Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH shouldn't put money towards this present?

233 replies

speer · 11/09/2021 23:27

DH is very close to his brother and nephew (16) and they often spend time together.

BILs birthday is coming up, the other day nephew messaged DH telling him he wants to buy him some tickets, but might need his help (buying them online). Nephew told DH he'll pay for his own ticket and BILs but DH could go if he wanted, and he is.

Anyway, today nephew messaged DH saying he doesn't think he has enough money for the tickets (they are expensive, even for just one person!) and has asked DH if he'd give him the money.

DH has already bought BIL a present and these tickets would just be from nephew, and not DH as well even if he put some money towards them.

AIBU to think he shouldn't do this? Just to add, our finances are joint, I wouldn't care if it was his own money.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Angrywife · 14/09/2021 15:34

I'd have suggested you get them, it obviously means a lot to your Nephew

RunRunStop · 14/09/2021 12:33

No not everything needs to be a “lesson” but my opinion is that this is an important one for a 16 year old to have and will hopefully lead to him making sensible financial decisions in the future and not getting into debt etc. I think that’s an important “lesson”.

I still think they should all go to the event as they seem to enjoy each other’s company and it would be nice for them all. That’s providing the adults wish to and can afford it and they should pay their own way and the DN pay his (tbh if it was my child I’d pay for them if could afford as it’s an event I would enjoy going to with them).

ChequerBoard · 14/09/2021 12:32

3 family members wanting to attend an event together isn't a big deal IF you can afford the tickets easily. Wouldn't even be classed as a birthday gift in our house, just a nice shared experience for said family members.

TBH if it's causing this much angst you just can't afford it and should say no on these grounds.

All the guff about 'life lessons' and getting 'credit' for contributing towards a gift are just further indicators that it's not within the family financial envelope.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 14/09/2021 12:30

The best present would be the uncle teaching dn to live within his means.
Great suggestion dn, but as YOU can't afford it this time, how about saving for next year and getting a different present with the £70.
Same as most do when taking kids to the shops to spend their pocket money. No you can't afford that, either buy something else or save some more and come back when you have enough.
Unfortunately there's no telling if this ask will be a one off or a yearly occurrence. Nip it in the bud.

GreyhoundG1rl · 14/09/2021 12:26

I don't think everything we experience in life has to contain a "lesson"...

RunRunStop · 14/09/2021 12:09

No I wouldn’t do it. It’s not a great lesson for your DN for a start / yes it’s lovely he had this idea but he’s old enough to have properly looked at the prices and realise two tickets were well out of his budget. He can’t afford this. He can’t buy gifts that are massively out of his budget just because he thinks they’d be liked. If this was a girlfriend he wanted to spend £180 on (two tickets) and had only £70 to put towards I’d doubt many posters would be rushing to say OP should be paying the additional £110 so DN can buy gf the dream gift. It’s same principle and a really good life lesson for DN (ie don’t overspend even if for others and don’t try to buy people things you can’t afford). He needs to get his dad something else. You stick with the gift you already have.

Separately from any birthday involvement I would say DN should speak to his dad about the event. Explain that he’d like to go and thinks they’d all enjoy it together and Uncle had agreed he’d buy his own ticket and he (DN) had £70 towards his ticket. Then it’s up to his dad (and mum unclear if she’s on scene) if they can afford to pay £90 for the dads ticket and £20 for rest of DN ticket plus any additional costs like transport, etc. That is a family decision for them. I’d be quite proud of my child if they came to me with this proposal and provided I could afford it I’d buy at least half their ticket myself and enjoy spending time with them and my brother at the event. I’d be less proud if I found out they’d spent massively over budget on a gift for me when they didn’t have the money.

Littlemissmagnet · 14/09/2021 11:26

If he can afford it yes it will be worth the memories together much more valuable than money 2bh. It hopefully would be a special time for them all. :)

Plumtree391 · 14/09/2021 01:44

I think if you give money to help someone, it should be done discreetly and you should not want recognition for it. Never let your right hand know what your left is doing.

Localocal · 14/09/2021 00:43

Can you DH return the present he got for his brother and join the nephew in the tickets present for all three?

Mollymoostoo · 13/09/2021 20:27

@Justilou1

I think it’s a weird world view when *@speer*‘s financial contribution is completely dismissed, the participants have no knowledge of it at all so that “Uncle Generous Pants” gets all the joy and acknowledgement. AND *@speer* is excluded from the event, the closeness, the fun time, etc that she’s bloody paying for. Also, if she says no, she’s the patsy.
I agree. OP is also putting money in their joint finances.
whynotwhatknot · 13/09/2021 20:26

Tell nephew*

whynotwhatknot · 13/09/2021 20:25

If this is something you sa they can do another time then just nephew to carry on saving and do it at a later date as a belated present

thats alot of money to cover

Mollymoostoo · 13/09/2021 20:24

@speer

The tickets are about £90 each, Nephew has £70 as he thought the tickets were cheaper (not sure why he didn't check).

It is somewhere BIL would want to go, but also would Nephew and DH. Nephew doesn't have a job, I'm not sure why he can't ask SIL or if he already has.

Finances aren't tight, but DH would have to buy two tickets and put money to another, I wouldn't mind if he just had to put the £20 to the one.

It isn't a big birthday, and they could do this anytime (next year or in a few months etc).

No I don't think you should help. Yes it is a lovely thought but a 16 year old needs to learn that big items have to be worked and saved for. I would say it was a lovely thought but perhaps save and do it another time
HebalGerbil · 13/09/2021 19:55

Maybe @speer has failed to come back because her husband has found this thread and thought "sod that".

Not only has this bloke got to get her blessing to spend any of his own money but she has dragged other people into it to disapprove of his spending also.

I really don't like to use this one but in this circumstance I do actually think if the the sexes were reversed that the man would be labeled financially abusive.

cabingirl · 13/09/2021 19:54

I'd suggest that DH comes to an agreement with DN that he will buy the tickets but that DN is to repay the money for BIL tickets and the extra 20 he needs.

They can come up with a payment plan.

Howshouldibehave · 13/09/2021 19:41

Jesus, it’s 20 quid

No, it’s not.

If the OP’s husband pays for what’s being asked, it’s…

£20 for the uncle.
£90 for the nephew
£90 for the OP’s husband.

That’s without any other costs for the event-travel/food/drinks etc

masterblaster · 13/09/2021 19:38

Jesus, it’s 20 quid (or 40?). If money isn’t tight, why do you care?

I consider myself to be an Uncle to my nieces and nephews on my sister’s side. Do you not think of yourself as their Aunt?

Hugoslavia · 13/09/2021 19:32

DH should chip in the £20 for the ticket for DH, but not buy Nephew's ticket as it's not Nephew's birthday. If nephew wishes to also go with them, then he should see if his mother can treat him.

Passenger42 · 13/09/2021 19:18

Tell the nephew to shelve the idea of tickets as they are too expensive and to buy BIL something with his £20 that he has saved. Your DH sticks to his own birthday gift idea.

I think the nephew is trying to get your DH to fund a treat he really wants for himself 😃

Tigger1895 · 13/09/2021 19:14

Can your DH afford it and if so can you not say both presents are from himself and the nephew?

Ddot · 13/09/2021 18:54

NO without question no. This is the problem, Children think money grows on trees. His idea, if he cant afford then he should choose a different gift. How do children respect money if it's just always there. When he needs to stand on his own two feet, he will get in a right mess.

Howshouldibehave · 13/09/2021 18:02

Are you ever coming back, @speer?!

cherish123 · 13/09/2021 17:53

Could DN not ask his mum.?

Harleyband · 13/09/2021 17:50

I'd give him the money. No question. But I would make it my Christmas present to DN.

H007 · 13/09/2021 17:39

If he can afford it and wants to go he should it’s his family, the nephew can always pay him back.