in my case.

FrangipanFlower · 13/09/2021 08:26

After struggling to conceive and four losses, I now never ever offer anyone advice or platitudes if they’re TTC unless they ask. The relaxing thing pissed me off to high heaven no matter how well meaning. It’s up there with “Well, at least you can get pregnant!” And “Everything happens for a reason”.

ThatCampWitch · 13/09/2021 08:09

It took me 3 years to finally conceive the one I’m 14 weeks pregnant with now, with 3 miscarriages along the way. I need a huge cocktail of drugs including hormones and blood thinners to sustain a pregnancy. Relaxing doesn’t come into it!

timeisnotaline · 13/09/2021 01:15

It definitely works for some people so it’s a well meaning suggestion. I have friends who were about to start interventions but went on nice holidays and fell pregnant. One of them is very close and I’m sure she’d have reacted like you on being told to relax, but did destress on holiday! Obviously not if you have other medical issues as some on this thread mention.

Aorh · 13/09/2021 01:10

“Just read and it’ll happen” winds me up.

“Recognise that it can be a difficult journey and take the time to look after yourself and her as much relaxation in as you can so that difficult journey is slightly easier to deal with” is very true.

Yestoallthecake · 12/09/2021 23:53

I lost ivf twins at 20 weeks. 3 months later went on holiday, just needed a break from everything. I was obviously still aware of my cycle, how could you not after years of TTC. I came home from that holiday pregnant with my now 5 year old. I didn’t relax, my body just knew what it was now supposed to do as it had a practise run.

Peaplant20 · 12/09/2021 23:31

Totally with you OP. I did not relax and had no problem conceiving so don’t worry it won’t actually prevent you conceiving! I do think there is some logic to it though as stress hormones are bad for us in many ways. I agree with some previous comments - having sex throughout the month not just in the ovulation window, and tracking cycles x good luck!

gogohm · 12/09/2021 23:12

There's two angles from this - from a medical perspective you need to approach your gp after the appropriate amount of time (typically 6months or a year depending on your age) and go through the tests they suggest etc but from a lay perspective hearing people planning to do temperature charts, ovulation monitoring etc before they even start to ttc would prompt me to say just relax and enjoy having lots of sex!

Scubalubs87 · 12/09/2021 23:04

I hated this! HATED it. It did however happen that way for me - albeit, not because I became some sort of zen master. The month I finally fell pregnant, we were absolutely not trying; I'd had enough and I couldn't do it anymore. We had our first appointment at a fertility clinic the next month and I was just waiting for that. Trying was off the cards. The one and only time we had sex that month was after we got pissed at wedding. And somehow, that month was the month. I do very much believe that stress was a major factor in our problem conceiving but no one telling me to relax would have ever made me actually relax. And, ultimately, I was just incredibly lucky that there wasn't anything else at play stopping us from conceiving.

'Everything happens for a reason' is such an awful comment to make.

User65412 · 12/09/2021 22:54

Yes I hated this advice! That's the difference between sympathy and empathy.
I like control so started taking my temp and bbt charting as well as monitoring other markets such as cm. 'relaxing' didn't work for me but tracking my cycles in detail did. I may have got pregnant anyway but I definitely felt better knowing I was doing something proactive! Also didn't tell anyone except medical professionals as I just didn't need to hear it!