Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave 3yo in park whilst going to the loo?

737 replies

DoormatBob · 11/09/2021 21:55

Not sure if this is an AIBU or more WWYD but was at a rural touristy attraction. When we arrived both DD (3, nearly 4) and me needed the loo. DD went then refused to wait for me and ran out to the play area (toilets were within the play area but not staffed/ticketed).

I told her to wait but she said no and was off, told me she was going on the slides as she legged it away! We've been there before so she knows where she's going.

I had to go to the loo and therefore she played in the park for 2 minutes unsupervised.

AIBU
YES - i should have got her back and made her stay with me.
NO - she is OK for 2 mins, she knows where I am.

What would others do? She is very independent and confident but it's just the safety aspect.

OP posts:
HamCob · 11/09/2021 23:50

No way!
And for what it's worth my children would have had a proper b*locking for that sort of behaviour. You shouldn't be just letting her run off without consequences!

Staryflight445 · 11/09/2021 23:49

I feel the same as you @Mickarooni

Safety is non negotiable, if my kids refused to co operate I’d have to withdraw them from the situation entirely, until understood.

whynotwhatknot · 11/09/2021 23:49

youre one of them wishy washy parents

dont do that petal theres a love

get some fucking authority over your child ffs

lyntheyresexpeople · 11/09/2021 23:48

Absolutely bloody not. Anyone could have taken her. That's an incredibly dangerous situation, and one id take her straight home for! She needs to know that's unacceptable and dangerous. Honestly op, I don't think you are aware of how awful this could have been. Not having an authoritative tone is a frankly shit excuse.

avamiah · 11/09/2021 23:46

@Yaya26

Sorry. Think of Jamie Bulgers poor Mum. It only takes a few secs. Your darters 3. She has no idea of evil/danger.
Totally Agree with you and i was just about to post the same. I’m from Liverpool and let me tell you his mum only took her eyes off him for less than a minute when he was abducted by 2 school kids and as we all know the rest is UNSPEAKABLE.

So OP count yourself lucky you still have your child and Never do that again.

Mickarooni · 11/09/2021 23:46

The comments about ‘punishing’ are interesting. I don’t see this as a punishment, I call it consequences. It’s not because I’m spiteful or get a kick out of ruining their fun but this was dangerous! Even at that age, they need to learn that reckless actions - like running off - have consequences. In this case, it might be them being removed from the activity or being given a stern talk or whatever. I believe in pick your battles with parenting but when they do something that could put them at risk of harm, I feel I must respond in a way to help them understand that it’s not ok to do that.

Moonbabysmum · 11/09/2021 23:41

I wouldn't have give back for my wee, like everyone else, and i think it would be a dangerous thing to do, but ..

I have a child that's slightly older (4), and as we've been unlocking, I've found it difficult at times to work out what boundaries are right now. I had a 2yo, and then Covid hit, and I have a 4yo, who in have barely been out in public with (with other people around). There's also less opportunity to spend time with other parents, and it's hard working out what's too strict and what's too lax.

I've been recently letting my 4yo often use the cubicle next to me (on the understanding it's not locked, and only if it's a quiet/small set of loos). We chat throughout, and I've zero concerns of her running off, but compared to people on here, perhaps I've been too relaxed. But if I'm honest, i have no idea what other parents of 4yo do, because i haven't been spending time with any.

So I get that your boundaries barometer might be a bit off, and I'm not going to judge you on that, however much of a daft decision i think it was.

What I'm more concerned about is your lack of authority with your child. They shouldn't think that ignoring you like that is a possibility. If you say stop in public, or stay here, they need to. They don't just get to ignore you like that.

FuckPilledLatteplus · 11/09/2021 23:41

Proof that some people should not be allowed to procreate

This Escalated to eugenics quickly

FuckPilledLatteplus · 11/09/2021 23:39

Honestly not a troll

Me think the doormatbob doth protest too much

Yaya26 · 11/09/2021 23:35

Sorry. Think of Jamie Bulgers poor Mum. It only takes a few secs. Your darters 3. She has no idea of evil/danger.

Seldon · 11/09/2021 23:34

Proof that some people should not be allowed to procreate

Rein it in a little please

takealettermsjones · 11/09/2021 23:32

I don't know if this has already been said but if she's got form for running off, why isn't she on reins?

MrsWhites · 11/09/2021 23:25

@DoormatBob

Honestly not a troll, reverse or anything else. Posted as I obviously didn't feel comfortable with what happened and its playing on my mind a bit.

Not trying to justify anything but honestly had no concerns she would go off anywhere else, there is one gate in/out, toilets by the gate she was heading to the opposite end. A long way from any road (set within a country park).

She was over excited, we had just arrived and she doesn't always appreciate other people have to do things too.

I am not an authoritive speaker and I see that with her reactions to me sometimes. I have a senior position at work but sometimes say things in meetings and no one hears. Would never be a manager.

Don’t want to pile on what others have said as you obviously realise it wasn’t an ideal thing to do.

Thing is, If you don’t start laying down some boundaries she is going to think more and more that she doesn’t need to listen to Mummy because there are no consequences.

minionsrule · 11/09/2021 23:24

A 3 year old should NEVER be in charge of a situation.
You should have kept her in the cubicle till you were both done

Thesearmsofmine · 11/09/2021 23:19

@WetWeekends

I agree it would be fairly pointless to punish her for it. They don’t really get the concept of punishments like that at her age in my experience. I would definitely have followed her though and spoken very sternly to her saying that it was dangerous and she must always do as Mummy says. Also you can’t be sure she wouldn’t wander off, they can always surprise you at that age! She could’ve seen a friend or an ice cream van etc that made her leave the play area.
An almost 4 year old can absolutely understand consequences as long as they are immediate and explained clearly.
PurpleOkapi · 11/09/2021 23:18

@wombforanotherone

Ignore the posters saying you should punish her for running off. There's no need. Her brain told her she wanted to play, that's all. All you need to do is not allow her to run off. You are the parent and you keep her safe, and teach her what to do by showing her not telling her. No matter what her 3 year old brain tells her to do (which obviously will not be sensible or reasoned most of the time because it is a baby brain but this doesn't mean she is "naughty"). Simples.
I agree that OP should have tried harder to stop her from running off in this situation, but I don't think this should be generalized to all situations where a small child runs off. They can be slippery, and I don't think it's reasonable to write off all 'escapes' as the parent's fault for failing to keep a physical hold on the child, and thus not proper to punish. All you're doing there is teaching the child that if she can manage to slip away, she'll be rewarded by getting to do whatever it was the parent was trying to stop her from doing. So why wouldn't she try to escape every time? And if she does, she's bound to be successful occasionally. What if she was trying to chase a ball into the street or play with something dangerous? A three-year-old won't understand why those things are different from running to the slide on a playground, because they can't understand those dangers. But three is old enough to understand what "No" means, and to have consequences for ignoring it.
Itsmeagainandagain · 11/09/2021 23:16

Im not having a go at you as i dont believe in perfect parents. You know yourself the answer to that. To much badness in the world and im sure you wont do it again

HandforthParishCouncilClerk · 11/09/2021 23:16

You already know this is a terrible idea so I won’t add to that. What I will say is in future, take her into the cubicle with you but you go first while she waits so she won’t be able to leg it as she’ll still need to go.

WorraLiberty · 11/09/2021 23:15

@WetWeekends

I agree it would be fairly pointless to punish her for it. They don’t really get the concept of punishments like that at her age in my experience. I would definitely have followed her though and spoken very sternly to her saying that it was dangerous and she must always do as Mummy says. Also you can’t be sure she wouldn’t wander off, they can always surprise you at that age! She could’ve seen a friend or an ice cream van etc that made her leave the play area.
Of course they get the concept at that age.

And they get it a lot faster if the adult in charge of them is actually in charge.

"Why are we going straight home Daddy?"

"Because you refused to listen to me and you ran off".

What's not to understand?

TartanJumper · 11/09/2021 23:13

It's difficult to comment without knowing the park and the area it's in

It's not really, though.
The mum was in the toilet building. The child was unattended in a park. There's really no way that it's safe or reasonable to let the child run off to play while the mum finishes up in the loo. Forget the slim (but still present) chance of abductions etc - what if she'd walked in front of someone on a swing, or fell off the slide and broken her arm in those few minutes?

WorraLiberty · 11/09/2021 23:12

@wombforanotherone

Ignore the posters saying you should punish her for running off. There's no need. Her brain told her she wanted to play, that's all. All you need to do is not allow her to run off. You are the parent and you keep her safe, and teach her what to do by showing her not telling her. No matter what her 3 year old brain tells her to do (which obviously will not be sensible or reasoned most of the time because it is a baby brain but this doesn't mean she is "naughty"). Simples.
And your post is just as worrying as the OP's.

Ignore posters who say the child should be punished for running off?

I told her to wait but she said no and was off, told me she was going on the slides as she legged it away!

That ^^ is punishable all day long in my book and imo anyone who wouldn't give that child a consequence, shouldn't be in charge of small children.

Yes the OP was negligent for letting it happen, but the child doesn't get to dictate to the adult in charge or what's the point in having a parent with her at all?

NortieTortie · 11/09/2021 23:10

YADBU. Mine are 4 and almost 6 and I would lock them in the cubicle with me.

I'm a massive helicopter parent in the park, especially after that woman slit Emily Jones' (aged 7) throat as she was scooting to her mother last year. Not a chance in hell I'll leave my childrens' side.

DancingQueen85 · 11/09/2021 23:09

You shouldn't have done it but people's reactions on this thread are totally ott. Particularly the person who suggested that they would have called the police on you!
It's difficult to comment without knowing the park and the area it's in.

WetWeekends · 11/09/2021 23:09

I agree it would be fairly pointless to punish her for it. They don’t really get the concept of punishments like that at her age in my experience. I would definitely have followed her though and spoken very sternly to her saying that it was dangerous and she must always do as Mummy says. Also you can’t be sure she wouldn’t wander off, they can always surprise you at that age! She could’ve seen a friend or an ice cream van etc that made her leave the play area.

JustLyra · 11/09/2021 23:09

@wombforanotherone

Ignore the posters saying you should punish her for running off. There's no need. Her brain told her she wanted to play, that's all. All you need to do is not allow her to run off. You are the parent and you keep her safe, and teach her what to do by showing her not telling her. No matter what her 3 year old brain tells her to do (which obviously will not be sensible or reasoned most of the time because it is a baby brain but this doesn't mean she is "naughty"). Simples.
Almost 4 is absolutely old enough to face a natural consequence for ignoring her mother and putting herself in danger.