Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids earlier?

360 replies

40220s · 11/09/2021 18:41

My mum was 35 when she had me. She died when I was 16, and I had my first baby at 40. My dad died when I was 30.

One of my friends at school got pregnant at university and I remember my dad making some comment about being glad it wasn’t me. But I look at her now and it got me thinking. If I’d had my first baby at 20 and my mum had me at 20 … maybe there’s something in doing it that way, as you’re more likely to have extensive support from family.

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

OP posts:
Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 15:38

[quote ManifestDestinee]**@ManifestDestinee that was quite a nasty post but the ‘worst case scenario’ for somebody 40+ would be a lot shorter - egg quality has diminished, no baby, the end

It wasn't nasty at all, it was needed for balance to the bizarre "have your children while you're still a child, it'll be great" post. Hmm[/quote]
I don’t think she meant that. She was countering the idea that ALL teenage mums slob around estates all day drinking white lightening. She may be an unusually successful young mum, but given the number of unusually fit and spritely 90 year olds mentioned on these types of threads, don’t you think it works both ways? Of course a similar response to the ‘my mum had me at 45 and is still going strong at 103’ could be, ‘have children when you’re an OAP, it’ll be great’. Just needlessly mean.

ohdear10 · 13/09/2021 15:37

@Realyorkshiretea

16/17 is mad to me - education not finished, only just out of childhood yourself, not even a taste of freedom. Im glad it worked for you though!

@ManifestDestinee that was quite a nasty post but the ‘worst case scenario’ for somebody 40+ would be a lot shorter - egg quality has diminished, no baby, the end.

On a balance having my own family is more important to me than a career. So I would choose the teen mum scenario, albeit reluctantly. Plus you can work on a career if you really want to, you can’t work on your fertility after it’s vanished.

Which is why I think balance - late 20s, early 30s - is best if the circumstances are right.

My anecdote was 16/17 because that's what i was, but the same applies to all young parents (so up to about 25). Basically, there's help available in Britain in 2021. To can be financially screwed as a more established adult vs in your 20s.

I just don't get why some people are so adamant we're all suffering and sad with our lives and in poverty. Not the case.

Even my very strongly religious, non white parents let me stay at home. This isn't the 1960s where unwed mothers are shipped off.

ohdear10 · 13/09/2021 15:33

@ManifestDestinee

Let's say you have your first child at 16/17. You get to live at home rent free. Your parents help you financially. You get free education in this country, and free/heavily subsidised childcare. When you're 18, you are entitled to UC, and when you start work/further study, you get more subsidised childcare. You're child gets a free school place and you had living grandparents. Extra loans and grants for having a child in study. Child benefit.

Lets say you have your first child at 16...you don't get to live at home rent free because your mother says no. Your parents don't help you financially because they can't afford to, they can't babysit as they work or are disabled so you can't go to school and you leave with a couple of GCSE's, if you're lucky. You get a crappy zero hour job until you have another kid, you never do any further study, your life sucks and then your kid had a kid at 16 and you're stuck raising that kid to as you want better for yours than you had.

More likely than your pie in the sky brilliant idea for children to have children.

Way to be an ass. I just described my own living situation and even put a disclaimer for people who lack comprehension that I'm not advocating teen pregnancy. Young parents are perfectly able to have kids, even teenagers, and be unscathed.

My point is, finances are not an issue. You're coming across as resentful now. Why put down young parents? Bit of a chip on your shoulder there @ManifestDestinee

Porcupineintherough · 13/09/2021 15:31

@dummyd then why are the children of teenage mothers less likely to have good educational outcomes, more likely to have poor health and lower life expectancy and be more likely to become teenage parents themselves?

ManifestDestinee · 13/09/2021 14:54

@ManifestDestinee that was quite a nasty post but the ‘worst case scenario’ for somebody 40+ would be a lot shorter - egg quality has diminished, no baby, the end

It wasn't nasty at all, it was needed for balance to the bizarre "have your children while you're still a child, it'll be great" post. Hmm

littlebird13 · 13/09/2021 14:48

There's pros and cons to having kids younger and older.
I was 21 when I had dd1. Just Had dd2 at 25.
At the time with my first I did feel young, although very mature and financially stable etc. I wouldn't wanted to have done it any younger and it was unplanned. Dd2 was planned.

I feel I have a lot of energy to give my children. My oldest will be 18 in our 40th year. We always joke that those will be our prime years. Planning to buy a little sports car etc and go travelling when they've both gone to uni or moved out. I also think it will work well as we should be better off financially too.
However, we love our little family dynamic and by no means wishing their childhood away. I hope that being close in age our children will be really close to us.
I'm very glad I had them when I did and wouldn't change it for anything now.

Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 14:40

16/17 is mad to me - education not finished, only just out of childhood yourself, not even a taste of freedom. Im glad it worked for you though!

@ManifestDestinee that was quite a nasty post but the ‘worst case scenario’ for somebody 40+ would be a lot shorter - egg quality has diminished, no baby, the end.

On a balance having my own family is more important to me than a career. So I would choose the teen mum scenario, albeit reluctantly. Plus you can work on a career if you really want to, you can’t work on your fertility after it’s vanished.

Which is why I think balance - late 20s, early 30s - is best if the circumstances are right.

MariaDingbat · 13/09/2021 14:39

This is very strange to read as I lost my mum at 17, my dad at 31 and had my first child at 40. I've never seen anyone who has lost parents at the same age I did, no matter had their child at the same age. It's tough losing your parents so young and I'm sorry you had to go through it.

I sometimes wish I had kids years ago because there a chance my daughter won't get a sibling because of my age, but I also remind myself that it took longer to get to a point where I was settled enough in my life and career to buy a home and start a family because I was doing a lot on my own with no family. It feels like starting a few steps behind everyone because you're missing the support and guidance others have. So it's been hard work, but I'm really glad I managed to get here. My daughter is fantastic and I hope all be lucky enough to have another, but if we don't, she's enough.

ManifestDestinee · 13/09/2021 14:30

Let's say you have your first child at 16/17. You get to live at home rent free. Your parents help you financially. You get free education in this country, and free/heavily subsidised childcare. When you're 18, you are entitled to UC, and when you start work/further study, you get more subsidised childcare. You're child gets a free school place and you had living grandparents. Extra loans and grants for having a child in study. Child benefit.

Lets say you have your first child at 16...you don't get to live at home rent free because your mother says no. Your parents don't help you financially because they can't afford to, they can't babysit as they work or are disabled so you can't go to school and you leave with a couple of GCSE's, if you're lucky. You get a crappy zero hour job until you have another kid, you never do any further study, your life sucks and then your kid had a kid at 16 and you're stuck raising that kid to as you want better for yours than you had.

More likely than your pie in the sky brilliant idea for children to have children.

KatharinaRosalie · 13/09/2021 14:30

Its probably better to live with parents with a baby

The plan that you'll just live with your parents and they can help out with the baby will be challenging, if the parents were looking forward to their freedom in their early 40s, like many people on this thread have said.

CaMePlaitPas · 13/09/2021 14:26

I had mine at 26 and 27. I wish I had had them younger.

YouMeandtheSpew · 13/09/2021 14:24

I often think I wish I’d had children younger and had more.

Then I realise I wouldn’t have been able to afford to have more children if I’d started younger. And I wouldn’t have had anything like the flexibility in my job that I have now. And I also wouldn’t have the child that I have.

So for me I think it all comes to the same thing. I would either have been limited by money or age. As it happens I’m limited by age, less so by money.

dummyd · 13/09/2021 13:38

@Porcupineintherough

If "biologically" was what matters most then kids from very young mothers wouldnt disproportionately have poorer outcomes. Its quite handy to be able to support your children emotionally and financially and quite a lot of people arent in a position to do that at 24. And children first then career is particularly disastrous if your dp decides he's not cut out for fatherhood in the first few years and buggers off and you are utterly financially dependent on him.
Let's say you have your first child at 16/17. You get to live at home rent free. Your parents help you financially. You get free education in this country, and free/heavily subsidised childcare. When you're 18, you are entitled to UC, and when you start work/further study, you get more subsidised childcare. You're child gets a free school place and you had living grandparents. Extra loans and grants for having a child in study. Child benefit.

Truly, it's not the end of the world. In no way do I advocate teen pregnancy but my point is there's no reason it's not possible. If you have the motivation, even if you're WC or poorer, you can totally do it.

What I outlined was basically me, as a lone parent as a teen. Younger parents in their 20s get much the same support. No man needed, you won't be financially fucked at all. Its probably better to live with parents with a baby I study, than to be an unemployed SAHM (no shade), if we're talking about being reliant on the father.

Jerseygirl12 · 13/09/2021 13:34

middleager
Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s? dunno but two of my friend’s DC are both around 27, have 2 DC are married, one has a three bedroom house, one a four bedroom one and seem very happy. Neither of them went to university but they both have jobs they enjoy.

Porcupineintherough · 13/09/2021 13:03

If "biologically" was what matters most then kids from very young mothers wouldnt disproportionately have poorer outcomes. Its quite handy to be able to support your children emotionally and financially and quite a lot of people arent in a position to do that at 24. And children first then career is particularly disastrous if your dp decides he's not cut out for fatherhood in the first few years and buggers off and you are utterly financially dependent on him.

middleager · 13/09/2021 12:51

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

My grandmothers were both very poor with large families. They had children in their 20s, 30s and 40s.

Erictheavocado · 13/09/2021 12:41

When I had my first in my late 20's, I was considered old to be a ftm. Now, I'd be average or even slightly young. I do wish we'd had our dcs when I was younger - having dc1 when I did had repercussions we could never have imagined (or planned for) which continue even now, over 30 years later. OTOH, if we had had our dcs sooner, we wouldn't have had the same dcs, or dgc, so, on balance I'm glad we had them when we did.

G5000 · 13/09/2021 09:45

Not relevant if you always wanted to be a SAHM anyway, but if not, there's also the childcare aspect. If I have had children in my early 20s, I would not have been able to afford childcare. 2-3 DC with even a couple of years between them, and that would have meant a gap of several years on my CV. Again not impossible - but quite challenging to get back on the career ladder with no or very little work experience but looking for flexibility to fit around family obligations.

Of course you can say that grandparents are young enough to help - but a granparent in their 40s is probably still working. Plus, this would not work with the plan to be done with childcare and have your freedom back.

Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 09:19

[quote ithinkilikeit]@Realyorkshiretea well I think 30 is ‘young’. It’s pointless to discuss with you because you will disagree with everything I say so I think it’s best if we leave it here.[/quote]
I mean biologically Confused in childbearing, but not in life. That’s just a fact?

ithinkilikeit · 13/09/2021 08:57

@Realyorkshiretea well I think 30 is ‘young’. It’s pointless to discuss with you because you will disagree with everything I say so I think it’s best if we leave it here.

herculesoffline · 13/09/2021 08:54

@TomatoSquash

If you have your kids at 20 then you have hope of having a life after they’ve grown up. You have a future to look forward to. You won’t even be 40 when they leave home. However if you have your kids at 40 you have a constant sinking sensation that this is it for you, you’ll be an old person of 60 when they leave home and you have no future.
To be fair I know plenty of 25-30 year olds who live at home while "saving for a mortgage" and will do for the foreseeable
Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 08:51

@ithinkilikeit

30 is hardly ‘young’. I would like it if society stopped drumming it into women that it is, yes. At the moment the stigma isn’t having children around 40, it’s having children in your 20s, as previous posters have highlighted. Ergo there needs to be a cultural shift to help women that want to do so have children younger than what is currently the norm in certain circles.

user1471523870 · 13/09/2021 08:51

Mmmmhhhh a tricky one.
I had mine VERY late in life even if I started to try in my early 30s.
While I wish I had him ten years earlier, I still enjoy very much the fact I had a chance to live a very full life before having him. I built my career, travelled a lot, and generally speaking experienced a lot in life. Now, my child is just completing that, and I feel zero urge for time to speed up so he leaves home and I can 'have a life again' as many young mums desire.
To add another element to the picture, I don't know anyone who had a baby before turning 30, with most of my friends becoming parents the first time around 34-35 and quite a few around 40.

ithinkilikeit · 13/09/2021 08:45

@g5000 and I totally agree with you here. Maybe the divide is between public and private sector professions but my profession was one where people are literally desperate to enter it. If you can’t do the job they quite literally have 1,000 others that are willing. While now due to employment law they cannot explicitly fire you for preganancy everything is results driven so if you need time off for childcare and cant stay long nights then this will inevitably reduce your results and then they will fire you for that.

I don’t think this is a good thing but practically not much can be done about it and this worked for me because I did not want children in my 20’s anyway but people who did want children young inevitable left or where never in the industry in the first place as people realise you are expected to put the time in as a junior.

ithinkilikeit · 13/09/2021 08:40

@Rollmopsrule is exactly how I feel about the situation.

@Realyorkshiretea I think you’ve got It into your head that i think having children young is wrong. The last thing on my mind at all times is what age people choose to have kids. I simply could not care less. What I think is you want a cultural shift to having kids younger whereas I want a cultural shift to where having children young or old is not stigmatised because people realise people are doing what is right for them.

I will not be explaining any further either because I think you are purposely trying to miss the point.

Swipe left for the next trending thread