Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I am idealising this idea? (Remote living)

238 replies

AtlasPine · 12/09/2021 12:25

What is it really like living remotely? I dream of a house on a hillside miles from town but that’s possibly because of being in one of the busier parts of London now. Have you or do you live remotely? What are the unexpected pitfalls? Would you recommend it in practice?

OP posts:
EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 16:07

I can totally understand what @SoloISland says about the need for incomers to respect the heritage of the people who have been living somewhere and not push to change things or throw your weight around. That's totally reasonable

Fully in agreement with this. But then, being from a remote place means I've seen it happen all too often, and it rarely end with those that do that settling in permanently.

If I have said anything that suggests otherwise, then it's a misinterpretation based on the fact that I'm not taking as an incomer, I'm talking as a 'born and bred with a family tree that goes back many generations on both sides'.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/09/2021 14:53

I prefer to be somewhere where that doesn't matter. Where I can be me without every man and his dog trying to find a box to put me in. And, in my opinion, that's fine too.

I agree with this and this is why ultimately I think I would really struggle to settle somewhere really remote.

I can totally understand what @SoloISland says about the need for incomers to respect the heritage of the people who have been living somewhere and not push to change things or throw your weight around. That's totally reasonable.

But ultimately I want to reserve the right to be who I choose to be, not have my place in the ecosystem assigned to me by people just because they have lived somewhere longer than me. And I don't want people assuming I am no more than the sum total of my upbringing and background.

Not all small rural communities are backwards-looking by a long stretch but in my experience there is definitely a sense that you have to fit in with what the community wants and occupy what they see as your rightful place if you want to fit in.

Call me selfish but I'd rather live somewhere where I can make my own rules. And cities let you get on with it in a way small towns generally don't.

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/09/2021 14:43

@BertramLacey

In fairness though, you did have options. Not wanting to do things is very different to not being able to do them.

I see your point and I agree that in general there is, of course, more going on in cities than in isolated areas. However, it didn't feel like a choice. I had no-one to go with, and would have been bullied, beaten up and ostracised if I had gone, so it didn't present as a choice. I don't know if the bullying would have been less bad elsewhere - maybe it would have been caught earlier and dealt with better? Maybe I'd have had better escape routes? I don't know.

People wjobd
BertramLacey · 13/09/2021 14:35

In fairness though, you did have options. Not wanting to do things is very different to not being able to do them.

I see your point and I agree that in general there is, of course, more going on in cities than in isolated areas. However, it didn't feel like a choice. I had no-one to go with, and would have been bullied, beaten up and ostracised if I had gone, so it didn't present as a choice. I don't know if the bullying would have been less bad elsewhere - maybe it would have been caught earlier and dealt with better? Maybe I'd have had better escape routes? I don't know.

Rozziie · 13/09/2021 14:04

@BertramLacey

being cut off from other kids my age was really bad for my development. I started university at 18 having never kissed anyone, never dated, never really having been to a party. I was painfully shy and was probably naive to a dangerous extent, as were others who grew up very rurally.

Quite a bit of that applies to me, although I grew up in suburban London. I wasn't naive, but the rest applies. That was down to going to a very rough comprehensive school where I was badly bullied and so ended up severely lacking in self esteem. Nowhere is perfect, there are advantages and disadvantages to any kind of living

In fairness though, you did have options. Not wanting to do things is very different to not being able to do them.
EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 13:39

Actually YOU are being far more intrusive and offensive

I apologise that my experience and feelings about my own life are so offensive to you.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 13:38

No there isn't actually

Yes there is.

In the example someone else used, if I spoke to an Afghan refugee, I wouldn't be asking who their grandparents were in order to find a way for them to be accepted.

I would be interested in them and their life.

You are happy with being quizzed, that's fine. You seem to be okay with needing to prove your heritage in order to meet with others approval. That's fine too. Your life.

I prefer to be somewhere where that doesn't matter. Where I can be me without every man and his dog trying to find a box to put me in. And, in my opinion, that's fine too.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 13:37

@EverybodyIsInteresting

It wasn't an observation about him.

It was an observation about the 'others who (you) did not know then were difficult men' and the fact that he needed to find 'to find reasons for approval'.

YAAAWWWWNNNN

Actually YOU are being far more intrusive and offensive than he was or than anyone here...lol....

One last point. If you are coming into a very old traditional community on a small island or anywhere remote you? You stay courteous, do not take offence. Do not push.
A small remote community is their home and so much more.
And that is to be honoured and respected.

Ireland is a foreign land. I am an incomer,

Over and our from me. Expecting a delivery of many bags of good island turf... Six years on..
Bye

BertramLacey · 13/09/2021 13:32

being cut off from other kids my age was really bad for my development. I started university at 18 having never kissed anyone, never dated, never really having been to a party. I was painfully shy and was probably naive to a dangerous extent, as were others who grew up very rurally.

Quite a bit of that applies to me, although I grew up in suburban London. I wasn't naive, but the rest applies. That was down to going to a very rough comprehensive school where I was badly bullied and so ended up severely lacking in self esteem. Nowhere is perfect, there are advantages and disadvantages to any kind of living

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 13:31

@EverybodyIsInteresting

fuck me. I’ve lived in a city bigger than London and of COURSE people are curious about where you come from/what’s your story?

There's a big difference between being interested in the person's story, and quizzing them on their ancestry!

No there isn't actually. And as I said before, you clearly know nothing re Irish history and culture. Ancestry is very very important in Ireland. Whatever your origins it is a a basic topic in conversation and I am a foreigner in a strange land.

I do and saw nothing untoward or offensive in his conversation. Far from it.

I was very happy with that first meeting. Even happier when I called him a few days later to make an appointment to visit and view a rental on the island.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 13:26

It wasn't an observation about him.

It was an observation about the 'others who (you) did not know then were difficult men' and the fact that he needed to find 'to find reasons for approval'.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 13:24

@AlphabetAerobics

😂 fuck me. I’ve lived in a city bigger than London and of COURSE people are curious about where you come from/what’s your story?

I never once assumed “racist plonker” - but always told them what they wanted to hear.

If people had zero interest in anything outside themselves they’d really not be much fun to be around. I assume you’re not interested in eg the stories of women fleeing Afghanistan? That you’ll just pretend they were born and bred Henley so you don’t appear small-minded?

Ah thank you so very much. lol …
SoloISland · 13/09/2021 13:22

@EverybodyIsInteresting

The man who asked was all in favour of my coming here and trying to find reasons for approval from others who I did not know then were difficult men... sheer kind diplomacy

The fact that he felt he needed to find reasons for you to be approved by others says enough.

Gee you are prickly … lol... Like the island gorse.

Not at all. I was actually delighted when he started to ask more about me. After all I knew by then as we had chatted for a while that he was born on the island, had been driving boats since he was six.

And it was obvious by my voice that I am English so he knew that. He was simply finding links with Ireland is all. Which I have.

This man goes out of his way to help and support all the islanders. I have no issues with anything that day.

And he has the interests of the island at heart ..

That is the foundation of community. Openness and friendly conversation - and not taking offence where none is intended or real

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 12:50

Yes, I'd even go so far as to say windy rural roads you know well are EASIER to drive at night than during the day

Totally agree. Unless it's a single track road and you don't know where the passing places are!

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 12:49

Being 'quizzed about ancestry' implies something a bit more than a pleasant conversation between two people looking for connections.

Where I'm from has a similar sense of place and community, and have often been part of similar conversations. I've never been 'quizzed on my ancestry' though.

LeafOfTruth · 13/09/2021 12:44

@Coogee

and you'd need to be confident driving on windy rural lanes in the pitch black!

It’s a lot easier if you turn the headlamps on.

Ha! Yes, I'd even go so far as to say windy rural roads you know well are EASIER to drive at night than during the day. You can see the other guy coming at you a lot sooner/above hedge lines if he's got lights on than during the day when you'll only know when you can see the car.

I've lived in some rural places and would always prefer to drive windy roads I know at night. If you know the road, you already tend to know where the passing places and pot holes are Grin

SeriouslyISuppose · 13/09/2021 12:38

@EverybodyIsInteresting

Being English of course.. I was quizzed about my ancestry.. lol.. And I do have Irish ancestry..

A perfect example of people being nosy and wanting to know your business. I've never felt the need to quiz anyone on their ancestry. It's most often irrelevant. But there are people where I come from that only consider you a local if all your grandparents were born and brought up there. I wish I was joking.

Some people can be so small minded about what is, effectively, something completely outside of your control.

I wouldn’t necessarily see that as ‘nosy’. Ireland is a small place, with a strong sense of local place and kin networks, so it’s entirely natural for people to be interested in connections. I rented an Airbnb in a different part of the country recently and when I eventually met the neighbour, two fields away, we figured out that we were in fact distant cousins and our grandparents were from the same townland at the opposite end of the country. And resident English people in particular often have an Irish connection.
Rozziie · 13/09/2021 12:20

@lazylinguist

I think anyone with kids should think twice before moving somewhere rural because it's honestly horrible and grim in many ways.

There is nothing grim about where we live (on the edge of the Lake District)! My dc are now 13 and 16 and we've lived in a village in a rural area for 7 years. They've been happy here so far. Dd16 is beginning to get slightly itchy feet now and is liking the idea of going to a (preferably smallish) city for university , but she has plenty of local friends, gets the train into Lancaster or occasionally Manchester or hangs out more locally. Ds13 has no desire to be anywhere bigger or busier yet.

I find it odd when people talk about a downside of rural living being the necessity of moving away to have a career. I don't really know anybody who went to university and then went back to settle and work in the place they came from, whether town, city or rural. It wouldn't occur to me to expect my dc to want to come back to live locally as adults.

@lazylinguist I think you might have a very different idea of 'rural' to mine. If your daughter is able to get a train to Lancaster or Manchester, then you're not really isolated at all, are you? My idea of a rural area is not one with a train station with trains running to major towns and cities. The area I grew up in had no public transport at all. I couldn't walk anywhere at all, not even a local shop. The nearest train station was about 50 minutes away by car!

Regarding the second point, university is extremely expensive now. At least those growing up in London, Manchester, etc. have the option of staying at home for university or working for a few years and saving up.

thetemptationofchocolate · 13/09/2021 12:20

I live a fair distance from the nearest town, and would definitely struggle without a car. But we do have fast fibre broadband, electricity and mains water (but no gas supply).
I like it here, but I am quite a solitary kind of person. Someone more gregarious would struggle a bit I would think.

cardibach · 13/09/2021 12:20

I lived in a very remote area from when DD was 5 to after she had left home post university. I found it a great place for her to grow up, despite the inevitable ferrying around, and I also enjoyed it. I’ve moved to near Cardiff now though as it’s sooooo much easier to be an older person in a city. Watched my parents struggle rurally - 45 mins to a hospital, no shops within walking distance, no independence once they couldn’t drive…
The country is lovely, but it’s not a place to be old. Nobody should retire there.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 12:18

The man who asked was all in favour of my coming here and trying to find reasons for approval from others who I did not know then were difficult men... sheer kind diplomacy

The fact that he felt he needed to find reasons for you to be approved by others says enough.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 13/09/2021 12:16

fuck me. I’ve lived in a city bigger than London and of COURSE people are curious about where you come from/what’s your story?

There's a big difference between being interested in the person's story, and quizzing them on their ancestry!

theemmadilemma · 13/09/2021 12:13

There's rural, and then remote.

We both WFH so we needed decent broadband in order to move which did limit us.

We're reasonably rural, although we have neighbours on the same road. The village is about a mile away, so you do need a car in winter. Takeaway is limited. But we're in a great location that everything else I need is within a 20 min radius, and 30 or so into a city if we need it. Best of both worlds.

SoloISland · 13/09/2021 12:12

Of course my lifestyle IS essentially solitude. My long term illness means so little energy and I need peace and privacy,

So it is not for me about community or facilities. I rejected several islands I checked out because they were just too busy and active communally and socially.

My neighbour the ferryman came along long faced and worried when I was new. Confessing that they have no facilties here and very upset.
I assured him that I do not need or seek faciltiies.

There are supply lines, a couple or three post deliveries a week. Ferries daily. Supreme air ambulance cover.

For me that is all I need and seek. I would love to be a total solitary but this is the nearest there is

Somehow this thread has focussed on community and problems therein rather than just remote, concerns that apply to any community.

Remote for me means as little contact with others as is feasible and safe.
Which I have here and am at peace with.
Necessities and urgent needs.
Being else independent and not near or in contact with.

The last person I spoke to on the island was the ferryman last week re the shopping. And that is the norm for me and my remote life. REMOTE for me means this.

Peace43 · 13/09/2021 12:03

To add I work full time from home in a professional job and my kid loves living here. I make the effort to drive her to facilitate play dates and hobbies.