Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I am idealising this idea? (Remote living)

238 replies

AtlasPine · 12/09/2021 12:25

What is it really like living remotely? I dream of a house on a hillside miles from town but that’s possibly because of being in one of the busier parts of London now. Have you or do you live remotely? What are the unexpected pitfalls? Would you recommend it in practice?

OP posts:
AlphabetAerobics · 13/09/2021 08:31

When I awoke this morning I could hear just one thing - a boat engine. No idea if it was half a mile away - or two miles. As someone else said up thread - it’s very calming.

Trees blowing down are not a concern, however I’m planning to plant pinus nigra and may well regret that in 20 years. Grin the houses are built to last. I think that’s why we see such devastation in the south-east when a storm comes through -the houses just aren’t built for it. Here if a stone wall has been up for 500 years, chances are it’ll make it through this winter.

I personally don’t understand the need to be close to shops. I don’t want to go to the supermarket every day. Worked in Tesco in London when I was young - seen enough supermarkets to last me. My nearest big supermarket is 2 hours and a ferry ride away, so when I do go in I’ll call around friends and tell them to put in a click and collect to save THEM a boring job.

I was a little worried about the lady previously who said she’d be devastated and “have to leave” were her husband to die in the house. At least one person has died in this house and all I think is lucky them! And also have a feeling they’re here looking out for us.

The salt air is hard on cars, so that’s a fair expense - tip for the landlubbers- don’t ever buy a second hand car with island plates!

CounsellorTroi · 13/09/2021 08:24

I love city living but there was one time I really felt lucky to live there - when DH got cancer and was having radiotherapy every day for several weeks. The cancer hospital was only a few minutes drive away.

BigHeartyTruffle · 13/09/2021 08:14

I would really echo everything people have said about it being rubbish as a teenager. I grew up in a tiny village, went to the village primary school, had loads of friends at the same school in the village and we had a brilliant time running riot between each other’s houses and around the countryside.
From secondary school onwards it was a bit of a nightmare. I relied on my parents for lifts everywhere and to be honest spent a lot of my time really bored, which as others have said led to mischief! I don’t think it led to any long term damage but I would have much rather have lived somewhere with a bit more going on.
Incidentally, I now live in a city and absolutely love going to visit my parents in the countryside - feels like a “weekend retreat” Grin. Also now my mum has retired she has made an invaluable group of friends in the village, who gave her so much support (practically and socially) while she was going through cancer treatment.

BertramLacey · 13/09/2021 08:11

Maybe it doesn't happen where you are. But I know people from other small communities that have moved away, and they all feel similarly to me. So it seems like your community is either the exception, or is just different if your whole family isn't part of it.

IME small communities vary hugely even within one area. I live in a small town. I mean officially it's a town but if you drove through it, you'd think it was a village. People know me but if they gossip, I'm pretty much unaware of it. The people at the grocery store know where I live and they will drop stuff off for me if they haven't got it in stock but will be getting it later that day. The next town along is a different matter though. I know people who've moved from there because of the level of prying gossip. I think in small communities a handful of people can make a big difference to your experience of the place.

I grew up in a city. I was horribly bullied and formed no enduring friendships. There's no-one from back then that I'm still in touch with. I didn't go to gigs, or pubs or do any of the things I could have done given my location. I watch teenagers near me and many of them do enjoy life round here, if they like outdoor activities. They may well have to move to work and study though.

In my 20s I enjoyed being in big cities. I think it would make me ill if I tried it now.

CrabbyCat · 13/09/2021 08:05

My parents spent every school holiday somewhere fairly remote. As others have said, for a primary aged child, it was idyllic, for secondary aged less so - other than the twice weekly bus into the nearest small market town, there was no way of doing anything independently. DSis lives there now, her oldest DC is now 14. So far doesn't seem as bad for them, fibre broadband made it to the hamlet a few years ago and they spend hours on their tablet which I suspect is what they'd do in a city anyway.

We are rural but less remote. The main thing I'm noticing at the moment is how much is restricts choices about kids after school activities unless you are prepared to drive for miles.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 07:56

@Whinge

I basically just felt like life was happening somewhere else, and I was just wishing away all my teenage years waiting for mine to start. My last ex was from London and I felt so incredibly jealous of all the opportunities he'd had and all the memories he has from his teenage years, bonding with people who are still his best friends now, getting to play small gigs, learning who he was. I think anyone with kids should think twice before moving somewhere rural because it's honestly horrible and grim in many ways.

Sadly I don't think your experience is an uncommon one. I'd be really interested to hear from others who were teenagers living rurally. Anecdotally from those I know, it wasn't a positive experience for any of them. Primary years were fantastic. But being a teenager living rurally was for many of my friends a very difficult few years, mostly spent counting down until they could escape.

I left home aged 17, for that reason. Ended up going back (long story) and staying way longer than I intended.

Opportunities where I'm from are very limited. They are improving - the internet has played a big part in that. But there is a constant concern about young people moving away and not coming back. Depopulation is an issue. There is however a huge number of people that seem to want to move there. But often the idyll that they thought they were going to doesn't match with the reality, and after a couple of years they head back to the mainland. Some do love it though.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 07:48

@alwayscrashinginthesamecar1

I am a fairly introverted and self sufficient person, but living in a remote rural area (especially one with cold and windy weather) would be my idea of utter hell. I have visited and stayed on several Irish islands, and they are beautiful of course, but I like people and shops and restaurants and doing different things., so deeply rural life just sounds rubbish to me. I am lucky enough to live beside a beautiful beach, and am also 40 minutes by train to the city centre, that's much more my kind of thing. But we are all different, and thank goodness for it!
lol.. absolutely all are differnet. Else it would get crowded out here.. lol...I used to visit islands wherever I was and hated leaving in the evening. Now I never leave...

But remote life IS a way of life not an address. You either love it or run for your sanity..lol…

Off to finalise my shopping list... tweaking..

Whinge · 13/09/2021 07:48

I basically just felt like life was happening somewhere else, and I was just wishing away all my teenage years waiting for mine to start. My last ex was from London and I felt so incredibly jealous of all the opportunities he'd had and all the memories he has from his teenage years, bonding with people who are still his best friends now, getting to play small gigs, learning who he was. I think anyone with kids should think twice before moving somewhere rural because it's honestly horrible and grim in many ways.

Sadly I don't think your experience is an uncommon one. I'd be really interested to hear from others who were teenagers living rurally. Anecdotally from those I know, it wasn't a positive experience for any of them. Primary years were fantastic. But being a teenager living rurally was for many of my friends a very difficult few years, mostly spent counting down until they could escape.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 07:43

PS not sure if I mentioned this on the thread ? It only intensified what I was already living anyways.

I have serious CFS/ME. And when I asked about the illness in old age I was told by the experts that they do not know as very few live to my age and the main cause of death is overhwleming infection.
I already knew that my immune system is down
SO talked it over with faraway family and we decided to take my island solitude a stage further.
So no more outings etc and that for me when supply lines are so good, is prefect. And saved me having to replace my old car. And retake a driving test due to my age.
So when covid hit I was already in total isolation and my neighbours etc know and respect that. There is a big gate and we chat over it. Masked....
I live as an old style anchoress now. Lacking nothing. And safe in every way.
With deep and enduring pleasure..

This thread has really reaffirmed the rightness FOR ME of my chosen lifestyle. THANK YOU ALL

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 13/09/2021 07:37

I am a fairly introverted and self sufficient person, but living in a remote rural area (especially one with cold and windy weather) would be my idea of utter hell. I have visited and stayed on several Irish islands, and they are beautiful of course, but I like people and shops and restaurants and doing different things., so deeply rural life just sounds rubbish to me. I am lucky enough to live beside a beautiful beach, and am also 40 minutes by train to the city centre, that's much more my kind of thing. But we are all different, and thank goodness for it!

HedgeVeg · 13/09/2021 07:37

Depends on your definition of remote, but we live on a small island (3 sq miles) with a population of about 1900. Food is delivered once a week on a big boat, which is regularly unable to dock.
Everyone knows everyone: so you'll be greeted by name in the street, but there's no avoiding the awful ones either.
Amazon deliver here Grin (though not next day) which maintains some sanity but if you want something you can't find on the island, getting off the island is very challenging, particularly in winter.

It's an adventure, but not one we will make a lifelong commitment too.

Stircraazy · 13/09/2021 07:37

I am in the countryside. small village nearby. I think having a mix of incomers and long term residents is the best to avoid gossip, make friends.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 07:34

@Malin52

I don't even live that rurally but things I never thought about were:
  • tradespeople: rarely in the locale and if they are then they are expensive and impossible to book. Shower not working? Electricity suddenly off? 3 week wait before someone will come to 'look'
  • so hard for people to visit if you are miles from train stations etc. also don't expect to pop to a fiends house unless you fancy a major expedition. Ime people just say it's too far to visit.
  • run out of milk? 40 mins there and back in the car. You have to be so organised.
  • you need a car that can cope with extremes of weather and potential terrain. These are usually expensive to run

Plenty more that have already been mentioned.

As I have posted, we get instant attention in power cuts - far faster than on the mainland. ESB our power people have a fine reputation well deserved. And not a huge disaster to be without for a while. Minor really. Ditto a shower; washing is easy enough.

Milk? I keep dried in and that is fine. Milk also freezes well.

And running out if milk is hardly a real problem? A minor thing. .

Yes organised and that becomes second nature. It really does
And that actually is a large part of the appeal ; taking full responsibility for your life and welfare. Not sweating the small stuff

I could list dozens of really hard things re city life but they are not my problem now and never will be.. Thankfully.. Worst is the loneliness in crowded places. Shudders. Faces in a crowd. Impersonal passers by.

But each to their own. Nothing folk have listed here exists as a real problem, Assuming the post re walking six miles to buy frozen peas was a hoax... lol...

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 07:33

@SoloISland I can only speak from my experience. Which is 45+ years of living remotely and 4 years of city living.

Maybe if it's not a place where you are born and brought up, it's different. Maybe if everyone around you don't know you and all your family.

But I am glad to be free of it. I find it stifling. I know what people say about others, I know the assumptions that are made. I was told at work a relative of mine had been killed in a car accident. He hadn't been. He was in a car accident, but he walked away with a single broken bone. When I was pregnant, people decided it was my ex's baby. It wasn't.

Where I am now, it's not free of care. People do care, people are interested. They just have enough people around and enough things happening that the kind of crap that goes on in small communities doesn't happen.

Maybe it doesn't happen where you are. But I know people from other small communities that have moved away, and they all feel similarly to me. So it seems like your community is either the exception, or is just different if your whole family isn't part of it.

bumblingbovine49 · 13/09/2021 07:30

@icedcoffees

How rural are you talking? We're in a small rural town:
  • nearest hospital is a 45 minute drive.
  • no UBEReats or other delivery services.
  • no bus service, irregular trains (often cancelled, especially in winter and they don't run at all on Sundays or BH's), limited and expensive taxi services that need to be booked well in advance for long journeys.
  • the nearest airport is three hours away
  • poor roads in winter which means we're often cut off from everything. DH has numerous "snow days" each year as the roads are closed due to snow and ice or accidents.
  • no cinema, bowling alley or chain restaurant within 45 minutes.
  • harsh winters in terms of weather.

But there are lots of positives

  • gorgeous views and loads of isolated, quiet walks and places to go
  • miles of empty coastline to explore
  • exceptionally dog friendly
  • everyone knows everyone and helps out in an emergency or when you're stuck or in trouble
  • some great local independent restaurants, pubs and cafés
  • property prices are very low - you can get a 4 bed terrace with a garden for less than 80k.
  • fantastic work-life balance for most.

It all depends on what you want and what sacrifices you're prepared to make to get it.

For me the positives are really nowhere near enough to offset the negatives but I am a city girl at heart and getting older so find the idea of too much isolation scary. I want to be able to walk to a shop and get to a hospital reasonably easily as I get older. I know quite a few older people who live in very isolated places ( in the country my parents were born in) and their lives become so small.very early in their old age. It suits some of them but a lot of them are very unhappy . When I compare it with the life full of friends and activities my parents.had for the first 20 years of their retirement I know which I want
SoloISland · 13/09/2021 07:22

From my back garden

And the over one hundred and fifty year old shed wall. Built by the then owner by hand with rocks from the shore.

To think I am idealising this idea? (Remote living)
To think I am idealising this idea? (Remote living)
Stircraazy · 13/09/2021 07:20

Are you single @SoloISland - I'm just thinking it's quite hard to make such a dramatic move as the chances are your partner is not on board with all it entails.

I would probably turn off the internet part of the week, food shop much less often, make fewer car journeys if DH agreed, but he feels he worked hard all his life and deserves to benefit from it now.

Malin52 · 13/09/2021 07:20

I don't even live that rurally but things I never thought about were:

  • tradespeople: rarely in the locale and if they are then they are expensive and impossible to book. Shower not working? Electricity suddenly off? 3 week wait before someone will come to 'look'
  • so hard for people to visit if you are miles from train stations etc. also don't expect to pop to a fiends house unless you fancy a major expedition. Ime people just say it's too far to visit.
  • run out of milk? 40 mins there and back in the car. You have to be so organised.
  • you need a car that can cope with extremes of weather and potential terrain. These are usually expensive to run

Plenty more that have already been mentioned.

Stircraazy · 13/09/2021 07:17

We lived in a city in the SE of England and school was 1500 pupil comp. DS1 enjoyed it, lots of sports nearby. Moved north DS2 went to a 400 pupil comp in a small rural town! loved it, thrived, captained the footie team, made lots of friends, could cycle to meet up, drive when he was older. Still close to them 10 years on. DS1 in touch with a couple.

It often depends on temperament or luck whether a move is a good think or not.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 07:16

Opps I meant forty minutes.. I keep forgetting the top row of my keyboard has gone awol.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 07:13

@EverybodyIsInteresting

If you like living in a place where you are quite happy for people to (think they) know your business, rural living is perfect for you.

If you value privacy then odd as it might sound, live where there are lots of people.

That is not true out here. Privacy is respected. No one intrudes on my privacy not I on theirs. I actually know a great deal re many folk here but so what? Respecting them all the more.

And folk will only know the superficial stuff.

City so called privacy is lack of care and caring.. The worst kind of reclusivity. Anonymity.

Here there are boundaries we do not cross because we respect.

No nosey parker officials either..

icedcoffees · 13/09/2021 07:09

[quote UrbanRambler]@icedcoffees So, in your area you could buy a 4 bed terace with garden for £80K? Blimey, that's cheap. Whereabouts are you?[/quote]
Yes - there's one for sale on my road for about that price now.

I'm in rural, coastal Cumbria.

But nobody wants to live here as a general rule as it's isolated, we still have half day openings on Wednesday and Saturday. Most things close on Sundays. We don't have UBER or takeaway deliveries. No McDonald's, no fast food, no chain shops or restaurants except two small supermarkets within a 45 minute drive.

The roads are bad, and we get cut off fairly easily in winter due to floods, snow or ice too.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 07:06

[quote icedcoffees]@GettingItOutThere I'm in Cumbria on the coast - outside the National Park.

But people don't want to live here because it's isolated and doesn't have many amenities - no bus service, no UBER, no takeaway deliveries, no McDonald's etc etc.

Our house cost us just under 60k and has a two bedrooms and a garden.[/quote]
What is UBER? I have never had McDonalds etc. Not even fish and chips for many years and that was when I had a family member here. lol..

Puzzles me here the craze for takeaways, Chinese food etc. lol..same over here. .

But mulling all this fascinating thread over in the night? Remote is not a place. It is a way of life like no other. Unique. Living it is not about replicating city or town life but adapting and enjoying the change. And the challenge.

Wonderful thread; thank you everyone,

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 07:00

If you like living in a place where you are quite happy for people to (think they) know your business, rural living is perfect for you.

If you value privacy then odd as it might sound, live where there are lots of people.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 06:47

[quote CurlyhairedAssassin]@SoloISland:
And no car and nowhere to go or need to go in bad weather.. Love being snug inside when a Force OTT gale is shaking the place... LOVE that. Safe and snug by the stove with home made chicken soup simmering and a cat or three purring.. Ah BLISS...

Well you do make it sound nice. But what about when tree comes down onto your shed, or blocks the only road, or when tiles are blown off the roof? It's bad enough when that happens when there are services around to help you but I can't imagine how I'd feel if I were out in the country miles from anywhere and totally on my own and a tree came down onto an electricity pylon and cut off my electricity. It wouldn't feel so cosy and safe then.[/quote]
Honestly if you are getting into the realms of what iffery and what aboutery?

We have no tall trees on this side of the island, . The gales scoured them all.... lol...

And think? The folk who lived out here generations ago built houses that are as solid as the rocks they are built on. No flimsy roof tiles. Houses built in the safest aof places and low to the ground.

There is a ruining cottage next door and it was built by hand well over a hundred and fifty years ago. Will try to attach a photo of the gable end wall of one of the sheds/
Power cuts are no great deal. Because of a council and ESb cock up I was without electricity for my first five months out here September to January.

I remember only the sheer peace of that winter. The only thing I missed was the internet and when I went over for shopping as I was doing then and had a car, I took my laptop with me. Got stranded over once and the Parish priest was told and kindly found me and stumped up for a B and B. With free internet.

My memories are of peace in storms. I had a gas cooker by then but the first while it was not connected. I had provided a camping stove in case of this and had the solid fuel stove . Of reading in bed with a torch on my shoulder. Listening to the small radio I bought.

Totally safe and totally cost,

We do get the occasional power cut. But they give the islands priority and ESB, the power folk, have a hugely efficient breakdown /repair system. Especially out here,
A few months ago my power failed. and the trip switch was no help. I had thought it was a power cut but when I called a neighbour?Then it was just the sockets that were out. By then the repair engineers had been notified and I called them to tell them the new situation, He told me to get my own electrician but when I said I was alone and where I was an my age etc? They came over by a special ferry and fixed it. No charge,
Really there is as they say nothing to fear but fear itself.

But as I was thinking earlier. living remote is a way of life not a location.