Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave 3yo in park whilst going to the loo?

737 replies

DoormatBob · 11/09/2021 21:55

Not sure if this is an AIBU or more WWYD but was at a rural touristy attraction. When we arrived both DD (3, nearly 4) and me needed the loo. DD went then refused to wait for me and ran out to the play area (toilets were within the play area but not staffed/ticketed).

I told her to wait but she said no and was off, told me she was going on the slides as she legged it away! We've been there before so she knows where she's going.

I had to go to the loo and therefore she played in the park for 2 minutes unsupervised.

AIBU
YES - i should have got her back and made her stay with me.
NO - she is OK for 2 mins, she knows where I am.

What would others do? She is very independent and confident but it's just the safety aspect.

OP posts:
Hotpinkangel19 · 12/09/2021 08:08

I have a 3 year old and would rather wet myself in public than let my daughter leave the toilets without me.

KaptainKaveman · 12/09/2021 08:07

@cunningartificer

She’s three. It only takes a moment for a child to be snatched or to fall off a high slide or run off where you can’t find her. You shouldn’t leave her alone. She needs to learn she can’t run off when you tell her to stay with you. Take her into the loo with you.
100% this.
daisychain01 · 12/09/2021 07:54

@Gorl

There isn’t a parent in the world who hasn’t had a moment where they think ‘that wasn’t the best way to handle that’.

Nothing bad happened, your daughter is totally fine, you won’t do this again. It’s all ok. Every parent learns as they go.

Some people on this thread are being unreasonably harsh.

In the situation as described, no people are not unreasonably harsh.

This is where MN is at its best, because the plain talking can potentially save a child from a disaster in the making, no oh dear never mind, you weren't to know #bekind all that tosh. Straight forward, candid and spelling out reality.

letsmakethishappen · 12/09/2021 07:50

Takes a sec for a kid to be abducted your poor child

DysmalRadius · 12/09/2021 07:41

After she left the cubicle which I should've dealt with clearly I panicked a bit and as mentioned to avoid drawing unwanted attention let her do what she wanted.

Whose unwanted attention were you trying to avoid?

rattlemehearties · 12/09/2021 07:39

OP please understand that it's good parenting to give children firm boundaries. It makes them feel safe. You need to be consistent. Some things are non negotiable eg staying with you in the loos. No need for grand "punishment", the natural consequence of her refusing to stay with you/running off is you go home and explain why.

usernotfound0000 · 12/09/2021 07:36

I wouldn't have done it. DD is 6.5 and I've only just started to let her go to the loo alone, and only if I can see the toilet entrance from where I am.

SchoolGossipWoes · 12/09/2021 07:34

Gerry, is that you?

CharleyMarley · 12/09/2021 07:34

@Cherryana

3 is too young. I think 6 is too young. I think 7 with an older brother or sister A sensible 8 would be fine I think.
100% this
knittingaddict · 12/09/2021 07:31

So:

  1. It's not a reverse.
  2. Op is a man.
  3. They came on mn with a scenario that 99% of people (well 94% in the case of mn Hmm) would immediately think is unreasonable.
Hmm
Stormwhale · 12/09/2021 07:30

Good god no. My dc would be told their options - wait nicely with me and go back to the park together or be physically held there and then have to leave and go home. No way in hell would I let my 3 year old out of my sight in a public place.

Fundays12 · 12/09/2021 07:27

Nope would have taken her home there and then so she never did it again.

Lottie2017 · 12/09/2021 07:26

Gosh, no no no. A child can potentially be snatched even when their parent is within the playground, let alone leaving the area for three minutes. A child can panic, wander off, get lost. I am amazed that anyone would do this with a three year old.

ToddlerLockdown · 12/09/2021 07:25

I would have locked her in the toilet with me. If she escaped before I could do this, I would’ve gone after her and got her before I went. Only needs a second for something to go wrong. 5 minutes of toddler tantrum is worth it if it protects them

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2021 07:20

@HarebrightCedarmoon

Yes, she should be in the cubicle, but in reality no harm was done and next time the OP will have her in with her.

I'm finding some of the responses here bordering on hysteria though, and far more worrying than the OP. Also a load of grown adults having a good old pile-on - over 300 posts worth, is rather unedifying.

Exactly. I'm not 100% convinced of OP's motivations in posting here, I have to say. But the level of hyperbole & drama, as well as some odious comments about OP, is unacceptable & frankly ridiculous.
Motherofalittledragon · 12/09/2021 07:19

Yes YABU, and your DD shouldn't be pleasing herself what she does.

JustLyra · 12/09/2021 07:18

@HarebrightCedarmoon

Yes, she should be in the cubicle, but in reality no harm was done and next time the OP will have her in with her.

I'm finding some of the responses here bordering on hysteria though, and far more worrying than the OP. Also a load of grown adults having a good old pile-on - over 300 posts worth, is rather unedifying.

I find the lack of comprehension in some of the replies quite bizarre.

The OP had the child in the cubicle with him this time…

BustopherPonsonbyJones · 12/09/2021 07:18

You’ve had a sinking heart feeling where you know you’ve made the wrong decision. I’m sure you won’t do it again after reading the comments on here and nothing happened, so It’s not the end of the world. I’m also very relaxed about this kind of thing but even if the child is sensible, I wouldn’t try it again before they’re in Year 2.

Definitely work on boundaries. She should not be telling you what to do - it will cause massive issues when she is school and lots of grief for you (even ignoring safety considerations). Take her home immediately to show her she is not in charge. Carry her, kicking and screaming, if you have to do so.

knittingaddict · 12/09/2021 07:16

For context I brought up my children in the 80's and 90's and often find modern parenting a bit OTT.

There is absolutely no way I would have left a 3 year old in those circumstances. I had my heart in my mouth just reading it.

Also a 3 year old running off, not listening and not doing as they were told? Not happening. I know some children are more willful than others, but no way would I let that happen. It's a slippery slope and too dangerous to contemplate.

(I'm on my phone and haven't read the whole post. While writing it's crossed my mind that this may be a reverse. If it is I will be very cross. Very cross indeed.)

HarebrightCedarmoon · 12/09/2021 07:16

Yes, she should be in the cubicle, but in reality no harm was done and next time the OP will have her in with her.

I'm finding some of the responses here bordering on hysteria though, and far more worrying than the OP. Also a load of grown adults having a good old pile-on - over 300 posts worth, is rather unedifying.

SunonmyFace · 12/09/2021 07:15

Ultimately you know this wasn’t right so you have come on here for support. FairPlay OP. Have you actually thought through the parenting dynamic, not meant to be a. Silly question. You are in charge. Have a look at approaches and use one, for example team-cartwright.com/ask-tell-good-decisions/
In this circumstance, for me, it would have bee down to their level for a face to face chat and either a 3 minute enforced sit on a bench ( yes possibly with restraint) or a trip back to the car, not necessarily to leave but as part of the consequence and a slightly easier location for the time out. Time out would allow a reset, quick recap on listening to Mum/ Dad to stay safe, and back to the park.
Lots of parents have their own challenges, can’t run after the child, all the more reason to have clear boundaries, it is all about keeping them safe. Keep it simple and be consistent. good luck OP.

PS, a few people have said “get a grip, imagine when they are 13,” I find thinking of this scenario, really gives me strength when in a tricky parent situation :)

strawberrydonuts · 12/09/2021 07:12

*With hindsight yes but as a 37yo male physically restraining feels awful when the act of leaving the cubicle wasn't itself immediately dangerous.

Again not a justification but I wouldn't risk a tantrum in the men's toilets, they aren't nice. I should've made it perfectly clear before going in but I didn't expect what she did. She isn't often like that*

Just be thankful nothing bad happened, and just please change your behaviour next time and don't be so wet.

If she tantrums, she tantrums. That's what kids do. You need to be a bit stronger with her - she is the child and you are the parent. You know what's safe and she does not.

You don't have to restrain her, you just keep the door closed, tell her very directly that she has to stay with you and if she runs off you will be going straight home (and follow through with that). If you really struggle then as others have said, a leash at that age is fine to keep her with you in the toilets.

You do need to be a bit firmer - it's about keeping her safe, but on another note if you're letting her run rings around you now imagine what she'll be like in a few years!

EarringsandLipstick · 12/09/2021 07:12

@Generalpost

There's no way I would ever do that when I'm out both my 5 and 6 year old come in the cubical with Me.
Well that's insane. A 5 & a 6 yo can and should be able to wait outside the cubicle for you.
Brokensunflower · 12/09/2021 07:09

The bigger issue is she needs to learn to do what she's told!

HeronLanyon · 12/09/2021 07:07

Just not great. If I saw a child of that age alone in a park for a second I would drop what ever I was doing to keep close eye and within around 5 seconds if no adult appeared I’d be on the phone to the police keeping eagle eye on the child and ready to intervene if roads nearby etc. That’s how bad this was.
Op sounds as if you and your child would benefit from some assertiveness/parenting training. As others have said you have many years before you can reasonably say ‘well that’s her decision, I’ll step back’. You need an authoritative voice and your child needs to hear it and know there will be follow through consequences if they try to ignore it. Parenting skills don’t come naturally to everyone. You need far better assessment of risk and role and how to manage both.
No doubt any help you get will help you at work also.
Posting and getting good advice on mumsnet is a good start but I’d say you need a lot more help with this from your posts. No shame. Not everyone is great at parenting - important thing is you’ve recognised it now you need to do something about it. Pronto.
Good luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread