Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH shouldn't put money towards this present?

233 replies

speer · 11/09/2021 23:27

DH is very close to his brother and nephew (16) and they often spend time together.

BILs birthday is coming up, the other day nephew messaged DH telling him he wants to buy him some tickets, but might need his help (buying them online). Nephew told DH he'll pay for his own ticket and BILs but DH could go if he wanted, and he is.

Anyway, today nephew messaged DH saying he doesn't think he has enough money for the tickets (they are expensive, even for just one person!) and has asked DH if he'd give him the money.

DH has already bought BIL a present and these tickets would just be from nephew, and not DH as well even if he put some money towards them.

AIBU to think he shouldn't do this? Just to add, our finances are joint, I wouldn't care if it was his own money.

OP posts:
SteakandOnionPie · 12/09/2021 10:16

So he's going to fork out £200 plus the present he's already bought and it isn't even a big bday? I'd say no. Fine if it was a joint present for a big birthday and he put more in, but he'll have to keep quiet he contributed, spend loads and it isn't a big birthday anyway.

toomuchlaundry · 12/09/2021 10:15

Would it be something your BIL and DH would have arranged at some point to go to?

Is there a possibility of the nephew getting a job to pay towards the tickets?

I suppose this has been a lesson on how much things cost

Howshouldibehave · 12/09/2021 10:14

@speer

The tickets are about £90 each, Nephew has £70 as he thought the tickets were cheaper (not sure why he didn't check).

It is somewhere BIL would want to go, but also would Nephew and DH. Nephew doesn't have a job, I'm not sure why he can't ask SIL or if he already has.

Finances aren't tight, but DH would have to buy two tickets and put money to another, I wouldn't mind if he just had to put the £20 to the one.

It isn't a big birthday, and they could do this anytime (next year or in a few months etc).

So nephew hasn’t even got enough money to pay for himself?!

What made you say that the present would be solely from the nephew even if DH paid, @speer? Did the nephew ask that?

Presumably the first thing the dad is going to say is…’where did you get the best part of £200 from?!’, to his 16 year old son (who has no job) and then it will all come out and really taint the whole thing. He will be embarrassed and cross.

I wouldn’t want any part of it. I would tell nephew it was a nice idea but that it wasn’t happening this time.

Nephew wants to give a high glory present, paid for almost entirely by your DH and wants to take all the credit for it! It’s not a big birthday and you have already bought a gift.

It wouldn’t be happening if it was my situation.

Beaudalaire · 12/09/2021 10:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 10:10

£70 would buy a more than generous present. I don’t expect my teens to spend that much on me.

With presents it really is the thought that counts.

TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 10:09

So £200 all in. No.

JustSayingItHowItIs · 12/09/2021 10:08

*So the nephew grows up learning that he can a) lie to people he loves (this is a gift from me, dad) and v) expect people to bail him out when he over commits to what he can't afford.

If I was the parent and found out later that a gift I found incredibly touching and generous from my 16 year old, and which I'd effusively thanked them for, was actually paid for by someone else, I'd be really upset. And it would absolutely affect how I saw that child and the person who'd facilitated that deception.

Nephew needs to recognise that and ask for a loan, not a donation.*

It's really not that deep... OP hasn't even come back to this thread with more details.

speer · 12/09/2021 10:07

The tickets are about £90 each, Nephew has £70 as he thought the tickets were cheaper (not sure why he didn't check).

It is somewhere BIL would want to go, but also would Nephew and DH. Nephew doesn't have a job, I'm not sure why he can't ask SIL or if he already has.

Finances aren't tight, but DH would have to buy two tickets and put money to another, I wouldn't mind if he just had to put the £20 to the one.

It isn't a big birthday, and they could do this anytime (next year or in a few months etc).

OP posts:
saraclara · 12/09/2021 10:06

Your DP would be giving him an apprenticeship in CFery, frankly.

This is a seminal moment. On the upside, the nephew wants to please his dad with a thoughtful gift. But he hasn't thought through the commitment, he hasn't thought through what he's asking from his uncle (and that its your money too) as he hasn't thought through the philosophy of gift giving or the deception he's putting in place.

His uncles job is to make him aware of these things.

"Mate, your dad's going to think this is from you, and you're going to feel really shitty when he's effusively thanking you and thinking he's got the best son in the world, and you know it's not really from you. Do you really want to deceive him like that?
You've made a commitment to buying those tickets, and you need to face up to it. But I can help you out with a loan, if you like. How much can you afford to pay back each month?"

JustSayingItHowItIs · 12/09/2021 10:05

I think it's fine.

I often buy presents for my DB from his DS's as their mum doesn't bother or care. They're no longer together so I always chip in with presents for their dad.

Walkingalot · 12/09/2021 10:02

@Herecomesthesun70 - Yep! Sorry everyone, wrong thread, doh.

TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 09:58

@traintraveller

It's hardly begging FFS. I would help him out, they could say the ticket is a joint present and your husband can save the present he has bought for christmas. Or you could lend him the cash.
Cadging, sponging, cheeky fuckery, whatever.
EmeraldShamrock · 12/09/2021 09:58

I'd offer to lend him it or give the gift between them.
Can DH return orginal gift or pass it on to someone else.

traintraveller · 12/09/2021 09:56

It's hardly begging FFS.
I would help him out, they could say the ticket is a joint present and your husband can save the present he has bought for christmas. Or you could lend him the cash.

ClaireEclair · 12/09/2021 09:54

@Howshouldibehave

She’s a teenager with just pocket money and I have the money so why not?

So, not the same situation that the OP is in, then.

Well we don’t know that as the OP hasn’t come back to answer the questions.
Beautiful3 · 12/09/2021 09:52

Mabe save hix present to gift at Xmas, go halves on this one?

TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 09:50

So the nephew grows up learning that he can a) lie to people he loves (this is a gift from me, dad) and v) expect people to bail him out when he over commits to what he can't afford.

Yup.

Howshouldibehave · 12/09/2021 09:50

She’s a teenager with just pocket money and I have the money so why not?

So, not the same situation that the OP is in, then.

TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 09:49

If I was the parent and found out later that a gift I found incredibly touching and generous from my 16 year old, and which I'd effusively thanked them for, was actually paid for by someone else, I'd be really upset.

Quite. If I found out that a present from my DS was actually cadged from one of my siblings who had already got me a present I’d be livid.

In that situation I would simply refund my sibling, and have strong words with my son.

I have not brought my kids up to beg for money for things they can’t afford and put relations in an awkward situation.

ClaireEclair · 12/09/2021 09:47

I always buy the gifts from my niece to give to her mum. If I didn’t she wouldn’t get anything because her dead beat ex wouldn’t even consider buying a card. Doesn’t bother me at all. She’s a teenager with just pocket money and I have the money so why not?

Howshouldibehave · 12/09/2021 09:46

So the nephew grows up learning that he can a) lie to people he loves (this is a gift from me, dad) and v) expect people to bail him out when he over commits to what he can't afford

This.

But I feel it’s impossible to answer properly without more information from @speer

How much are the tickets?
How much has nephew saved?
Why isn’t he asking his mum?

shouldistop · 12/09/2021 09:44

Well how much money is it and can he afford it?

I can't imagine grudging my dh spending money on his family unless it was going to leave us short.

saraclara · 12/09/2021 09:43

@Saoirse82

Of course DH should help out if he can afford it and I'd think you were a right miser if you had an issue with this. Why would you not want to help Confused?
So the nephew grows up learning that he can a) lie to people he loves (this is a gift from me, dad) and v) expect people to bail him out when he over commits to what he can't afford.

If I was the parent and found out later that a gift I found incredibly touching and generous from my 16 year old, and which I'd effusively thanked them for, was actually paid for by someone else, I'd be really upset. And it would absolutely affect how I saw that child and the person who'd facilitated that deception.

Nephew needs to recognise that and ask for a loan, not a donation.

boxonthehill · 12/09/2021 09:42

I feel the same as most - on the surface I'd do it.

The only caveat is if DN is earning money (my friend's 16 year old is doing an apprenticeship and at 16 earns £900 a month no outgoings) and has just not bothered to budget.

Or, if you can't afford it obviously.

Cuddlyrottweiler · 12/09/2021 09:34

There are lots of factors.
Can he easily afford it?
Is it actually a gift for DB more than a self gift for DN?
Will DH enjoy going?
Does DN have a big income (he's 16, he doesn't earn a lot.)
Is he a CF or is he a good kid that loves his dad and trusts his uncle?

Unless there's gonna be a drip feed, I think he should do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread