Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids earlier?

360 replies

40220s · 11/09/2021 18:41

My mum was 35 when she had me. She died when I was 16, and I had my first baby at 40. My dad died when I was 30.

One of my friends at school got pregnant at university and I remember my dad making some comment about being glad it wasn’t me. But I look at her now and it got me thinking. If I’d had my first baby at 20 and my mum had me at 20 … maybe there’s something in doing it that way, as you’re more likely to have extensive support from family.

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

OP posts:
Ozanj · 11/09/2021 23:47

[quote NortieTortie]@ouchmyfeet women are perfectly able to have a career in their 20s, even when having a child Hmm I have to say at my children's school, most SAHMS are well into their 30s/40s. Perhaps it's area/industry dependent, but I, personally, can't see many young women willing to live fianncially dependent on their DH .. times change.[/quote]
All the sahm I know had their first child between 16-20. So I think this is probably highly subjective

ithinkilikeit · 11/09/2021 23:47

@SeriouslyISuppose and you bring up another good point to @user908768543. I would have been a shit mother most of all because I did not want a child. Tbh I think if you take a survey of 20-25 year olds now you would find the majority of them do not want one yet.

user908768543 · 11/09/2021 23:45

@ithinkilikeit and I'm just saying you don't know about what hasn't happened. We all know pregnancy and motherhood changes us entirely. I wasn't mentally or financially stable at 22, I hadn't completed my studies, I'm sure it's possible if I hadn't have fallen pregnant I'd have been one of the posters here saying how awful it would have been if I'd fallen pregnant at that time. But I did, and I wasn't awful, it was hard work don't get me wrong nor am I saying people should do it the way I did it, but it really wasn't the sentence of misery some people make it out to be, quite the opposite. Becoming a mother gave me a drive to succeed and I hope if any young pregnant women are reading this thread they know it isn't automatically game over as others would like them to believe.

EmeraldShamrock · 11/09/2021 23:45

I think it is a worry for most DM's of any age.
I am not afraid of dying but I'm terrified of dying when my DC are young.
You're not alone feeling like this it is very common. Flowers

ithinkilikeit · 11/09/2021 23:43

@Realyorkshiretea I don’t understand this obsession you have with men and commitment. I think we can see using statistic of single motherhood now that women having children later or earlier had little to no effect on the rate of men being committed to their partners at all.

I don’t care about men and their vommitment. I care about women choosing to have children when they want and it seems women are now choosing to have women later. I really don’t think women having children earlier will prompt better maternity leave at all. It will prompt employers to hire women even less because in their eyes they are ‘encumbered’ even earlier and that makes them unappealing employers. So they wouldn’t receive any maternity leave at all instead. We live in a capitalist country and that is what it comes down to.

repog · 11/09/2021 23:43

Let me introduce myself, senior leader by 33, programme managing multi million pound projects and signing off on decisions that have a national impact, oh and a mother at 22.

But statistically that's quite unusual even without motherhood

Ozanj · 11/09/2021 23:43

@user908768543

This. Everyone I know who had kids in their 20s has no career. They literally all work in low paid, insecure positions and industries. Honestly I think having kids so young is pretty daft and short sighted.

It sounds like you have a very limited circle, perhaps the problem isn't young mums but your small world? Ironic that you are slamming a whole demographic with your snobbery, and yet your stupidity knows no bounds, heard of irony? Let me introduce myself, senior leader by 33, programme managing multi million pound projects and signing off on decisions that have a national impact, oh and a mother at 22. Nice to meet you, now you don't have to repeat that moronic comment ever again.

She was talking from her own experience. It was really quite obvs. Don’t be so fucking rude or use abelist language.
NortieTortie · 11/09/2021 23:42

@ouchmyfeet women are perfectly able to have a career in their 20s, even when having a child Hmm I have to say at my children's school, most SAHMS are well into their 30s/40s. Perhaps it's area/industry dependent, but I, personally, can't see many young women willing to live fianncially dependent on their DH .. times change.

Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 23:40

@ouchmyfeet

Your comment (in my experience) relates more to very young teen mums than 20 something mums. Which is clearly due to interrupted education.

I know a lot of 20 somethings who finished their degrees (usually picking up a man along the way!), went travelling for a year, got a foothold in their chosen profession, enjoyed life for a couple of years then had a baby at say 26 or 27.

The other 20 something mums i know are a teacher, an engineer, a solicitor and a trainee social worker.

I know a few teenage mums, one is now a qualified midwife and still with the dad, the other is a tattoo artist and her life is a bit of a mess (not saying the two things are related!)

FeelingBored · 11/09/2021 23:39

I had my DD in my early 30s - TBH I didn't enjoy my twenties that much as I was so stressed about career, boyfriends, then in a not-great relationship with DD's dad. I think there's a lot to be said for having children young - by the time you are in your 40s (as I am now) you know yourself much better and are well placed to forge ahead in life/work. Of course there's no "right way" but I do think we are needlessly negative about having children young.

ithinkilikeit · 11/09/2021 23:38

@user908768543 I am not patronising anyone. I simply was saying I would have been a horrible mother at 20 and that is the truth. I would not have been able to emotionally, physically or financially handle children and would not have been able to give them a good upbringing. The only person I can speak for is myself . I am not judging anyone nor making anyone feel bad. I was simply asking the OP to look at their own situation at that age and actually contemplate if they would have been able to be a good mother at that age before they say they wish they had had children then.

SeriouslyISuppose · 11/09/2021 23:35

[quote user908768543]@ithinkilikeit you simply don't know what kind of mother you'd have been at 20, just as I don't know what kind of new mum I would have been if I'd waited at 30. I find women here are so quick to say they'd have been awful it would have been shit for the kids etc etc (quite ignorant to how that sounds to younger mums), but honestly when you're actually in the situation you do the best you can and if you're an ambitious woman then you would make it work. If you're the kind of woman who went to uni, made a career, waited for kids, then I bet you wouldn't be the kind of woman to have given up on all ambitions if you fell accidentally pregnant at 20 nor be a shit mum. I am a brilliant mum, I am ambitious, conscientious, financially stable and my kids are happy living a life I'd have been very happy with as a child, I'm not an outlier, I'm not supermum, I'm just a woman who fell pregnant younger than ideal and I bet many of the older mums here would have been very similar if they were given the same deck of cards and chose to proceed. But we'll never know, so please don't patronise younger mums with these assumptions.[/quote]
It’s fairly clear it would have interrupted, if not ended, her studies and that she and the baby risked being extremely poor, regardless of ‘what kind of mother’ she would have been at 20. She also says she was ‘a mess’ and didn’t want a baby.

user908768543 · 11/09/2021 23:33

This. Everyone I know who had kids in their 20s has no career. They literally all work in low paid, insecure positions and industries. Honestly I think having kids so young is pretty daft and short sighted.

It sounds like you have a very limited circle, perhaps the problem isn't young mums but your small world? Ironic that you are slamming a whole demographic with your snobbery, and yet your stupidity knows no bounds, heard of irony? Let me introduce myself, senior leader by 33, programme managing multi million pound projects and signing off on decisions that have a national impact, oh and a mother at 22. Nice to meet you, now you don't have to repeat that moronic comment ever again.

ZednotZee · 11/09/2021 23:29

This. Everyone I know who had kids in their 20s has no career. They literally all work in low paid, insecure positions and industries. Honestly I think having kids so young is pretty daft and short sighted.

I think that's very class dependent.
The MC women I know who had children in their twenties all have decent professional careers.

notthemum · 11/09/2021 23:29

@Tomatosquash.
Wow.
I had my dd two months before I was 18. I had no clue what I was doing and life was very difficult because of all sorts of factors.
My DF died when I was almost 26 and he and my dd had formed a wonderful bond and even now I am so glad that I had her when I did and they were able to be so close.
My DM had her eldest child when she was 21. She was only allowed to visit relatives or take me on trips in school holidays when I was young. My DM was in her late 50s when my DF died.
She learned to swim, she took many trips all over world America, Austria, Holland, many others, she got lost a lot but didn't care, she had loads of fun. She learned line dancing and joined a tai chi class.

From 58ish she had a fabulous time and didn't regret a second.

Nancydrawn · 11/09/2021 23:28

Gosh, if I'd had babies in my early 20s, it would have: a. been with the wrong man; b. derailed my career; and c. preventing me from figuring out who I was as a person before I became a mother.

Instead, I have a husband I love, trust, and respect; a career that is financially and personally satisfying; and a real sense of who I am, what I value, and what I can handle. None of which I had at 28 let alone 22.

There are lots of good reasons to have a baby early. But personally, I'm very glad I didn't.

ZednotZee · 11/09/2021 23:26

I had my two eldest at twenty two and just twenty six.
My dad died nine months after my second child was born and I'm so happy that he got to meet them, he was such a lovely grandy and my eldest remembers him fondly.

But you know OP, we do what we think is best at the time and I'm sure you had a lovely and carefree youth, which you don't experience when you are a mother at twenty two.

ouchmyfeet · 11/09/2021 23:26

[quote Southwestrunningmum]@TomatoSquash but then in your 20s your unlikely to have had a career. Pros and cons and I think you’ve offended most 69 year olds[/quote]
This. Everyone I know who had kids in their 20s has no career. They literally all work in low paid, insecure positions and industries. Honestly I think having kids so young is pretty daft and short sighted.

NortieTortie · 11/09/2021 23:25

yanbu for your feelings. This sounds like a very emotional and personal moment for you, what an awful thing to go through so young - you have my deepest sympathies Flowers

I had my children very early - 18 and 20 - and while I can tell you there are pros and cons to all walks of life, the only ones you'll be thinking of are the pros you couldn't experience. I think that's fine, natural even, and the best thing you can do is make peace with this. Is counselling an option?

KT727 · 11/09/2021 23:20

I'm 33, I've not had kids yet, I just really hope to be able to have a baby (or ideally 2) in the next 7ish years but I would have to meet the right guy first. You are lucky you have kids whether you're older/younger when you have them.

I think losing your parents so young must have been awful so I can see why you think it might have been better if your Mum had had you earlier but then you wouldn't be you (with the way things change based on time/situation (a butterfly's flaps its wings!) etc. resulting in a different embryo) if she'd had a baby younger!

OppsUpsSide · 11/09/2021 23:16

I had mine younger than my friends, I had my last before most had had their first. I do think I would find it harder going if I was just starting now, just in terms of energy, but I also wonder if that’s because they’ve worn me out! I also really appreciate the relationship as they get older, they’re good company. But, I never had the chance to be broody. I am only just experiencing finding babies inexplicably cute and appealing, and I definitely couldn’t/wouldn’t be able to have one now!

kikisparks · 11/09/2021 23:08

I think it’s all fine, whether you become a mum (or dad) at 21 or 41. People have such strong opinions about old parents, young parents, single child families, large families, working mothers, stay at home mothers, lone parents, step mothers, childfree people etc etc and it’s nearly always women being judged. As long as you have the finances, health and emotional tolerance to meet your child(ren)‘s needs then just make the decision that’s right for you (and any partner), there’s pros and cons to all the options. There isn’t a best way to do things that fits everyone, we’re all different.

EsmeeMerlin · 11/09/2021 23:04

I think there are some benefits to being a younger parent and some to being an older parent.

However there are no guarantees in this life. My dad had me when he was 20 years old, he died at 31 from cancer so I lost a parent at 10 years old. Having younger parents didn’t stop me losing a parent at a young age.

Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 22:56

*not subtley obviously! Bedtime for me I think 😵‍💫

user908768543 · 11/09/2021 22:56

@ithinkilikeit you simply don't know what kind of mother you'd have been at 20, just as I don't know what kind of new mum I would have been if I'd waited at 30. I find women here are so quick to say they'd have been awful it would have been shit for the kids etc etc (quite ignorant to how that sounds to younger mums), but honestly when you're actually in the situation you do the best you can and if you're an ambitious woman then you would make it work. If you're the kind of woman who went to uni, made a career, waited for kids, then I bet you wouldn't be the kind of woman to have given up on all ambitions if you fell accidentally pregnant at 20 nor be a shit mum. I am a brilliant mum, I am ambitious, conscientious, financially stable and my kids are happy living a life I'd have been very happy with as a child, I'm not an outlier, I'm not supermum, I'm just a woman who fell pregnant younger than ideal and I bet many of the older mums here would have been very similar if they were given the same deck of cards and chose to proceed. But we'll never know, so please don't patronise younger mums with these assumptions.