Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Arachnophobics - I want to understand. DSis is leaving holiday.

271 replies

Dollywilde · 11/09/2021 21:15

Ok first off I hate spiders. I really do. Once got a randomer off my local FB to remove one.

But we are on holiday. First family holiday since baby was born. My sister has left after one night because she can’t cope with the spiders.

I paid for and organised it. They’re not huge (nothing bigger than a 5p piece). She’s severely arachnaphobic, I get that. But I’m cross, we have activities planned and she wanted to come and I can’t believe she’s letting this ruin the holiday.

It’s her thing, she’s going, I get it doesn’t affect me aside from the fact we all wanted a lovely holiday together. And I know it’s a real phobia.

Basically, can people shake some sense into me to stop me being cross? I don’t want to be cross with her. But walking out half way through a holiday I paid for is making me sad. We were having such a lovely time and this has basically made the entire break a waste of time and ££££.

OP posts:
Mamanyt · 13/09/2021 00:56

The definition of "phobia" is an irrational fear of something. She can no more help this than she can stop breathing...or not without a lot of therapy. You'd be just as reasonable blaming her for all that constant in and out with the air that she does. While it's perfectly normal to be disappointed about something like this, being angry about it is both useless and counter-productive.

Look, it doesn't matter what size that spider might be. In her mind, it is five feet long, has fangs that drip venom, and is plotting her demise, probably gathering all its friends to help. And she CANNOT STOP THINKING ABOUT THAT. If she is as phobic about them as I once was, she may get anxious and slightly nauseated simply looking at photographs of them. In fact, I still do, although after LOTS of therapy, I am able to take a fly-swatter and kill one...I no longer run, screaming, from the house. It is miserable.

Was it just the two of you? That's the only way I can see that she would have spoiled your entire holiday. If it was, find lovely ways to pamper yourself. If not, enjoy the people you are with while trying to feel badly that she is missing the fun because of a fear she has no control over.

Blueink · 13/09/2021 00:56

That’s a lot of spiders! Full on phobia, the small size of 10(!) of them wouldn’t help

Fleshmechanic · 13/09/2021 00:52

After reading how many, I think you're unreasonable. I couldn't stay somewhere with that many. I couldn't afford to leave but I would be very unsettled and upset. I can see why she had to go, even though its shitty and unreasonable. She should try to get therapy if she can.

nanbread · 13/09/2021 00:32

OP I would strongly encourage your Dsis to look into Havening. It can make phobias go away sometimes in half an hour.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 13/09/2021 00:26

London zoo hold the most amazing courses to conquer this. My friend went from paralysis at the sight of a spider to holding a tarantula, amazing.

Hakunapotato · 12/09/2021 23:37

If you see 10+ spiders of varying size in one day, and you have a phobia, you will be on high alert for what’s coming next! If there were 10 moths/mice/snakes/other phobia appeared out of the blue you’d be constantly worrying about the next one appearing. I always hated spiders growing up and then someone chased me with one and threw it at me. Since then my heart thuds, I sweat, feel lightheaded and can’t sit at peace. For those saying they wouldn’t let spiders leave their holiday, think about how bad your phobia would have to be to willingly give up a holiday 1 night in after looking forward to it, packing, travelling etc. I’m guessing she’s a bit gutted herself!

Libraryghost · 12/09/2021 23:04

@KaycePollard I LOVE my ex neighbour. To be fair she was in a massive mood that day, heavily pregnant etc and we laugh about it now but seriously she cured me overnight. Every time I see a spider I see that look in her eyes 🤣. Ladies with this phobia I am not being unkind. I get it, I was beyond irrational about spiders but you can overcome it in time. Start by looking at pictures or learning about them, take baby steps. But if you tell yourself you cannot do anything about it then you never will.

louderthan · 12/09/2021 22:41

Spiders don't bother me at all but I am terrified of sn*kes. The thought of staying somewhere with even one is just....no. I would run a mile. Don't care how much it cost.

VeganCow · 12/09/2021 22:24

OP you say you're struggling to understand your sisters reaction to the spiders. It's a sliding scale of fear. I'm struggling to understand how you had to get a Facebook randomer to remove a spider for you, because they don't bother me at all and I leave them be in my house.
But we're all different.
Surely you see that you can't judge her reaction when yours was ott to some people too?

BritMommyAbroad · 12/09/2021 21:59

I’m with your sister on this. I’m guessing she really didn’t want to abandon the holiday either, so for her leave because of her fear, it must be bad. That’s the thing about phobias, they’re not rational. Whilst you can look in from the outside and rationalize it, she can’t.

cricketmum84 · 12/09/2021 21:17

@Speakuptomakeyourselfheard

My husband nearly wrecked our hire car in Spain because he went to put his sun visor down and a spider came out of it! He went nuts vering all over the road, almost hit another car, and finally did an emergency stop on the side of the road. I had to strip everything out of the car, but couldn't find the bloody thing. He was terrified after that, so I had to drive in case it popped up again, as they don't bother me at all thank goodness. Bless him though, as he comes to the rescue with me, if there's a mouse in the house, so we help each other with our weird phobias.

I also had to drive to the rescue when my daughter got a youngster to babysit, both she and the grandkids were terrified of a tiny spider, so she phoned me and asked me to go and get rid of it. Couldn't help wondering how she'd have coped in a real emergency!

One of my neighbours actually killed someone because a spider was in his car, he lost control, mounted the pavement and hit her. Very sad.
Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 12/09/2021 21:05

My husband nearly wrecked our hire car in Spain because he went to put his sun visor down and a spider came out of it! He went nuts vering all over the road, almost hit another car, and finally did an emergency stop on the side of the road. I had to strip everything out of the car, but couldn't find the bloody thing. He was terrified after that, so I had to drive in case it popped up again, as they don't bother me at all thank goodness. Bless him though, as he comes to the rescue with me, if there's a mouse in the house, so we help each other with our weird phobias.

I also had to drive to the rescue when my daughter got a youngster to babysit, both she and the grandkids were terrified of a tiny spider, so she phoned me and asked me to go and get rid of it. Couldn't help wondering how she'd have coped in a real emergency!

whiskersonkittenss · 12/09/2021 20:57

I was phobic but I didn't think I'd need to state that. I used to be frightened of needles to the point I missed vaccinations in school and wouldn't go on holiday because I'd need vacs. Not sure what happened in my brain but I forced myself to donate blood now I'm fine. I also used to leave rooms, panic, sweat and cry over spiders...

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 12/09/2021 20:55

Gold star for you @KaycePollard for being SO MUCH MORE MATURE than all the people setting feminism back by uh... suffering from a phobia. The bastards.
For the record I don't mind spiders except for big ones but I am perfectly capable of understanding why other people might develop a phobia of all of them. But maybe we should all run through a list of our fears with you to check if we're allowed to have them?

godmum56 · 12/09/2021 20:49

@whiskersonkittenss

I used to be frightened of spiders then started watching YouTubers who keep tarantulas. I now have 6 tarantulas. I don't know if it would help anyone else to watch the care and husbandry of these creatures but they are so interesting
being frightened is not the same as havng a phobia
Cozytoesandtoast00 · 12/09/2021 20:48

RincewindsHat 😱
This happened to me on an overnight train overseas.
They were literally crawling everywhere. I was terrified and the locals thought it was hilarious.
The lights went out as the journey went on. I didn't sleep a wink and discovered dead cockroaches underneath where I was sitting at daylight.
I now have an intense fear of cockroaches. Funny really.

Sandfairy69 · 12/09/2021 20:43

I actually stayed overseas 33 years frightened to return to the U.K. and our ridiculous house-spiders so definitely understand your sisters very real phobia. Maybe holidays in September in a wooded area was not the best idea but she could also have thought about that and said no thanks.

whiskersonkittenss · 12/09/2021 20:38

I used to be frightened of spiders then started watching YouTubers who keep tarantulas. I now have 6 tarantulas. I don't know if it would help anyone else to watch the care and husbandry of these creatures but they are so interesting

CorianderAndCream · 12/09/2021 20:25

I'm not arachnophobic but I do have a different phobia. It's nothing like regular fear or dislike. It's runs through your body and causes absolute abject terror. Mines so bad that My heart rate drops and I pass out. Once went into hypotension.

drspouse · 12/09/2021 20:18

@Branleuse

Where is she going to go to that wont have any spiders when september is spider season?
I was wondering this, how does she cope with her home, going for a walk, going to the shops, cinema etc?
godmum56 · 12/09/2021 20:11

@Hardbackwriter
"The one thing I do find a little difficult to accept about people with this kind of phobia (and I realise this might be total ignorance) is that they think spiders are too terrifying to contemplate but they always expect others to do it for them. I had a housemate many years ago who had quite a long list of things - spiders, bees, wasps and other insects, anything very mouldy or filthy, anything involving going into a small space (specifically our attic) - that she deemed completely beyond her as she found them all too frightening and unpleasant, so she expected me to deal with them all - I did end up resenting the fact that these things were all apparently too unpleasant or dangerous for her to put herself through, but they were all ok for me to have to do. I find it hard to imagine finding something that terrifying but merrily sending others off to deal with it so I didn't have to. But as I said, perhaps this is something you can't understand if you don't have a phobia."

With me I know its a phobia... I know it can't hurt me....I know its stupid...but that doesn't stop the panic....thats why I can ask other people who are not phobic about my phobia to deal with stuff.... but your flatmate may well have been a cf....phobia is not finding things unpleasant or dangerous...its genuine panic

LaDamaDeElche · 12/09/2021 20:03

People who are saying they have arachnophobia but can deal with medium sized spiders don't have arachnophobia 🤷🏻‍♀️ They might be a bit scared of spiders. I'm a bit scared of cockroaches, but I don't have a phobia. They freak me out and give me goose pimples all over my body, but I can deal with them and get them out of the house, even though I'm scared. I do have arachnophobia and in the situation you are describing I would leave. I broke my iPhone screen once because I scrolled onto a photo of a spider someone had posted on FB. I can't even touch a photo of a spider. It's a real fear. Same as you wouldn't expect someone with claustrophobia to go potholing or someone with a phobia of heights to stand on the edge of a cliff, you can't expect someone with a phobia of spiders to stay, abs especially sleep in a place knowing they're are spiders running around.

Hardbackwriter · 12/09/2021 20:03

@Dollywilde

To those who say it’s a bit much… maybe 10 of the 16 (and all the big ones) were on arrival yesterday. Which I guess makes sense since they asked for windows to be open on exit. The others (all small) have been since our initial entrance.
I think this update, that CP are currently requiring windows to be left open between guests (which makes sense for covid reasons) is quite important. I would guess your sister didn't know this, and it's made her terrified that the place is full of them hidden in corners. I can see how it's pushed a lodge holiday in September from 'a bit risky for an arachnophobe' to 'absolutely no way'.

I also find it a bit hard to fully understand your sister, OP - I don't have any phobias (obviously I have things that frighten me but nothing at that level) and it is very hard to understand if you don't. But I would say that you don't have to understand it to be kind about it (which it sounds like you are doing), and it might be best to think of it as her being ill. You might be disappointed and sad if she'd got food poisoning and left the holiday but you wouldn't be cross.

The one thing I do find a little difficult to accept about people with this kind of phobia (and I realise this might be total ignorance) is that they think spiders are too terrifying to contemplate but they always expect others to do it for them. I had a housemate many years ago who had quite a long list of things - spiders, bees, wasps and other insects, anything very mouldy or filthy, anything involving going into a small space (specifically our attic) - that she deemed completely beyond her as she found them all too frightening and unpleasant, so she expected me to deal with them all - I did end up resenting the fact that these things were all apparently too unpleasant or dangerous for her to put herself through, but they were all ok for me to have to do. I find it hard to imagine finding something that terrifying but merrily sending others off to deal with it so I didn't have to. But as I said, perhaps this is something you can't understand if you don't have a phobia.

whatthejiggeries · 12/09/2021 19:58

I would ask to move rooms I don't expect to share with multiple spiders

ERFFER · 12/09/2021 19:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread