Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh’s girlfriend from past

261 replies

Ibizafun · 11/09/2021 17:46

Dh and I are in our 50’s, happily married (2nd marriage). He’s kept in touch with a girl he dated for 3 yrs when he was 17-20 just sending birthday texts. Apparently they were friends for some time after the relationship.

Dh showed me a message from her saying she’s now working near our area and does he fancy a cup of coffee one day. I think she is now single. Dh says he’s curious as to how her life turned out and why don’t we ask her here.

He has integrity and I’m not worried about cheating but he does think it’s ok to be friends with her. I guess I’m worried if there’s still a spark, do I need those feelings stirred up in him? Am I being unreasonable to say one coffee to catch up but no friendship.

Have asked my friends but would love it confirmed here!

OP posts:
Deletesystem33 · 11/09/2021 20:21

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@Deletesystem33

I'm a real woman, not some fake, lying cool wife, and I'd be fine with it.[/quote]
I'm sorry you can't comprehend other people feeling differently from you. It must be very limiting.

DukeOfEarlGrey · 11/09/2021 20:20

@Ibizafun

Thank you. Different advice from my friends saying why do I need it, single women are dangerousGrin
Your friends' attitude seems a bit misogynistic. Perhaps remind them that married women are just as capable of having affairs with married men Shock
SecretSpAD · 11/09/2021 20:11

Asking to meet up now could be more an age thing rather than an end of marriage thing. I know that when I was 50 last year I became more curious about what old friends who I'd known at school and Uni were doing than j had been before. Obviously they weren't people I'd kept in touch with much, other than the odd comment on Facebook.

You think he's one in a million, but he will think you are too. You say it's both of your second marriages. He loved another woman once to marry her.....and yet its this one who he split up with when he was barely out of his teenage years that is bothering you! Why?

Your friends are nuts. If a man and a woman are going to have an affair then marital status of the person is irrelevant, as it seems you know. However, sometimes, someone can just be curious to know how a person from their past is doing.

Meet her together, who knows, maybe you'll like her.

BertramLacey · 11/09/2021 20:08

I am stunned that the YABU figure is so high. Like hell would the vast majority of women be OK with this. Come ON!!!

I understand and appreciate that many women wouldn't like this situation. I also understand that many would be okay with it, and some would be okay but watchful. I understand that you wouldn't like it. So why the disbelief on your part that anyone might have a different opinion to yours? Why think that so many people are just lying, simply because they're saying something different to how you feel?

Celticdawn5 · 11/09/2021 20:06

I wouldn’t like it and I certainly wouldn’t welcome her coming into my home.

Tistheseason17 · 11/09/2021 20:05

Why does your DH want to explore it further in person after this long?
If they were such good friends it would not have taken so long to meet up.
I reckon he's intrigued as to whether she is still attractive.
Unfortunately, curiosity could cause problems. That said, if he would never cheat - trust him.
I trust my DH but he'd never want to do this anyway so it's a moot point for me.
Perhaps, cuppa at yours is an option?

ViperHalliwell · 11/09/2021 20:04

@Ibizafun

He has always described her as attractive. When I say I have the right to decide who he’s friends with, what I mean is I expect him to respect my feelings if I am uncomfortable with a friendship, as I would prioritise his feelings in the same position.
If one of his friends was rude to you or made a pass at him or declared her undying love or something like that, he'd of course put you first and stop seeing her. As you would with the reverse. But this woman hasn't done anything; you haven't even met her. And if they were friends for years after breaking up and have kept in touch, I'd really think of her as a friend more than an ex, but you'd get a better feel of that if you met her.

I do wonder why she never asked to meet up when she was married!!! From what you wrote, I thought she'd just moved near you for work. Maybe she's just reaching out to whoever she knows in the area because she's new there.

As for "why do I need it?" - you don't need or want it for yourself; why would you? But your H seems to want to catch up with his old friend. Do you never have things you want that he doesn't care about but agrees to or does for/with you anyway?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 11/09/2021 20:01

my loyal, trustworthy, principled husband sleepwalked a physical affair with her.

We must stop infantilising men like this especially because by association we then demonise women.

He didn't sleepwalk into it. He made a series of selfish, reckless, disloyal and incredibly hurtful decisions.

He wasn't powerless to the feminine wiles of this temptress. He chose to be unfaithful, first emotionally (presumably) then physically.

A series of many decisions that he knew would hurt his partner is not sleepwalking. It's plain old fashioned cheating.

wombleflump · 11/09/2021 19:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BigThumb · 11/09/2021 19:59

Not all single women are “dangerous” but not all single women are innocent little angels either. This woman might just want a catch up with an old friend. She might want a try at the back up plan bloke. Who knows?

Men can’t be forced to have an affair though (physical or emotional). In your position, I’d be interested to know why he’s so curious how life turned out for someone who only warranted birthday texts over the years. Emotional affair (and more) territory here but not because of her.

2bazookas · 11/09/2021 19:55

I think I do have a right to decide who he’s friends with when it comes to single women he’s dated!

I absolutely don't agree.

Trying to own and control an adult you don't even trust, is never going to make either of you happy.

godmum56 · 11/09/2021 19:53

difficult one. One of my late husband's previous girlfriends was my sister. And no it wasn't a problem.

Chloemol · 11/09/2021 19:51

Please you sound so insecure

He is entitled to be friends with whoever he wishes stop being so controlling

KirstenBlest · 11/09/2021 19:51

Emotional affair territory for sure. Make your boundaries clear, and make sure you have your ducks in a row.

Hekatestorch · 11/09/2021 19:47

Your friends are correct.

Really? The friends are correct that single women are dangerous?

Affairs are down to dangerous single women, not the men shagging them?

And again, whose fault is when both people having an affair are in a relationship and there's no single woman to blame?

Angrymum22 · 11/09/2021 19:47

I’m a rl cool wife and I was fine with it. He discussed it with me and I didn’t see the problem. Our relationship was and still is in a good place, but it was the gradual change in behaviour that triggered my gut feeling. That and seeing a message on his phone (charges it on a stand in the kitchen so in plain view) by chance.
Weirdly I still trust him but just not with this “perfect” ex.
It’s not something I’d like to go through again.

TangledTrees · 11/09/2021 19:47

Ypu won’t want to hear this, but my DH had an affair with his ex from his teenage years.
A heady mix of nostalgia, reawakened teenage lust brain memory and opportunity (when he bumped into her after over 20 years) and my loyal, trustworthy, principled husband sleepwalked a physical affair with her. Nearly destroyed me.
One of my best friends’ DH did exactly the same thing with his equivalent ex who messaged him innocently on facebook.

My advice to you would be to be alert, ans if he wants to meet with her, meet as a group.

TableFlowerss · 11/09/2021 19:46

@Amberheartkitty

I don’t know a single woman in real life who would be comfortable with this. Same goes for the men. Your friends are correct. Affairs always start as ‘we are just friends’ then move onto the next level.
Same here! It’s only on MN everyone is super cool with everything. Meanwhile in the real world their DH is off shagging the next door neighbour!
TableFlowerss · 11/09/2021 19:45

Your feelings are totally valid OP. Ignore all of the posters saying you’re controlling etc…

It wasn’t just a friendship, it was a sexual relationship, at some point and people get bored, which is why affairs start. They often start because an opportunity arises. This could be that opportunity.

Obviously it may not be at all. She may not have any desire to start up anything with him but you’re right to be cautious.

The term ‘The other woman’, hasn’t made its way in to the English language by chance, it’s because it’s men that usually have affairs!!! How often do you hear the term ‘5the other man’.

Ignore those that are stonewalling you and saying you’re controlling. You’re right to feel as you do and you should be able to speak to him about it. In my friendship group this wouldn’t happen because my friends would find it disrespectful.

Amberheartkitty · 11/09/2021 19:43

I don’t know a single woman in real life who would be comfortable with this. Same goes for the men. Your friends are correct.
Affairs always start as ‘we are just friends’ then move onto the next level.

BertramLacey · 11/09/2021 19:42

In the real world I don't know one single woman who would be happy with this.

In the real world I don't know any tax collectors. I don't doubt their existence though.

Don't let strangers on a forum tell you how you are supposed to feel about this.

The OP asked strangers on the internet for an opinion on this. It's kind of the point of the thread. The OP doesn't have to listen, but then she might want to think about why that is.

JBEM4 · 11/09/2021 19:42

@Ibizafun

I disagree with all those saying it’s not my business though.. we’re married and are meant to respect each other’s feelings surely? Even if one might be a bit neurotic?
Yet you don't respect your husband enough to trust his word?

Never bodes well to carry the emotional hurt from a previous relationship into a new one. Your husband doesn't deserve to be punished for your insecurity

Mummadeze · 11/09/2021 19:42

My opinion is that it is great that he has suggested she meet both of you. I would invite her into your home and meet her as a couple. Maybe you will really get along with her and you can all stay in touch. But gauge how they both are around each other and see what your instincts are telling you. Am pretty sure the attraction will be long gone as you sound like you have a good relationship. If it makes you feel any better, every ex I have met in later life has been No way near as attractive as I remembered them!

Livelovebehappy · 11/09/2021 19:38

And whilst you say you have a happy marriage, and he has integrity, this doesn’t mean his head can’t be turned. Many men in what their wife’s perceive as happy marriages stray. My DH was a man of integrity and a loving husband and father, who had a personality change overnight when he had a chance meeting with an old female friend. It ended our marriage, although we did get back together a few years later.

MyPatronusIsACat · 11/09/2021 19:37

@Livelovebehappy

Ignore the posters on here accusing you on here of being insecure and controlling OP. My DH has a female friend who he has worked with for many years, and obviously I’m comfortable with this. But if she was someone he had had a romantic connection with, whether 2 years ago or 30 years ago, it would still make me feel uncomfortable. Just attend the coffee with them and you will be able to tell if she has an agenda. I hear of many women holding a candle for their first loves, many years later.
Exactly what I think - and said earlier in the thread. And I just flat out do not believe any woman who says she wouldn't give a shit about it, and would not be even slightly worried. Of course they would!