Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids earlier?

360 replies

40220s · 11/09/2021 18:41

My mum was 35 when she had me. She died when I was 16, and I had my first baby at 40. My dad died when I was 30.

One of my friends at school got pregnant at university and I remember my dad making some comment about being glad it wasn’t me. But I look at her now and it got me thinking. If I’d had my first baby at 20 and my mum had me at 20 … maybe there’s something in doing it that way, as you’re more likely to have extensive support from family.

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

OP posts:
Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 22:54

[quote ithinkilikeit]@Realyorkshiretea I would have to disagree. Childcare burden always falls on women and I don’t think a return to the 50’s were women had children younger. Even on Mumsnet it’s well reported how women’s lives shrink with children. They are limited in career and in ability to be spontaneous because they need to divide a stable home for a child. I am happy with the trend of women having children later. Women deserve a fun and children 20’s and 30’s if they want it. I don’t think it’s a con at all. At least not for me.[/quote]
But if having children is seen as such a drag, why do it at all, even later?

I don’t see it as returning to the 50s, I see it as subtley encouraging women to do what is riskier for their health to enable men to delay commitment, and prop up the economy.

SelkieQualia · 11/09/2021 22:53

@TomatoSquash

Plenty of 60 year olds would be enormously insulted by that Well put it this way: You have to sacrifice yourself for 20 years to raise kids. By the time they leave home and I’m free I’ll be 60 and it’ll be too late to leave DH and find someone to fall in love with. But if I’d had them at 20 I could leave DH at 40 and still be young enough to find someone else.
Nonsense. My mum is 66 and has just met and moved in with the love of her life.
ParkheadParadise · 11/09/2021 22:50

@Realyorkshiretea
Thank you for your kind words. I'm ok, Dd2 keeps me busy.

ithinkilikeit · 11/09/2021 22:49

@Realyorkshiretea I would have to disagree. Childcare burden always falls on women and I don’t think a return to the 50’s were women had children younger. Even on Mumsnet it’s well reported how women’s lives shrink with children. They are limited in career and in ability to be spontaneous because they need to divide a stable home for a child. I am happy with the trend of women having children later. Women deserve a fun and children 20’s and 30’s if they want it. I don’t think it’s a con at all. At least not for me.

DJSteves · 11/09/2021 22:48

Had mine very young now 44 with a 24year old. Glad I did as I became infertile in my 20's so never had the chance to have any more. Have no regrets money was tight for a few years but I had boundless energy and have a great life now doting on nieces and nephews and a good career.

ithinkilikeit · 11/09/2021 22:46

I’m always confused about threads like these. The poster seems to focus on one specific benefit of having kids young and dies not actually cross examine there own life to see if that would be a good decision.

At 20, I had not finished uni, had no money and was a mess. I would feel deeply sorry to any child born to 20 year old me. I would never had had the career I have if I had kids then not the experiences. Not that that would be all and as I would have had different experiences but I am sure people on here don’t need to be educated about the obvious difference in employment, wealth etc between those who have children young versus older. Of course there are outliers but in general building your career when young does equal better financial outcomes. For some people that is not important and fair enough but I do actually think rationally that I would definitely not have been happy to have kids so young. I also have read many comments on here about those who had kids younger and regretted it and wished they’d built a career, travelled etc. The grass is always greener.

repog · 11/09/2021 22:32

I think the ‘trend’ of older motherhood isn’t good for society in terms of women’s rights and quality of life.

I think the trend now is no kids tbh

Strangevipers · 11/09/2021 22:30

@user908768543

You ok hon ?

SO hilarious and original!

Grin
ShopoholicIn · 11/09/2021 22:30

I had my first one at 32 and second one at 38 and I really really wish I had them earlier but no way at 20.. I was busy with college then planning my career and wasn't planning or ready for a family or kids at that age... But maybe 25-27 would have been better..

user908768543 · 11/09/2021 22:25

You ok hon ?

SO hilarious and original!

Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 22:25

@ParkheadParadise I have seen a few of your posts while lurking. I’m so sorry you have been through such heartbreak with your DD1. I often think of you, and hope you’re doing okay - just wanted to send my best wishes. Flowers

Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 22:23

@KatharinaRosalie

Yes but they start having children in their 20s whereas in the U.K. it’s 28+.

That's the average age for having your first child in England is 28.9, not the age when people start having kids. Same number is 28.6 years in Iceland. Not much of a difference.
Sure there are many countries where women indeed have children much earlier, but they don't tend to be beacons of equality and progress.

My point is that, proportionately, you are more likely to have your first baby in Iceland at 23 than 34. In the U.K. it’s the other way round.
pollypokcet · 11/09/2021 22:22

That's to @ParkheadParadise
Must've been a real shock. We never expect to outlive our kids, especially at that age.

KatharinaRosalie · 11/09/2021 22:22

Yes but they start having children in their 20s whereas in the U.K. it’s 28+.

That's the average age for having your first child in England is 28.9, not the age when people start having kids. Same number is 28.6 years in Iceland. Not much of a difference.
Sure there are many countries where women indeed have children much earlier, but they don't tend to be beacons of equality and progress.

tryrantosaurus · 11/09/2021 22:15

Aw, that's so sad. Sorry for your loss x

Meercatmama · 11/09/2021 22:14

As an aside if i had written this in my early thirties you would have got a completely different response Bringing up children and balancing everything is so hard

Ragwort · 11/09/2021 22:08

Personally I would have hated to have had my DC any younger - I was 43 when my DS was born, am over 60 now and, despite earlier comments, still enjoying life and feel I am making a positive contribution to society and still got lots of things to look forward to. It was so much easier to be financially secure when we became parents, I know we were very lucky and people can struggle financially at any age, but for us it was a huge plus. I read about people's financial difficulties on Mumsnet and am so grateful that money has never been an issue for us ... and that wouldn't have been the case if I'd become a mother in my 20s or 30s. (Not that we are well off by Mumsnet standards- we live in a relatively low cost area which means housing is below the average price).

Realyorkshiretea · 11/09/2021 22:07

[quote KatharinaRosalie]link disappeared statice.is/publications/news-archive/inhabitants/births-2019/[/quote]
Yes but they start having children in their 20s whereas in the U.K. it’s 28+.

I think the ‘trend’ of older motherhood isn’t good for society in terms of women’s rights and quality of life.

It means the government can be rubbish about maternity leave and pay, because they rely on a lot of babies being born to mums further down the career line & financially better off. They also don’t need to support younger mums to find good employment with small children by making higher education setting child friendly etc.

I have also noticed a lot of posts such as @Siameasy where women have really struggled to find a man who will commit & have children in late 20s - I think in part because as far as the men are concerned, their friend’s wives aren’t having babies then, so it’s ‘too soon’ compared to everyone else. They fail to grasp the biological clock and their aims of leaving it as late as they can are justified by seeing their peers wait until late 30s/early 40s. So it’s harder to find a man who will commit in their late 20s for those women who actually want it - so they end up setting down later, and the cycle starts again.

Then the women end up taking on the greater health risks from being an older mum.

It’s a self fulfilling thing really - people want to have kids at the ‘socially acceptable’ age and copy their friends, so they wait until they’re older, have children, and then become part of the middle class norm that says that is the ‘right age’, which more people then copy.

Is there anything in this or does that sound very judgey? I just don’t think it’s doing women a great service, overall. I think it’s a bit of a con.

Meercatmama · 11/09/2021 22:07

I had my first at 26 and my second at thirty. We were told my my husbands consultants to go early to reduce risks and allow time to conceive. It worked for us baby wise thankfully and never regretted that decision. However were we ready no. Created some resentment and a strain on a finances but the worst was we seemed to grow apart with the demands of parent hood to the point of serving divorce paper on each other whilst living in the same house at one point. This was complicated by two parental bereavements and some immediate family problems. We realized that it was the stresses around us not and boundaries in relationship was the problem not that we did not love one another, I look back on my thirties as a time of immense struggle and at times depression. However on the positive note my husbands parents got to know two of the six grandchildren they had before they died ( the others born after) My dad saw my eldest up to his 15th birthday and my youngest to his 11th and would have seen beyond if he had not has been stricken with lung cancer. My mum now 77 loves her grandchildren and fully participates in their lives and her two great grandchildren. What have I missed? Not having extended maternity leaves my first was 3 months the second 6 months Husband was self employed mine the secure job and two recessions Changing my career younger but I was tied to the bank I worked with as my mortgage was with them and my wage was the main bread winner. Being in job I hated for 7 years but it was safe and going through two recessions. Buying a three bedroom house that was really beyond us at 21 years of age and doing it up having no savings and being faced with the fertility time bomb. Not be able to travel and do nice things
What has been brilliant
Family relationships
Being young enough to enjoy all the sports and activities my kids wanted to do
Being able to look after and enjoy my grandchildren and join in
Now mortgage paid off enjoying spending the money on us
Planning couple and family holidays
Watching my family grow and being a really active part of it
Being able spend time looking after my mum and having not guilt about the children
Would I do it again this way. Yes I love being myself doing the things I want but also having the balance of the family without them having to help me while I help my mum. But the best thing is being able to spend time with my mum and sons individually doing the things they love for my mum it is going to shows being local or west end. I have the time and energy even when working full time.

LM20 · 11/09/2021 22:03

My dad (age 42) passed away 5 days before my first child was born (I was 20), my mam (age 45) passed away 5 months after I had my second child (I was 25). Having my children younger/older wouldn’t make much difference in my case.

Strangevipers · 11/09/2021 21:58

@user908768543

Everything happens at a certain time and for a reason

Yes I'm sure this gives the OP great comfort following her mother's premature death Hmm read the room.

You ok hon ?
41sunnydays · 11/09/2021 21:56

Yep I wish I had mine earlier too. I actually tried when I was 25 but couldn't conceive.

I feel old and tired and wish I had more energy to spend time with the children

DeepaBeesKit · 11/09/2021 21:53

In some ways I wish I had had mine slightly younger, mid- late twenties instead of 30s. I think these days a lot of us wait to get everything perfect, money, house etc. DH and I did this and while it's nice, we had enough financially to manage earlier. I had a bumpy journey with miscarriages etc and felt like my age didn't help.

Siameasy · 11/09/2021 21:49

I think 30 would’ve been ideal for me because then I would’ve had DC 2 when DC 1 started school.
However I just really struggled to meet someone once the partying years of my 20s were over. Didn’t meet DH until I was 35! By the time DC1 started school there was NO WAY I was going in for round two

One pro though was that I worked full time until I was 40 so I have built up a reasonable pension-when you go back part time, the contributions take a hit

nokidshere · 11/09/2021 21:48

Older parents often seem to say this sort of thing. That they feel young or act young.
But I never quite get it.... you are the age that you are. Not the age you imagine yourself to be. People don't usually feel the age that they are.. how does an age even feel.

It just means I don't feel any different than I did when I was 40