Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people wade in on threads that clearly they can’t contribute to?

159 replies

wannagotoaustralia · 12/09/2021 20:31

Does anyone know what I mean? A thread will say something like ‘Dog owners - I need your help’ and someone will post to say ‘well I’ve never owned a dog but I think …’

Or you get something like ‘AIBU to think Friends is really misogynistic’ and someone replies with ‘don’t know - never seen it.’ Or ‘what would you buy an eight year old boy for Christmas.’ ‘Nothing, I only know one boy and he’s two.’ Sometimes they’ll admit ‘so that doesn’t really help.’ So what’s the point? Are people just that desperate for attention?

It’s not to aid sinking threads either, it happens even on busy threads that a lot of people are enjoying.

So - AIBU to ask if you’ve noticed this and AIBU to think it’s really annoying?

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 12/09/2021 21:32

@Cocolapew

They must be the same people who post reviews on Amazon saying they haven't got the item yet or bought it for a present so can't say if it's good or not Confused.
I am always aghast at those!
Redcrayons · 12/09/2021 21:30

mums of toddlers coming on to advise on teenagers.

A recent one about getting teens to do stuff around the house. You should have Them started young. Didn’t we all have toddlers following us round ‘helping’. Come back in 10 years and tell me it doesn’t take your child an hour to hang their coat up.

YourFinestPantaloons · 12/09/2021 21:27

@Nayday

The best/worst are the ones which reply in order to state this isn't a problem for them

OP: My DS can't do basic arithmetic. What can we do?

Reply: DS actually did his Maths degree aged 3 and actually is pretty much a genius at everything, no idea what I'd do in your terrible position!

This is especially annoying when it's threads about giving birth.

"I had my DS last week and I'm home now, it was an EMCS, my scar got infected and now I can't sit up or turn over properly, AIBU to expect DH to do the dishes?"

"Ha! When I had my DD, I was home before I delivered the placenta and up a ladder with her in a sling painting the roof tiles."

SpikeyFloof · 12/09/2021 21:27

To be fair I think there is a genuine confusion for some (rather technically inept/inexperienced) people there because they get an email from Amazon 'asking them' (obviously it's actually just autogenerated) to leave a review or answer a question about the product and they think that it is actually an email specifically to them so they should reply to explain why they can't. Which is actually quite sweet, though I agree it often makes the reviews useless.

Aww, this reminds me of my technophobe dad who told everyone that Facebook had forced him to make an account so he could get his meds. I think he was trying to register on Pharmacy Direct or similar and clicked the 'log in with facebook' option instead of signing up by email. He was adamant that Mark Zuckerberg was withholding medication until people signed up to Facebook! Grin

SecondCityShark · 12/09/2021 21:26

Definitely OP. I posted about this on a woo thread a few weeks ago. The thread was about scary stories, not 'let's debate whether ghosts exist'. But you always get people coming on to tell everybody that we are talking nonsense.

You don't have to contribute to a thread!

YourFinestPantaloons · 12/09/2021 21:25

Hahaha YANBU. I wonder if some people think it's mandatory to comment on every thread?

BrightYellowDaffodil · 12/09/2021 21:23

The Amazon reviews are similar to the Amazon questions:

Q: Does this curling wand heat up quickly?
A: Not used it yet, sorry.

I think some people think everything is addressed to them personally. It's similar on our local Nextdoor group, which some people seem to think is an extension of their personal FB page. No, Sandra, I don't think the fact that you're feeling better from your cold really needed its own post and corresponding alert to all the hundreds of people in the group...

Kendodd · 12/09/2021 21:23

Don't mind either way.

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 12/09/2021 21:17

I just clicked into this from Active, and mainly post on Style and Beauty, sometimes The Litter Tray.

I think people click in from Active and chip in (like I am doing right now) rather than actively visit the boards, but so often there are threads along the lines of:

OP - tell me your favourite luxury bath products, please?
S&B posters - helpfully recommend lovely things
Random posters - I use bleach, I can’t believe people would waste 10p on bubbles, how vain

OP - how soon after getting a rescue cat should I wait before letting him/her out?
LT posters - offer useful advice/share experience/ask for photo of cat
Random posters - I hate cats, no-one should ever keep one as a pet

ArsenicNLace · 12/09/2021 21:14

I saw one on style and beauty where the heading was 'foundation recommendations for over 50's skin'. One of the first replies was 'I don't know. I never wear foundation'??!!!

I couldn't understand why anyone who didn't wear foundation even bother to click on the thread in the first place? I just ended up with the thought they're the sort of person who thinks they're superior to other people because they have more important things to do than think about their appearance. Very odd.

bwfcchick88 · 12/09/2021 21:09

@wannagotoaustralia

Does anyone know what I mean? A thread will say something like ‘Dog owners - I need your help’ and someone will post to say ‘well I’ve never owned a dog but I think …’

Or you get something like ‘AIBU to think Friends is really misogynistic’ and someone replies with ‘don’t know - never seen it.’ Or ‘what would you buy an eight year old boy for Christmas.’ ‘Nothing, I only know one boy and he’s two.’ Sometimes they’ll admit ‘so that doesn’t really help.’ So what’s the point? Are people just that desperate for attention?

It’s not to aid sinking threads either, it happens even on busy threads that a lot of people are enjoying.

So - AIBU to ask if you’ve noticed this and AIBU to think it’s really annoying?

I agree with you!
LemonViolet · 12/09/2021 21:07

I’ve never seen anyone post like that so I can’t say if YABU Grin

I love replies which are completely against the whole point of the thread…. like I recently started a thread about what’s your favourite posh cheese sandwich, and someone replied “none I hate cheese”……like, clearly this isn’t the thread for you!

Rogue1001 · 12/09/2021 21:06

If it wasn't equally as annoying to have posters who just basically agree with what every previous poster has written, but although they're the first to say it then I'd agree

Geamhradh · 12/09/2021 21:05

@BlairWaldorfLovesShopping

People come onto the style and beauty board all the time to tell us that we should just wear whatever we like and they don’t care what they look like as long as they are comfortable.
And that they only use a scrubbing brush and Vim yet get stopped in the street to be told how youthful they look despite being 106.
SirChenjins · 12/09/2021 21:05

There’s a good one on another thread at the moment where someone is asking if others ever feel they’re being ‘preached’ to by TV programmes, and if they also feel annoyed by it.

One person obviously has nothing to contribute because they’ve said “Get a grip, anything vaguely moral and decent seems to amount to preaching according to people like you”. Literally nothing else. I mean, where do you even go with that? 🤷‍♀️😂

TomorrowSomething · 12/09/2021 21:04

Ah sorry - I pretty much repeated Hardbackwriter there!

Hardbackwriter · 12/09/2021 21:04

@RedskyThisNight

My particular gripe is parents of toddlers wading in on teenagers threads.

If a poster says that (e.g.) their teenager refuses to brush their teeth, it's rather missing the point to tell us all that your 4 year old can do this.

It also annoys me when people give advice based on their own memories of being a child/teenager. People go on massive rants about how amazingly well behaved/polite/grateful they were, how they would have never dreamt of being rude to their mum as a teenager or causing her a moment's trouble as a toddler etc, never pausing to them 'hmm, is there any chance that my recollection here is less than 100% objective and complete?'.
TomorrowSomething · 12/09/2021 21:03

@Cocolapew

They must be the same people who post reviews on Amazon saying they haven't got the item yet or bought it for a present so can't say if it's good or not Confused.
I always assumed that Amazon sent an email or something to encourage people to participate - and some people assume it's a question addressed personally to them so feel obliged to answer. They always seem really polite too!
Hardbackwriter · 12/09/2021 21:01

@Cocolapew

They must be the same people who post reviews on Amazon saying they haven't got the item yet or bought it for a present so can't say if it's good or not Confused.
To be fair I think there is a genuine confusion for some (rather technically inept/inexperienced) people there because they get an email from Amazon 'asking them' (obviously it's actually just autogenerated) to leave a review or answer a question about the product and they think that it is actually an email specifically to them so they should reply to explain why they can't. Which is actually quite sweet, though I agree it often makes the reviews useless.
mustlovegin · 12/09/2021 21:00

Can't say I got it for my neice and I don't know if she used it yet

Grin
BlairWaldorfLovesShopping · 12/09/2021 21:00

People come onto the style and beauty board all the time to tell us that we should just wear whatever we like and they don’t care what they look like as long as they are comfortable.

thedancingbear · 12/09/2021 20:59

Haven’t got a clue. This is the first time I’ve visited this so called ‘mums net’

Annoyedanddissapointed · 12/09/2021 20:59

Little aside tho. It's like Amazon q&as😂
"Does this work well with x?"
"Can't say I got it for my neice and I don't know if she used it yet"

SirChenjins · 12/09/2021 20:59

I think they just like the attention and hope people will notice them and their pointless post. Otherwise I have no idea - I have never been able to figure it out. I’m not sure if they’re the most annoying type of poster or if it’s the ones who don’t rtft, join a long thread 20 pages in and give an response that was covered on page 2.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 12/09/2021 20:58

Sorry. Can't help