Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people wade in on threads that clearly they can’t contribute to?

159 replies

wannagotoaustralia · 12/09/2021 20:31

Does anyone know what I mean? A thread will say something like ‘Dog owners - I need your help’ and someone will post to say ‘well I’ve never owned a dog but I think …’

Or you get something like ‘AIBU to think Friends is really misogynistic’ and someone replies with ‘don’t know - never seen it.’ Or ‘what would you buy an eight year old boy for Christmas.’ ‘Nothing, I only know one boy and he’s two.’ Sometimes they’ll admit ‘so that doesn’t really help.’ So what’s the point? Are people just that desperate for attention?

It’s not to aid sinking threads either, it happens even on busy threads that a lot of people are enjoying.

So - AIBU to ask if you’ve noticed this and AIBU to think it’s really annoying?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SchadenfreudePersonified · 14/09/2021 19:27

if I find a recipe online I like the look of, I check the comments to see if anyone has actually made the dish and can confirm the recipe works. What I usually find, especially on US sites, is a long succession of people saying 'Looks great! I'll be trying this out real soon!' dated eight years ago. Did they try it? Was it so awful that they actually died as a result, and that's why they didn't come back to tell us what it was like?

That's something I always wonder, too! Grin

Lndnmummy · 14/09/2021 12:14

It happens all the time on boards or topics raised by people of colour. OP will say “To parents of black children how do you find.....”. Parents of black children tend to respond and then comes the “my children are white but I think it’s a non issue to have white plasters/tights/monkey stickers are not outrageous” etc. It’s exhausting and infuriating.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 14/09/2021 12:06

@Marcee

This is an online site. People can los8t what they want as long as within the guidelines
Just because they CAN doesn't always mean they SHOULD.
Holly60 · 14/09/2021 12:00

I’ve never seen a thread like that so I can’t help you Grin

SchadenfreudePersonified · 14/09/2021 11:59

@SirChenjins

I think they just like the attention and hope people will notice them and their pointless post. Otherwise I have no idea - I have never been able to figure it out. I’m not sure if they’re the most annoying type of poster or if it’s the ones who don’t rtft, join a long thread 20 pages in and give an response that was covered on page 2.
Mrsfrumble · 13/09/2021 20:24

The problem is that if a thread makes it into Active Conversations, a lot of posters don’t pay any attention to which topic was originally posted in before wading in; hence canine phobics in Doghouse threads etc.

That’s why the Special Needs topics now don’t appear in Active Convos as I mentioned upthread, as too many people were posting irrelevant or judgmental responses without understanding or respecting the context of the thread.

Potplant · 13/09/2021 20:03

Twins threads.

Well mine are 15 months apart so this is what I would do. ITS NOT THE SAME

Iamthewombat · 13/09/2021 18:03

I’ve seen some fantastically awful financial advice on here (I’m an accountant). All dispensed by people who don’t really understand finance but that’s what their hairdresser’s boyfriend’s dad does so it must work, right?

Eg stretch yourself to the absolute limit to buy the most expensive house you can, borrow over 40 years, it will be worth it, it was for my auntie in 1995, never mind pension contributions, your house is your pension and you can’t lose blah blah.

Or people who post sage, nose tapping statements that, if they took two minutes to think about, they would realise are entirely misconceived.

Eg, re Victoria Beckham’s excuse for a business which has incurred tens of millions of losses since incorporation. But that’s OK, according to the Mumsnet Warren Buffetts. Because it’s tax losses, see? Yeah, tax losses. They don’t count.

Entirely failing to grasp that a loss is still a loss and that the tax saving on it is only a percentage of that loss, just as tax on income is only a percentage of the income. So a loss of £1m would save you, er £190k with corporation tax at 19%. Never mind that though, eh? Keep tapping the noses and giving us your unique financial insights.

lurkingfromhome · 13/09/2021 17:44

@Wainwriter

YANBU

What particularly annoys me is when it's clear that it's not just a lighthearted chitchat type thread, but actually important. I saw one a while ago where the op had written two sentences and wanted to know which was correct. Can't remember exactly, but think it was for a job application or important work presentation. She posted it in pedants' corner too, so clearly targeting people who might know. The first few responses said things like 'Sentence A sounds right to me.' 'Yes, A definitely ' or even 'Not sure, but think it's A'. It wasn't. It was B. Luckily a few others later explained the correct answer but I couldn't believe that people who clearly didn't 'know' the answer decided it would be a good idea to post!

I can only imagine the horrors of the legal and medical sections if you are actually a lawyer or doctor and know what you are talking about!

This!! Why do so many posters feel the need to answer questions on slightly specialist subjects that they know the square root of fuck all about. The grammar ones make me cringe (I write grammar books). "Hmm, I'm not sure OP but sentence A sounds right to me, so I'm saying that's the one that's correct". "Definitely A is right because [makes up some non-existent rule of syntax]". No, love, it really isn't.

If I came across a post from someone asking a question to do with biology, or brain surgery, or carpentry, or farming, or line drawing, or psychiatry, or coding, I would NOT POST. Because I don't know the first arsing thing about any of those subjects.

SirChenjins · 13/09/2021 17:32

@barbrahunter

i must admit that I'm not keen on the sanctimonious posters, for example some poor soul posts that she's desperate because her 'D'H is treating her badly in some way, and then someone posts 'well I wouldn't let him treat me like that', or 'well what did you expect if you married someone like him?'
I agree. I also dislike the ‘why haven’t you left the bastard already’ posts as if it’s the simplest thing in the world to financially, emotionally, physically and mentally split up - and then get really ratty with the OP who hasn’t managed to ‘get their ducks in a row’ by the end of the thread. Sometimes it’s like watching vultures descend.
alloalloallo · 13/09/2021 17:28

^My particular gripe is parents of toddlers wading in on teenagers threads.*

If a poster says that (e.g.) their teenager refuses to brush their teeth, it's rather missing the point to tell us all that your 4 year old can do this.

OMG! yes!

I remember posting on a teens thread once - a kind of “survivors of teens” thread - that my then 16 year old DD’s bedroom was a complete skip and I was completely fed up with it

Lots of helpful posts from parents of 3 year olds who make tidying up a game and their kid loves to help mummy clean - yeah, so did mine, when she was 3 Hmm.

SmellyOldOwls · 13/09/2021 17:22

@Threewheeler1

The weight threads annoy me. Someone explains that they're doing all the right things but struggling with losing weight. Poster comes along and details how they've managed to stay the same weight since they were 18 and didn't put on any excess weight in pregnancy or menopause, don't watch what they eat, don't really exercise but are just really 'lucky' to be slim. Great. Super helpful.
There's always someone too who says 'eat less, move more, it really is that simple' IS IT AYE
SmellyOldOwls · 13/09/2021 17:21

@barbrahunter

i must admit that I'm not keen on the sanctimonious posters, for example some poor soul posts that she's desperate because her 'D'H is treating her badly in some way, and then someone posts 'well I wouldn't let him treat me like that', or 'well what did you expect if you married someone like him?'
Yes there's always one who chimes in with 'why did you marry a man child OP my husband would never dream of setting the dishes beside the dishwasher'
SmellyOldOwls · 13/09/2021 17:11

@RedskyThisNight

My particular gripe is parents of toddlers wading in on teenagers threads.

If a poster says that (e.g.) their teenager refuses to brush their teeth, it's rather missing the point to tell us all that your 4 year old can do this.

Haha. I love these posters. 'Surely if my 13 week old goes to bed without complaint, your 5 year old can! You just need to be firm!'
Annoyedanddissapointed · 13/09/2021 17:10

@simitra

The ones which really get on my nerves are when some troll completely ignores the actual question being asked or debated. Instead they deliberately de-contextualise a word or phrase that the OP or a previous poster has used in their discussion. They then wade in to deliberately attempt to waylay the discussion with an accusation of "thats ageist/racist/homophobic" or whatever.

These are usually people with a grasshopper mentality who lack the facility to debate any subject in a balanced manner.

I rolled my eyes so hard at this sometimes I considered booking an optician check up...
barbrahunter · 13/09/2021 17:06

i must admit that I'm not keen on the sanctimonious posters, for example some poor soul posts that she's desperate because her 'D'H is treating her badly in some way, and then someone posts
'well I wouldn't let him treat me like that', or
'well what did you expect if you married someone like him?'

sweatervest · 13/09/2021 17:01

i am laughing out loud at this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

especially the "didn't want to read and run" thing .... who gives a shiny if someone's read and ran?! would people otherwise just read the message and get to the last full stop and just rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrun out of the room/house/continent etc etc.

i love this kind of thread. (fyi)

DomingoinLittleOakley · 13/09/2021 16:42

It's not something I could get worked up about OP.
Grin

MrsWinkly · 13/09/2021 16:05

The weight threads annoy me.
Someone explains that they're doing all the right things but struggling with losing weight. Poster comes along and details how they've managed to stay the same weight since they were 18 and didn't put on any excess weight in pregnancy or menopause, don't watch what they eat, don't really exercise but are just really 'lucky' to be slim.
Great. Super helpful.

Returnoftheowl · 13/09/2021 15:56

@SquirryTheSquirrel

If your thread is in AIBU or Chat I think it's reasonable to expect anyone might chip in with an opinion - you can ignore posters whose experience isn't relevant.

If you post in a more specialist topic, you are less likely to get random opinions, so my advice would be to try to find a topic matching your query or the issue you want to discuss.

But this doesn't stop people!

I post on the Doghouse board...a board solely about dogs/dog ownership etc. I'm always surprised at the number of people who take the time to come into a dog specific board just to leave a comment about how much they dislike dogs and that they don't understand why anyone would have one as a pet. What are they gaining from that?!

MattDamon · 13/09/2021 15:51

@TheCheeseBadge

I remember a thread where the OP was quite clearly experiencing discrimination while she was on Maternity Leave.

The first 20 or so posts were all of the same ilk: "well you decided to have a baby, why should the employer accommodate your maternity leave", "it is possible to go back to work 2 weeks after you've had a baby, you know". None of them had any idea that maternity rights are protected by law, or seemingly that we are not in 1980 any more. I was utterly gobsmacked to witness that attitude on a parenting site - these were women that were commenting, perfectly happy for a woman to continue to be discriminated against because her "poor" employer has to keep her job open for her while she has the gall to have a baby.

Thankfully some people who talked sense came on and the OP ended up getting some actual good advice.

It's the same with 90% of child maintenance threads. OP will reveal her ex makes 6 figures and should she request an increase to reflect that?

Cue huge pile on of hard scrabble mums who managed to survive on a fiver a week from their feckless exes and anyone who needs more than that is somehow 'greedy'.

JaneJeffer · 13/09/2021 15:41

The worst is when you post a proven fact with links and everything and someone still tries to tell you it's wrong in a really sneering way and then their "mate" comes to join in.

incognitodorrito · 13/09/2021 15:32

Just wanted to add that i have also nothing to add really.

simitra · 13/09/2021 15:28

The ones which really get on my nerves are when some troll completely ignores the actual question being asked or debated. Instead they deliberately de-contextualise a word or phrase that the OP or a previous poster has used in their discussion. They then wade in to deliberately attempt to waylay the discussion with an accusation of "thats ageist/racist/homophobic" or whatever.

These are usually people with a grasshopper mentality who lack the facility to debate any subject in a balanced manner.

SureOfcourseIChanged · 13/09/2021 15:11

This reminds me of something I've needed to get off my chest for years.

I knew one woman on FB from back in the day who ALWAYS shared with us in her comments that she was off to do x and would be back to read the OP properly and reply. It was a grande version of "Didn't want to read and run" (She did that too).
It was a group and amongst people commenting away, she'd grace the thread with her "I just took 5 seconds to look at my computer, I'm leaving with my daughter/son to ride a bike/take a walk/pick flowers/mow the lawn/do a bake sale/chair a meeting with the President of Y. I'll be back shortly to reply. [No response from anyone]

Then...

'Right I'm back from my rather oh so busy day and I've now had time to sit with a cuppa and ponder over your question [which had gotten tons of comments already and no one seemed to notice her painful absence]. Now read my priceless gem of a comment...'

Sometimes, she'd write what others have already written. Other times, she'd have something good to add but it always ticked me off that she had to announce her ever-so busy life before and after, as if anyone asked or cared and she took the threads as if they're her personal Q and A sessions. Didn't help that she had a few minions in their clique who lapped up her every word but most people never responded to her self-important soliloquy. She'd been one of the oldest members so seemed like she'd appointed herself the guru of information and president of comments in the group.

And Breathe! I feel better.

Sorry, OP, can't be of any help to your dh problem. Mine is a humble cyclist! You can get your ducks in a row though.