Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't like being preached at in TV shows

263 replies

NutellaEllaElla · 12/09/2021 19:09

Is it just me? Has it always been this way? There seems to be a moral to every story. Try not to judge my TV watching habits Grin but i'm thinking Grey's Anatomy, The Good Doctor, New Amsterdam. There's probably more i'm not thinking of right now. Was it always so heavy handed on social issues?

OP posts:
SunIsBehindGreySky · 15/09/2021 21:06

We need more stories that prioritise the most effective solutions, such as reducing flights we take, trying to eat a low-carbon diet, and using less energy within our homes.

“Lifestyle changes also need to be talked about in terms of how they relate to changes to infrastructure and policies that help people make the shift to lower-carbon living. And we should be talking about inequalities in wealth that mean that some households, on all continents, consume much more than others.”

I have always been on the green side, I don't need people telling me off for others crimes.

What I do not understand is why we should be taking things seriously to the point of some almost wanting us to go back to the dark ages lifestyle whilst today Kate took a helicopter rather than a car (I gather child number four is on the way with it's huge carbon footprint) the Ginger Prince of Bel air wasted goodness knows how much energy on the PR and clothes and magazine stunt whilst he Obama are living it up with their huge carbon footprints, if they were that worried you would think they would be living differently.

Lightfish · 15/09/2021 21:03

@FlemCandango

Highway to Heaven, Littlest Hobo, Quantum Leap anyone remember those. Back in the 80s it felt like all US TV came with a side order of moralising, all flavoured with patriarchy, racism and rugged individualism. There were only a few channels so it was impossible to avoid. That was hard.

New Amsterdam forgot to include a compelling plot and interesting characterisation, Grey's Anatomy is ridiculous fluff and the Good Doctor list me with its one note portrayal of Autism. So the heavy moralising is not the main issue that puts me off those programmes. Shondaland lost all moral high ground imo when marital rape was whistled past in Bridgerton!

I must be a very conflicted person as I am rewatching Quantum Leap and thoroughly enjoying it!

On the other hand the fact that practically every advert features a mixed race family or person (because black people can't be too black) annoys me every single time. As a black woman with a mixed race child I find it all too cynical and lazy.

I feel that it does not lead to enlightenment, but instead to people switching off. I accept being a minority. We should be visible, but our representation should be realistic and not over exaggerated. It is not doing us any favours. Adverts should be more representative (as much as they can be when they are from a middle class viewpoint).

mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 21:01

it happens in schools too with charities

There needs to be a serious charity overhaul and the public funding that goes into them IMO

But that's probably a topic for another thread

Grin
SunIsBehindGreySky · 15/09/2021 20:55

If I understand correctly, Bafta is a charity (partly funded by the British taxpayer)

This means we are all paying into a charity, who funds another charity (?) that provides free training to scriptwriters on how to perfect the fine art of indoctrination?

It seems to be a pattern, it happens in schools too with charities.

mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 20:53

Can I go back to this, trying to understand who is who in all this shambles

The report, from albert, a Bafta-backed sustainability project

If I understand correctly, Bafta is a charity (partly funded by the British taxpayer)

This means we are all paying into a charity, who funds another charity (?) that provides free training to scriptwriters on how to perfect the fine art of indoctrination?

www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/sep/15/cake-mentioned-10-times-more-than-climate-change-on-uk-tv-report

SunIsBehindGreySky · 15/09/2021 20:52

Ideologies are being presented and hammered into people's minds as undisputable facts, that's the problem.

I guess the morals part is that many definitions have changed, evil now seems to be someone who refuses to tell lies.

mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 20:42

Stories with morals aren’t a new thing but we are going through a very moralistic phase in tv and some genres of literature

I wouldn't call this moralistic though. Morals have nothing to do with being vegan or non gender critical for instance.

Ideologies are being presented and hammered into people's minds as undisputable facts, that's the problem

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 15/09/2021 20:14

Coming back to the main topic of the thread, if that’s allowed, yanbu op.

I remember reading Victorian children’s books a few decades ago and wondering how kids put up with it. Now many children’s books are just as bad, it’s just the theme of the preachiness is different.
Fwiw the moral is generally something I am totally behind, it’s just so clunkily and implausibly written. There was a recent middle grade historical set in WW2 where the climax is basically a young girl evacuee lecturing the whole village on how they should be nicer to refugees. Instead of giving her a clip round the ear or telling her off for getting above herself they are suitably chastened and promise to be nicer in future. It reads like one of those ‘and then everybody clapped’ stories on social media.

Stories with morals aren’t a new thing but we are going through a very moralistic phase in tv and some genres of literature. It used to be something we mocked American tv for but ours is just as bad now.

Cutabove · 15/09/2021 19:38

@mustlovegin

It's not defamation when it's true

Since when, someone being accused of something is not allowed to set the record straight and defend herself?

She's allowed to defend herself. If it really is defamation then maybe she could take legal action, being a big fancy super rich lawyer and all.
mustlovegin · 15/09/2021 19:34

It's not defamation when it's true

Since when, someone being accused of something is not allowed to set the record straight and defend herself?

CorrBlimeyGG · 15/09/2021 18:58

This could be interesting, as some woke share these views and some western views China don't.

Cancel culture, dogwhistle racism, and now some tenuous 'woke' reference. This thread has turned into a GB News bingo card!

Cutabove · 15/09/2021 18:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

CorrBlimeyGG · 15/09/2021 18:51

Bit unfair to say I was "very racist" (which is defamation)

It's not defamation when it's true.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 15/09/2021 18:45

This could be interesting, as some woke share these views and some western views China don't.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9993849/Chinas-new-digital-crackdown-ensure-Marxist-internet-fight-bulling-fake-news.html

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 18:43

@lockdownmadnessdotcom

I immediately thought of Dr Who too. Banging you over the head with a sledgehammer about some sort of social issue, even to the extent of having a number to call fi you are affected by the issues in the programme afterwards. How about easy-going entertainment?
Hollyoaks used to do that when I wantched them.

The thing is, Dr Who is worldwide, that issue will be absolutely missed by millions anyway

Annoyedanddissapointed · 15/09/2021 18:41

@SunIsBehindGreySky

I remember when English people were always the villain in American films, I particularly like Alan Rickman in the Bruce Willis films.
I think it's the posh accent. They were always rich, crazy, genious villains (Eloooooon).
HereForThis · 15/09/2021 18:16

[quote Sagaz]@xenia i hate when mn do that, delete a post without understanding the discussion. It happens too often. The post is deleted purely because it was reported. The mod on duty thought 'i don't understand' and pressed delete.[/quote]
Oh goodness! So you're saying you're psychic and we have a thicko for a mod then? That's what you just basically said. MNHQ needs a revamp and training ASAP!

HereForThis · 15/09/2021 18:12

but I get fed up with people saying that if you use expressions like cancel culture or woke you must be racist.

What do you think when people say that if you use expressions like Karen, you must be a misogynist?

LateDecemberBackInLowB12 · 15/09/2021 17:51

@Xenia

Bit unfair to say I was "very racist" (which is defamation) when the post isn't there. I said a 1950s/60s story line where the main character was a black Northern Ireland leading footballer was part of this problem so many of us on here have seen. It made it hard to believe the story line. Even in 2021 NI is 0.2% black so surely it is not racist to say that a "Endeavour" having that lead character felt unlikely in NI all those years ago whereas in 2021 in London it would be likely. I just didn't want anyone w ho did not read my original post to think I was a racist person which would be so far from the truth!
Oh,come on, you said a lot more than that, and you know it.

no it isn't. Cancel culture is a thing and people get cancelled for stating the blindingly obvious, like men should not be taking part in womens' sport

The trans debate really doesn't have to rear its head on every single thread Hmm

I also didn't report that post. I think it's very helpful for everyone when we can see the views of posters, then there's no room for wide eyed innocence and "I didn't say that though"

Sagaz · 15/09/2021 17:28

@xenia i hate when mn do that, delete a post without understanding the discussion. It happens too often. The post is deleted purely because it was reported. The mod on duty thought 'i don't understand' and pressed delete.

Ancientcistern · 15/09/2021 17:24

Racists rarely admit to being so. But thankfully mumsnet disagrees with you.

Xenia · 15/09/2021 17:17

Well it wasn't racist but there we are.

The original post is the theme of the thread - that some programmes in the current seasons are giving us lectures, like the kind I had when on business addressing a conference in Iran where the whole thing started with a propaganda film. It is not unknown in the UK., the Arches on radio 4 was partly set up to make positive Government propaganda and present it to UK farmers. If we don't like TV shows we will switch them off here in the UK and programme makers will make something else but it certainly has been a big thing for many viewers this season and made some shows harder to enjoy.

Cutabove · 15/09/2021 17:06

@lockdownmadnessdotcom

Cancel culture' is the cry of people who just 'tell it like it is' then add an "I'm not racist though" somewhere along the way

no it isn't. Cancel culture is a thing and people get cancelled for stating the blindingly obvious, like men should not be taking part in womens' sport. I didn't see Xenia's original comment, but I get fed up with people saying that if you use expressions like cancel culture or woke you must be racist. People who say that are as bigoted as the racists, and actually if people were a little more tolerant of views they don't like, and aimed to debate them properly rather than just "cancelling" people, we might not have ended up with the mess that is Brexit.

Anti-racists are just as bad as racists. Where have I heard that before?
Cutabove · 15/09/2021 17:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SunIsBehindGreySky · 15/09/2021 16:58

I remember when English people were always the villain in American films, I particularly like Alan Rickman in the Bruce Willis films.