Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids earlier?

360 replies

40220s · 11/09/2021 18:41

My mum was 35 when she had me. She died when I was 16, and I had my first baby at 40. My dad died when I was 30.

One of my friends at school got pregnant at university and I remember my dad making some comment about being glad it wasn’t me. But I look at her now and it got me thinking. If I’d had my first baby at 20 and my mum had me at 20 … maybe there’s something in doing it that way, as you’re more likely to have extensive support from family.

Does anyone else think that this might be a ‘better’ way than the middle class approved route of kids in your 30s?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dutchessmom · 22/09/2021 09:44

Up until a few months ago I would say that I wish I had my first younger, so I would be younger when ttc #2. But now I believe that everything happens for a reason. Also, if I want to be closer with my son, I have to try and achieve that kind of relationship with him and not blame it on my age. For example, I used to say that I get tired easily following his schedule, because I am 42, but now I see at as an investment to our relationship and I gain the energy I need from that.

Realyorkshiretea · 14/09/2021 11:00

@ManifestDestinee

There was a thread from a woman wanting to charge her 16-year-old daughter rent/board the other day. This site is nuts

How is it nuts? One woman posted that so my point (which is not opinion, but fact) that 16 year olds are children is crazy?
Cop yourself on.

But I would also like to point out that using words like ‘abhorrent’ is extremely offensive and incredibly old fashioned. It’s not ideal, but it isn’t ‘abhorrent’

It's not old fashioned at all, and if you find it offensive I don't care. I find your posts claiming its a great idea to be offensive. Anyone who thinks 16 year olds having babies is ok is off their head, and I'd worry about their parenting.

You are actively lying now because I have never said it is okay or ideal for teenagers to have kids. Why are you making things up? If you’re willing to make such a ludicrous accusation can you cut and paste exactly what I said to back it up?
Rozziie · 14/09/2021 09:55

@ManifestDestinee

There was a thread from a woman wanting to charge her 16-year-old daughter rent/board the other day. This site is nuts

How is it nuts? One woman posted that so my point (which is not opinion, but fact) that 16 year olds are children is crazy?
Cop yourself on.

But I would also like to point out that using words like ‘abhorrent’ is extremely offensive and incredibly old fashioned. It’s not ideal, but it isn’t ‘abhorrent’

It's not old fashioned at all, and if you find it offensive I don't care. I find your posts claiming its a great idea to be offensive. Anyone who thinks 16 year olds having babies is ok is off their head, and I'd worry about their parenting.

I was backing up your point that 16-year-olds are children, Einstein. Some people really need everything spelled out, eh?
ManifestDestinee · 14/09/2021 09:45

There was a thread from a woman wanting to charge her 16-year-old daughter rent/board the other day. This site is nuts

How is it nuts? One woman posted that so my point (which is not opinion, but fact) that 16 year olds are children is crazy?
Cop yourself on.

But I would also like to point out that using words like ‘abhorrent’ is extremely offensive and incredibly old fashioned. It’s not ideal, but it isn’t ‘abhorrent’

It's not old fashioned at all, and if you find it offensive I don't care. I find your posts claiming its a great idea to be offensive. Anyone who thinks 16 year olds having babies is ok is off their head, and I'd worry about their parenting.

Nonicknamesforcatapillars · 13/09/2021 20:40

Whatever age you’ve had kids, young or old, if it’s worked out well for you then you’re going to think that it’s the better way round to do it.

There are positives and negatives to all ages. Obviously there are the extreme, young teens and late 40s that I wouldn’t think was the best plan, but really anywhere between 18 and 42 is perfectly acceptable IMO. Obviously the ideal would be that everyone started and finished having their kids between 25 and 35, but that’s generally not how life works out for most people.

I do think there is a massive stigma on being a young mum these days, it is very much viewed as the lesser option. I would really love to see that changed. It really can work out well for many people as it did for me. I don’t buy into the whole young parents children have poor outcomes malarkey. Obviously a young teen with no support will find it harder to parent successfully. But someone in their late teens or early 20s can provide just as good a start in life for their children as an older parent. Of the 6 kids in the top group when dd1 was at primary, 4 of them had been born to mothers under the age of 21. Those kids are now at college and doing well for themselves. This is obviously very anecdotal, but you can’t assume that young parent = poor outcome come for the child.

What we need is more affordable child care so that more women feel that they can afford to have their families at a better age biologically, rather than feeling they have to wait until their late 30s to be more financially secure and able to afford that horribly expensive childcare.

Popcornbetty · 13/09/2021 20:04

Oh definitely not, I had my dc in early 30’s (last one at 34) and felt it was the right age for me. I never felt ready earlier and was too busy travelling and being selfish! When I’m 40 they will both be in school and my youngest will be 6 so I don’t think that’s too bad at all. I feel still young enough to have fun with them and be there but have had life experience and no regrets.

Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 19:55

@ManifestDestinee

Firstly, 18+ aren’t ‘children’. 16 year olds aren’t either, but they’re only just ‘legal’. You’re using silly language to make the scenario sound as bad as possible

16 year olds ARE children. If you think that is silly language then there is no talking to you.
You may think children having children is a great idea, fortunately the vast majority disagree with you. It's abhorrent.

What?!?!?! Are you feeling okay?! I have not at any point, said or implied that teenagers having kids is ideal or even okay.

But I would also like to point out that using words like ‘abhorrent’ is extremely offensive and incredibly old fashioned. It’s not ideal, but it isn’t ‘abhorrent’. What is abhorrent is the nasty way in which you’re projecting your own issues by making out anyone that doesn’t follow your nonsensical life path is a crap mum.

Rozziie · 13/09/2021 19:46

@ManifestDestinee

Firstly, 18+ aren’t ‘children’. 16 year olds aren’t either, but they’re only just ‘legal’. You’re using silly language to make the scenario sound as bad as possible

16 year olds ARE children. If you think that is silly language then there is no talking to you.
You may think children having children is a great idea, fortunately the vast majority disagree with you. It's abhorrent.

There was a thread from a woman wanting to charge her 16-year-old daughter rent/board the other day. This site is nuts.
ManifestDestinee · 13/09/2021 19:38

Firstly, 18+ aren’t ‘children’. 16 year olds aren’t either, but they’re only just ‘legal’. You’re using silly language to make the scenario sound as bad as possible

16 year olds ARE children. If you think that is silly language then there is no talking to you.
You may think children having children is a great idea, fortunately the vast majority disagree with you. It's abhorrent.

Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 19:04

Thanks @Blossomtoes nice to know some doesnt think I’m Sue Radford in disguise Grin

I’ve also said in an arbitrary way I think late 20s to early 30s is the best age, which is further towards 40 than teenage Confused

Itstheprinciple · 13/09/2021 19:00

I had my DD at 25. My mum had me at 25 and her mum had her at 25.

So, to summarise, 25 is a pretty good age to have children!

Blossomtoes · 13/09/2021 18:59

[quote Rozziie]@Realyorkshiretea there's something that makes me really uncomfortable about your posts and the language you use...you sound like a brood mare and as if you think all women should be that Confused[/quote]
That’s nonsense. Advocating parenthood at an age when your fertility is at its height and you’re as physically fit as you’re ever going to be is just common sense. She’s hardly recommending that people start popping babies out the minute they’re able and continue through to the menopause.

Recessed · 13/09/2021 18:59

YANBU, my mum got married young and had us in her early twenties. It's always been brilliant having a younger mother. She was only 53 when I had DD1 at 30yo and was an enormous help. We've had amazing holidays together and really enjoy each other's company. That can happen at any age of course but didn't seem to be too common when I was younger. For example my friends with older parents never wanted to holiday with them when we were at uni/early twenties but I jumped at the chance and went all over the world with my mum.

There's always downsides to every situation though. The likelihood of your relationship lasting when you have DC in your late teens/early twenties is quite slim I imagine (my parents divorced when I was mid-twenties). There's also a confidence that comes with being an older mother, my mum was brilliant and confident as a mother but she wasn't confident in herself and I think that rubbed off on us. Also finances were an issue and that also rubs off on children and has an impact on confidence/self-esteem.

Still when it comes down to it nothing is greater than having as much time as you can with the people you love. However I wouldn't wallow too much as there's nothing can be done to change these things - focus on the positives of being a more mature, financially stable and wise mum to your DC!

Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 18:44

[quote Rozziie]@Realyorkshiretea I meant all your posts. You have an attitude of someone who thinks deep down that women's sole (or at least main) purpose is to breed, and that should be focused on at all costs, at the expense of everything else.[/quote]
Confused in almost every post I have written, I have qualified it with something like ‘IF women want a family’ or ‘IF they want multiple kids’. I’m under no illusion that all women are destined to be mothers, far from it. I have an only who will probably stay an only for medical reasons, so I would be rubbish as a brood mare anyway.

I think your view on what I’m saying is testament to the fact it had been drummed into women that they must prize money and material possessions over relationships and having a family, because to think otherwise is ‘regressive’ and ‘going back to the 50s’. The fact is biology doesn’t care about your ideas, and this mentality is a con, as evidenced by several women on this thread who feel they were pressured into prioritising work at the expense of their own happiness.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 13/09/2021 18:42

I had my DS at 21and had tons of energy. I went to university at the same time and .angel a career. I lived being his mum and we are best friends now I'm 60.

Rozziie · 13/09/2021 18:38

@Realyorkshiretea I meant all your posts. You have an attitude of someone who thinks deep down that women's sole (or at least main) purpose is to breed, and that should be focused on at all costs, at the expense of everything else.

Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 18:35

[quote Rozziie]@Realyorkshiretea there's something that makes me really uncomfortable about your posts and the language you use...you sound like a brood mare and as if you think all women should be that Confused[/quote]
I was merely flipping manifest’s post to show how nasty it is in reverse.

Marlena1 · 13/09/2021 18:35

This thread is so depressing! My mum had me at 36, I had my second at 36. I only started feeling guilty about this when I joined MN! My mum is very active with my children, but my 82 year old dad took on my first when I went back to work (only thing is he won't chamge a nappy so someone has to be around!). One thing I would say though is outlook/personality has a lot to do with it. A lot of the people bitter about older parents on this thread seemed to have very old fashioned outlooks which can be stiffling/embarrassing to teenagers.

Rozziie · 13/09/2021 18:34

@Realyorkshiretea there's something that makes me really uncomfortable about your posts and the language you use...you sound like a brood mare and as if you think all women should be that Confused

Realyorkshiretea · 13/09/2021 18:28

@ManifestDestinee

Also, clinging onto the teen part is a massive red herring when I already said I was basing off my own situation (teen parenthood) which is a younger age and therefore 'worse'

You don't need the quote marks around worse. It IS worse. Doom and gloom, if you want to call it that is essential when talking to teens, if it stops even one from getting pregnant. Children having children is a terrible idea, which we don't need to pretend is ok.
You might have done alright with it, but the majority don't. It's not something to be recommended to anyone.

Firstly, 18+ aren’t ‘children’. 16 year olds aren’t either, but they’re only just ‘legal’. You’re using silly language to make the scenario sound as bad as possible.

Personally I think a couple in their mid 40s having a first baby is a terrible idea - the baby will probably end up an only child with elderly parents by the time they’re 30. Nobody to remember their childhood with, and if they’re not settled at that point they will have no close blood family to be there for them during good times & bad. You might get the odd one that does alright with it but 🤷🏼‍♀️

So there’s some doom and gloom for you. At least with teen mums, they’re likely to see their kids through to middle age & give them siblings.

ManifestDestinee · 13/09/2021 15:57

Also, clinging onto the teen part is a massive red herring when I already said I was basing off my own situation (teen parenthood) which is a younger age and therefore 'worse'

You don't need the quote marks around worse. It IS worse. Doom and gloom, if you want to call it that is essential when talking to teens, if it stops even one from getting pregnant. Children having children is a terrible idea, which we don't need to pretend is ok.
You might have done alright with it, but the majority don't. It's not something to be recommended to anyone.

IceLace100 · 13/09/2021 15:51

I understand the argument for having babies in your 20s (as opposed to late 30s/ 40s). Defo good for health and if you want a large family.

But can we all agree having a baby at 16 isn't optimal. Sure there are girls (because at that age they are girls, not women) of that age who make it work, and good for them. But it's not optimal.

tryrantosaurus · 13/09/2021 15:44

Thank you @Realyorkshiretea

It's really not hard to get. Doom and gloom helps absolutely nobody. It's not said I'm the best interests of young girls and women who are pregnant or mothers.

Also, clinging onto the teen part is a massive red herring when I already said I was basing off my own situation (teen parenthood) which is a younger age and therefore 'worse'.

ManifestDestinee · 13/09/2021 15:41

My anecdote was 16/17 because that's what i was, but the same applies to all young parents (so up to about 25). Basically, there's help available in Britain in 2021

But it doesn't apply, at all. There is help available in theory, but practically there is little. If a child of 16 has a baby they are going to want huge support from family, and if they don't have it, they are fucked. You clearly did, but many don't.

ohdear10 · 13/09/2021 15:40

[quote Porcupineintherough]@dummyd then why are the children of teenage mothers less likely to have good educational outcomes, more likely to have poor health and lower life expectancy and be more likely to become teenage parents themselves?[/quote]
Most teenage parents are troubled in other ways. I'm not staying it doesn't happen, that's dumb. Many will have lower outcomes. And IMO a lot of teen and young parents poor outcomes (for those that have poor outcomes) is due to negative opinions around them. Put downs, and bring tops you'll never finish college, school, university- so might as well drop out. That you'll always be poor, not having anyone to guide you, more than anything.

Those who do, would have low outcomes anyway unfortunately. The resources are out there in society.