Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Same mum brings older siblingto parties and let's them join in

265 replies

mymobileisonsilent · 12/09/2021 17:18

Now I know some people have to bring siblings and ask in advance. However I know this person doesn't ask, as they brought their older sibling to my child's party a few weeks ago and didn't ask. I had made packed lunches, so I didn't have extra boxes . In fact they didn't even say when arriving. The very rude child then demanded lunch and a party bag, the mum was oblivious and today was style same.

Today this sibling who is at least 5 years older than the birthday child took prizes when not enough for the actual friends of the birthday girl. AIBU, or should I and al parties over cater for a everyone to bring siblings?

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 12/09/2021 22:06

@Moonface123

I always think the more the merrier, this was never a problem for me and alot of the time l hosted parties solely by myself. Not everyone has a husband or partner to leave other sibling with, or an army of help. The sibling who gets the party bag and cake is usually happy to share, or l would usually just make do with something else, like a balloon, not a big deal. l think it's abit mean to exclude siblings.
@Moonface123 - there is a BIG difference between what you are describing, and what the OP is describing.

If you, as the host, are happy to accommodate extra guests, that is fine, and your choice. But it is NOT fine for someone else to impose extra guests on the host, unasked and uninvited.

It’s like saying that, because you are happy to share your bag of sweets with everyone, I should be able to walk up to someone and plunge my hand into their bag of sweets and take what I want, without asking.

PatchworkElmer · 12/09/2021 22:02

This happened to us at DS’s 3rd birthday. Friend breezed in with 2 invited kids and 2 much older step kids I’d never met before. Far too old for the activity, needed feeding so had to cobble something together. I don’t understand why she didn’t message to check. Her DP came too and therefore surely could’ve stayed home with the step kids rather than treating it like a family outing. DC’s party this year is pay per head with food included (rather than us making the food). I’ll be explicit on the invites that siblings can’t come unless parents are willing to pay.

GreyhoundG1rl · 12/09/2021 21:56

@Heckythump1

Can I put it on the invitation? Or is that seen as rude? My daughter is only in year 1, and obviously no party last year due to covid! Can I also suggest that parents just drop the children and go? We're having it at home and it would be a real squeeze with 10 children and a parent each!
If you're happy without the parents there (some prefer the parents to stay rather than be in charge of hordes of children!) then yes, it's fine to say so.
Heckythump1 · 12/09/2021 21:54

Can I put it on the invitation? Or is that seen as rude? My daughter is only in year 1, and obviously no party last year due to covid! Can I also suggest that parents just drop the children and go? We're having it at home and it would be a real squeeze with 10 children and a parent each!

GreyhoundG1rl · 12/09/2021 21:54

@Isahlo

Totally agree this is first degree cheeky fuckery, But my heart totally breaks for some kids sometimes I’ve spent a long time working in schools. And we’ve had big group parties, but not quite whole class (2/3rds ish) where twins or siblings in the same class (some schools have a foundation class, a 1/2 a 3/4 and a 5/6 class) have only one sibling from the class invited, but parents have to stay and supervise, and by default so does the non invited sibling (eg swimming party for 4/5 year olds)

when kids are older, say KS2 age plus, or of an age where parents don’t have to watch, you can explain and take the non party invited somewhere distracting but IMO you’ve got to be an extra special type of nasty to not invite a young child to a party that because of supervision rules they have to watch their sibling and all their friends enjoy.

I remember taking DN to a party like this at the leisure centre for inflatable swimming, where a twin who was 4 was sat in the glass fronted cafe and waiting room that over looked the pool clutching a blue panda pop and repeating after her mum, “I’m brave, I’m strong, I’m a good friend” whilst she absolutely choked on her little tears.
Absolutely ruined me. Had I been taking my o n dd and known the mum of the birthday child, I would’ve bribed my dd with McDonald’s left and let the twin go.

I'd never invite one of a pair of twins (iyswim) or a child who had a sibling in the same class, that's bloody awful. I've even invited both twins when they were in different classes and my dc was only friends with one of them (boy/girl) twins. That scenario is outside the normal etiquette rules, I think...
Isahlo · 12/09/2021 21:52

@Heckythump1

There's a Mum that always brings the older sibling to parties in my daughters class... it's my daughters party soon, and i'm paying per head for entertainers to come and face painting etc, I don't want to pay for an extra kid who my child doesn't even know, it's expensive enough!

What do you say if they just turn up and expect to stay?

I think you’ve got 2 options Either “Invited children only” Or “This is a pay per child event, I’m paying for x number of child’s friends, if you want A to join that will be £££ thanks”
GreyhoundG1rl · 12/09/2021 21:51

@Heckythump1

There's a Mum that always brings the older sibling to parties in my daughters class... it's my daughters party soon, and i'm paying per head for entertainers to come and face painting etc, I don't want to pay for an extra kid who my child doesn't even know, it's expensive enough!

What do you say if they just turn up and expect to stay?

Tell her in advance that it's a drop off and there is a strict number limit, so the invitation is extended to the named child only. I'm assuming it is drop off? It can be for her, anyway...
Isahlo · 12/09/2021 21:50

Also to add to my post. Obviously it’s different for clearly separate siblings and that’s fine my point was to highlight very small children in the same peer group where you can’t explain it in the usual “oh they’re all Susies friends from year five, all your friends are in year one so you wait for your own friends party”

Heckythump1 · 12/09/2021 21:48

There's a Mum that always brings the older sibling to parties in my daughters class... it's my daughters party soon, and i'm paying per head for entertainers to come and face painting etc, I don't want to pay for an extra kid who my child doesn't even know, it's expensive enough!

What do you say if they just turn up and expect to stay?

Isahlo · 12/09/2021 21:48

Totally agree this is first degree cheeky fuckery,
But my heart totally breaks for some kids sometimes
I’ve spent a long time working in schools.
And we’ve had big group parties, but not quite whole class (2/3rds ish) where twins or siblings in the same class (some schools have a foundation class, a 1/2 a 3/4 and a 5/6 class) have only one sibling from the class invited, but parents have to stay and supervise, and by default so does the non invited sibling (eg swimming party for 4/5 year olds)

when kids are older, say KS2 age plus, or of an age where parents don’t have to watch, you can explain and take the non party invited somewhere distracting but IMO you’ve got to be an extra special type of nasty to not invite a young child to a party that because of supervision rules they have to watch their sibling and all their friends enjoy.

I remember taking DN to a party like this at the leisure centre for inflatable swimming, where a twin who was 4 was sat in the glass fronted cafe and waiting room that over looked the pool clutching a blue panda pop and repeating after her mum, “I’m brave, I’m strong, I’m a good friend” whilst she absolutely choked on her little tears.
Absolutely ruined me. Had I been taking my o n dd and known the mum of the birthday child, I would’ve bribed my dd with McDonald’s left and let the twin go.

thelegohooverer · 12/09/2021 21:39

Are the parents meant to stay at these parties? I can see that it would be difficult to have a sibling sitting miserably to one side if you don’t have alternative childcare.

Once mine were over 3 the norm was to drop and run and I’ve never had siblings staying. They often came at pick up and I made extra party bags because it’s hard to give to one child while a little one is looking on. But it was never expected.

Do these parents who push their extra dc in return the favour and host siblings at their parties?

Barnybrown · 12/09/2021 21:26

@ Getawaywithit it is different if you pay for your child to attend the venue - the parent I had who did this just literally left her 4 year old with the invited older sibling and went ! I had to pay £14 extra for the child to bounce. I definitely understand if a mum (or dad) has a particular difficulty with childcare and asks in advance and doesn’t expect me to pay for the extra sibling. But people don’t always do that unfortunately !

mymobileisonsilent · 12/09/2021 21:18

Asking to bring a sibling and then
paying for a sibling is different than just letting your extra child rock up, take prizes, push in the front of the party bag queue. It's nothing against single parents. I know for a fact this parent is not a single parent. It maybe that the DH was working, but the sibling was old enough to understand she wasn't the one invited.

I ended up with 3 extra siblings at my DC's party. Well I had more but some asked which I then catered for and did party bags for and a few were just babies.

OP posts:
ItsSnowJokes · 12/09/2021 21:08

@Getawaywithit

When my dc were younger I had to bring younger dd along to any party or my older dd who was always the invitee at the time couldn't have attended. I always dropped off when I could or paid separately to ply and eat if it was somewhere like soft play it here were times I had to stay and there wasn't that option. No one ever complained but i have since worried about it seeing responses on here

I have been single for years with no real support. I always had to take my other children. I always paid entry and a meal and never expected a party bag, Seems single parents and those without support at the right times have never really been welcome. Not sure why that surprises me but it’s very sad for the children concerned.

No its not a matter of not being welcome, it's about not expecting a free party for a sibling. You are doing the right thing, other parents don't and just expect for their children to be provided for as well as the invited child.
GreyhoundG1rl · 12/09/2021 21:07

@Getawaywithit

When my dc were younger I had to bring younger dd along to any party or my older dd who was always the invitee at the time couldn't have attended. I always dropped off when I could or paid separately to ply and eat if it was somewhere like soft play it here were times I had to stay and there wasn't that option. No one ever complained but i have since worried about it seeing responses on here

I have been single for years with no real support. I always had to take my other children. I always paid entry and a meal and never expected a party bag, Seems single parents and those without support at the right times have never really been welcome. Not sure why that surprises me but it’s very sad for the children concerned.

I don't understand your post, Getawaywithit? You felt unwelcome because all your other children weren't invited en masse to every party? And this was sad for them?
Getawaywithit · 12/09/2021 20:59

When my dc were younger I had to bring younger dd along to any party or my older dd who was always the invitee at the time couldn't have attended. I always dropped off when I could or paid separately to ply and eat if it was somewhere like soft play it here were times I had to stay and there wasn't that option. No one ever complained but i have since worried about it seeing responses on here

I have been single for years with no real support. I always had to take my other children. I always paid entry and a meal and never expected a party bag, Seems single parents and those without support at the right times have never really been welcome. Not sure why that surprises me but it’s very sad for the children concerned.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 12/09/2021 20:59

@IHateCoronavirus

This is so rude of people. Mostly they get away with it.
They do. Because despite all the pithy and smart-arse responses that we can all think of afterwards, in the heat of the moment, and when you're dealing with organising/running a party, you don't have the presence of mind to just ask the CF parent what the actual fuck they think they are playing at?

And CF parents know this, know they are unlikely to be called out on their cheeky fuckery, and take advantage of that.

So rude and totally unacceptable. ANY siblings whatever their age, need to be taken away and entertained elswhere. Or if it's a soft play party scenario, paid for separately, actively parented and kept well away from food/party bags.

GreyhoundG1rl · 12/09/2021 20:49

@Bighousebustup

I’m doing my DD’s in a hall and I’m worried people will think it’s no big deal to bring siblings, but my entertainer has a limit on how many children they can have without needing to pay for a second entertainer. Just because it’s in a hall doesn’t mean there can’t be the same cost/number restraints.
Yes, exactly that.
GreyhoundG1rl · 12/09/2021 20:49

If its an entertainer in a hall type then I think its fine to bring a sibling if you check first
If it was fine to bring a sibling it would be mentioned on the invitation. You don't get to decide what's fine. At least you mentioned checking first, which is good, but sometimes this just puts people on the spot and they feel awkward refusing.

Bighousebustup · 12/09/2021 20:46

I’m doing my DD’s in a hall and I’m worried people will think it’s no big deal to bring siblings, but my entertainer has a limit on how many children they can have without needing to pay for a second entertainer. Just because it’s in a hall doesn’t mean there can’t be the same cost/number restraints.

starmoonsun · 12/09/2021 20:33

If pay per guest party eg trampolining then no extra siblings unless arranged directly with host in advance. If its an entertainer in a hall type then I think its fine to bring a sibling if you check first, if their close in age / young its not very nice to say they have to sit and watch. Most parents I know would over cater anyway easy to get extra crisps, biscuits etc and wouldn't expect a party bag but again lots seem to do extra or give sweets.
Also you soon learn who the cheeky parents are who tend to ask if siblings can come along. Most parents I've found often invite siblings if numbers not important anyway especially when reception/year 1 age.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 12/09/2021 20:18

@Barnybrown

@ Moonface123 not everyone can afford to pay for your children to attend their child’s party just because you don’t have childcare. Parties are expensive and they are for the birthday child’s friends - it isn’t mean not to invite children who aren’t even known to the birthday child. You are about to get flamed on here - and if you are genuinely suggesting it is mean not to include siblings in parties they aren’t invited to them I think you probably deserve to!
Agreed on all points!
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 12/09/2021 20:16

@catfunk

Id make a big song and dance of 'oh I didn't realise they were coming so I haven't catered for them sorry' and would add something to the invite such as 'if you need to bring someone else along please let me know as I will be catering for invitees only otherwise' Hopefully that'll make them realise that if everyone bought an extra kid it'd double the numbers !
Far too polite. 'No' is a complete sentence, as I have learned from MN. These CFs rely on nobody saying an outright no to them. Hints won't work, politeness will be read as a sign of weakness.
CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 12/09/2021 20:15

The parent is being very rude, I’d not blame the kid at all.

I’d clearly put on invite whether siblings are welcome or not.

I never mind if they ask first so I can accommodate the extra child and usually have enough for 1 or 2 extra party bags but not asking is rude.

olidora63 · 12/09/2021 20:15

Why don’t people just drop off and pick up at end of party nowadays? I have three children who all had parties and attended parties but we never had parents or siblings at the party . I really just don’t understand why you would! I just had the grandparents and a couple of godparents to help if necessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread