Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Same mum brings older siblingto parties and let's them join in

265 replies

mymobileisonsilent · 12/09/2021 17:18

Now I know some people have to bring siblings and ask in advance. However I know this person doesn't ask, as they brought their older sibling to my child's party a few weeks ago and didn't ask. I had made packed lunches, so I didn't have extra boxes . In fact they didn't even say when arriving. The very rude child then demanded lunch and a party bag, the mum was oblivious and today was style same.

Today this sibling who is at least 5 years older than the birthday child took prizes when not enough for the actual friends of the birthday girl. AIBU, or should I and al parties over cater for a everyone to bring siblings?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GloriaSicTransitMundi · 31/01/2022 15:54

@SMabbutt

If the party is at a hall or your house have someone on the door who is assertive with a table and or gate blocking the way in. Give them a clipboard with the invitees names and a space for the parents name and contact details. Sign them in, have them sent in to the party by a trusted helper and say goodbye to the parent and siblings.

If it is at a soft play or similar give list of names to the front desk and also wait by the signing in area with your own sign in sheet. If a parent tries to walk in with siblings just say oh sorry you need to pay to come in with your other dc. They don't allow child spectators. I'm sure this lady can help sort you out. Oh and there's food and drinks you can buy at the cafe area if you want anything while we are eating in the party room. Then smile sweetly and pass the invited guest over to your oh or nominated helper. If they try to gatecrash the food just hand them back and say sorry, you've gone the wrong way. The cafe is over there. See you at x o'clock. Bigvsmile. Close door.

This exactly - my niece did this, I was her 'enforcer'. Worked a charm as I was visitng from out of town specifically for my DGN's 6th bithday and didn't know anyone. DN gave me a clipboard with list of names and a packet of wristbands. As each child arrived, I ticked off their name and put on a wristband and the leisure centre staff let them through into the party room where DN was waiting with the birthday boy.

I told parents and anyone not on the list sorry, can't help you but the cafe's over there, come back in two hours to collect little Jimmy. I did get lots of muttering and snide looks from parents and loud tears from one much older sibling but just smiled and pointed out the cafe again.

DN had warned me but I thought she was exaggerating, I thought surely her having paid £15 per child for food and activities plus provided cake and goody bags AND specified no parents or siblings, she would only get the invited children. But no! Must have been at least 5 siblings and the same number of parents expecting to party as well, for free.

Showing my age - was very different in my day!

Scatterbrainbox · 31/01/2022 14:54

I must have been really lucky when mine were small. Nobody ever turned up expecting entry to soft play or party bags for uninvited guests. Sometimes at soft play parties, they would being a sibling and pay their own entry or play with them separately.

If it wasn't a pay per head venue the parent (Inc myself when I hosted) would always say that they were welcome, why on earth wouldn't you?!

Oblomov22 · 31/01/2022 14:47

Why are you all so weak that you don't say anything when this all started. Just a polite no, this is not ok, would suffice.

Gonnagetgoing · 31/01/2022 14:20

@Hightemp

Siblings coming to parties were not a thing when my lots were younger…it was unheard of and also there wasn’t the expectation that parents stayed as well! Completely baffles me why this is the trend nowadays!
@Hightemp - if you're my era 1970s then agreed - siblings never came to parties unless as in my and DB's case as our birthdays were same month but he was 2 years younger then often siblings in class were of course invited. Same too, no parents stayed, no such thing as drop offs as they weren't even cheeky then! In fact parents got in the way, having drinks, organising and supervising other people's kids if they did stay!
Gonnagetgoing · 31/01/2022 14:17

As for party bags - we often just had small toy or colouring pens/pad balloon and cake. That was their lot, nothing special!

Gonnagetgoing · 31/01/2022 14:15

when I was a child (child of the 70s) I often had parties with DB as we have birthdays in the same month. Often this meant siblings came as 2 year age gap between all. My best friend had a 5 year younger sibling but she always came along, not an issue. I can't recall parents being there probably not but there were at least 4 responsible adults.

If I went to parties no siblings came. If I went to McDonalds or bowling parties (big and new events then) no extra siblings either.

my NDN has 3 kids eldest now 11, she got sick of all the siblings turning off and 'drop offs'. She just specified after a while that it was fine if they wanted to bring siblings and drop off but to let her know well in advance and preferably if kids were too young to have a parent stay to supervise. One boyfriend of her 8/9 year old was constantly bringing his siblings round on playdates, mum allowed as free childcare.

Ionlydomassiveones · 31/01/2022 14:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

hookiewookie29 · 31/01/2022 14:05

My son is now 23 but I can remember one of his classmates turning up at his party- and the Mum walked out when I wasn't looking and left the other 4 siblings behind as well! One of them was only 3! And they all demanded party bags!

Tree543 · 31/01/2022 13:55

I've had to bring my older child along to parties when the youngest was too young to leave. But he sat with me and the other parents and brought a book or an ipad to occupy him. I wouldn't have dreamed to allow him to eat the food or take a party bag, that is so rude.

St0rmTr00per · 31/01/2022 13:54

I always over cater class parties by 5 for this kind of thing. Shouldn't have to, I know, but I hate the idea of turning a child away. However its when you get to the pay-per-child parties it gets harder. Our school had one family that do this and get their older child to join in and even ask where her meal it. While mum sits smiling at you from afar. I just had to get tougher when she would come to tell me she wanted pizza for her lunch choice and say "im sorry, its been booked for the exact amount of children. However they do serve food in the bar area if your mum wants to get you some lunch". Annoying thing is the families here that do this never have parties of their own.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/01/2022 13:50

PS - I don’t mean he’s fat by that, I mean he’s useless

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/01/2022 13:49

I’m a single parent too so I know it’s hard.

A lot of the worst CF mums have got a lump of lard husband sat at home on his arse, I find.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/01/2022 13:48

@MagentaGiraffe you sound a million miles from these people. You ask and accept no for an answer if not. It’s not the same. The pushy CFs will jsut tell you their other child is coming or more likely just try to drop them off/ shove them into the party and run. Or remain but ignore extra child/ baulk at the suggestion they pay for them if it’s a soft play or similar.

Gizlotsmum · 31/01/2022 13:37

I always used to check if I couldn’t drop and leave ( I also always made sure sibling had food with them and knew it wasn’t their party)

LookItsMeAgain · 31/01/2022 12:59

here you go:

Same mum brings older siblingto parties and let's them join in
HappyDays40 · 31/01/2022 12:58

I would also feel mean making a child stand out or not be able to eat because of numbers. The issue is always the parent not the child.

LookItsMeAgain · 31/01/2022 12:56

@BlackBirdOfChernobyl

My mum never hosted parties for birthdays, instead we had a birthday treat. Usually to a place chosen by the birthday child followed by dinner at McDonald's. It would be us four kids plus a specific friend of the birthday child. Once, only once, did a parent try and shoehorn in an uninvited sibling. My mum told the cf mother, "sorry, but I'm only paying for five kids at the zoo, so he will have to wait outside til we're finished. Also, I'm not paying for any food for him so he'll have to wait til he gets home." The cf mum backed down. No-one ever tried that trick again with my mum.
@BlackBirdOfChernobyl Why did you post this on a thread that was last updated on 19th September 2021???
HappyDays40 · 31/01/2022 12:53

Next time we re in the church hall so they can bring whoever they likeGrin. I'll make sure I've got extra.

HappyDays40 · 31/01/2022 12:51

We had a this at my sons 6th birthday and the numbers were capped. We had a a wildlife guy who was fantastic but he catered for a maximum of 12 children. My son had only just started the school so assumed that the two additional children who came with "Izzie" were other children who had been invited and their parents had made arrangements. It was only when "Leo and Connie " did arrive that I realised that Izzie's mum had dropped off her two siblings and I'd welcomed them in! So we had 14 , wild life man was very gracious and my lovely mum ran out for supplies for party bags.
When Izzie mum collected her three I told her that I was a little surprised about how rude people could be, she hasn't looked me in the eye since.
Other parents commented that I had fallen for an age old trick. Some people have some neck OP.

Darbs76 · 31/01/2022 12:41

It’s so rude. If you must bring a sibling then you ask in advance and pay for their entry if necessary and bring their own food. They don’t join in with games or party bags unless asked

BoredZelda · 31/01/2022 12:41

And yes, those touting the drop and go as the ultimate solutions

I couldn’t ever drop and go. If my daughter had a sibling and my husband was working, I’d have had to take them with me. I always asked if I could stay and yes, I spent most of my time keeping kids in order whilst the host was in the kitchen, sometimes cooking stuff and sometimes drinking with their friends.

BoredZelda · 31/01/2022 12:39

Today this sibling who is at least 5 years older than the birthday child took prizes when not enough for the actual friends of the birthday girl.

And the party organisers said nothing?

I was at a kids party once where the older brother and his friend were jumping in and taking the sweets from the piñata and the little kids got nothing. I made them stop. They did and it was fine.

JustLyra · 31/01/2022 12:36

@Whatwouldscullydo

And yes, those touting the drop and go as the ultimate solutions

Well the host is busy cooking and trying to get the food out and making tea and coffee for the parents. Someone's gotta watch the kids, the ones who fel off the bouncy castle or didnt engage with the entertainer or understand the games or whatever.

Ime it's those who would be considered rude by staying, or having a sibling with them that are doing just that.

Uninvited older siblings have at time been a help. Extra pair of hands fir crowd control etc

I'd rather have them there and buy an extra bag if sweets tbh deal with it all on my own.

The adult hosting the party should have had enough helpers to do all of that, or should have asked parents stay.

The only adults pitching it should be those organised by the host, not random parents with toddlers - and in my experience they’re too busy trying to stop their toddler running away/getting too close to the food/bursting balloons to be much help anyway.

Mummacake · 31/01/2022 12:30

My exH did that to my kids once. I was mortified. The birthday child's mum called me and apologised but there wasn't space for my older and younger child to attend. I had no idea and said I'd let dad know ass it's his weekend. He just wanted to dump the kids. Awful behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread