Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I am idealising this idea? (Remote living)

238 replies

AtlasPine · 12/09/2021 12:25

What is it really like living remotely? I dream of a house on a hillside miles from town but that’s possibly because of being in one of the busier parts of London now. Have you or do you live remotely? What are the unexpected pitfalls? Would you recommend it in practice?

OP posts:
Rozziie · 13/09/2021 12:03

@witheringrowan I didn't live in a village, I lived in an isolated house in the middle of nowhere with no other houses in sight. I couldn't even walk to a shop to get myself a can of Coke or a bag of crisps. I was completely reliant on my parents for absolutely everything and was unable to gain any independence.

As I said, I also entertained myself. I taught myself three foreign languages, piano and flute to Grade 8 standard and watched a lot of arty foreign films. But for an autistic child who already had social difficulties, being cut off from other kids my age was really bad for my development. I started university at 18 having never kissed anyone, never dated, never really having been to a party. I was painfully shy and was probably naive to a dangerous extent, as were others who grew up very rurally.

It also completely cuts off options for things like dance classes, gymnastics, team sports, etc. I enjoyed dance classes as a younger child living in a town and it simply wasn't possible to carry on when we moved to live rurally. I also had no ability to take my music any further. This reduced my options for the future at a very young age.

AlphabetAerobics · 13/09/2021 12:02

😂 fuck me. I’ve lived in a city bigger than London and of COURSE people are curious about where you come from/what’s your story?

I never once assumed “racist plonker” - but always told them what they wanted to hear.

If people had zero interest in anything outside themselves they’d really not be much fun to be around. I assume you’re not interested in eg the stories of women fleeing Afghanistan? That you’ll just pretend they were born and bred Henley so you don’t appear small-minded?

Peace43 · 13/09/2021 12:00

Depends how remote. I live in a small rural village. We only get EE and it only works in direct line of sight to the mast (so not in most parts of the village!). We now have fibre but it hasn’t made it to the next village up the valley yet. There is no cable or mains gas. I have an oil fired boiler and a tank that I order a top up for every few months. Most major supermarkets deliver which is great because the nearest decent sized shop is a 30 minute drive away. We have a Spar, small welsh language primary school, pharmacy, pub and a saddle shop!
Everyone has lived here forever (I grew up here, moved away for 10 years and then came back). The walks are lovely, everyone chats to me. I know all the ladies in the Spar, the postman, the Hermes lady etc by name. My family live here. I love my wood fire. I can’t hear traffic. It’s a total pain in the arse to leave the valley to go shopping and I miss Starbucks!

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 12:00

@lazylinguist

I think anyone with kids should think twice before moving somewhere rural because it's honestly horrible and grim in many ways.

There is nothing grim about where we live (on the edge of the Lake District)! My dc are now 13 and 16 and we've lived in a village in a rural area for 7 years. They've been happy here so far. Dd16 is beginning to get slightly itchy feet now and is liking the idea of going to a (preferably smallish) city for university , but she has plenty of local friends, gets the train into Lancaster or occasionally Manchester or hangs out more locally. Ds13 has no desire to be anywhere bigger or busier yet.

I find it odd when people talk about a downside of rural living being the necessity of moving away to have a career. I don't really know anybody who went to university and then went back to settle and work in the place they came from, whether town, city or rural. It wouldn't occur to me to expect my dc to want to come back to live locally as adults.

Nothing horrible or grim out here, lol... all peaceful and beautiful....,...
SoloISland · 13/09/2021 11:57

@EverybodyIsInteresting

Being English of course.. I was quizzed about my ancestry.. lol.. And I do have Irish ancestry..

A perfect example of people being nosy and wanting to know your business. I've never felt the need to quiz anyone on their ancestry. It's most often irrelevant. But there are people where I come from that only consider you a local if all your grandparents were born and brought up there. I wish I was joking.

Some people can be so small minded about what is, effectively, something completely outside of your control.

Ah nol

The man who asked was all in favour of my coming here and trying to find reasons for approval from others who I did not know then were difficult men... sheer kind diplomacy..

And by the way, what do you know of Irish history where the English are concerned? Not good, not good at all...

I understood perfectly and took no offence. He is a lovely man this one.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 11:53

scrowyl re your last paras.. We have a couple like that out here. I was the first they attacked so I vamoosed home.
Heard later that, to quote the person telling me that they had been put back in their box... They thought they were going to reorganise and save the island...

I did as you say is right. Just came and watched and waited,

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 13/09/2021 11:50

Oh lordy, Young Farmers was NOT my style when I lived in a country town. I was taken to what was locally known as the Culchie disco once, never ever again. As I've said on here before, some people are country people and some just are not!

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 11:47

re being near a hospital. I have always known and thought but refuse to let fear and what might happen dictate my life.

We cannot all crowd in large towns

Also reading recent threads re ambulance delays gives a more aware scenario.

AlphabetAerobics · 13/09/2021 11:46

@Scrowy oh yes, the assumption that everyone’s uncultured, thick as mince and racist is tiresome.

From my house I can see two houses I know hold “grade 8” pianists (those are just the ones I know of), there are polyglots and those who’d be right at home on university challenge.

But… seeing them in filthy clothes and a year overdue a barber would have many sneer.

Scrowy · 13/09/2021 10:50

Yes on the teenagers thing, it was obviously some time ago now for me but I never really felt 'trapped' in the same way that a lot of parents on here report their teenagers feel living in rural areas.

I was in Young Farmers though, and out with them several nights a week from age 11 until my late 20s and the older members would pick us up if parents couldn't/wouldn't take us and once I became an older member I did the same.

As a teen nearly all of my friends also lived on farms or semi rurally, we saw each other at school and at young farmers.

I would encourage anyone living in a rural area to sign the children up for young farmers even if you have never been on a farm in your life. It's a very quick way to make friends for younger teenagers and a great social opportunity for older teens.

They do everything from public speaking/debate competitions, to baking/making, community work, fundraising for local charities, competing in indoor and outdoor sports and there's always a little bit of 'stock judging' thrown in for good measure.

lazylinguist · 13/09/2021 10:42

I think anyone with kids should think twice before moving somewhere rural because it's honestly horrible and grim in many ways.

There is nothing grim about where we live (on the edge of the Lake District)! My dc are now 13 and 16 and we've lived in a village in a rural area for 7 years. They've been happy here so far. Dd16 is beginning to get slightly itchy feet now and is liking the idea of going to a (preferably smallish) city for university , but she has plenty of local friends, gets the train into Lancaster or occasionally Manchester or hangs out more locally. Ds13 has no desire to be anywhere bigger or busier yet.

I find it odd when people talk about a downside of rural living being the necessity of moving away to have a career. I don't really know anybody who went to university and then went back to settle and work in the place they came from, whether town, city or rural. It wouldn't occur to me to expect my dc to want to come back to live locally as adults.

witheringrowan · 13/09/2021 10:23

@Whinge

I basically just felt like life was happening somewhere else, and I was just wishing away all my teenage years waiting for mine to start. My last ex was from London and I felt so incredibly jealous of all the opportunities he'd had and all the memories he has from his teenage years, bonding with people who are still his best friends now, getting to play small gigs, learning who he was. I think anyone with kids should think twice before moving somewhere rural because it's honestly horrible and grim in many ways.

Sadly I don't think your experience is an uncommon one. I'd be really interested to hear from others who were teenagers living rurally. Anecdotally from those I know, it wasn't a positive experience for any of them. Primary years were fantastic. But being a teenager living rurally was for many of my friends a very difficult few years, mostly spent counting down until they could escape.

I grew up in a village of about 100 people, and at the time my sisters & I were the only children. I really don't recognise the stories of boredom & frustration. My teenage years felt very free, but it was mostly wandering around the countryside. My best friend lived in a village about 20 minutes drive away, so we were reliant on lifts from parents, but we'd spend most Saturdays hanging out together. One sister spent her weekends helping at the local stables, my other one did a lot of complicated art projects.

I read a huge amount, trips to the cinema or to go shopping were a big event, I had to get used to talking to adults from a young age because there were no other teenagers in the village, but I don't remember being bored or frustrated, and I don't think now that I missed out on much compared to those who grew up in a city. I had be resourceful and independent, entertainment wasn't laid out on a plate, but I think that has been valuable later in life. The biggest downside is lack of employment opportunity & the necessity of moving away for a career - of the three of us, 2 are in London, 1 is in Paris, and it's a full weekend at the minimum if I want to go to see my parents.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 10:20

Being English of course.. I was quizzed about my ancestry.. lol.. And I do have Irish ancestry..

A perfect example of people being nosy and wanting to know your business. I've never felt the need to quiz anyone on their ancestry. It's most often irrelevant. But there are people where I come from that only consider you a local if all your grandparents were born and brought up there. I wish I was joking.

Some people can be so small minded about what is, effectively, something completely outside of your control.

HereticFanjo · 13/09/2021 10:12

Love this thread!

Scrowy · 13/09/2021 10:09

[quote hellcatspangle]@Scrowy you're not selling it very well 😂[/quote]
Just trying to be realistic Grin

In reality I love living rurally but the difference for me is that other than a short stint at a city university (which I also liked but found my self craving wide open spaces too much to stay)I've always lived rurally remotely so it runs through me like writing through rock. All those things on my list are as routine for me as locking the doors would be for someone in the city.

I've also seen lots of people come and go over the years in nearby remote properties wanting this life but finding the reality isn't what they were expecting. Some stay a decade or so but very few stay 'forever'.

People always think they will like the remoteness because they think it is all about pretty countryside and no neighbours. The 'difficulties' like frequent power cuts sound like fun adventures, and probably are the first few times. Then it becomes an irritation and the rot starts to set in.

The saddest bit for me is how many people move to a rural area and then try and change it. Complain about tractors working, mud on the roads, smell, people being 'unfriendly' in the pub or the local shop. Those people are always the ones in the converted barn conversions and the ex farmhouses who shut themselves away and treat the locals as if they were straw chewing thickos.

The people who move into the local village and throw themselves into village life and embrace things the way they are find themselves very quickly considered part of the community no matter what colour/background they are.

80sPadme · 13/09/2021 10:02

I'm in rural Scotland and do enjoy most of it, I town is quite apathetic to change though and are happy with outdated facilities and run down buildings. Sometimes motivating the school to make changes is exhausting and it's very isolating at times. Other than that it is wonderful.

Rozziie · 13/09/2021 10:00

@Doomscrolling

I’ve really enjoyed reading everyone’s different experiences.

I have several different friends who changed their lives and live very remotely. I love vicariously sharing their adventures but still turn away with a slight shudder. When various medical emergencies cropped up, air ambulances had to take them many miles away and the delays in treatment had some significant impacts. I may be a soft urbanite, but my goodness there are advantages.

I go to the theatre six or seven times a year. I while away an afternoon at the cinema at least once a month and then browse a good book shop. I like eating in restaurants, and having a wide range of foods available. I want to be able to to get medical help when needed. A dream of a rural idyll is lovely, but in reality I choose differently.

(I still keep chickens though. Even city people can do that)

A few people in my secondary school died because they had accidents (usually farm accidents) and they just couldn't get to hospital in time - the nearest A&E was well over an hour away. Quite a few others lost parents to sudden illnesses that might well have been survivable had they had a hospital nearby. The nearest maternity hospital was about 1.5 hours away so God help you if you went into early labour and something went wrong. People really just don't think about this stuff when they assume rural living is idyllic and lovely.
SoloISland · 13/09/2021 09:42

@Doomscrolling

I’ve really enjoyed reading everyone’s different experiences.

I have several different friends who changed their lives and live very remotely. I love vicariously sharing their adventures but still turn away with a slight shudder. When various medical emergencies cropped up, air ambulances had to take them many miles away and the delays in treatment had some significant impacts. I may be a soft urbanite, but my goodness there are advantages.

I go to the theatre six or seven times a year. I while away an afternoon at the cinema at least once a month and then browse a good book shop. I like eating in restaurants, and having a wide range of foods available. I want to be able to to get medical help when needed. A dream of a rural idyll is lovely, but in reality I choose differently.

(I still keep chickens though. Even city people can do that)

Air ambulance cover here is a lifesaver. Once was evacuated with internal bleeding . As soon as they answered triple nine you could hear the urgency ramping up and by the time a designated neighbour got me to the helipad the Bird was landing.
By ferry and road would have been over two hours; as it was when I lived in the Kerry mountains. Two hours to get to me then two hours to the hospital. …
The Irish Coastguard are heroes, Rescue one one six was lost with all crew not so long ago
SoloISland · 13/09/2021 09:34

[quote EverybodyIsInteresting]@SoloISland I can only speak from my experience. Which is 45+ years of living remotely and 4 years of city living.

Maybe if it's not a place where you are born and brought up, it's different. Maybe if everyone around you don't know you and all your family.

But I am glad to be free of it. I find it stifling. I know what people say about others, I know the assumptions that are made. I was told at work a relative of mine had been killed in a car accident. He hadn't been. He was in a car accident, but he walked away with a single broken bone. When I was pregnant, people decided it was my ex's baby. It wasn't.

Where I am now, it's not free of care. People do care, people are interested. They just have enough people around and enough things happening that the kind of crap that goes on in small communities doesn't happen.

Maybe it doesn't happen where you are. But I know people from other small communities that have moved away, and they all feel similarly to me. So it seems like your community is either the exception, or is just different if your whole family isn't part of it.[/quote]
Being a small offshore island with a tiny populations makes a difference.

An d I am not in touch with anyone socially out here. I do what small kindnesses I can remotely and support the local community like that.

No it has not been all sweetness and light; no community ever is. But I weathered a few issues early on with calm and efficiency and am left in peace now.

Weathering all the snags etc. I did have to call the Gardaí once so they know I will do that at need,

Being English of course.. I was quizzed about my ancestry.. lol.. And I do have Irish ancestry..

I came here with three rescued cats. Now I care for the cats left when folk die. Deep rural cats are cruelly neglected in Ireland so I quietly set that right. No reproof to them. Just do what is needful with a loving heart. Stretches my pension.. lol

My responsibility is what I think and do. Not what others think and do. Render to no man evil for evil.. I hear no gossip and say none.

And what matters to me is the sheer peace and beauty here in the life I lead. The lands and ocean. Wild flowers, birds.

Just heard the chopper; I don't think it was for here but I will check with my nearest neighbour and offer prayer and concern.

hellcatspangle · 13/09/2021 09:13

@Scrowy you're not selling it very well 😂

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 09:12

@HedgeVeg

Depends on your definition of remote, but we live on a small island (3 sq miles) with a population of about 1900. Food is delivered once a week on a big boat, which is regularly unable to dock. Everyone knows everyone: so you'll be greeted by name in the street, but there's no avoiding the awful ones either. Amazon deliver here Grin (though not next day) which maintains some sanity but if you want something you can't find on the island, getting off the island is very challenging, particularly in winter.

It's an adventure, but not one we will make a lifelong commitment too.

That is a high density population. Far too much so for me. I checked al the islands and discounted the ones like that.. lol..

We are very few here now. Very few. . Couriers do not come out here but An Post are excellent.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 09:08

@Sagaz

This has been an interesting thread. I am happy on my own and don't need company, but yet, I need to know that other people are nearby.

I would feel terrified being on an island on my own. In fact, that was the end of a Liz Nugent book!

When I left Orkney , ie anither island, I was terrified at the realisation that anyone could get to my home. Just terrified. I felt so vulnerable. Safe again now

I could relish being alone out here as long as they did food drops etc... lol... Very practical..

Doomscrolling · 13/09/2021 09:00

I’ve really enjoyed reading everyone’s different experiences.

I have several different friends who changed their lives and live very remotely. I love vicariously sharing their adventures but still turn away with a slight shudder. When various medical emergencies cropped up, air ambulances had to take them many miles away and the delays in treatment had some significant impacts. I may be a soft urbanite, but my goodness there are advantages.

I go to the theatre six or seven times a year. I while away an afternoon at the cinema at least once a month and then browse a good book shop. I like eating in restaurants, and having a wide range of foods available. I want to be able to to get medical help when needed. A dream of a rural idyll is lovely, but in reality I choose differently.

(I still keep chickens though. Even city people can do that)

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 08:39

When I awoke this morning I could hear just one thing - a boat engine

I could just hear birds. In fact I hear more birdsong where I live now than I ever heard in the place I'm from. Maybe it's the lack of trees.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 08:32

@CounsellorTroi

I love city living but there was one time I really felt lucky to live there - when DH got cancer and was having radiotherapy every day for several weeks. The cancer hospital was only a few minutes drive away.
I hear you. When my Dad was in hospital on the mainland for weeks at a time having treatment for cancer, I could only visit a couple of times due to the distance and cost of travel.

I am very glad you could be there for your DH.