Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't like being preached at in TV shows

263 replies

NutellaEllaElla · 12/09/2021 19:09

Is it just me? Has it always been this way? There seems to be a moral to every story. Try not to judge my TV watching habits Grin but i'm thinking Grey's Anatomy, The Good Doctor, New Amsterdam. There's probably more i'm not thinking of right now. Was it always so heavy handed on social issues?

OP posts:
SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 14:13

I'm a bit confused, are those the only options? grin

Seems so, you are either some version of evil if you don't follow the Quazi religious acts of penance or be a great person because you believe, think and do things in the exact woke puritan way.

They demand you "be kind" in exactly a certain way including telling lies, don't travel unless walking in recycled shoes or on a bicycle, don't buy anything new, don't see anyone in person, spend half your day trying to repurpose everything you can, spend goodness knows how long reading an approved list of books to educate yourself, spend ages examining your self and be mindful of loving yourself only and nobody else, the you must love others more than yourself as they must be loved more than anyone else due to their special oppression points, then you have to work out where you sit on the hirarcy and check your privilege and spend a long time examining your bias, beat yourself up and then you must finally spend time watching screens being told off by the people on screen about how dreadful you are and how you must do what the people on screen are telling you to do as if they are the local Vicar or Tyrant. Then anyons who works for the state and gets compensation via salary and a pension is a living saint who is perfect and makes no mistakes and must be venerated as extra special, you have to get out the oil to massage their egos or they will be butt hurt feel a victum and moan how they are not appreciated.

or some kind of saint.

Ireolu · 13/09/2021 14:02

I can barely watch law and order SVU. Very topical and not always well executed. It's not what I want from a TV show. I want to be able to switch off from it all.

sloanerangerpandora · 13/09/2021 14:00

The climate change advert with the overly smug kids.

TreeSmuggler · 13/09/2021 13:53

Is this a new thing? I think it's always been around, hence why the "I guess we all learned something today" joke on South Park has been funny for 25 years.

New Amsterdam is no comparison to the great medical shows like ER and Greys (early seasons) and seems to be mainly about moralising. However I will give it two things. 1) It never pretended to be anything else. 2) It does try to explore issues, often the main character (very woke) ends up making things worse and realises there are things he hasn't considered.

Nietzschethehiker · 13/09/2021 13:35

I completely agree OP. I spend all day professionally talking about "the big issues". I spent decades working in roles that heavily dealt with some awful issues. When I watch TV I want to watch something that allows me a moments respite.

I'm self aware enough to fully understand that my seemingly odd (to the outside world) love of specifically dystopia post apocalyptic zombie films is because , whilst I agree they are usually intended as a metaphor for social issues , I choose to watch them on a level that I can appreciate a world where choices become easy because they are life or death. A world where the stresses and norms of society distill down into a very simple choice of live or die.

Given that I spend my entire life navigating a neuro diverse family through " normal" and somewhat judgemental society , a break from that, life to be simple (if dangerous) is attractive.

Of course I don't really want the world to be in peril and zombies are so ridiculous that it's not a likely threat means I get a moment to imagine life without the convoluted stresses and strains of expectations, without the nagging concern it could actually happen.

If I wanted to moralise I would work, or study. When I watch TV I don't want to think about the real world. I don't actually watch anything else so its fairly obvious why I do.

Totally ridiculous to claim that anyone who uses TV as entertainment avoids anything moral and positive but given the username for the initial negative post I can guess why it was said.

NutellaEllaElla · 13/09/2021 13:14

@SunIsBehindGreySky

It helps nobody and just serves to annoy most people or make the rest think they're saving the world by watching telly!!!

I was talking to a woman who told me she is a witch, she said she is inundated with young females wanting to be a witch also, she said most of them want to curse people, then said she doesn't teach that.

I guess people sat on the sofa feeling they are achieving some sort of utopia is preferable to groups of young women trying to do bad things to people.

I'm a bit confused, are those the only options? Grin
OP posts:
SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 13:11

It helps nobody and just serves to annoy most people or make the rest think they're saving the world by watching telly!!!

I was talking to a woman who told me she is a witch, she said she is inundated with young females wanting to be a witch also, she said most of them want to curse people, then said she doesn't teach that.

I guess people sat on the sofa feeling they are achieving some sort of utopia is preferable to groups of young women trying to do bad things to people.

NutellaEllaElla · 13/09/2021 13:11

That's the thing isn't it. It doesn't convert anyone. It either patronises the right-on or makes them feel self righteous. People who don't agree 1. Probably aren't watching and 2. Wouldn't change their mind anyway

OP posts:
rainbowmash · 13/09/2021 13:07

Agree. I'm a self-proclaimed Social Justice bore... but I hate the heavy-handed issue peddling. It helps nobody and just serves to annoy most people or make the rest think they're saving the world by watching telly!!!

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 12:05

Just attempt to make me part with my cash via a nice advert for your product

Yes, they ignore the product completely and just preach. It's irritating

WineByTheSea · 13/09/2021 11:50

I also feel that Greys has got really heavy handed with the lecturing. And Station 19 is the worst. The writing is so bad, I don’t mind the moral woven through the story, but now they just talk to each other and lecture the audience that way, it’s infuriating. You have the young students telling the oldies all about non binary and how they mustn’t identify a patient as male or female. Apart from anything else it’s bloody relevant in a hospital ffs.

I’ve watched Greys since the start and I’m really tempted to stop because of it. Maybe they’ve got new writers? It’s really not as good as it used to be, they have always had social issues in it but it’s not bashed you over the head with it.

BlueRaincoat1 · 13/09/2021 11:49

I totally agree. I'm a big Greys Anatomy fan, have watched it all, twice!
But the last 2 seasons have been awful for shoe horning in social issues with really poor writing. For example, when Owen was criticised for missing a diagnosis because the symptoms in Asian people meant it was more likely to be X and he didn't consider this. The implication being that he was racist. It was handled/written really badly - in previous season there would have been a much stronger story surrounding the issue - in this case the patient barely featured , there was no story, just a lecture.
Also when Maggie lectured Amelia about the invisbility of black girls in safeguarding - really important issue, handled terribly.

I'm not sure I'd watch it again if it stays like this, it's really tedious.

ManifestDestinee · 13/09/2021 11:38

@ElizaBenson

Greys anatomy is a shondaland programme, to be fair with those you know what you are getting, strong black characters, particularly black women, usually tons of sex and some strong messages, if you don't like her programmes there are plenty of others to watch, personally I love them (although sometimes the sheer amount of sex is boring...) maybe you just aren't the target audience and should try something else?
No, you don't understand. IT used to be like that, but the last series was literally whole episodes of lecturing with a vague storyline shoehorned into the remaining few minutes. They might as well been standing at lecturns fgs.
ILookAtTheFloor · 13/09/2021 11:33

It's the adverts that get me.

Please stop preaching to me about climate change. Just attempt to make me part with my cash via a nice advert for your product.

2389Champ · 13/09/2021 09:27

Even the news - especially the Beeb - do it. I want my current affairs factual without bias and for me to be able make up my own mind about what’s happening in the world. There’s always an ‘angle’ and bias to most reporting. If there’s an exceptional weather event - it must be climate change etc etc

Celebrities on chat shows looking amazing and implying they look so good because they only eat organic, raw, prehistoric food which takes 9 hours a day to prepare and is only harvested when the moon is alignment with the planet Jupiter (but we all secretly know it’s because they have a great Botox practitioner) and that if we were all eating the same, we could look just as beautiful.

I just want to be informed, not lectured.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 13/09/2021 09:10

Highway to Heaven, Littlest Hobo, Quantum Leap anyone remember those. Back in the 80s it felt like all US TV came with a side order of moralising, all flavoured with patriarchy, racism and rugged individualism. There were only a few channels so it was impossible to avoid. That was hard

This…..exactly this

As you say you just couldn’t avoid it 😀

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 13/09/2021 09:09

I don’t have a problem with modern tv or adverts

I did have a massive issue with programs like tj hooker back in the day…..that really obvious’lesson’ right at the end

Ive just remembered that the brady bunch movies takes the piss out of the ‘end of episode lesson’ in the old series

FlemCandango · 13/09/2021 09:09

Highway to Heaven, Littlest Hobo, Quantum Leap anyone remember those. Back in the 80s it felt like all US TV came with a side order of moralising, all flavoured with patriarchy, racism and rugged individualism. There were only a few channels so it was impossible to avoid. That was hard.

New Amsterdam forgot to include a compelling plot and interesting characterisation, Grey's Anatomy is ridiculous fluff and the Good Doctor list me with its one note portrayal of Autism. So the heavy moralising is not the main issue that puts me off those programmes. Shondaland lost all moral high ground imo when marital rape was whistled past in Bridgerton!

Mantlemoose · 13/09/2021 09:05

Yep that's why I rarely watch tv now. It's meant to be an escape from real life. I'll watch a documentary if I want info.

Lookingoutside · 13/09/2021 09:02

@limitedperiodonly

‘My friend worked for the Department of Health and they were always having meetings with scriptwriters to shoehorn in messages for the proles.’

The proles? Nice.

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 08:56

People just turn off, stop buying brands or using services

I try to avoid spending on brands that jump on the preachy bandwagon unless there is a good reason to do it or they are the only option in the market. Public services are more tricky, but you can still not donate when it's a 'charity', etc and contribute to the ones that seem more to the point and genuine

GrolliffetheDragon · 13/09/2021 08:52

[quote Libraryghost]@GrolliffetheDragon what a black person will not buy a bog roll unless they are featured in the advert? A white person will stop watching sky because it’s got Idris Elba promoting it? Can’t watch Sky , it’s for black folks. Now that’s racist![/quote]
Advertisers care about what sells products. But yes, people like to see people who are like them, it's part of my representation is important.

Off the top of my head - Go look up Ursula le Guin's Earthsea books and the responses from black people who found that here was a fantasy book where the people looked like them. Or the unusual amount of women who bought the original Tomb Raider game.

As for a white person will stop watching Sky, I do seem to recall that the first British Vogue with Naomi Campbell on the cover saw a drop in sales.

One would hope things have changed, but going back to Doctor Who, lots of men complaining about Jodie Whittaker and whining about why can't girls look up to male role models and how sexist it is to want a female role model. Funny how that doesn't apply to boys...

Giggorata · 13/09/2021 08:39

Yet another vote for Countryfile no longer being any good for farmers/actual rural dwellers.

I don't mind Greg Davies' “what have we learned today?” Summing up at the end of each Taskmaster…

SunIsBehindGreySky · 13/09/2021 08:36

They aren't achieving anything other than feeling superior and getting rich, I assume eventually another Brexit type incident will happen. People just turn off, stop buying brands or using services.

The state know people will use the service they fund via tax and businesses have worked out they will not loose all customers. They are accepting vigilante behavior now, because they take taxpayers money to fund police who are not interested in their old job description, some things have become legal as they don't prosecute it investigate they exoect us to be Agatha Christie and do the work for them (same as feckless parents child financial abuse so called support type agencies) and are now having grad police checking illegal Quazi religion thinking.

It's end of Empire democracy corruption era in the cycle where we are in Tyranny.

mustlovegin · 13/09/2021 08:36

What do we fund all this stuff for? We are idiots paying tax, license fees, service users if stats brands or buying brands, using business and they think we are just there passive to be lectured to, think and do as they tell us to and give them power and money

^ This