Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I am idealising this idea? (Remote living)

238 replies

AtlasPine · 12/09/2021 12:25

What is it really like living remotely? I dream of a house on a hillside miles from town but that’s possibly because of being in one of the busier parts of London now. Have you or do you live remotely? What are the unexpected pitfalls? Would you recommend it in practice?

OP posts:
SoloISland · 13/09/2021 06:21

@AlphabetAerobics

I’d also add that there’s no way in hell an OAP would be “left to rot” on their own. Roads not being cleared? Yeh… at 80 you’ve lived enough winters to have stocked cupboards. You have a gas or Rayburn cooker, “power cut” projects, GPs who still do home visits, neighbours who carry your shopping home, mobile library and if the power goes to shit for days on end, you’ll be scooped up on the back of a quad and taken into someone else’s warm home.

There’s no way an OAP here would be left with no recourse to help, they’d never even have to ask.

The school serves the community here and the OAPs come in regularly to spend the morning with the kids and the kids will visit their houses for carols type thing. Nobody is left alone - unless they want it.

I can’t sleep without the sound of a Gale… if I go away i have Alexa play storms to me. 😁

Thank you for this reality. When I needed urgent help? One phone call was all I made. Less than minutes later I was in hospital. And if my shopping list does not reach the mainland supermarket before Thursday? There will be someone here to check. When I lived in a council flat in the middle of Sheffield, the man in the flat below me died and no one found him for a while. He was an older man who closed the door when he got home and never went out then Here they do not intrude but …
Stompythedinosaur · 13/09/2021 00:34

We are pretty rural, but are in a small village (40 houses together, but we are miles from anywhere else). If I'm honest I had fantasised about being completely alone, but feel it wouldn't have suited my dc so much.

There are downsides - need to be organised with shopping as the nearest small shop is half an hour each way, an hour to a proper supermarket. In the winter we are regularly snowed in for a week or more, so supplies are important. A proper pantry is very helpful for food storage for this!

We have electricity but no gas, our heating depends on keeping stoves lit and bringing in coal or wood. This took us a while to get used to, and tbh it is still a huge demand on time in the winter and a pain in the backside. If the stove goes out the house is freezing. Also, if the electricity goes off (which happens pretty regularly) then the stove only heats the room it is in, and we all have to camp out in that room until it is back on.

The lack of local jobs is a big problem. I commute an hour and a half each way, and we spend a lot on fuel. It makes days very tiring. Local childcare options are limited (though we have a fab childminder, I know families who can't find anything suitable). The "local" school is not particularly close, the dc are collected by bus (though this is itself a bit of an experience when they are only 4) and they drive 35 mins to get there. The catchment high school is an hour and a half each way.

When we first moved here it took years to be accepted in any way by the local community. We will always be "outsiders" but after 12 years people will at least speak to us! We had to be pretty thick skinned in the first five years.

There are upsides, of course. It is beautiful. The houses are cheap. It is safe for the dc - playing out is absolutely the norm. Everyone knows each other, which can be a blessing or a curse. Small disputes can become overblown, but there is a real sense of community in serious situations (half the village helped dig our car out when I went into labour with dc2).

A big thing people don't always thing about is the increased chance that your dc will move far away as soon as they hit adulthood. There is very little here for young adults - limited housing, no jobs. Some people return later to have families, but not always.

Sagaz · 13/09/2021 00:01

This has been an interesting thread. I am happy on my own and don't need company, but yet, I need to know that other people are nearby.

I would feel terrified being on an island on my own. In fact, that was the end of a Liz Nugent book!

Rozziie · 12/09/2021 23:10

@thepeopleversuswork

It depends to a large extent on your personality: some people might really take to it.

But I would say that remote, rural communities always look more attractive to ta visitor than to someone who lives there.

We had family friends who lived in a seemingly idyllic house on the beach in a remote and very beautiful part of the countryside. We would visit in the summer. It was an incredible place to stay: the epitome of pastoral bliss. I later learned that the wife in the family had had a series of breakdowns because she felt so isolated for most of the year and they eventually ended up moving back to a city because she couldn't deal with it.

You don't say if you have children but I think you need to think very hard about a rural life for them. Very rural areas are great for small children, not so much for teenagers. Opportunities are more limited, schooling can be a challenge, having a social life requires a great deal of ferrying around from parents and there's often very little to do, leading to higher levels of delinquency and drug-taking.

+1 on the teenagers in rural settings point. It was awful being a teenager in a rural area. I had absolutely nothing to do. No youth clubs, no groups, no hobbies. Nothing at all, because there was no bus route and my parents were both working at the time so couldn't give me any lifts. It felt like being trapped in a prison. Summers would just stretch on and on, with every day just like the one before. I used the time wisely to learn languages and teach myself things, but it was no replacement for developing social skills and spending time with people my age.

The opportunities thing was a very big one for me as well...I had quite a lot of musical talent but just nowhere to develop it. If I'd lived in or near London I'd have auditioned at the BRIT school or whatever, but where I was there was just nowhere to do anything like that. Likewise I had to move away at 18 to go to uni....never had the option of saving money by staying at home because there was nowhere commutable.

I basically just felt like life was happening somewhere else, and I was just wishing away all my teenage years waiting for mine to start. My last ex was from London and I felt so incredibly jealous of all the opportunities he'd had and all the memories he has from his teenage years, bonding with people who are still his best friends now, getting to play small gigs, learning who he was. I think anyone with kids should think twice before moving somewhere rural because it's honestly horrible and grim in many ways.

UrbanRambler · 12/09/2021 22:42

@icedcoffees So, in your area you could buy a 4 bed terace with garden for £80K? Blimey, that's cheap. Whereabouts are you?

TractorAndHeadphones · 12/09/2021 22:21

Just popping on to say thanks all - DP has dreams of rural idyll so showing him.

haba · 12/09/2021 22:17

@SoloISland and @SeriouslyISuppose - thank you for your informative posts, I am so enjoying them!

Van34 · 12/09/2021 21:46

We live in a village of 5 houses (10 people). We are 2.5 miles from the next village where there is a small shop and a pub. It's 8 miles 15minutes to the town which is small but sufficient. Its the best move we ever made. The world could end and we would be non the wiser. Life is slow and calm. We have the best of both worlds with deliveries available from most supermarkets but very little in terms of traffic through the village (dead end). No just eat but that's not an issue fir us really. Do it!! Rural life is awesome

SeriouslyISuppose · 12/09/2021 21:22

[quote CurlyhairedAssassin]**@SoloISland:
And no car and nowhere to go or need to go in bad weather.. Love being snug inside when a Force OTT gale is shaking the place... LOVE that. Safe and snug by the stove with home made chicken soup simmering and a cat or three purring.. Ah BLISS...

Well you do make it sound nice. But what about when tree comes down onto your shed, or blocks the only road, or when tiles are blown off the roof? It's bad enough when that happens when there are services around to help you but I can't imagine how I'd feel if I were out in the country miles from anywhere and totally on my own and a tree came down onto an electricity pylon and cut off my electricity. It wouldn't feel so cosy and safe then.[/quote]
If @SoloISland is where I think, trees aren’t an issue, and she needs a boat rather than a car.

Mintjulia · 12/09/2021 21:04

@leavesthataregreen Interesting isn't it. Four years studying and living in south London and then five years in North London, working. I gave it a good try.

When I left, I didn't have a single person to say goodbye to. It was a relief to leave such a cold blank place. Yet it took five minutes to find some good natured gossip and a shared bottle of wine in Wiltshire. Smile Each to their own.

leavesthataregreen · 12/09/2021 20:40

@Mintjulia

I agree with *@ivykaty44*, I lived in London for 10 years and have never been so lonely as then.

Living in a village may mean no takeaway or theatre but people are available and friendly.

That's interesting because I have never been lonely in London. Even when I first moved there, alone. I made friends within a week or so. Whereas in a village - superficial smiles and hellos but all the cliques are formed.
wildmountaintime · 12/09/2021 20:34

@PersonaNonGarter So sorry to hear that. RIP. Praying.

MrsBobDylan · 12/09/2021 20:28

This is my advice for anyone considering any type of move - work out what you want most from where you live.

It can be practical or emotional. For example, when we moved we wanted it to be cheap (practical). My IL's wanted a property on the sea front (emotional). Then be prepared to compromise on everything else.

icedcoffees · 12/09/2021 19:59

@GettingItOutThere I'm in Cumbria on the coast - outside the National Park.

But people don't want to live here because it's isolated and doesn't have many amenities - no bus service, no UBER, no takeaway deliveries, no McDonald's etc etc.

Our house cost us just under 60k and has a two bedrooms and a garden.

Slippy78 · 12/09/2021 19:56

For all of those mentioning the broadband issue it soon won't be a problem. Starlink will be available to the general public any time now enabling a 150Mb connection wherever you are at a reasonable cost.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 12/09/2021 19:56

@SoloISland:
And no car and nowhere to go or need to go in bad weather.. Love being snug inside when a Force OTT gale is shaking the place... LOVE that. Safe and snug by the stove with home made chicken soup simmering and a cat or three purring.. Ah BLISS...

Well you do make it sound nice. But what about when tree comes down onto your shed, or blocks the only road, or when tiles are blown off the roof? It's bad enough when that happens when there are services around to help you but I can't imagine how I'd feel if I were out in the country miles from anywhere and totally on my own and a tree came down onto an electricity pylon and cut off my electricity. It wouldn't feel so cosy and safe then.

GettingItOutThere · 12/09/2021 19:53

@icedcoffees

How rural are you talking? We're in a small rural town:
  • nearest hospital is a 45 minute drive.
  • no UBEReats or other delivery services.
  • no bus service, irregular trains (often cancelled, especially in winter and they don't run at all on Sundays or BH's), limited and expensive taxi services that need to be booked well in advance for long journeys.
  • the nearest airport is three hours away
  • poor roads in winter which means we're often cut off from everything. DH has numerous "snow days" each year as the roads are closed due to snow and ice or accidents.
  • no cinema, bowling alley or chain restaurant within 45 minutes.
  • harsh winters in terms of weather.

But there are lots of positives

  • gorgeous views and loads of isolated, quiet walks and places to go
  • miles of empty coastline to explore
  • exceptionally dog friendly
  • everyone knows everyone and helps out in an emergency or when you're stuck or in trouble
  • some great local independent restaurants, pubs and cafés
  • property prices are very low - you can get a 4 bed terrace with a garden for less than 80k.
  • fantastic work-life balance for most.

It all depends on what you want and what sacrifices you're prepared to make to get it.

where can i get a house and garden for 80k?!

in a nice area!

SeriouslyISuppose · 12/09/2021 19:45

Sorry, @IngridTails, identifying! (You’re not missing much, it wasn’t particularly good…)

@SoloISland, I still quite fancy living in a lighthouse myself, and have rented lighthouse keepers’ cottages a couple of times for a stay.

I should say I also lived in London for a decade and loved it, and remain nostalgic for it long after I left. The only place in the UK I’ve ever lived where I was totally miserable was a village in the Midlands, which I think was more about insularity than anything.

SoloISland · 12/09/2021 19:37

@Larryyourwaiter

I had a friend who moved remotely. It didn’t work out, there were a few things that killed it for her. The only shop in the hamlet closed, all the shops in the area were super expensive, she spent her whole life driving children about and no one came to visit. We all did visit, but only once or twice. It was a 3 hour round trip, it’s not like popping in for a cuppa. I didn’t like it as we all had to go and her husband and kids were about and was hard to be alone with her. She’s back round the corner now.

I actually know someone who regularly gets cut off for weeks in the winter. She loves it. It’s just her, husband and her dogs. Her only complaint was you have to get used to UHT milk.

The supermarket here does not sell UHT milk. I get three litres fresh, every two weeks, freeze two litres then go on to dried. Grand.
ie ability to adapt is the key.

When I lived in Orkney, I had a goat for milk... hens, geese and ducks,,, Peafowl so tame the peacock would stand in the door with his tail spread,,, Two Jacobs sheep for wool, and was still breeding Siamese cats. Huge vegetable garden ,, and terrifying gales in winter. The gales followed me here.. I earned money by knitting Aran sweaters for the export industry. I have written books, knitted for craft fairs and street markets.. So now I have RETIRED to my small island.. as I have yearned o do since I was sixteen years old.... and hoping never to cross to the mainland again..

islandanchorhold.blogspot.com

AlphabetAerobics · 12/09/2021 19:24

I’d also add that there’s no way in hell an OAP would be “left to rot” on their own. Roads not being cleared? Yeh… at 80 you’ve lived enough winters to have stocked cupboards. You have a gas or Rayburn cooker, “power cut” projects, GPs who still do home visits, neighbours who carry your shopping home, mobile library and if the power goes to shit for days on end, you’ll be scooped up on the back of a quad and taken into someone else’s warm home.

There’s no way an OAP here would be left with no recourse to help, they’d never even have to ask.

The school serves the community here and the OAPs come in regularly to spend the morning with the kids and the kids will visit their houses for carols type thing. Nobody is left alone - unless they want it.

I can’t sleep without the sound of a Gale… if I go away i have Alexa play storms to me. 😁

Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 19:23

I grew up very rurally - in a hamlet more than a village - one of those places where a car drives past and everyone twitches the curtains. Spooky…

I. Hated. It.

Last bus into the local town was something like 4pm, had to drive about 20 minutes to get a pint of milk (and that was during normal opening hours, if it was 11pm you’d be stuffed). Stank of pig shit all the time, was bored stiff, massive spiders coming in the house constantly & I just whiled the years away watching TV unless I had a pre-planned social event. Nothing could be done spontaneously, was so lonely and envious of the kids in town who could just pop round to see each other.

Locals are usually the very elderly, and those who get left behind after leaving school because all their peers with social lives and ambition move to cities. I have to be honest there seems to be so many more oddballs living rurally than in cities.

If you don’t have kids, you’re an introvert and you have a serious and solo hobby like photography/painting/horse riding/archery/cross country running, then go for it. Otherwise choose a nice small town within an hour of a good city.

SoloISland · 12/09/2021 19:14

@2bazookas

Pitfalls are lack of mains public services (water, gas, sewage, sometimes electricity.) or if there is electricity, long power cuts ( because they repair remote supplies last). Not getting roads cleared after snow. ( Difficulty persuading workmen to come to remote location.
 All of the above are perfectly manageable if you are young fit  capable resilient and independent.    But if you  become old frail  ill or disabled you may be forced to leave  at very little notice.</div></div>

Our old folk live out here with their frailties often until their deaths. Some into their hundred years and more With occasional hospital stays.

So your last para? I have disability and am nearly eighty but will do likewise. Very happily.

SoloISland · 12/09/2021 19:07

@SeriouslyISuppose

I used to live on an otherwise uninhabited island — just me. Canister gas cooker, well water, no electricity, wood/turf fire, no non-ruined buildings apart from my cottage, no ferry. Used to arrange with a local fisherman to do a trip to the nearest port to do a supermarket shop periodically, but in bad weather, the island wasn’t reachable at all, as the only slipway was tiny and exposed. I could see the mainland, but often couldn’t have got there if I wanted to.

I loved it, but I enjoy solitude, am physically hardy, had a lot of reading material for bad weather, and was writing a book. And I knew it was for a finite period.

I still dream of that. I really do. Yearn..

Pampered here but this is as near as I will get. My accommodation is suitably simple as there is no bath or shower and no one available to plumb in my washing machine. Back to my childhood life. .
My other yearning was and is to live in a lighthouse. Somewhere like Fastnet right out in the ocean.

We get cut off for a few days each winter. I LOVE it. Feels so safe. Snug and unassailable.
I inquired about one on a different island but was told it was so bad ... it was on land..... that no one would deliver fuel up therein in winter.

Inishkea appeals but here is good too. lol..

thepeopleversuswork · 12/09/2021 18:57

@SoloISland

My post was not aimed at you, it was really at the poster who claimed living in London was isolating.

Horses for courses obviously but this trope irritates me because it’s a cliche usually dispensed by people who have never lived in London and it’s really unfair.

The picture you paint of your life is actually very desirable and I would love to live like this when the time is right (not yet). I can totally see the appeal.

I stand by what I said though about this life not being ideal for younger people.

glacialseafoam · 12/09/2021 18:55

We live off grid 8 miles from nearest small town with crap tiny supermarket. Can’t see any houses from our house/land. Neighbours drive to see us.

Super friendly community, peaceful, amazing views, incredible lifestyle, unbeatable for our kids.

But we are happy in our own/each other’s company and working towards self sufficiency. We have a small holding and we’re literally living our dream.

Annoying if you forget to buy something, but you soon learn!
Had to do school run until this year which took an insane amount out of my day.
When I drive to town to get a takeaway it’s lukewarm by the time I’m home. Haha

Wouldn’t change it for anything, it’s incredible. But very very different to city living.