Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh’s girlfriend from past

261 replies

Ibizafun · 11/09/2021 17:46

Dh and I are in our 50’s, happily married (2nd marriage). He’s kept in touch with a girl he dated for 3 yrs when he was 17-20 just sending birthday texts. Apparently they were friends for some time after the relationship.

Dh showed me a message from her saying she’s now working near our area and does he fancy a cup of coffee one day. I think she is now single. Dh says he’s curious as to how her life turned out and why don’t we ask her here.

He has integrity and I’m not worried about cheating but he does think it’s ok to be friends with her. I guess I’m worried if there’s still a spark, do I need those feelings stirred up in him? Am I being unreasonable to say one coffee to catch up but no friendship.

Have asked my friends but would love it confirmed here!

OP posts:
RonniePickering · 11/09/2021 23:06

Yeah I’d say “fuck that” 🤷🏼‍♀️

stonebrambleboy · 11/09/2021 23:02

OP you are not controlling or insecure.
I know a number of middle-aged single women who are desperate for a man.Who justify affairs by saying 'it isn't me who broke the marriage vows '.

MyPatronusIsACat · 11/09/2021 22:47

@StormBaby

Those of you who think this situation isn’t dangerous territory are kidding yourselves. I had an ex get back in touch after 20 years when my first marriage went through a rough patch, it was almost as if he knew I was vulnerable, and it ended up being an emotional affair. The ‘what ifs’ are very attractive IMO. I’m very careful now to never put myself in the position ever again. It’s an easy trap.
100% this.

As I said earlier, it's so common for old flames to meet up, and their feelings for each other to re-ignite.

There is sooooo much wrong with the OP's DH meeting up with this woman.

MyPatronusIsACat · 11/09/2021 22:44

@ilovemydogandmrobama2

Totally agree with the posters who suggest meeting her together, as it isn't really an issue of whether he would cheat, but DH and I are mostly have the same circle of friends. He will go out with his mates, and I will go out with mine, but he has met most of my exes and I've met most of his, so not a big deal.

Quire normal to be curious how her life has turned out.

Yeah the meeting together - (the OP and her DH and his old girlfriend who is suddenly interested in meeting up with him,) is a red herring.

They will meet up as a 3, then the DH and the old flame will meet alone. (Without OP's knowledge.)

It's textbook.

I'd bet a month's salary that an affair will ensue IF the OP doesn't put her foot down now.

Then again, it may happen anyway. If the OP protests, he may just see his old flame in secret...

Tough one. Sorry @Ibizafun but it doesn't sound good... It sounds to me like your DH is still attracted to this woman.

I hope I am wrong.

Hekatestorch · 11/09/2021 22:30

@PumpkinsGalore

Don't allow it. She needs to be told to sod off! Politely or otherwise! Chances are high that she has bad intentions. Why risk it?
And what amazing formula did you use to work out, that the chance of her having bad intentions is higher than the chance of her, simply moving back to the area and thinking it was chance for a catch up.

Besides which 'don't allow it' is really poor advice. He is a grown adult.

If something happened between them, it would because he wanted it to. It which case he will just go behind ops back anyway.

She can have all the negative intentions she wants. Doesn't mean she gets anywhere.

Of course, unless op feels that he is the type that just can't say no. Which is a problem in itself.

Hekatestorch · 11/09/2021 22:26

@StormBaby

Those of you who think this situation isn’t dangerous territory are kidding yourselves. I had an ex get back in touch after 20 years when my first marriage went through a rough patch, it was almost as if he knew I was vulnerable, and it ended up being an emotional affair. The ‘what ifs’ are very attractive IMO. I’m very careful now to never put myself in the position ever again. It’s an easy trap.
And I ended up back in touch with my ex, we didn't have an emotional affair or an affair. It was nice to see him, we have stayed in touch from time to time. Not everyone steps over the line.

Its really strange to think that because it worked our that way for you. Its definitely going to work out that way for everyone.

toocold54 · 11/09/2021 22:22

I think I do have a right to decide who he’s friends with when it comes to single women he’s dated!

You do not have the right to decide who he’s friends with!! He’s a grown adult and you’re not his mum!
If my boyfriend ever tried to tell me who I can and can’t be friends with them I’d be finishing it as that’s controlling and unhealthy.

If someone is going to cheat on you then they will. I really don’t think the risk is increased if it’s an ex from 30 years ago.

PumpkinsGalore · 11/09/2021 22:20

Don't allow it. She needs to be told to sod off! Politely or otherwise! Chances are high that she has bad intentions. Why risk it?

BertramLacey · 11/09/2021 22:16

Those of you who think this situation isn’t dangerous territory are kidding yourselves.

Or, we just have different experiences and are different people. I'm not invalidating or questioning your experience, so why not just acknowledge that mine is different from yours?

StormBaby · 11/09/2021 21:42

Those of you who think this situation isn’t dangerous territory are kidding yourselves. I had an ex get back in touch after 20 years when my first marriage went through a rough patch, it was almost as if he knew I was vulnerable, and it ended up being an emotional affair. The ‘what ifs’ are very attractive IMO. I’m very careful now to never put myself in the position ever again. It’s an easy trap.

GreenClock · 11/09/2021 21:35

I think that in many cases, there is something special and intriguing about a teenage-era ex. It’s different to someone you dated at 30 or 40, or even an ex-spouse. The nostalgia is often intense. For this reason, I’d be wary of this particular woman.

I would be less wary if they’d stayed in touch, even sporadically, over the years and known each other’s spouses etc. But this “out of the blue” scenario is different and I wonder what precipitated it.

It’s to his credit that he told you but that doesn’t mean it’s ok for him to meet her when you’re not comfortable with it.

nonevernotever · 11/09/2021 21:32

As a counterbalance to those whose partners did reconnect with lovers after a similar period, let me tell you about DH . In town he bumped into a girlfriend from uni some 25 years previously. They went for lunch to catch up. Both married, though she trotted out some version of the my husband doesn't understand me line. She then shocked my DH completely by suggesting they get a hotel room for the rest of the afternoon. He declined (probably rather more rudely than was polite) and abandoned the rest of his lunch. Up until that moment he had been completely oblivious as to what was in her mind . All of which is a roundabout way of saying that a man who can be persuaded to cheat won't be stopped by you withholding permission, but a trustworthy man remains trustworthy. In your circumstances I'd be alerting DH to the possibility that she might expect more from him, not because I don't trust him, but just because I know how unobservant he can be. When he's alert to something he can shut it down much quicker and more subtly than the blunt response you get when he's surprised into it.

ilovemydogandmrobama2 · 11/09/2021 21:15

Totally agree with the posters who suggest meeting her together, as it isn't really an issue of whether he would cheat, but DH and I are mostly have the same circle of friends. He will go out with his mates, and I will go out with mine, but he has met most of my exes and I've met most of his, so not a big deal.

Quire normal to be curious how her life has turned out.

Angrymum22 · 11/09/2021 21:02

Something lit the spark 30yrs ago whose to say it won’t ignite again. That’s the difference to any other female friendship.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 11/09/2021 20:57

Whilst you dont get to choose his friends, you have every right to not be happy with it.

I wouldnt be happy with it tbh.

HalzTangz · 11/09/2021 20:51

@Ibizafun

I think I do have a right to decide who he’s friends with when it comes to single women he’s dated! Especially as he asked me how I felt. Can ask her to ours but it’s the prospect of friendship after I’m not sure I’m comfortable with
Actually you don't have any right to say he can be friends with just as he doesn't have right to tell you who to be friends with. You are both adults and free to choose your own friends.

There must be something you are letting on about, you say he has integrity yet in the same breath worried a coffee meet might ignite a spark. If they wanted to have an affair they would have done it in the 30 years they have been in touch. Surely the fact he suggested meeting her together shows he has no interest in her, and that he wants to show his wife off to her

Moonmagic24 · 11/09/2021 20:45

Are these responses to be believed?
NO! Do not trust this woman...At all.
If they 'meet' it could change your happy dynamic.
Where does it lead to after that?
Who in their sane mind would enjoy this fragility?

KirstenBlest · 11/09/2021 20:38

It's not the women who are dangerous, it's the situation.

The DH is curious, goes to meet OW. OW is attractive and seems new and fresh (conversation-wise) compared to DW. DH wonders 'what if'. OW is free and might be up for an affair. DW obviously trusts him. DH starts to woo OW, turns into a complete shit because he is only thinking with his dick.

As I pp, classic EA territory.

Compare it to a bar of chocolate or packet of biscuits. If it's in the shop or inside a cupboard, you haven't seen it so don't think about it. If it's opened and in front of you, it's a lot harder to resist.

Old flames should remain in the past.

Angrymum22 · 11/09/2021 20:36

Controlling is insisting on joint SM account or having full access to DH’s smart media. It’s not controlling to say you are uncomfortable with DH meeting up with an ex, having not seen them for 30yrs.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 11/09/2021 20:35

@Intransigentcat

prokupatuscrakedatus

You make an excellent point. The idea that it is women in society who are the ones who lead men astray is strongly embedded.

You'd think women would take a step back and look at what the end game of buying into this narrative is, especially given what is going on in Afghanistan. Girls there will now need to wear a Niqab and black gloves to even get an education. Women will be forced to wear all black in public. Because women are seen as dangerous and tempting. Too dangerous and too tempting to be allowed any freedom.

Women who feel like men should be responsible for their own actions are derided by other women on here as 'cool wives'

No wonder patriarchy is so unbreakable when so many women happily shore it up.

Calling single women dangerous in this day and age is pretty disgusting misogynistic shit. What"s next, stoning them?

👏👏👏
Hekatestorch · 11/09/2021 20:33

Its clear op doesn't doesn't trust her husband as she says she does.

To op single woman, wanting to meet up with a married friend of 30 years equals dangerous single woman wanting to steal her man.

Yet married man, also wanting to meet up with dangerously single female friend of 30 years is totally innocent and trustworthy and 'one in a million'.

If op was really not worried about cheating and confident he wouldn't, she would also know any sign of inappropriate behaviour from her would mean him cutting her off. Or of he felt old feelings surfacing he would cut her off.

This is the problem. Either he has done things that make him untrustworthy or Op is letting something, someone else did to her years ago (the ex who cheated) ductile her decisions and thinks this should also dictate her DHs friendships.

Puffalicious · 11/09/2021 20:29

@Intransigentcat

prokupatuscrakedatus

You make an excellent point. The idea that it is women in society who are the ones who lead men astray is strongly embedded.

You'd think women would take a step back and look at what the end game of buying into this narrative is, especially given what is going on in Afghanistan. Girls there will now need to wear a Niqab and black gloves to even get an education. Women will be forced to wear all black in public. Because women are seen as dangerous and tempting. Too dangerous and too tempting to be allowed any freedom.

Women who feel like men should be responsible for their own actions are derided by other women on here as 'cool wives'

No wonder patriarchy is so unbreakable when so many women happily shore it up.

Calling single women dangerous in this day and age is pretty disgusting misogynistic shit. What"s next, stoning them?

Bloody brilliant post.

If your husband strays, he strays. It's his decision.

If I had to live on my nerves that my DH would come into contact with single women who may want him I'd be wrecked. He is a great package- I chose him, after all, but his loss if he would ever stray. I can hand on heart say I feel he never would , but nobody can ever say never as you cannot control or make decisions for others.

Get some self respect and value yourself.

Intransigentcat · 11/09/2021 20:25

prokupatuscrakedatus

You make an excellent point. The idea that it is women in society who are the ones who lead men astray is strongly embedded.

You'd think women would take a step back and look at what the end game of buying into this narrative is, especially given what is going on in Afghanistan. Girls there will now need to wear a Niqab and black gloves to even get an education. Women will be forced to wear all black in public. Because women are seen as dangerous and tempting. Too dangerous and too tempting to be allowed any freedom.

Women who feel like men should be responsible for their own actions are derided by other women on here as 'cool wives'

No wonder patriarchy is so unbreakable when so many women happily shore it up.

Calling single women dangerous in this day and age is pretty disgusting misogynistic shit. What"s next, stoning them?

Iovina · 11/09/2021 20:23

@Angrymum22

This happened with my DH last year. Ended up verging on an emotional affair. If your marriage is good then I would tell him that you don’t feel comfortable with it. Our relationship weathered the storm and we are back on track. Maybe it was because there were no problems at the time. Like your DH, my DH was curious, it nearly ended up with him loosing everything.
This is what usually happens in these scenarios; this board is full of them. Especially concerning as DH has commented upon her attractiveness...
Jenala · 11/09/2021 20:22

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@SheABitSpicyToday

Seriously? After 30 years. That’s very insecure of you.

@barskits

After 30 years, I too would be suspicious of the motives of a newly-single woman contacting a married man and asking him if he fancies a coffee.

Yep this ^ It's very suspicious, and very worrying that the OP's husband wants to meet her 'to find out how her life turned out...' Hmm yeah right. Wink

I am stunned that the YABU figure is so high. Like hell would the vast majority of women be OK with this. Come ON!!! Hmm[/quote]
It's possible to both not like it and also feel it's not OK to dictate who your partner is friends with.

OPs feelings are valid and understandable. Still doesn't make being controlling ok.