Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people wade in on threads that clearly they can’t contribute to?

159 replies

wannagotoaustralia · 12/09/2021 20:31

Does anyone know what I mean? A thread will say something like ‘Dog owners - I need your help’ and someone will post to say ‘well I’ve never owned a dog but I think …’

Or you get something like ‘AIBU to think Friends is really misogynistic’ and someone replies with ‘don’t know - never seen it.’ Or ‘what would you buy an eight year old boy for Christmas.’ ‘Nothing, I only know one boy and he’s two.’ Sometimes they’ll admit ‘so that doesn’t really help.’ So what’s the point? Are people just that desperate for attention?

It’s not to aid sinking threads either, it happens even on busy threads that a lot of people are enjoying.

So - AIBU to ask if you’ve noticed this and AIBU to think it’s really annoying?

OP posts:
swimlyn · 13/09/2021 14:30

I don’t think they’re sneaky.

Clicking their email launches a website page immediately showing a text box. When you type your answer, before publication you get a confirmation along the lines of “Your comments will be published with the username JBloggs”

You can back out at any stage.

RandomLondoner · 13/09/2021 13:49

I think some people think everything is addressed to them personally.

I think with Amazon questions you don't have to be stupid or a technophobe to think this. You receive an email in which you are being directly asked a question. It's perfectly normal to reply a direct question with a direct answer. The responses would be perfectly sensible if replying just meant an email went to the asker. It's only Amazons sneaky behind-the-scenes software publishing the answer on their site that contextualises the response in such a way as to make the respondent look gormless.

swimlyn · 13/09/2021 13:33

Don’t forget the posters that post repetitively saying the same thing.

They appear to want everyone else to agree with their view on an issue, and they are going to keep saying it again and again and again and again and again…

It never works of course and usually kills a good thread.

This applies a lot to political discussion, the 'trans widows gang', and more recently anything SIDS related. Destroying intelligent discussion regularly. Such a shame.

Say your bit and leave it. Discuss points raised that are connected to the topic. Fine.

Bang on and on and on tediously. Not fine.

YouTubeAddict · 13/09/2021 11:56

So annoying!

Plus…’following’

Youcancallmeval · 13/09/2021 10:44

Read a thread yesterday where someone did make a helpful comment and the OP kicked off because it wasn't what she had specifically asked, which changed the tone of the thread somewhat.

DustyMaiden · 13/09/2021 10:23

Amazon actually email you asking the question.

TheCheeseBadge · 13/09/2021 10:23

@Annoyedanddissapointed I agree that that is the case with some responses, but a lot of them were along the lines of "Well women in America manage it so you could as well". The OP had showed no interest in going back to work before her leave was due to end, she wanted to know if she was being treated unfairly.

If you're dishing out legal advice (which is what the OP was asking for!), you should probably clarify which country your "advice" applies to.

Mrsfrumble · 13/09/2021 10:20

This sort of thing is why the SN topics are “hidden” and don’t appear in Active Convos, isn’t it? Because someone would post about their autistic child’s restricted eating or whatever, and some twat with no experience of ASD would roll up and say “well MY child loves their veggies! You need to be more strict! No healthy child ever starved themselves and there were no picky eaters in my day!” Hmm

BlackberrySky · 13/09/2021 10:13

I find it odd when people come onto a thread 16 pages in with
"I haven't RTFT, but have you tried (insert most blindingly obvious suggestion that was covered in the first three responses)"

Annoyedanddissapointed · 13/09/2021 10:10

@TheCheeseBadge I think that's due to mix of people from different countries. As I understand maternity leave in US is essentially non existent. Elsewhere, where I am from, it's years and years for a change.
It's like woth doscrimination in general. US laws are totally different to UK laws but that doesn't stop people claiming wrong stuff for the country

3cats2kids1dog · 13/09/2021 10:07

It's the wild extrapolators who amaze me.... who seem unable to grasp that opinions vary on most subjects and one opinion on something does not define either the person or all similar persons
OP: Should i use plain or self-raising flour in my scones
Extrapolator: If you use anything other than plain flour, you must by a puppy-killing, brexit-voting, woman-hating, thicko who just doesn't really understand recipes. Also stupid.

CounsellorTroi · 13/09/2021 10:06

@Returnoftheowl

Haha, I've definitely seem that on The Doghouse board... Someone asks for advice about a certain aspect of the dog, someone else wades in with "I hate dogs, you should get rid of it". What use is that?! I'm not a fan of horses, so I don't frequent the Tack Room board!
It’s similar to when someone starts a thread asking a question specifically aimed at childless/childfreee people, you always get parents wading in. Always.
TheCheeseBadge · 13/09/2021 10:05

I remember a thread where the OP was quite clearly experiencing discrimination while she was on Maternity Leave.

The first 20 or so posts were all of the same ilk: "well you decided to have a baby, why should the employer accommodate your maternity leave", "it is possible to go back to work 2 weeks after you've had a baby, you know". None of them had any idea that maternity rights are protected by law, or seemingly that we are not in 1980 any more. I was utterly gobsmacked to witness that attitude on a parenting site - these were women that were commenting, perfectly happy for a woman to continue to be discriminated against because her "poor" employer has to keep her job open for her while she has the gall to have a baby.

Thankfully some people who talked sense came on and the OP ended up getting some actual good advice.

rookiemere · 13/09/2021 10:02

@PullMeInToTheScreenYY - DM is rude and disrespectful and expects me to do all her personal care- Response : if only my beloved DM were alive today, I'd gladly wash her feet.

PullMeInToTheScreen · 13/09/2021 10:00

YANBU op, it's rude, annoying and stupid.

Another bugbear is people projecting so much from their own experiences/ feelings they basically say the op is lying.

Eg "I really want to see my sister on Christmas day but she's 5000 miles away, I live in a homeless shelter with no money and have a fear of flying and she will be working on Xmas day anyway"
Posters: "well you clearly don't want to see her OP"

Etc...

LolaButt · 13/09/2021 09:50

Lived experience means nothing on MN.

Because some know it all will come along and argue with you that your lived experience is wrong, despite them never having dealt with the same issue.

Key phrase - know it all’s know fuck all.

PinniGig · 13/09/2021 09:44

I love Amazon reviews and answers to questions other people have posted.

Q “Does this product work?”

A “Well my order only arrived today and is still in the packaging but I think it works”

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/09/2021 09:39

I don't mind useless responses as much as I do those who wade into a long running thread with a generally wordy response based purely on the OP, blithely ignoring any updates from them. Or worse based on the title without reading even the first post.
I mean how arrogant do you have to be to do that ?

Shocking, isn't it? Can you imagine how these same people would react if the GP completely ignored them talking about their arthritis symptoms and then just suggested eating more fruit and veg; or the garage recommending checking the oil and coolant instead of listening when you're trying to tell them about the brake pads grinding?

Interestingly, they usually claim they 'don't have time for that' - if their time is at such a premium and so stretched already, it's not mandatory (or probably very wise) to come on any forum at all in the first place!

I think these are the sort of people that the red-top and gossip magazines' headlines are aimed at, when they scream about some bog star or another "Chris tells Hannah that he's leaving!!!" and it turns out to be a pathetic non-story about how he phones her at the end of his working day to let her know he's on his way home.

sst1234 · 13/09/2021 09:24

There is a thread running right this minute in the property section which is on 17 pages now, which is rare for any thread on that board. OP has put rightmove link for her house and asked for feedback on why she is struggling for offers. Some mod the responses are a perfect example of what’s been discussed here. People coming along and saying ‘I don’t know your area but for that price I would expect something like this (100 miles away’. Or saying, ‘for the price, I would expect X,Y,Z’, as though you get the same house for one price all over the country. Other priceless comments include, ‘oh I would expect a property over million pounds to be in London, you are far outside of London’. Honestly, people really believe that there are no million pounds houses outside London. Feel sorry for OP, as she has had more curtain twitcher type comments than helpful ones.

SirChenjins · 13/09/2021 08:47

@rookiemere

I don't mind useless responses as much as I do those who wade into a long running thread with a generally wordy response based purely on the OP, blithely ignoring any updates from them. Or worse based on the title without reading even the first post. I mean how arrogant do you have to be to do that ?
Oh YY to this. MN now has this really useful thing where you can see everything that the OP has written - you don't even have to rtft any more to see their updates if you don't want to - but oh no, poster after poster offering pointless advice. It should be grounds for being banned permanently from MN.
rookiemere · 13/09/2021 08:19

I don't mind useless responses as much as I do those who wade into a long running thread with a generally wordy response based purely on the OP, blithely ignoring any updates from them. Or worse based on the title without reading even the first post.
I mean how arrogant do you have to be to do that ?

TheNatureOfTheCatastrophe · 13/09/2021 08:15

I get that sometimes it's a valid S&B opinion to say that the OP should give a style a swerve if it's never going to suit her, or that you personally prefer to plough your own furrow. Very few S&Bistas will follow every single trend (I'm not sure any of them ever wore a cold shoulder top).

But if the OP clearly does care about where a particular look is placed on the fashion cycle the "why on earth would you even care?" response is both unhelpful and insulting.

WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow · 13/09/2021 08:14

I think a lot of them just do it to be obnoxious tbh. The amount of bitch plopping you see in eg the Christmas topic. I mean it’s a topic for people who want to discuss Christmas at any time of the year, usually a friendly, chatty place. If you’re not interested in thinking about Christmas until 22nd of December that’s fine but jumping into threads to Hmm Hmm Confused Confused at the very idea that some people do look forward to it and put a lot of effort into making it special is just being a dick.

Extra dick points for those who mosey in to accuse anybody giving dc something more than a pair of charity shop knickers for Christmas of destroying the environment.

LeonardLikesThisPost · 13/09/2021 08:03

To be fair, with the S & B one, you can love clothes (hence frequent S & B board) but not be into fashion.

So when someone says something like "I love skinny jeans and they suit me, they're out so can't wear them any more 😭 but I look shit in mom jeans, how can I look less shit in these horrid things???" Then yes, someone will suggest it's OK for the poster to wear what she likes and not slavishly follow fashion diktats. That's just discussion.

wannagotoaustralia · 13/09/2021 08:02

There are loads of chat threads, though. There is absolutely no need to barge in on someone needing advice with ‘I’m a SAHM’.

OP posts: