Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids earlier?

360 replies

40220s · 11/09/2021 18:41

My mum was 35 when she had me. She died when I was 16, and I had my first baby at 40. My dad died when I was 30.

One of my friends at school got pregnant at university and I remember my dad making some comment about being glad it wasn’t me. But I look at her now and it got me thinking. If I’d had my first baby at 20 and my mum had me at 20 … maybe there’s something in doing it that way, as you’re more likely to have extensive support from family.

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 11/09/2021 20:27

I think theres advantages and disadvantages to both. It depends on so many things. Like grandparents might be younger but they might also have to work. And it depends when your friends have kids and what the typical age to have kids is in your area so you dont feel the odd one out.

Either way we live.long enough now to get a decent chunk of child free time, whether that's before kids if you have them later or after kids if you have them earlier.

I had mine mid 30s and I sometimes wish I'd had them earlier. Seeing the amazing relationship with grandparents I think it would be nice if they could have been in their lives longer etc. And I'm not looking forward to menopause with teenagers. But I dont dwell too much on the what ifs. In a parallel universe I might have had kids 10 years earlier and resented all those exotic holidays I missed out on, and the kids might not have been as close to my parents or my parents might have been ill or something. At least being older we are more financially secure and have got all the partying out of our system. Even if I do feel slightly embarrassed when my child tells me I'm the oldest mum in the class

Bobsyer · 11/09/2021 20:15

I had my first at 26. My sister has just had her first at 36.

I wish I'd waited longer, but I also wish I'd chose a man who didn't already have a child, as I'm sure part of the reason I had my own fairly early was that we had that constraint already so why not have my own now?

(Please don't take this as I'm not happy with my lot. I absolutely am, but looking back critically having a stepson radically changed my life in ways I could not have foreseen).

MimiDaisy11 · 11/09/2021 20:07

It’s hard to have it all and to have it perfectly timed.

Personally I had anxiety issues in my 20s so I think I would have been really anxious all the time.

It’s pretty common to think the grass is greener. There’ll be people regretting having kids early or late.

cabingirl · 11/09/2021 20:04

I don't think I realised how much I would miss having my Mum around as my DD grew up. And now how I realise how little time I might have with future DGG.

But hindsight is no use really.

WeeBenny · 11/09/2021 20:03

I had my only child at 23 and it was a major struggle we never had any support and childcare was so expensive. It nearly broke us. I've just split from his dad and he's nearly 13 now. By the time I'm 40 he'll be an adult. I see my friends just starting to have babies and I'm glad I done it this way round but everyone's circumatances are different

Skyeheather · 11/09/2021 20:01

I wish I'd had my kids earlier because I'd love to have another two but I'm too old now. It would have also been nice to have had a bigger age gap between the two I've got but my biological clock didn't allow it!

MuslinsRLife · 11/09/2021 20:00

Pros & cons of everything. My relative who suffered with secondary infertility was so sad she hadn’t started earlier (did manage to conceive DC2 eventually).
I think I may have started a little too early (21) but I’m also happy with my decision, I now have 3 beautiful children & a good career & nice house - as mentioned upthread. I may be different as I’ve been working since 17 & worked my way up the company so wasn’t at uni with no money.

I wouldn’t have wanted to have been an older mum but I appreciate its not that easy or simple. A lot of people wouldn’t want to be younger parents too which is fine.

I’m so sorry for your losses Flowers

LimeRedBanana · 11/09/2021 19:59

I’d have inevitably ended up doing it all alone.

OneMoreForExtra · 11/09/2021 19:59

Fuck, yes. Had both mine in my 40s. Now in my 50s with primary aged children. Like others I spent a decade trying to get pregnant so no real option there, plus I'm in absolute awe of people who managed to form and hold a committed relationship in their 20/30s which was entirely beyond me

Older parenthood is a mixed bag: Yes my career is stronger and I have a bigger house than most in my mum group (but not all).

Bit I didn't spend my childless 30s whooping it up, I spent I miserably dating lovers or being lonely while my could up friends were busy with family stuff at the WE. Once I met DH we had some great holidays though.

Parent wise, Im the oldest in the group but there are close seconds. I'm not friends with idiots so mainly this is fine but it did catch my breath when it turned out one of their mums was my age. But my older friends are celebrating the finances and space that departing adult kids bring, and I wi be that 60 something wondering wondering whether there's time to start again with a new partner.

So very very mixed bag... but on balance if i could have had them in my 30s, I would have.

PatchworkElmer · 11/09/2021 19:58

I think there are merits to both. DH has a colleague in his very early 40s who has adult children, AND a very good job. So he and his wife are now enjoying lovely holidays and disposable income etc, at a time when most people are still very much in the ‘dependent children’ stage.

For us it wouldn’t have worked out that way (at least I don’t think so). Having children a bit later gave me especially a chance to build my career- if I’d had a baby at 20 I suspect I would’ve found it harder to work my way up (because childcare costs would’ve been a huge struggle and my parents were still working so I would’ve had no help).

I was 29 when I had DC and whilst physically I wish I’d been younger (more energy), it was probably the right time for us in terms of career, resources, etc. We’re relatively comfortable now and able to afford the ‘nice to have’ stuff like extracurricular activities and the odd holiday at Center Parcs. I’ll be 50 when DC is hopefully independent-ish. Fingers crossed this is a good balance!!

Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 19:57

Yeah but you'll be free in your 40s and can do all the stuff you missed out on then. That's what I plan on doing!

Same! All being well my daughter will be independent when I’m in my mid 40s. The dream is to work in NYC for a while and then travel in S America. Maybe my daughter will join me for a while Smile its incredibly exciting.

Op, I think your strength of feeling comes from the fact you lost your mum young Flowers but YANBU, either - generally speaking I think having children late 20s-early 30s is optimum, if circumstances are good. And I think you make a good point about late motherhood being a middle class trend - as a first time mum in my late 20s, my friends almost saw me as a teen mum Confused

In other countries, such as Iceland, it is the cultural norm and healthy to have kids early - early to mid 20s. And their society is leaps and bounds ahead of ours in many respects - their kids certainly don’t turn to crime or run around like feral animals.

I do wonder if society is doing women a bit of a disservice by making older motherhood seem like the best option, and selling a myth that you can only travel/have fun/climb the career ladder in your 20s and 30s.

LimeRedBanana · 11/09/2021 19:57

YANBU and I’m sorry for your losses.

My parents had me relatively late by 70s standards, and I also lost them relatively young, although not as awfully young as you.

My Mum died well before my DC were born and it’s my life regret that she didn’t meet my DC and vice versa. My Dad only had 6 years with my DC.

But there’s no-one I’d rather have had DC with that DH, and I met him when I met him.

Having DC sooner/earlier would have necessitated having them with someone unsuitable, which would have been fraught, and I’d have inevitably ended up doing it all.

That is in no way preferable.

TakeMe2Insanity · 11/09/2021 19:56

@SethWho

I wish I had had my 1 younger so I had had time for more.
This!
YerAWizardHarry · 11/09/2021 19:56

I had my son at 19, my mum had me at 21 and her mum had her at 21. My sons great grandparents are younger than most of his peers grandparents. We are all very close and it’s great to have such a fab support network. Not to say it wasn’t hard having a child so young though!

H1Drangea · 11/09/2021 19:55

Well , my mum was lucky enough to meet my Dad when she was 14 and they married when she was 19 , and then had 3 children before the age of 24
I didn’t meet DH til I was 33 , but I am lucky in that I had loads of lovely holidays , got on the property ladder and conceived easily twice when we married
Both Dc off our hands now and independent and we are ( still bloody working ) happy together
Sadly Mum died at age 61 and my children don’t remember her ( I do , every day )

BasicDad · 11/09/2021 19:54

@ParkheadParadise

I had my dd1 at 15 She died at 23, I was 38 and 7 months pregnant with dd2 at the time( a surprise arrival) No one knows how their life will turn out.
True, and I hope you're OK Flowers
YukoandHiro · 11/09/2021 19:53

Yes I've thought about this a lot. In a lot of ways it would have been easier and better to do it earlier. I had my second at 39. My husband is older too.

But the career I'm in would probably have been completely over if I'd done it earlier. As it is I've built up the seniority to have some flexibility in my schedule

MattyGroves · 11/09/2021 19:51

I am happier being financially secure and able to pay for childcare and a cleaner than I would be with family support. This is partly having a difficult relationship with my mother but also partly personality and choice. I really don't like the sound of the very entwined family relationships I read about on Mumsnet. I like that my DH and I make the decisions and are a family unit rather than having family constantly popping round.

G5000 · 11/09/2021 19:51

I had a lot of fun in my 20s when I was single and childfree. Wouldn't change it for anything. Working crazy hours, living in different countries, travelling all over the place with friends, partying til morning. Wouldn't change it, so many great memories.
I don't think I could do all of that in my 40s. DH would mind if I would hang out with random beautiful Italian men and I wouldn't want to go dance til morning even if you paid me. Also packing up and moving abroad is significantly easier if it's just you and your studio flat to pack up.

And what if your kids feel the same way, that they want to have their DC in their 20s? Would you really go and travel the world instead of staying to be close to your grandchildren?

ManifestDestinee · 11/09/2021 19:50

I quite like mine

Well if you'd had kids earlier you'd have different kids. IF you like the ones you have why would you wish you had different ones?

Ginqueen1 · 11/09/2021 19:49

I had my first child at 20 and my second at 27. I think having them younger has some advantages like more energy your parents hopefully get to be grandparents for longer but the disadvantages not being more financially stable your career is put on hold etc. I don’t regret it now but at the time felt I missed out on a lot. I look at my friends in their late 30s and early 40s with babies and don’t think I could do it but they probably felt the same about me back then.

Tired1234567 · 11/09/2021 19:49

Me too. I honestly don't understand this life experience you supposedly gain in the 10 years between 25 and 35. I did all my going out, travelling etc when I was 18. I'm not sure how different I am at 35 compared to 10 years ago... apart from a lot more tired.

Sundaynightnamechange · 11/09/2021 19:48

@TomatoSquash

Plenty of 60 year olds would be enormously insulted by that Well put it this way: You have to sacrifice yourself for 20 years to raise kids. By the time they leave home and I’m free I’ll be 60 and it’ll be too late to leave DH and find someone to fall in love with. But if I’d had them at 20 I could leave DH at 40 and still be young enough to find someone else.
You can leave your H at anytime you know (or he could leave you) definitely not better for the kids to live in an unhappy atmosphere.
Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 19:47

@TomatoSquash

If you have your kids at 20 then you have hope of having a life after they’ve grown up. You have a future to look forward to. You won’t even be 40 when they leave home. However if you have your kids at 40 you have a constant sinking sensation that this is it for you, you’ll be an old person of 60 when they leave home and you have no future.
No future?? I generally err on the side of younger is better (if circumstances allow), but to say older parents have no future to look forward to seems very OTT Confused
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 11/09/2021 19:47

I don't envy my friends who have young kids/babies now in our early 40s. One is pregnant with her second at 42 which I think is mad (but I'm very happy for her, I just would never)
On the other hand mine is 13 and I'll be 46 when he's an adult. That's amazing.