Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids earlier?

360 replies

40220s · 11/09/2021 18:41

My mum was 35 when she had me. She died when I was 16, and I had my first baby at 40. My dad died when I was 30.

One of my friends at school got pregnant at university and I remember my dad making some comment about being glad it wasn’t me. But I look at her now and it got me thinking. If I’d had my first baby at 20 and my mum had me at 20 … maybe there’s something in doing it that way, as you’re more likely to have extensive support from family.

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

OP posts:
FireworkParrot · 12/09/2021 08:23

I had my DDs when I was 29 and 31 and feel that was about the right age (for me) old enough to have experienced Uni, living independently and having fun in my 20s but young enough that I'll be around 50 when they're the age to leave home and plenty of time to save for retirement. Obviously life doesn't always work out how you plan it but I was lucky that I met DH in my mid 20s and so I didn't want to be having any DC past the age of 35.

LuckyAmy1986 · 12/09/2021 08:12

@EmeraldShamrock

I think it is a worry for most DM's of any age
I am not afraid of dying but I'm terrified of dying when my DC are young
You're not alone feeling like this it is very common

I would think the feeling is much more strong in someone who lost a parent at an early age. And I don’t mean a bit worried. Like a real, debilitating fear that gets worse especially as you reach the age your parent was when they died.

losing a parent is hard at any age

Please never say this to someone who lost a parent young. And please tell me you know it’s just be harder to lose your mum as a child/ teen that later in life? Please?

LuckyAmy1986 · 12/09/2021 08:05

1 from cancer so I lost a parent at 10 years old. Having younger parents didn’t stop me losing a parent at a young age

This argument is so stupid!!! Yes you can lose a parent at any age but it is more likely if they are older. It’s just a fact fgs

LuckyAmy1986 · 12/09/2021 07:54

we don’t sweat the small stuff that younger parents do

@pinkhousesarebest what small stuff, just out of curiosity?

Franticbutterfly · 12/09/2021 07:35

I had my first 3 months shy of my 27th birthday and it was the best time ever to start a family. I'd hate to be in the starting blocks at the age I am now. By the time I'm 50 I hope to be going on holidays galore with DH. On the downside I felt compelled to end my career once DD1 arrived and have worked jobs that I'm way overqualified for for 13 years, although I'm hopefully taking up a masters to get into a new career next year. It also took us a long time to buy a house. I wouldn't swap it though and am glad I'm one of the youngest mums in DD1's friendship group (she seems to think this is cool).

Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 06:55

@gibletjane

It isn’t ‘feministic’ to have children as late as possible, in fact the idea as a whole benefits men more than women

I think the reason some women have dc later is because a) need to find a partner b) finances & c) career. And many women now chose not to have dc. I think it's good women have more choice.

But that isn’t choosing to have children later, that’s not having a choice because the circumstances aren’t working for them?
TheQueenOfDreams · 12/09/2021 06:51

In my experience most women, not all, had dc late due to not finding a man who wanted to commit and have dc when younger. Ideally, I’d have had kids between 28 and 33.
I’d got my degree, had fun with friends, established a career but didn’t have the commitment for kids.

gibletjane · 12/09/2021 05:26

It isn’t ‘feministic’ to have children as late as possible, in fact the idea as a whole benefits men more than women

I think the reason some women have dc later is because a) need to find a partner b) finances & c) career. And many women now chose not to have dc. I think it's good women have more choice.

MissTrip82 · 12/09/2021 04:48

I don’t feel that way, no.

But I was studying medicine, working at night to support myself and caring for a terminally ill relative. I’d have been very stupid indeed to add a baby to that.

I really do tire of the ludicrous binary that either you have the first of six babies at 12, or you’re face down in a skip for most of your twenties.

Many of us had full lives and significant responsibilities at 20, whether parents or not.

Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 04:03

@repog

It isn’t ‘feministic’ to have children as late as possible, in fact the idea as a whole benefits men more than women

Why is it feminist to have them young?

It isn’t!
Stilesandlydia · 12/09/2021 03:04

I’ve thought about this a lot. It’s all well and good for people to say I’m glad I’ve had my children young and now I can enjoy myself etc . But the truth is that we don’t have a choice. I don’t just mean those that suffer from infertility. You actually have to find a partner to have a child with! Not every finds their life partner at age 18 or in their twenties. And even if You’ve had your children young, they will have kids of their own so you’ll probably have to help out plus work as well. You won’t have time to go travelling and what not.

Having kids young is no guarantee that you’ll live long. I’ve had lots of people in my family die young. My cousin was early thirties, my mother’s dad was early thirties too, mums brother was late 40s etc . We can go at anytime and nothing is guaranteed. My own grandmother was 70 when she died and I was only 17. I could’ve had her in my life for at least another 10 years.

At the end of the day, parents will usually die before their children. As long as they’re given a good foundation then that’s all that’s required.

repog · 12/09/2021 01:55

It isn’t ‘feministic’ to have children as late as possible, in fact the idea as a whole benefits men more than women

Why is it feminist to have them young?

Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 01:51

@Newmumatlast not necessarily. We have legislation in place now that wasn’t around back in the 70s. We could make SPL better, so employers wouldn’t assume it would only be women taking the leave if she became pregnant, and therefore wouldn’t be disadvantaged in the recruitment/promotion process. There’s lots that can be done to ensure women wouldn’t immediately be transported back 50 years.

Newmumatlast · 12/09/2021 01:45

@Realyorkshiretea

It isn’t ‘feministic’ to have children as late as possible, in fact the idea as a whole benefits men more than women.
I dont get this. I saw your follow up post about commitment. However surely you could argue it benefits men if women have kids young, when their career is less developed and they're earning less meaning it ends up making sense for them to be SAHM as childcare is so expensive. It keeps women out of the market and away from competing with men. Keeps men in top roles as when women then go back, they have missed out on years. Whereas women having kids later will have had more chance to advance their careers such that time out to have kids has less impact and childcare is more affordable. Just playing devils advocate
Newmumatlast · 12/09/2021 01:39

@nokidshere

However if you have your kids at 40 you have a constant sinking sensation that this is it for you, you’ll be an old person of 60 when they leave home and you have no future.

I had mine at 39 & 41. It took me 17yrs to get pregnant so it wasn't by choice. I'm now 60, one of them is working and getting his own place and the other is away at uni.

My life is fantastic. I'm not old, I definitely don't sit around with a sinking feeling that 'this is it'. I have friends, hobbies, a fab DH and a great sex life with no 'children' at home. What's not to like.

Agree with you. I had my first in my 30s and hope to have more. I totally see the advantage of having children young in terms of spending more time with them but it has never been an advantage to me that you get your independence back when you're still young. For me, parenting is a life long commitment and I don't see it that once they're grown you can just go off and do whatever you like. My parents moved closer to where I moved for work, they help with childcare, and they are still absolutely committed to family life. Yes they are retired and have holidays but they're not off touring the world. They want to be with us because they love their family. I feel the same. I am glad I got studying and paving my way in my career out of the way before kids because now I am financially stable and can afford to take time out when I want to. If I had kids young I would've struggled to get to where I am. I think its completely dependent on the individual as to which is best
EmeraldShamrock · 12/09/2021 01:18

the fact is having children young is more likely to lead to a lower wage over a women’s lifetime. That is a well documented fact.
Some people don't prioritise earning big money or travelling.
Fact is you might have more money waiting until later but less time to spend with them.
Losing your parents is hard at any age.
Plus having a baby young doesn't mean you can't have a career later.
I wasn't young or old 28 and 34.
Pp's saying they'd be a shit DM when older or younger cannot know that for certain, we all make the best of what we have.

Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 00:51

@ithinkilikeit

I really get confused when people say things on here like ‘well actually that chose benefits men in general’. Sorry when I make choices I think about myself. Do not give a hoot whether ‘men’ benefit or suffer from it.

It hi k women should have feee choice. Not be paranoid about making sure their choice does not benefit ‘men’.

I’m not talking about the choices of an individual. I’m talking about the overall effect on society. Hth.
Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 00:49

[quote ithinkilikeit]@Realyorkshiretea I did not say anything about feminism and women should be Abel to make choses without thinking whether it benefits men or not. Not sure how men benefit from women having children later but even if they do it does not take away a women’s right to choose to have kids whenever she wants.[/quote]
They benefit because it normalises them only making a commitment at the very last minute, when the health risks for the women are higher.

Of course women should choose if and when to have children. My point is only that for those who want to have children in their 20s, society shouldn’t be so geared up against making that happen in terms of employment, social stigma, expense and men being told it’s far too young.

GrealishHairband · 12/09/2021 00:47

I have an 18 year old and a 12 year old and I’m still in my 30’s. I have a family member in their mid 40’s with a toddler and after spending a few days with them I’ve told my husband to go ahead and book a vasectomy if he wants one. I couldn’t do it at this age.

I didn’t really have a career when my first was born, having them gave me some purpose and I trained for a qualification that has given me some amazing opportunities after they were born and before DC2 came along. I wouldn’t have ever thought of this career before having them so having kids young definitely worked out for me and now I’m at a stage where my career is taking off and I have older independent kids who I don’t have to give quite as much headspace to (in terms of school runs/childcare etc).

I did plenty of socialising, solo holidays before having DC1, lived with friends for a year, crammed in a lot. And now I’m getting to that point where DH and I have more time for us again except now we have plenty of cash to enjoy ourselves. It’s a win win for us anyway.

ithinkilikeit · 12/09/2021 00:45

I really get confused when people say things on here like ‘well actually that chose benefits men in general’. Sorry when I make choices I think about myself. Do not give a hoot whether ‘men’ benefit or suffer from it.

It hi k women should have feee choice. Not be paranoid about making sure their choice does not benefit ‘men’.

ithinkilikeit · 12/09/2021 00:44

*able

ithinkilikeit · 12/09/2021 00:43

@Realyorkshiretea I did not say anything about feminism and women should be Abel to make choses without thinking whether it benefits men or not. Not sure how men benefit from women having children later but even if they do it does not take away a women’s right to choose to have kids whenever she wants.

Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 00:34

It isn’t ‘feministic’ to have children as late as possible, in fact the idea as a whole benefits men more than women.

Realyorkshiretea · 12/09/2021 00:33

[quote ithinkilikeit]@Realyorkshiretea but maybe the woman doesn’t want kids. Your falling into a very tried and frankly misogynistic stereotype that it’s women who are gagging for kids as soon as they’ve go their provisional licence and it’s men who push them to have kids later.

Even reading this thread you can see this is not true for a lot of women and they chose to have kids later because they wanted to.

I would have loved the men you are describing in my 20’s. I didn’t want commitment I wanted to have fun.[/quote]
If she doesn’t then she doesn’t have to have them Confused I didn’t say women should be encouraged to have children, I said if they do then society shouldn’t make it so difficult for her, like it is at the moment. Because there is no real benefit to women from older mums being the societal norm.

ithinkilikeit · 12/09/2021 00:30

@user908768543 well of course having children in general reduces wages but that doesn’t rebute my point at all.