Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Same mum brings older siblingto parties and let's them join in

265 replies

mymobileisonsilent · 12/09/2021 17:18

Now I know some people have to bring siblings and ask in advance. However I know this person doesn't ask, as they brought their older sibling to my child's party a few weeks ago and didn't ask. I had made packed lunches, so I didn't have extra boxes . In fact they didn't even say when arriving. The very rude child then demanded lunch and a party bag, the mum was oblivious and today was style same.

Today this sibling who is at least 5 years older than the birthday child took prizes when not enough for the actual friends of the birthday girl. AIBU, or should I and al parties over cater for a everyone to bring siblings?

OP posts:
seven7sisters · 31/01/2022 12:20

ZOMBIE THREAD FROM LAST YEAR!!

ElftonWednesday · 31/01/2022 12:17

I found it changed between DD1 and DD2. DD1 had a joint party in Y1, we had one or two siblings but the parents had asked in advance. Four school years later at DD's party loads of siblings turned up without anyone asking first, joined in everything, queued up for party bags at the end. What was even worse a couple of families made it a family affair- several additional adults turned up and ploughed into the food before the kids. I mean there probably would be leftovers and I'd have no problem with them eating that but you don't take the food before the party guests have had a chance!

ElftonWednesday · 31/01/2022 12:12

If you are inviting someone to a party you are asking their parents to disrupt their weekend for you

No you fucking aren't you are providing two hours free childcare for them, plus feeding them!

Jesus wept.

godmum56 · 31/01/2022 12:12

@catfunk

Id make a big song and dance of 'oh I didn't realise they were coming so I haven't catered for them sorry' and would add something to the invite such as 'if you need to bring someone else along please let me know as I will be catering for invitees only otherwise' Hopefully that'll make them realise that if everyone bought an extra kid it'd double the numbers !
I would say this is giving them permission to do it! better to say "sorry cannot accommodate extra children.'
Ricksteinsfishwife · 31/01/2022 11:56

This was a thing twenty years ago too, for me, I have to be honest, it never bothered me, the more the merrier, there was always enough food to go round and I always did a few extra party bags just in case and always welcomed any stray extra kids and if a parent turned up with one in tow I’d go out of my way to say hi and they can stay, but our parties were always self catered community centre type things, we only have one child. So I wasn’t doing it myself. But I get why someone might be annoyed by it. I don’t really understand the “fuming” part or fuming for weeks and weeks, but guess we all have different things that infuriate us.

Hightemp · 31/01/2022 11:52

Siblings coming to parties were not a thing when my lots were younger…it was unheard of and also there wasn’t the expectation that parents stayed as well!
Completely baffles me why this is the trend nowadays!

BlackBirdOfChernobyl · 31/01/2022 11:46

My mum never hosted parties for birthdays, instead we had a birthday treat. Usually to a place chosen by the birthday child followed by dinner at McDonald's. It would be us four kids plus a specific friend of the birthday child. Once, only once, did a parent try and shoehorn in an uninvited sibling. My mum told the cf mother, "sorry, but I'm only paying for five kids at the zoo, so he will have to wait outside til we're finished. Also, I'm not paying for any food for him so he'll have to wait til he gets home." The cf mum backed down. No-one ever tried that trick again with my mum.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 19/09/2021 07:48

I have no personal desire to keep stickers, bubbles, plastic mazes or stretchy dinosaurs etc for myself!
Hahaha I feel the same!
I’d also never get any pleasure from making a child stand to the side and observe party games because they weren’t actually invited.

Chachachawoo · 19/09/2021 07:25

@ranoutofquinoaandprosecco

I've added a no siblings to party invites of people I know will turn up with them. Past caring if they don't like it!
I also did this when mine were little it's total cf behaviour and puts you the host in a horrible position with regard not having enough food and prizes. My daughter was terrified of bigger boys when she was tiny and I had to tell an unimpressed mum to take her older son home. She gave me a look. I couldn't care less. I'm not her free childcare. She hadn't asked in advance bc she knew it was not ok. Can't stand that sort of thing
MagentaGiraffe · 19/09/2021 02:03

[quote SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius]**@MagentaGiraffe* - I don’t think asking* if you can bring your other child makes you a cheeky fucker - what makes a cheeky fucker is turning up with an extra sibling/siblings, and foisting them onto the party without asking.

You sound like a polite and thoughtful person - you say you would be fine if someone said you couldn’t bring the other sibling, and I’m guessing that, if you do bring the other sibling, you don’t let them take over, as some CF parents allow (like the older sibling in a previous post, who was allowed to win all the prizes, for example), and wouldn't let your child expect a party bag - whereas CF parents’ kids are allowed to demand a party bag even if this means actual, invited guests end up without.

Long story short - you aren’t a CF. Thanks[/quote]
Thank you. That makes me feel slightly better. Of course we always ask in advance and wouldn't go if it was unsuitable to have more at the venue. Or if it was a paid per head thing obviously I would pay.

My experience has always been that anybody in similar situations does that too - asks and goes along if the organising parents says it is ok - and it's never been a problem either for people coming to my children's parties or for other parents who invite one of mine to theirs; they have always said siblings are welcome as do we, and party food is a buffet and cake usually so a few extras don't make any significant difference to cost. I always make up extra party bags too as there is always leftover stuff anyway and I have no personal desire to keep stickers, bubbles, plastic mazes or stretchy dinosaurs etc for myself! SmileGrin

RedToothBrush · 17/09/2021 14:53

@CyclingIsNotOuting

I’ve had this too, I ran out of party bags for DC’s friends because of unexpected siblings taking them. Lesson learnt and they are kept hidden until going home time. People still bring siblings without asking. It’s annoying, especially when the activity isn’t suitable for their ages. I now put on the invite a message about no siblings. People still show up with them!
Why on earth do you even let this happy?

CF do it because you let them!

Make it clear, there are no party bags for siblings. Then dish them out yourself. Tough titty. Instead you suck up the expense. WWWWWHHYYY???

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 17/09/2021 14:46

@MagentaGiraffe - I don’t think asking if you can bring your other child makes you a cheeky fucker - what makes a cheeky fucker is turning up with an extra sibling/siblings, and foisting them onto the party without asking.

You sound like a polite and thoughtful person - you say you would be fine if someone said you couldn’t bring the other sibling, and I’m guessing that, if you do bring the other sibling, you don’t let them take over, as some CF parents allow (like the older sibling in a previous post, who was allowed to win all the prizes, for example), and wouldn't let your child expect a party bag - whereas CF parents’ kids are allowed to demand a party bag even if this means actual, invited guests end up without.

Long story short - you aren’t a CF. Thanks

MagentaGiraffe · 17/09/2021 12:25

@MitheringMytryl

A two year old won't be having many party invitations yet. You have all that to come.

My two year old is often invited to parties. Probably once a month. I don't think that she is unusual in this respect.

And yes, I am expected to stay with her. It's normal for parents to stay and supervise. I'm sure that will change as she gets older.

Same. Obviously different if they are 5 or 6 and can stay on their own, but as a lone parent of a two and three year old, what are you meant to do?! Decline all party invitations for them both because you don't want to be seen as a CF by asking to bring both along? Most times there is an older/ younger sibling who is glad of a friend their age to play with: mine certainly love it when siblings come along because they then have a few friends their age to play with who are the brothers or sisters of the main invitee.
MagentaGiraffe · 17/09/2021 12:18

My two are still very small and very close in age. I am a lone parent. If one of them is invited to a party I ask if I can bring the other as they're too young to be left alone yet. I didn't realise I was being a CF. Sad If someone says we can't that's fine and we won't go, wouldn't be offended.

Whenever we've had parties siblings have always been welcome also and given food/ party bags. People have always asked in advance though if they can come, as I do. Nobody's ever been weird about it (as far as I know!) and most of these parents are people who have become friends subsequently for regular playdates even if I didn't know them previously, so I hope that indicates that they did not view this as CFery. 🤷🏻‍♀️

SMabbutt · 16/09/2021 20:16

If the party is at a hall or your house have someone on the door who is assertive with a table and or gate blocking the way in. Give them a clipboard with the invitees names and a space for the parents name and contact details. Sign them in, have them sent in to the party by a trusted helper and say goodbye to the parent and siblings.

If it is at a soft play or similar give list of names to the front desk and also wait by the signing in area with your own sign in sheet. If a parent tries to walk in with siblings just say oh sorry you need to pay to come in with your other dc. They don't allow child spectators. I'm sure this lady can help sort you out. Oh and there's food and drinks you can buy at the cafe area if you want anything while we are eating in the party room. Then smile sweetly and pass the invited guest over to your oh or nominated helper. If they try to gatecrash the food just hand them back and say sorry, you've gone the wrong way. The cafe is over there. See you at x o'clock. Bigvsmile. Close door.

dottymac · 16/09/2021 20:09

I'm with you scully - the amount of kids I've had to help out at parties that have just been dropped off - despite often being with large groups of strangers/not knowing where the toilet is/who to go to when they need something, or just a bit of reassurance. Maybe 5 onwards but younger than that isn't ideal really if it's somewhere like a large soft play or church hall etc. Also depends on the child. School is abit different so no comparison really with regards to dropping and running!

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 16/09/2021 19:29

I’m not sure how many times I’ve written this, but I’ll put it again…

“We will be politely declining party invitations”

ChurchWCat · 16/09/2021 19:14

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

Good for you *@Plumtree391*

I won’t be leaving my four year old.

But if every parent brought 2 siblings along that wanted to join in that would triple the potential cost of the party, especially if it's pay per head.

I don't think people are doing anything wrong by saying siblings can't join.

Plumtree391 · 16/09/2021 19:06

Oh fair enough. I do realise times have changed.

When mine was young, kids were left aged four. The parties were generally in the homes of children with whom they went to school, or neighbours, friends, family, so they were quite safe - or were they? I'm beginning to wonder now. All I can say for certain is that they were safe in my house.

It would have been a bit crowded if all the parents stayed to supervise their children.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 16/09/2021 18:55

Good for you @Plumtree391

I won’t be leaving my four year old.

Plumtree391 · 16/09/2021 18:08

[quote AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken]@woodhill

I’ve repeatedly said I don’t have anyone to drop them with. My children are 4,3 and newborn. I don’t feel comfortable leaving them with strangers at a party.

We wouldn’t go.[/quote]
You're sensible, I wouldn't want to leave a three year old and a newborn in a strange place. I'd leave a four year old at a party and take the other two off somewhere for a while.

woodhill · 16/09/2021 18:01

@stairway

Woodhill I’ve hosted a few parties when I could afford it I have to limit the numbers though. I wouldn’t host a party if there wasn’t going to be food, that’s no way to treat guests. When I’ve not had any money there is no parties.
Stairway - To me though it's the invited guests i.e. The dc not their siblings and parents unless the dc were say under 4 which is different.

I will see the etiquette when I go to dgd birthday soon😀

GreyhoundG1rl · 16/09/2021 11:50

@mymobileisonsilent

Off to a party this weekend, shall I take my toddler too, laughing that I should, as this parent brought theirs to our party (without asking) ? Ohhhhhh I won't, but I really should as revenge.
They'd probably be horrified, and bitch about your cheek to all and sundry. These people usually only see things from one perspective only.
mymobileisonsilent · 16/09/2021 11:48

Off to a party this weekend, shall
I take my toddler too, laughing that I should, as this parent brought theirs to our party (without asking) ? Ohhhhhh I won't, but I really should as revenge.

OP posts:
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 16/09/2021 11:29

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken - the point I was trying to make to you earlier in the thread (clearly not very well at all Blush) was that this thread is about cheeky fuckers who choose to use the party as free child care, and push uninvited children in to partake fully of the party food, games, prizes and party bags.

If you ask the party host parent politely if you can stay with your younger dc, and you take some food with you to give them when the party tea is happening, and you don't let them expect a party bag, you would not be anything like the parents in the OP.

And if it is a party in a church hall, the likelihood is that the party host would be happy for your other dc to stay, and join in, because there would be no extra cost to them - and I'm sure you wouldn't let your children spoil the party for the invited guests - by winning all the games, or making noise whilst the entertainer was doing their act, for example.

In my mind, there is a world of difference between a parent like yourself, who has very valid reasons for not wanting to drop and go, but has no-one local who could look after the other dc for you, and who asks if they can stay, and a CF who has one invited child but shoves others in uninvited and without asking, and lets them ruin the party for the birthday child and the invited guests.