Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave 3yo in park whilst going to the loo?

737 replies

DoormatBob · 11/09/2021 21:55

Not sure if this is an AIBU or more WWYD but was at a rural touristy attraction. When we arrived both DD (3, nearly 4) and me needed the loo. DD went then refused to wait for me and ran out to the play area (toilets were within the play area but not staffed/ticketed).

I told her to wait but she said no and was off, told me she was going on the slides as she legged it away! We've been there before so she knows where she's going.

I had to go to the loo and therefore she played in the park for 2 minutes unsupervised.

AIBU
YES - i should have got her back and made her stay with me.
NO - she is OK for 2 mins, she knows where I am.

What would others do? She is very independent and confident but it's just the safety aspect.

OP posts:
rhonddacynontaf · 12/09/2021 10:52

Absolutely never would I do this. I have children with SEN who need to be watched 24/7. But even my neurotypical 3yo is way too young to be left.

Goldenbear · 12/09/2021 10:50

I have sympathy for the OP as some of us have children that are wonderers, have strong feelings about doing things their own way. My two are beyond this stage now but my DD was like this and it is not always easy when they do have very strong emotions at that age and are guided by them. My DS never did this so I do have sympathy, I think at 3 though it is a matter of dealing with it as that is very young.

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 12/09/2021 10:49

You clearly know that it wasn’t ok and have had unanimous confirmation on here that it’s not ok.

Did you speak to dc mum about it? What did she say?

Comedycook · 12/09/2021 10:40

It's time to go to the toilet not play, I don't care if you don't have to, the rest of the party does need the loo. I'd have dragged her back to the toilets kicking and screaming if need be

Me too...but I can see that a man dragging a screaming three year old into the men's toilets would probably look quite suspicious to passer bys

NowEvenBetter · 12/09/2021 10:37

Shit dads come in so many forms, it’s fascinating.

BoredZelda · 12/09/2021 10:36

She was in the cubicle with me but she went first then opened the door and went out

How big was the cubicle? I find it incredible to see how it is impossible to grab a 3 year old in such a confined space.

As a 37 year old man

Men have a harder time keeping their children safe? Sounds like yet another excuse for piss poor parenting.

didn’t want a tantrum

And there we have the actual reason. You gave in because it was easier for you to avoid the conflict, leaving your daughter at risk.

JeffGoldblumsGlasses · 12/09/2021 10:36

Oh gosh no I wouldn't have left a 3 year old go alone in the park unsupervised and also let her dictate what she is doing. I don't think so little miss.

It's time to go to the toilet not play, I don't care if you don't have to, the rest of the party does need the loo. I'd have dragged her back to the toilets kicking and screaming if need be.

SarahBop · 12/09/2021 10:34

@TheLovelinessOfDemons

DS 10's nursery class went all over the place, they did a public transport day, they used all forms of public transport. He has ADHD and was a bolter until he was 6. When he ran off during a school trip in year 1, the school's consequence was that he missed the next trip. It's not that hard to keep a 3 year old in a cubicle when you pee. Some parents have no common sense.
This is totally different scenario.

The school were wrong here, this is discrimination!!

They should have had an adult assigned specifically to care for your Son, so that he couldn't run off....he has a protected characteristic.

I'm going to presume he wasn't diagnosed with ADHD at the time of this incident [and at the time of the follow up trip which he missed] and was therefore expected to be fully present and co-operate, because otherwise, the school have committed discrimination.

HeronLanyon · 12/09/2021 10:33

The risk is indeed vanishingly small.
But that’s not the end of our parenting skills. We balance risk and consequence if it (whatever we’re assessing) did happen.
In these circs that means Imo that it was a risk too far.
Additionally all sorts of other things were risked here where the risk was pretty high - roads getting lost falls frights dogs members of public getting concerned or involved etc etc.
As worrying for me would be that my 3 year old has learned that she can run off when told not to and that nothing happened and it was all probably exciting and fun for her. What 3 year old wouldn’t want to carry on doing similar ?

Burntfingerz · 12/09/2021 10:32

I could never, never leave my child unaccompanied anywhere. Let alone at aged three and in a park.

Thankfully your child is safe .

I may suggest some boundary setting with your child as there clearly isn't any.

Honestly, this is quite shocking.

Ifonlyidknownthen · 12/09/2021 10:25

I think you just need to ask yourself how you would have felt if you hadn't been able to see/find your dd when you came out the toilets? It would have been sheer panic and potentially had horrendous consequences, it's certainly something I'd never do have 3 dc.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 12/09/2021 10:20

DS 10's nursery class went all over the place, they did a public transport day, they used all forms of public transport. He has ADHD and was a bolter until he was 6. When he ran off during a school trip in year 1, the school's consequence was that he missed the next trip. It's not that hard to keep a 3 year old in a cubicle when you pee. Some parents have no common sense.

tellittomyhead · 12/09/2021 10:14

I'm a pretty laid back mum but no I would have went and got her

TartanJumper · 12/09/2021 10:13

@Macncheeseballs

The likelihood of anyone snatching a child in the time it takes you to go to the toilet is statistically very low
I agree in principle, but it's not impossible and not a risk many people would take.
Comedycook · 12/09/2021 10:12

My DC had a tendency to try to unlock the cubicle door while I was still on the loo...so I'd have one hand on the door at all times!

opalescent · 12/09/2021 10:11

I wouldn't dream of it, and I am pretty relaxed.

EishetChayil · 12/09/2021 10:09

I'm sorry to swear, but are you fucking joking?

Anything could have happened to her.

Terrible parenting. I really hope this is a troll.

babybythesea · 12/09/2021 10:08

@Macncheeseballs

God some really sanctimonious responses on here, how many people really have full control over a 3 year old?
Would you expect a nursery to be able to look after her? She’s old enough to go on little trips with a nursery class. Would it be acceptable for them to let her run off away from them? They’ve got more than one to look after. What happens if they all run off? After all, who has full control of a three year old?
ablutiions · 12/09/2021 10:08

Well OP my kids are a lot older than yours , and as a person with bowel issues I know you can't always jump up from the loo in pursuit so you were in a difficult position, and the deed is done, BUT

You say you aren't authoritative and your DD senses this. You really need to get a grip on this for safety's sake. For example after this incident, immediately you come out of the loo, go and get her. Pick her up, take her out of the play park and explain in a very scary voice that what she has just done is dangerous, not acceptable and NEVER to be repeated. If I say 'stay here' you stay here. Every time. If you don't then we go home. Understood? Then take her home.

I also learned 2 really good techniques I pass onto all parents

  1. tell them what you want them to do, rather than what you don't: eg. 'Don't hit your brother with that spade' turns into 'PUT THAT SPADE DOWN'

  2. when they want independence outside:instead of saying 'stay where I can see you', say 'STAY WHERE YOU CAN SEE ME'.

Oh, and ask once, nicely, then tell strongly, then enforce (by action or promised sanction). Repeat requests just undermine your authority. Seriously the little buggers will run rings round you otherwise Grin

mistermagpie · 12/09/2021 10:02

@metellaestinatrio

Ok, I think we can all agree OP was totally U. As others have said, my three year old would be in the cubicle with me and if she bolted I would get up and grab her. If it’s not possible to fit us both in with the door closed, I leave the door open and just wee quickly.

However, I’m curious - to all those saying they would never let their 5/6/7 year old out of their sight, do you have more than one child? I can’t always watch my 5 year old like a hawk in the playground because I am occupied with his younger siblings. I trust him not to leave the playground and check in with him regularly but the younger two need watching more closely and it’s impossible to keep them all together all the time. How do people manage this situation?

I have three children too so I know how hard it can be, but yes I do have my eyes on them all when we are out at the park. Eldest is (just) 6 so he might be further away than the 1 year old, but I would make sure I can still see him.
Nocutenamesleft · 12/09/2021 10:00

@metellaestinatrio

Ok, I think we can all agree OP was totally U. As others have said, my three year old would be in the cubicle with me and if she bolted I would get up and grab her. If it’s not possible to fit us both in with the door closed, I leave the door open and just wee quickly.

However, I’m curious - to all those saying they would never let their 5/6/7 year old out of their sight, do you have more than one child? I can’t always watch my 5 year old like a hawk in the playground because I am occupied with his younger siblings. I trust him not to leave the playground and check in with him regularly but the younger two need watching more closely and it’s impossible to keep them all together all the time. How do people manage this situation?

My friend is a child psychiatrist. She says we should allow children above the age of 7. To manage risk. It creates the correct neuro pathways which means that accessing risk is good for them.

In a park I think it’s fine to let the older child not in your sight 24/7 to help you get sibling. It helps them learn how to access risk. Which they do really need for this development. Some study I think in Israel( though don’t quote me) found that risk assessment at a young age (and oxytocin at birth) stops depression in teenagers. Though it got a bit complex for me to understand.

I’ve got two different aged children.

babybythesea · 12/09/2021 10:00

For me, the bigger issue is that she needs to learn to do as she’s told in instances like this, without exception.
There are times when children can have more of a say and debate with you, or get away with something you’ve asked them not to do - this isn’t one of them. Staying with you when out and about like this is essential.

It’s about your reaction to it. If she carried on playing with no consequences, then she’ll do it again next time. I think I’d be tempted, if a similar scenario occurs again (and it will) to say “If you run off, we are going straight home. Do you understand me?” And be prepared to carry it through.

When she’s at school they will rely on her understanding that ‘stay here’ means just that. You can’t have one adult for each child and even in a group of say, 3 children to one adult, if one child runs off, what does the adult do with the other two children while they chase the one? She is the same age as the children in the nursery I work with, and they absolutely can stay where they are asked so although she’s little it’s not an outrageous demand on her. We take our children out and about - they are little and won’t always get it right but obeying a direct command to stand still is pretty basic. It needs to be enforced now, at home, so that she’s not the child who gets to school thinking she doesn’t need to do what she’s told because it hasn’t mattered before.

Comedycook · 12/09/2021 09:59

to all those saying they would never let their 5/6/7 year old out of their sight, do you have more than one child? I can’t always watch my 5 year old like a hawk in the playground because I am occupied with his younger siblings

I have two DC with a two year age gap. I can honestly say my DC were never out of my sight in parks and playgrounds when they were little. It made my time there stressful but my anxiety would not allow me to not know where they were at all times

JustSayingItHowItIs · 12/09/2021 09:58

Absolutely not.

I'd have held my son on my lap if he even attempted to run off. By not saying what she has done wrong to her just enables this behaviour.

SarahBop · 12/09/2021 09:57

I told her to wait but she said no and was off, told me she was going on the slides as she legged it away!

THIS is the bit that caught me. Toddlers are buggers...but they will grow into even bigger buggers if they do as they please with zero guidance.

In this instance, and I'm gonna presume you were like mid-pee and she literally bolted before you had chance to stop her....I would've [after finishing peeing Grin marched out of that toilet, caught up with the little madam and had a VERY stern chat about how is absolutely not to ignore what you say/or to run away, made her sit with you in a time-out [miss some park fun as a consequence for not listening to you] OR even left the park altogether as a punishment.

I know it is HORRIBLE when they tantrum/kick off etc...but you really have to grow a thick-skin as a parent, don't think or assume what others are thinking when they look....you have to nip this kind of behaviour in the bud or she will be an absolute brat over time.