Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people wade in on threads that clearly they can’t contribute to?

159 replies

wannagotoaustralia · 12/09/2021 20:31

Does anyone know what I mean? A thread will say something like ‘Dog owners - I need your help’ and someone will post to say ‘well I’ve never owned a dog but I think …’

Or you get something like ‘AIBU to think Friends is really misogynistic’ and someone replies with ‘don’t know - never seen it.’ Or ‘what would you buy an eight year old boy for Christmas.’ ‘Nothing, I only know one boy and he’s two.’ Sometimes they’ll admit ‘so that doesn’t really help.’ So what’s the point? Are people just that desperate for attention?

It’s not to aid sinking threads either, it happens even on busy threads that a lot of people are enjoying.

So - AIBU to ask if you’ve noticed this and AIBU to think it’s really annoying?

OP posts:
slashlover · 12/09/2021 23:18

@FakeFruitShoot

On an unrelated but similar note, my DH, who is lovely and v intelligent, cannot deal with

"On a scale of 1 to 10 how likely are you to recommend The Mumsnet Co to a friend?"

Because he says his friends aren't currently buying a house / getting Sky so wouldn't discuss those sort of questions and he's not going to phone them up randomly to talk about banks. He always puts the lowest score even if the service has been amazing.

Similar to this. Grin Grin Grin
To wonder why people wade in on threads that clearly they can’t contribute to?
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/09/2021 23:18

Or someone asks how long it’s likely take for their new driving license to come in the post. Cue replies like, well I’ve no idea because neither myself nor anyone I know has applied for a new license in the last 6 years but I should think about 5 days.

Ooh, if anybody ever watches Jeremy Vine's show on Channel 5 when they have Mike Parry as a guest, he is exactly like that. Full of "Well, I should have thought that...." and "Surely a sensible person would do...." He's actually very (unintentionally) funny to watch, but probably not so much for the people in the studio (and irl) who have to act civilly towards him!

marioduck · 12/09/2021 23:17

Any doctors around to diagnose my potentially rare condition? First PP says they’re not a doctor but it sounds like a vitamin D deficiency because they had exactly the same symptoms and that’s what they had.

Come on, the problem with those threads is the question itself not the replies.

marioduck · 12/09/2021 23:14

Because some people are just here to have a chat and pass the time, rather than taking it that seriously.

Clearbloo · 12/09/2021 23:14

@FakeFruitShoot then you have people like myself who have KPIs/targets with these specific kinds of questions, where you bend over backwards trying to make sure people get good service for them to give you a low score even though they had a good experience.... where I work we are actually paid bonus (or not!) based on this "recommend a friend" question alone. Its so disheartening to read about people like your DH who, probably, have no idea about the impact of these irritating questionnaires on other people's lives! This is why I always give a 10/10 for any customer service questionnaire unless truly not deserved for some reason.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/09/2021 23:13

It’s the online equivalent of the person who imagines conversation requires them to find some personal experience or anecdote they think in some way relates to the topic you’re talking about. Unfortunately this may mean you tell them you’re studying physics and they interrupt to tell you their hairdresser’s auntie once had a budgie called Einstein.

I know they force them to do it (and those who apply to go on aren't usually the shrinkingest of violets), but I was watching a vintage gameshow on Challenge the other day (don't judge me) where one contestant's 'funny story' revolved around the fact that she'd once (probably decades previously) bought what she thought was a PAIR of shoe accessories at a jumble sale, but later discovered they were actually FOR THE SAME FOOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DameCelia · 12/09/2021 23:07

@Wainwriter reading the legal 'advice' people dish out on here is horrifying.
If you're not currently practicing in the field SHUT UP.

Bloodyavocadoagain · 12/09/2021 23:07

YANBU
It happens on so many threads in chat and AIBU in particular.

Any doctors around to diagnose my potentially rare condition? First PP says they’re not a doctor but it sounds like a vitamin D deficiency because they had exactly the same symptoms and that’s what they had.

Or someone asks how long it’s likely take for their new driving license to come in the post. Cue replies like, well I’ve no idea because neither myself nor anyone I know has applied for a new license in the last 6 years but I should think about 5 days.

What possible use do people think their reply is going to be ? That’s the problem i guess - they don’t think, they just plunge right in. Maybe they’re bored or no one asks for their opinion on anything in RL?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/09/2021 23:07

On an unrelated but similar note, my DH, who is lovely and v intelligent, cannot deal with

"On a scale of 1 to 10 how likely are you to recommend The Mumsnet Co to a friend?"*

Because he says his friends aren't currently buying a house / getting Sky so wouldn't discuss those sort of questions and he's not going to phone them up randomly to talk about banks. He always puts the lowest score even if the service has been amazing.

I sort of see where he's coming from, although I would figure that the impetus of the question was clearly assuming you would have a friend who might be interested, for the purposes of the question. The question could be better written, though.

Then again, maybe they're basing everything around a younger demographic (no offence to your DH) of people who apparently can't eat a sandwich without telling all of their friends about it. I play app games with my DS (quiz/gameshow type) and enjoy doing so, but am always open-mouthed at the end when they invite me to 'share' my (not particularly impressive) score with others. Are they trying to lose me friends by boring them all to an early grave?

Actually, Amazon do that as well, when they confirm your purchase and then urge you to tell all of your friends that you just bought an economy pack of wire coat hangers and a kitchen roll holder. Even if I were the hottest celebrity going, I still don't think the fatuous gossip mags would be in the least bit interested in reporting my latest ultra-boring purchases!

SeriouslyISuppose · 12/09/2021 23:06

It’s the online equivalent of the person who imagines conversation requires them to find some personal experience or anecdote they think in some way relates to the topic you’re talking about. Unfortunately this may mean you tell them you’re studying physics and they interrupt to tell you their hairdresser’s auntie once had a budgie called Einstein.

aliloandabanana · 12/09/2021 23:06

This annoys me too! On about every third Slimming World thread, on the dedicated Slimming World board, a poster will come on, ignore the question and tell the OP that SW is rubbish and they should just count calories. I've never checked if it's the same poster or if there's more than one, but they usually just get totally ignored.

Livvielo · 12/09/2021 23:04

@Shoxfordian

Don’t know what you mean Grin
This comment wins the internet today Grin
gogohm · 12/09/2021 22:56

It's a public forum so anyone can thread, sometimes I've had good advice/ideas from someone who is isn't a regular on a board (just saw it on active).

As for style and beauty, people offering their opinion even if it's not to your style is fine, we all have a style!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/09/2021 22:55

Didn't want to read and run OP

See, I never understand this. How would the OP ever know they’d been there…?

Virtue? Signalled!

FakeFruitShoot · 12/09/2021 22:55

On an unrelated but similar note, my DH, who is lovely and v intelligent, cannot deal with

"On a scale of 1 to 10 how likely are you to recommend The Mumsnet Co to a friend?"

Because he says his friends aren't currently buying a house / getting Sky so wouldn't discuss those sort of questions and he's not going to phone them up randomly to talk about banks. He always puts the lowest score even if the service has been amazing.

Wainwriter · 12/09/2021 22:55

YANBU

What particularly annoys me is when it's clear that it's not just a lighthearted chitchat type thread, but actually important. I saw one a while ago where the op had written two sentences and wanted to know which was correct. Can't remember exactly, but think it was for a job application or important work presentation. She posted it in pedants' corner too, so clearly targeting people who might know. The first few responses said things like 'Sentence A sounds right to me.' 'Yes, A definitely ' or even 'Not sure, but think it's A'. It wasn't. It was B. Luckily a few others later explained the correct answer but I couldn't believe that people who clearly didn't 'know' the answer decided it would be a good idea to post!

I can only imagine the horrors of the legal and medical sections if you are actually a lawyer or doctor and know what you are talking about!

Raggedyanabell · 12/09/2021 22:54

@Annoyedanddissapointed

Little aside tho. It's like Amazon q&as😂 "Does this work well with x?" "Can't say I got it for my neice and I don't know if she used it yet"
Yes!!!!! 😂 Why do they do it?!
BrightYellowDaffodil · 12/09/2021 22:54

Didn't want to read and run OP

See, I never understand this. How would the OP ever know they’d been there…?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/09/2021 22:53

I love the reviews where people rave about the best, funniest, most informative book they've ever read in their whole lives, and are amazed at just how incredibly cheap it was for such a bumper-sized serving of literary gold. And then give it one star.

Maddison12 · 12/09/2021 22:50

@Cocolapew

They must be the same people who post reviews on Amazon saying they haven't got the item yet or bought it for a present so can't say if it's good or not Confused.
Yes this is so annoying! Obviously I'm reading the reviews as I want to know if the item's any good, so "haven't had it out the box but looks good and postage was fast" is a bit pointless and unhelpful. Wait til you've used it then Confused
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/09/2021 22:50

There was a thread recently full of those of us paying tribute to and sharing memories of the work of a much-loved comedian who had just died. In amongst this, there was one person (who made sure to get in there early!) to say "Never heard of him".

Millions of other people (most of them not celebrities) died that same day - I wonder if that poster made the effort to personally show up at every one of their funerals, only to 'comfort' the grieving family and friends with the 'wise words' that she had no idea who it was who had died.

I have absolutely no interest in golf or football - I must make sure to specifically seek out some sites for fans of those sports, take the trouble to sign up and go on their forums to 'inform' them that they're all wasting their time because it's boring. Thus entirely missing the irony that they are not wasting their time, as they get a lot of pleasure from it; whereas I am thoroughly and unequivocally squandering mine Grin

Anordinarymum · 12/09/2021 22:50

Sometimes things get lost in translation

forinborin · 12/09/2021 22:48

@sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea

DP had a book published a few years ago and we love reading the 1 star reviews people have left: 'Looks great, but didn't buy it, money's a bit tight this month' (I don't know how they managed to leave review without buying it) 'Haven't had a thank you from the recipient' 'Bought five copies to give as gifts at Christmas' 'Haven't read it yet'
I think some platforms will allow you to leave a review if you bought but then cancelled before delivery. A few years ago, a relative got a one star review for a bnb they run with a "holiday got cancelled by the boss so couldn't come". Grin
forinborin · 12/09/2021 22:43

I think they could be chatbots in training.

DocAutumn · 12/09/2021 22:37

Nothing more annoying than the thread police.