Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't like being preached at in TV shows

263 replies

NutellaEllaElla · 12/09/2021 19:09

Is it just me? Has it always been this way? There seems to be a moral to every story. Try not to judge my TV watching habits Grin but i'm thinking Grey's Anatomy, The Good Doctor, New Amsterdam. There's probably more i'm not thinking of right now. Was it always so heavy handed on social issues?

OP posts:
SunIsBehindGreySky · 15/09/2021 16:56

I did read the deleted post and she was mostly observing who lives where and misrepresented of numbers of people in the UK regions. She also was sceptical if certain people would have been accurately represented in historical reinactments in the numbers and society positions. It's weird like gaslighting to rewrite history.

She was discussing a country that has a radio in every house and you can't turn the volume down or it off, I guess she would be better off comparing Hunger Games style interrupted propoghanda style broadcasting.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 15/09/2021 16:38

Cancel culture' is the cry of people who just 'tell it like it is' then add an "I'm not racist though" somewhere along the way

no it isn't. Cancel culture is a thing and people get cancelled for stating the blindingly obvious, like men should not be taking part in womens' sport. I didn't see Xenia's original comment, but I get fed up with people saying that if you use expressions like cancel culture or woke you must be racist. People who say that are as bigoted as the racists, and actually if people were a little more tolerant of views they don't like, and aimed to debate them properly rather than just "cancelling" people, we might not have ended up with the mess that is Brexit.

Cutabove · 15/09/2021 16:38

@Xenia

Bit unfair to say I was "very racist" (which is defamation) when the post isn't there. I said a 1950s/60s story line where the main character was a black Northern Ireland leading footballer was part of this problem so many of us on here have seen. It made it hard to believe the story line. Even in 2021 NI is 0.2% black so surely it is not racist to say that a "Endeavour" having that lead character felt unlikely in NI all those years ago whereas in 2021 in London it would be likely. I just didn't want anyone w ho did not read my original post to think I was a racist person which would be so far from the truth!
You complained that there were too many black people of TV and compared it to North Korea. You complained that there wasn't enough depiction of black gangs and black people as villans.

It it wasn't racist, it wouldn't be deleted.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 15/09/2021 16:35

As for Endeavour - well there was a lot wrong with that episode. I think Xenia's point is reasonable enough - it was a bit unrealistic for a NI player in the early 70s.

But also football players didn't make that sort of £££ in 1971 and definitely not playing for Oxford United!

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 15/09/2021 16:32

I immediately thought of Dr Who too. Banging you over the head with a sledgehammer about some sort of social issue, even to the extent of having a number to call fi you are affected by the issues in the programme afterwards. How about easy-going entertainment?

Xenia · 15/09/2021 16:32

Bit unfair to say I was "very racist" (which is defamation) when the post isn't there. I said a 1950s/60s story line where the main character was a black Northern Ireland leading footballer was part of this problem so many of us on here have seen. It made it hard to believe the story line. Even in 2021 NI is 0.2% black so surely it is not racist to say that a "Endeavour" having that lead character felt unlikely in NI all those years ago whereas in 2021 in London it would be likely. I just didn't want anyone w ho did not read my original post to think I was a racist person which would be so far from the truth!

lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 16:27

Yep I didn't like the Capaldi series either and I generally like Capaldi. It just wasn't fun any more somehow.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 15:41

Oops yes Steven Moffat, not Simon Blush

It was a massive opportunity missed though. I think they really needed to get it right especially with all of the "can't have a female Who" blokes, and they completely fucked it up. And for no reason to do with Whittaker's range either. She'd already shown us she could do alluring in Venus, she'd already shown us she can do ballsy in Attack The Block, she'd already shown us she could do wounded and compromised in Broadchurch. But what we got was this weird asexual moralising head girl brisk one dimensional character that managed to piss everyone off.

randomlyLostInWales · 15/09/2021 14:53

I have to admit I've gone off Attenborough in last few years as again it's very OTT preachy - it was always there but not so blatant which is a shame as I grew up on his programs.

(I do get it's bad but sometimes I just to to watch TV and relax).

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 15/09/2021 14:53

@Xenia

I am surprised I was deleted when I just calmly stated a few facts about some TV shows and also stated how firmly I am behind racial equality. Cancel culture.
You didn't calmly state facts, you were very racist, MNHQ were right to delete your post.

'Cancel culture' is the cry of people who just 'tell it like it is' then add an "I'm not racist though" somewhere along the way.

Driftingblue · 15/09/2021 14:49

Yes, this thread instantly made me think fi Dr Who as well. It always had morals included in the stories, it just wasn’t so heavy handed. The quality of writing simply deteriorated. An easy comparison is the Van Gogh vs Tesla episodes. They basically followed similar formulas, but one was amazing and the other felt like a school film-strip pulled out of the supply cabinet.

The writing for a female doctor is also completely wrong. When you are the smartest person in the room and you know it, it’s hard to set your arrogance aside. I know this really well because it’s how I live my life and it’s the kind of people I surround myself with. It does play out differently in men and women. The men are much more upfront with it while we women do temper it more, but that air of superiority is impossible to hide completely. It disappeared with this doctor and it made me so angry. I was so excited to see my personal version of a superhero be a woman and they turned her into a needy person who rarely displays her intelligence. Missy was still the Master when she was a woman. Even when she tried to be good it still felt like a continuation of the complicated motivations driving that individual.

randomlyLostInWales · 15/09/2021 14:47

Maybe it's just Simon Moffat? It kind of went to shit when he took over. But then he's the one who wrote "Blink" and introduced Carey Mulligan to the world. So he knows how to write and has some cracking ideas. Maybe not so good at doing anything else.

Chris Chibnall was made head writer and co-producer and I he's one I think who's been in charge for Jodie Whittaker's doctor though I think it was Steven Moffat for Peter Capaldi.

But there's clearly something going amiss with the writing though perhaps there more going on with it all than just the writing. DH thinks they're trying to make it more a children's show and less family entertainment - though I'm not sure writing for children needs the dumbing down that appears to have happened.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 14:46

I've stopped watching all Attenborough programmes.

I cannot fucking stand Attenborough these days. He just bangs on and on about how bad people are and how great it would be if they weren't around.

Be a bit of a bummer for your rating figures and the status you get from your badge from the queen though wouldn't it, sunshine?

Also, he's a total fucking toff. There's always a bit of 'oh no, the lower classes are BREEDING and their kids are all surviving these days' from that kind of guy.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 14:41

Yeah it was pretty racist m8. Black people are allowed on the telly now.

Ancientcistern · 15/09/2021 14:39

@Xenia

I am surprised I was deleted when I just calmly stated a few facts about some TV shows and also stated how firmly I am behind racial equality. Cancel culture.
What you said was racist, that's why it was deleted.
Wed8pril · 15/09/2021 14:37

@xenia

You do realise that there were black people in NI in the 60s, right? And what do you mean by black street gangs?

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 14:36

Yes they ruined the chance they had with Peter Capaldi too, who is also a fine actor.

Maybe it's just Simon Moffat? It kind of went to shit when he took over. But then he's the one who wrote "Blink" and introduced Carey Mulligan to the world. So he knows how to write and has some cracking ideas. Maybe not so good at doing anything else.

@lazylinguist it is a bit sexist isn't it. Missy is a great female character but Missy is a bad person!

Xenia · 15/09/2021 14:34

I am surprised I was deleted when I just calmly stated a few facts about some TV shows and also stated how firmly I am behind racial equality. Cancel culture.

randomlyLostInWales · 15/09/2021 14:28

lazylinguist - I agree I was looking forward to a female Dr Who and have been massively disappointed.

I did think it was just poor writing but frankly after Ruth Dr I do now wonder if it was Jodie Whittaker's portrayal as well though Peter Capaldi seemed to struggle and I think I've loved him in pretty much everything else I've seen him in.

The female Doctor has to be nice and kind.
I picked that up too with Jodie Whittaker' Dr and hated it and the message behind it - less so with Ruth Dr who seemed to gain gravitas once she knew she was the Dr.

lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 14:21

Actually it struck me as pretty sexist. Male Doctors are allowed to be a bit difficult and arrogant and flawed. The female Doctor has to be nice and kind. Hmm

HiGunny · 15/09/2021 14:19

Funny how many people have mentioned Dr.Who, it was the first program I thought of when I saw the thread title. I really wanted to enjoy the Jodie Whittaker series but the writing was just so clunky and preachy!

lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 14:19

They dressed her like a four year old boy and I couldn't tell you a single thought or motivation her character had that wasn't out of the Big Book Of Nice Kind Opinions during her entire time as Dr Who.

Bingo. What I liked about Tennant and Smith was that they were flawed geniuses. Their moments of selfishness or recklessness or darkness made them 'human' and likeable. Whittaker's Doctor was like an annoyingly try-hard, slightly zany but jolly nice Head Girl.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 15/09/2021 14:14

I had seen Jodie Whittaker - in Venus, where she held her own playing opposite Peter O'Toole which was frankly astonishing given that she was around 20 or so at the time I think? - and in Attack The Block, which I thought gave her absolute credentials to be in a sci fi series. I still think she's an incredible actor. But they absolutely wasted her. They dressed her like a four year old boy and I couldn't tell you a single thought or motivation her character had that wasn't out of the Big Book Of Nice Kind Opinions during her entire time as Dr Who.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 15/09/2021 14:09

I think it's a secret plot to make us all turn off TV and social media and make them redundant.Grin

lazylinguist · 15/09/2021 14:06

One would hope things have changed, but going back to Doctor Who, lots of men complaining about Jodie Whittaker and whining about why can't girls look up to male role models and how sexist it is to want a female role model. Funny how that doesn't apply to boys...

Unfortunately, I think lots of women (like me) really wanted to love Jodie Whittaker's Doctor and were vigorously mocking the men who said we couldn't possibly have a female one. Unfortunately, it was a massive disappointment. Probably not Whittaker's fault - I don't know, as I've never seen her in anything else. I didn't like her character, any of the companions, the dialogue or the social justice preachiness. The plots were... ok, I guess.