Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids earlier?

360 replies

40220s · 11/09/2021 18:41

My mum was 35 when she had me. She died when I was 16, and I had my first baby at 40. My dad died when I was 30.

One of my friends at school got pregnant at university and I remember my dad making some comment about being glad it wasn’t me. But I look at her now and it got me thinking. If I’d had my first baby at 20 and my mum had me at 20 … maybe there’s something in doing it that way, as you’re more likely to have extensive support from family.

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

OP posts:
KatharinaRosalie · 11/09/2021 21:08

In other countries, such as Iceland, it is the cultural norm and healthy to have kids early - early to mid 20s

Average age for having your first child in Iceland is 28.

Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 21:08

@Ozanj that’s if you compare older mums with the other end of the spectrum which is teen mums in very deprived areas. Nobody is advocating for that. You’re not taking into consideration the mums in their late 20s and early 30s, which is probably optimum when balancing age with other factors.

peboh · 11/09/2021 21:07

I can only comment on my own situation, but I had dd at 25 and that was a good age for me personally. I got to experience and travel in my early adulthood, and now I get to have the fun that comes with my child, and then I'll get a bit more "freedom" in my 40's. However it's so different for everybody. Some people thrive having children when they're younger, some thrive having them in their mid-late 30's.

Ozanj · 11/09/2021 21:07

@Ihaveaskedyouthrice

As the posts here have shown having kids young is no guarantee of anything. My mum had me at 41, I'm now 42 and she's 83. I had my children at 32, 35 and 37. My mum is in excellent health and is an amazing Nana to my kids. At times I do wish I'd had my kids earlier. I met DH when I was 23 so could have but then I think back to our 20s and we had an absolute ball so I could never regret that.
Yes. The only active grandparent in my family is one who was 80 when his first grandchild was born - he’s 90 now and still able to get on the floor with them to play. My 60+ year old parents who had all their kids before 33 were permanently disabled by their 40s. Class issue. He was a lot wealthier than the rest.
user908768543 · 11/09/2021 21:07

I had my children young, early 20s. At the time it was very scary, lots we hadn't sorted, lots of unknowns, a lot of winging it. But now in my 30s with hindsight I can appreciate the pros, I was young and naive which meant I didn't over think things, my body was unscathed, very much took it all in my stride and took on so many responsibilities my colleagues in their 30s were shocked at what I was managing, I didn't know any different. Life has just gotten easier by having so much pressure on me so young. If I'd become a parent now I think I would have been much more anxious and over the top, being maturer, knowing more, over thinking things more, but I'd have been a heck of a lot more financially stable which would have brought a lot of benefits too! I'd have enjoyed those early years more as I wouldn't have been juggling babies and career development.

I guess what I'm trying to say is I don't believe there's a perfect age, there is always a compromise, there are pros and cons whatever age, I have no regrets, and you shouldn't either OP- it's done now!

Staffy1 · 11/09/2021 21:05

Look at it this way, you might not exist if your mum had had kids younger and your kids wouldn’t be the same kids you have now if you had started younger, so there’s that.

StarryNightSparkles · 11/09/2021 21:04

Kim, during lockdown 2 I learned that I am going to be a grandmother at 40! That's a lot to take in and process lol.

The twists and turns of life take us all on individual paths. Have comfort that we all made choices for our lives at times that suited us. There's no right or wrong way in life.

I would say if you see a mum of any age smile, maybe offer a hand because being a mum is the hardest job in the world.

Youdoyoutoday · 11/09/2021 21:03

A midwife once told me that our bodies are better off having babies young, around 16, as we recover better. Sitting here with my big fat belly at 41 (my youngest is 2), I think she may have had a point Grin

But its swings and roundabouts, isn't it? Same thing doesn't suit all

Fairunibutterfly · 11/09/2021 21:03

Sorry, had to lol at TomatoSquash comment..sounds like you’re just waiting to leave dhGrin

To the op I think it goes both ways. Not unreasonable to feel how you do given your situation.

I had mine in my early 30’s and think if I’d started a little earlier I may have had a third plus I’ll be younger when I’m done raising them so could then maybe enjoy more when they’ve left home.

On the other hand I spent my 20’s finishing uni, travelling, getting to know dh and establishing my career…that means I’m quite happy to immerse myself in family life, done with clubbing etc and financially stable. If they leave home around 20 then I’ll be around mid-50’s which right now doesn’t seem too old so hopefully can still enjoy my hobbies then!

Ozanj · 11/09/2021 21:02

* I completely agree. I had mine at 21. By the time I was 40, active parenting was done and dusted. I had all that travel, childfree holidays and stuff in my 40s with the added bonus of much more money to enjoy it than I’d have had in my 20s. I have zero regrets.*

The class issue also applies. Poorer / less educated people are more likely to have kids young but also more likely to start having health issues / die young. The people who tend to live past 85 are the middle class / wealthy lot (in some wealthy areas the average life expectancy for wealthier people is 85-89!!) so this idea that these mothers will die when their kids are young is incorrect.

Ihaveaskedyouthrice · 11/09/2021 21:02

As the posts here have shown having kids young is no guarantee of anything. My mum had me at 41, I'm now 42 and she's 83. I had my children at 32, 35 and 37. My mum is in excellent health and is an amazing Nana to my kids.
At times I do wish I'd had my kids earlier. I met DH when I was 23 so could have but then I think back to our 20s and we had an absolute ball so I could never regret that.

RareritySparkles · 11/09/2021 21:02

I had my first at 29. I absolutely love the fact that I have a 18 year old who adores me at almost 50 when you become a bit invisible. Pros and cons like all things in life. I do wish I had mine all younger and closer together but it can never be changed. This is our one shot no retake life. It has its pros too.

I am sorry you lost your parents young

LuckyAmy1986 · 11/09/2021 21:00

@ParkheadParadise so sorry about your Daughter Flowers

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/09/2021 20:59

Except that I want to have the exact dc that I have (obviously!) I wish I’d waited til I was older. I was 29 (almost 30) when I had Dd and 35 when I had Ds, but certainly the first time, I wasn’t really ready, and exh certainly wasn’t.

Plus we didn’t really have any money!

Wole · 11/09/2021 20:57

@MimiDaisy11

It’s hard to have it all and to have it perfectly timed.

Personally I had anxiety issues in my 20s so I think I would have been really anxious all the time.

It’s pretty common to think the grass is greener. There’ll be people regretting having kids early or late.

I think this is so true. There is never a perfect time to have a baby and there will always be some people who regret it either way.
sofakingcool · 11/09/2021 20:55

I had my first at just turned 23, he's about to turn 18. Second at 28.

It was hard when DS1 was born, I was very quickly a single mum (even though we had a very established relationship, lived together etc) and it was really tough. On a positive I'm only 40 and DS is looking at Uni's etc. I'll likely have an empty house by the time I'm 50.

It's nice to think I've still got lots of time to live, but given my time again I would have waited a bit, feel I missed out on some of the young 20's stuff

MushMonster · 11/09/2021 20:53

I do think that the best time for a woman to have her children is on her twenties. Your body is ready and strong enough, and you have youth to cope with it and the child rearing part of it.
With support, you can still have a career.
I think this life style where we do have our children later and later in life is, indeed, damaging to our health, by quite a lot.

Wole · 11/09/2021 20:51

@TomatoSquash

Plenty of 60 year olds would be enormously insulted by that Well put it this way: You have to sacrifice yourself for 20 years to raise kids. By the time they leave home and I’m free I’ll be 60 and it’ll be too late to leave DH and find someone to fall in love with. But if I’d had them at 20 I could leave DH at 40 and still be young enough to find someone else.
If you're thinking like that you should probably leave DH now!
repog · 11/09/2021 20:51

I thought in the past women had dc earlier but they had more dc so plenty were still having them in their 40s?

If I had adult dc when I was in my 40s I think I would struggle with being "free again" but not have any friends in the same boat. Instead we can all moan about our teenagers together 😆

honeyfox · 11/09/2021 20:48

It's very true what a poster upthread said about the way you don't know how your life will work out. I lost my mum early 2010 to breast cancer (56) and we buried her mother last year at 90. My mum was an only child so I spent a lot of the last ten years supporting my widowed grandmother (visiting very often) while working full time at the other end of the country. As she was very religious I delayed getting pregnant till we were married in 2017 when I was 39 (we met at 33), and now I am 43, one miscarriage later and still trying. I wish we had just gone for it when we decided we wanted kids about 7 years ago. I don't regret putting her first as she would have been very upset about a baby outside marriage but I can see things differently in hindsight.

Blossomtoes · 11/09/2021 20:47

@TomatoSquash

If you have your kids at 20 then you have hope of having a life after they’ve grown up. You have a future to look forward to. You won’t even be 40 when they leave home. However if you have your kids at 40 you have a constant sinking sensation that this is it for you, you’ll be an old person of 60 when they leave home and you have no future.
I completely agree. I had mine at 21. By the time I was 40, active parenting was done and dusted. I had all that travel, childfree holidays and stuff in my 40s with the added bonus of much more money to enjoy it than I’d have had in my 20s. I have zero regrets.
MimiDaisy11 · 11/09/2021 20:43

@m0therofdragons

My cousins are 18 and 15 years younger than me. We share the same grandparents and my childhood memories are of my db and I visiting London museums, theatres, theme parks with them, and having parties at grandparents home. My cousins’ memories are very different - much older grandparents. I’m grateful I saw them younger (although thought they were ancient at the time). Now I’m 39 and granny is 95 and knows her great grandchildren from db and I but I doubt she’ll get to know dc from my 3 cousins who are in their very early 20s and at uni.
I think that’s a good point. I have a baby and my father-in-law is wheelchair bound now and he talks about how he used to run around and play with his other grandkids who are now late teens. I think he feels sad he won’t get to experience that with my son.
KimchiJjigae · 11/09/2021 20:40

starynightsparkles this was me too! I had my first at 18 and then another at 20 during my degree. I was in an abusive relationship which I left, ended up in a refuge for half a year, eventually rehoused, all while living away from family - and I completely took it in my stride, it didn't hold me back or change my ambitions and I still managed 2:1 STEM degree.

I'm early thirties now, with the older two and a new toddler, married, home owner and financially secure... and it's so hard juggling it all. I'm exhausted and look back in awe at 21 year old me and miss the simplicity of those days. I'm not sure the older me would have be so chilled and unfazed by my experiences.

That said - I'm glad I did and I wouldn't change it for me but I wouldn't recommend having children before 25, because I've had to work extra hard to catch up with my peers and make sacrifices.

The oldest children started the first few years of their lives, with me not having much and not many experiences as a result, were in nursery all week so I could study. Compared to my youngest who will never know going without and has the luxury of my husband and I being in a position to working flexibly so childcare is minimised. Thankfully, graduating and starting work when the eldest were still very young means they didn't miss out for long.

That said, I'm really looking forward to not even being 40 when my eldest are both adults and taking back some of the missed years. I have a lot to look forward to. Smile

TheSnootiestFox · 11/09/2021 20:34

@AllTheBs

I agree with *@Brian9600* I think your specific circumstances have a lot to do with your thinking. You lost both parents very young which must be very difficult, I couldn't imagine.

I had my first child last year at 35 and am now pregnant again with my second who will be born when I'm 37.

I didn't meet my now DH until I was almost 31, married at 33. Until I met him, I was on the fence as to whether I wanted children or not. Up until that point I had led a full and happy life (uni, travelling, etc.) and wasn't in a rush to change that. However, I met my husband and my life took a new direction.

I don't regret not having kids earlier in life as it would have meant missing out on the experiences I've had and those experiences have helped shape me into the person I am today.

I understand the 'what if' feeling regarding having more time with your parents/children but I believe (as cliche as it sounds) everything happens for a reason and what's for you won't go past you x

I think it depends on what you actually want out of life - this was my life almost word for word except I've always wanted kids, but couldn't meet anyone else who did. I would gladly have sacrificed uni and working overseas to get married young and have lots of babies 🤷‍♀️
m0therofdragons · 11/09/2021 20:29

My cousins are 18 and 15 years younger than me. We share the same grandparents and my childhood memories are of my db and I visiting London museums, theatres, theme parks with them, and having parties at grandparents home. My cousins’ memories are very different - much older grandparents. I’m grateful I saw them younger (although thought they were ancient at the time). Now I’m 39 and granny is 95 and knows her great grandchildren from db and I but I doubt she’ll get to know dc from my 3 cousins who are in their very early 20s and at uni.