Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't like being preached at in TV shows

263 replies

NutellaEllaElla · 12/09/2021 19:09

Is it just me? Has it always been this way? There seems to be a moral to every story. Try not to judge my TV watching habits Grin but i'm thinking Grey's Anatomy, The Good Doctor, New Amsterdam. There's probably more i'm not thinking of right now. Was it always so heavy handed on social issues?

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 13/09/2021 08:24

Just rewatched Sweet Tooth on Netflix. Its so bloody cute, and at the same time vomit-inducingly woke Envy (not envy)

LoislovesStewie · 13/09/2021 08:13

Another vote for Countryfile not being fit for purpose. I can almost see the presenter wagging his/her finger telling me I've been a naughty girl.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 08:08

Country file is no longer for farmers, but for city folk who want to preach to country folk. Actual farmers stopped watching when it moved to evenings!

What do we fund all this stuff for? We are idiots paying tax, license fees, service users if stats brands or buying brands, using business and they think we are just there passive to be lectured to, think and do as they tell us to and give them power and money, Harry expected it as a Royal and now he is entitled to being able to do the same as an independent, monetising his brand. We are in a duo capitalist and state tyranny, and many don't accept that we are.

SaskiaRembrandt · 13/09/2021 08:07

@Pedalpushers

People mentioning sci fi and zombie films as an escape, which are both generally metaphors for society and its issues...Hmm
Yes they are, and the word metaphor is key. Horror generally has always dealt with social issues but managed to do it in a way that doesn't leave the audience feeling like they've been preached at.
mellongoose · 13/09/2021 07:58

He-Man always had a lesson at the end that made 9yo me cringe.

Country file is no longer for farmers, but for city folk who want to preach to country folk. Actual farmers stopped watching when it moved to evenings!

LoislovesStewie · 13/09/2021 07:32

I thought it was just me who thought that! YANBU!!! Sometimes I want to be just entertained, I mean just taken out of the everyday world, so I can escape, is that too much?

Sagaz · 13/09/2021 07:07

@ElizaBenson

Greys anatomy is a shondaland programme, to be fair with those you know what you are getting, strong black characters, particularly black women, usually tons of sex and some strong messages, if you don't like her programmes there are plenty of others to watch, personally I love them (although sometimes the sheer amount of sex is boring...) maybe you just aren't the target audience and should try something else?
I know, i watch greys with my dd and i had to do my own ""framing". Id say "oh! In to the supply room! Sex at work !!! What a risk? " It was really bad for a few seasons. If a pair liked each other they were straight in to the supply cupboard. I had to point out to my dd that in real life if a man offered you sex in a supply cupboard you might be less than delighted. Chances are that'd be followed by six months of awkwardness. When characters actually suggested a date, id say oh good! Start with DINNER! See how that goes before you fumble in the supply cupboard.
TheChiefJo · 13/09/2021 03:10

There was always a little lesson at the end of Trapdoor. Berk (Willie Rushton) would sum up like 'don't throw away the things you've got or then you won't av em anymore' Grin

silentpool · 13/09/2021 01:26

I've stopped watching a lot of them. I'm quite happy if they introduce a diverse cast and raise issues in a natural way but recently I feel as if I'm being lectured rather than entertained.

burnoutbabe · 12/09/2021 23:31

Quite a lot of shows in the last year I watch (greys anatomy and the rookie) have become much more focussed on black issues which makes sense based on the casts and show runners but just a change from earlier episodes. But these writers have a platform and are just doing what they think is the best thing they can do. Sometimes it feels a bit forced but that just needs better writing at times. Better than in greys doctors discussing their sex lives in front of the patient and colleagues!

Kindlethefourth · 12/09/2021 23:31

New Amsterdam season 1 was ace. Season 2 did a great job despite the pandemic but the new season.......I wouldn't call it preachy but just huge clunking 'issues' with no subtly or character development. Character has a biscuit in desk drawer-cue binge eating disorder for him. Character takes a painkiller. Cue painkiller addiction for her. Max the doctor has radical new idea to solve every problem in the history of the world. Someone wise looks like a killjoy and points out flaw in his plan. Max gradually realises the flaw and works together with killjoy and together they solve the crisis..........then gazes into the eyes of Martha from Dr. Who as part of the will they won't they plot which they will extend until the ratings drop. Yet I will still watch it all Hmm

takehomepay · 12/09/2021 23:31

@Libraryghost

But *@takehomepay* what do you think it achieves? A racist person is not going to stop being racist because an Arab family is in Corrie or a black person is in an advert.
I'm not talking about ads, I don't watch much live telly so can't comment but positive representation of Muslims/Asians and other minorities in TV programmes is really important, it's important for minorities to be able to watch people like them on TV.
Libraryghost · 12/09/2021 23:25

But @takehomepay what do you think it achieves? A racist person is not going to stop being racist because an Arab family is in Corrie or a black person is in an advert.

TaraR2020 · 12/09/2021 23:22

I stopped watching New Amsterdam when I realised that what they actually wanted was socialised healthcare and yet for some reason Americans are so against it. Began to find it a bit infuriating!

Libraryghost · 12/09/2021 23:22

@GrolliffetheDragon what a black person will not buy a bog roll unless they are featured in the advert? A white person will stop watching sky because it’s got Idris Elba promoting it? Can’t watch Sky , it’s for black folks. Now that’s racist!

takehomepay · 12/09/2021 23:22

[quote Libraryghost]@takehomepay I havent seen the programme you are talking about. It’s a ubiquitous storyline. I have seen it a million times. That is the point I am making, it’s the same moralistic story over and over again. As for the UK being racist I would never deny there are racist people but I actually thing the majority are not. The outcry over racist tweets to footballers etc proves that most of are fundamentally decent. While tv dramas and adverts should most definitely be inclusive they also need to be realistic and less preachy. A racist will not see a mixed race couple in an advert and suddenly not become racist- they are preaching to the wrong people.[/quote]
I haven't seen that trope a lot (just in Transplant) but I don't think there has been much representation of Muslims/Asians/Arabs to date, and hopefully that will change.

Whilst it was good to see the outcry over racist tweets, it really doesn't mean that most BAME people don't experience racism in their every day lives. They absolutely do. It really is everywhere.

Libraryghost · 12/09/2021 23:19

When I was a kid in the 80s watching Grange Hill and the ‘Just say no’ storylines about drugs it always made me want to try drugs. I really do not like being preached to 😂

GrolliffetheDragon · 12/09/2021 23:18

@Libraryghost

The other one is the adverts. Every single couple is in a mixed race marriage. I don’t give a damn about mixed race marriages and I don’t think the majority do but please give it a break - most of the UK are not racist and do not need to be preached at. It’s like they daren’t have a white couple in case someone thinks they are not being inclusive.
Alternatively, perhaps having a black person in the advert means that black people are more likely to purchase the product?

As for racism, there is plenty of it in the UK. Just sticking with the theme of the thread, I've seen plenty of racism from a vocal minority of Doctor Who fans who strongly objected to Yaz and Ryan because they weren't white.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 12/09/2021 23:18

I think everyone is a bit abilest and I say this as a disabled person. Surely there is an evolutionary revulsion of illness that we saw the past year or so, revolt response is apparently stronger in women. Most people don't on a basic level want to get sick and die, and there is in some people a waryness that they don't want to catch what others have, you can see people relax when I tell them what I have isn't catching. I don't mind.

I think most people are a little bit racist, evolunatory tribes had to protect their resources to survive, you see it with rivalry between regions and counties in England and the French type jokes. Apparently it's tribal and very emotional people who are into football teams because they feel they belong to a big group and get to let off emotional steam.

We all know Harry's history in the army and environment yet he is telling all of us off.

I have had enough of it all. Who hasn't bought something that came from china, been in a flight, eaten Quinoa etc, and how can they say they are perfect environmentally? Who can say they didn't cheer an Olympic athlete who shares their nationality? People avoided others , took vaccinre and wear masks out of choice since March 2020 in varying ways because they don't want long covid or to be on a ventilator, they don't want to be disabled.

mustlovegin · 12/09/2021 23:14

It’s like the programme makers have a specific ratio they have to adhere to. It doesn’t seem inclusive, just contrived.

I think it's good to include everyone.

The problem is that they are getting the proportions wrong in relation to the UK market. I wonder if they care about the fact that 80%+ of the people they are trying to sell to cannot see themselves identified in their ads at all (as they appear to always be leaving out certain majority groups)

Libraryghost · 12/09/2021 23:13

@takehomepay I havent seen the programme you are talking about. It’s a ubiquitous storyline. I have seen it a million times. That is the point I am making, it’s the same moralistic story over and over again. As for the UK being racist I would never deny there are racist people but I actually thing the majority are not. The outcry over racist tweets to footballers etc proves that most of are fundamentally decent. While tv dramas and adverts should most definitely be inclusive they also need to be realistic and less preachy. A racist will not see a mixed race couple in an advert and suddenly not become racist- they are preaching to the wrong people.

MinesAMassiveSalad · 12/09/2021 23:11

The problem is bad writing.
And yes the adverts too lack subtlety and humour.

mustlovegin · 12/09/2021 23:08

I think if kids are watching stuff like Doctor who, which I kinda think it's for, then it's great to have strong moral messages

Morality is not a universally uncontested concept. We all hold our own views on different matters and rightly so - some opinions being more widely shared than others.

Perhaps Dr Who is an opportunity to teach our children what brainwashing looks like and the importance of critical and independent thinking.

takehomepay · 12/09/2021 22:57

@Libraryghost

The other one is the adverts. Every single couple is in a mixed race marriage. I don’t give a damn about mixed race marriages and I don’t think the majority do but please give it a break - most of the UK are not racist and do not need to be preached at. It’s like they daren’t have a white couple in case someone thinks they are not being inclusive.
On the contrary, the UK does have a racism problem, it's just more covert than in the US.
takehomepay · 12/09/2021 22:56

@Libraryghost

I think what I object to is the assumption that everyone is a racist bigot, a chauvinist pig, homophobic etc etc. The moral of the story is that the refugee always becomes a doctor and saves the bigot etc etc. Actually most people are not bigoted and don’t need to be taught otherwise. It’s so transparent!
Do you mean the programme Transplant? I think it's refreshing to have an Arab Muslim character (and a refugee to boot) as the lead in a prime time show, and not playing a terrorist.

it's sad that it has taken decades for this to happen and yet your response is a dismissive 'the moral of the story is that the refugee always becomes a doctor and saves the bigot'.