Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh’s girlfriend from past

261 replies

Ibizafun · 11/09/2021 17:46

Dh and I are in our 50’s, happily married (2nd marriage). He’s kept in touch with a girl he dated for 3 yrs when he was 17-20 just sending birthday texts. Apparently they were friends for some time after the relationship.

Dh showed me a message from her saying she’s now working near our area and does he fancy a cup of coffee one day. I think she is now single. Dh says he’s curious as to how her life turned out and why don’t we ask her here.

He has integrity and I’m not worried about cheating but he does think it’s ok to be friends with her. I guess I’m worried if there’s still a spark, do I need those feelings stirred up in him? Am I being unreasonable to say one coffee to catch up but no friendship.

Have asked my friends but would love it confirmed here!

OP posts:
Ibizafun · 12/09/2021 09:56

DumplingsAndStew she is definitely single, dh told me her marriage ended a few years ago.

OP posts:
Ibizafun · 12/09/2021 09:55

SeriouslyISuppose Prima DonnaGrin nope.. I have a husband who considers my feelings and values our marriage. He had no intention of anything untoward but how I feel trumps his curiosity as to how her life panned out. I’m sorry this upsets you!!!

OP posts:
DumplingsAndStew · 12/09/2021 09:52

@TwinsandTrifle

Oh, do fuck off dear. Morals like that will be a big part of why you still remain single

I really fucking hope that bit wasn't targeted at me?

Why are you acting like a woman who is moving back to the area she lived in 30 years ago is a marriage wrecker for asking an old friend if they want to catch up? THE OP DOESN'T EVEN KNOW IF SHE IS SINGLE

Hekatestorch · 12/09/2021 09:50

@TwinsandTrifle

Lol. I could have predicted the "maybe in the circles you moved in". I was going to type that in my post I expected that silly reply so much, I should have done.

No they don't move in my circles. People like that are disgusting and not welcome as a friend.

If someone has been faithful for 30 years, during which time, they've obviously met hundreds of attractive people, had ample opportunity to cheat of their own doing, but don't. Then get targeted by a relentless desperate person, until they are broken down, then sure, technically they have cheated. But to act like they played some equal part, when one person had that intention from the start and was relentless through sheer desperation? Funny how men can be called "poor poppets" and patronised if they are targeted. Bizarre that some are outraged if the women in question are called out for being the orchestrating predators they are. Thankfully it's the minority view of the posts.

Imagine if my male next door neighbour, knew I was married, left flowers on my car. Came out to "innocently" join me on walks with DC as I walked past the house. Popped round with a few recipes he'd seen that he thought I might like. Would I be some "poor poppet?" No. I'd be told how this man was deliberately over stepping the mark, and to keep him distanced. Not because I'm weak and can't rebut his advances. Because a man like that is bad news. And he is. Works just the same for women.

You know lots of these women. Therefore they are in your circles. Or else you wouldn't really know much about them.

Or are you just going on 2nd, 3rd, 4th hand gossip coming from people who have been cheated on. You can't know so much about their inner feelings and thoughts and not have a relationship with them.

No one is broken down into cheating. No many has sex with someone behinds his wife's back in the hope the woman backs off. Or because he just can't fight it anymore. Its not technically cheating. It's cheating. And then men hold at least the same amount if blame as the woman. You talk about men as though they were children lead astray.

If a woman willing cheats because a man keeps asking then she is a cheater. But let's not pretend it's equal. Men, generally hold more power. Be that physical or the circumstances. So yes, it's more intimidating.

And not many people cheat because they genuinely had no other choice.

The neighbour you describe....definitely is a different situation. Because people would be worried for the physical safety of you and your child

If you kept engaging with him and enjoyed having your ego stroke by him, reciprocated in flirty......then you would get different answers again.

TwinsandTrifle · 12/09/2021 09:44

Anyway quick update, asked dh to ask her here for coffee but told him I don’t feel comfortable with anything more (at this point anyway without knowing much about her). Dh’s reply was he can’t be bothered, definitely not bothered enough to risk upsetting me.

@Ibizafun I'm so pleased to hear this. And I'd be a little wary of this. I'll tell you why: He would have been bothered to go out and meet her on his own, in a coffee shop somewhere. But your offering for her having that coffee at your home, which is even less effort, and he "couldn't be bothered" to see her at all.

That would suggest to me he knew the kind of tone this catch up would have, and it wasn't the kind that his wife could hear. I don't mean anything too untoward, but I think it would have been lots of reminiscing etc between two exes.

I'm glad there's the mutual respect for him to recognise this and you've come to the right decision together.

SeriouslyISuppose · 12/09/2021 09:41

@Ibizafun

Anyway quick update, asked dh to ask her here for coffee but told him I don’t feel comfortable with anything more (at this point anyway without knowing much about her). Dh’s reply was he can’t be bothered, definitely not bothered enough to risk upsetting me.
Well, big round of applause for behaving like such a prima donna that your husband is afraid you’ll fly off the handle and start issuing friendship bans if he sees his teenage ex-girlfriend thirty years on?

Honestly, OP. And the idea of inviting her to the house so she’s on your territory and you can keep a watchful eye?
Hmm

SilverTotoro · 12/09/2021 09:38

This isn’t a gender issue in my view. If one of my exes or my DHs exes got in touch when newly single to meet up after many years of only sending happy birthday type messages I’d suspect ulterior motives! One of my exes actually unsuccessfully tried this a few years ago though, so perhaps I’m biased!

Ibizafun · 12/09/2021 09:37

LadyOfLittleLeisure I may not have the right in your opinion, but if you read my update my feelings are worth more to dh than any ‘rights’.

OP posts:
TwinsandTrifle · 12/09/2021 09:36

Lol. I could have predicted the "maybe in the circles you moved in". I was going to type that in my post I expected that silly reply so much, I should have done.

No they don't move in my circles. People like that are disgusting and not welcome as a friend.

If someone has been faithful for 30 years, during which time, they've obviously met hundreds of attractive people, had ample opportunity to cheat of their own doing, but don't. Then get targeted by a relentless desperate person, until they are broken down, then sure, technically they have cheated. But to act like they played some equal part, when one person had that intention from the start and was relentless through sheer desperation? Funny how men can be called "poor poppets" and patronised if they are targeted. Bizarre that some are outraged if the women in question are called out for being the orchestrating predators they are. Thankfully it's the minority view of the posts.

Imagine if my male next door neighbour, knew I was married, left flowers on my car. Came out to "innocently" join me on walks with DC as I walked past the house. Popped round with a few recipes he'd seen that he thought I might like. Would I be some "poor poppet?" No. I'd be told how this man was deliberately over stepping the mark, and to keep him distanced. Not because I'm weak and can't rebut his advances. Because a man like that is bad news. And he is. Works just the same for women.

LadyOfLittleLeisure · 12/09/2021 09:34

@Ibizafun

I think I do have a right to decide who he’s friends with when it comes to single women he’s dated! Especially as he asked me how I felt. Can ask her to ours but it’s the prospect of friendship after I’m not sure I’m comfortable with
I really think you do not have this "right". At all.
Moonmagic24 · 12/09/2021 09:33

If 'it' goes through, imagine the day...
Excitement?
Will it be treated as a 'date' ?
Aftershave?
Special attire?
Extra spruced appearance?
Will the 'meeting' overrun?
Will personal feelings be explored and/or exercised?
Nothing is as harmless as it seems when two people are involved.
Curiosity can be so powerful leading some to opt for the high thrill aspect.
The other woman has NOTHING to lose.
*Please consider the poster, first and foremost. She is seeking support.

Ibizafun · 12/09/2021 09:32

Anyway quick update, asked dh to ask her here for coffee but told him I don’t feel comfortable with anything more (at this point anyway without knowing much about her). Dh’s reply was he can’t be bothered, definitely not bothered enough to risk upsetting me.

OP posts:
Hekatestorch · 12/09/2021 09:17

You're missing the point. As PP said, by this stage, they're desperate. Not for my man, for any man. They don't desire him in particular. It's just, "a man" finally. I find it really strange a few PP are pretending these women don't exist. They are pretty common.

Might be common in your circles. But they aren't in mine. Guess what must be common in your circles, shitty men.

Or maybe you are just paranoid?

And absolutely, the relentless pursuit and putting themselves on a plate, is deliberate and calculated. And should the man that's been targeted, ever, ever fall for it. Then they justify how they didn't do anything wrong, because "I'm not the one who broke my marriage vows"

Or the men could shut it down and cut contact with the woman. But they don't because they like the ego stroke. And yes, it's absolutely a man's fault if he steps over the line.

Just like it would be entirely my fault, if stepped over the line with any man, behind my dps back. Mine and mine alone.

Oh, do fuck off dear. Morals like that will be a big part of why you still remain single.

Your misogyny is really making you angry.

And just to clarify, of course he's done something wrong. But this is no "their eyes met across a crowded room" this is one person being selected then pursued by a desperate person. And desperate people know no bounds.

And what? Someone showing interest on uou or even getting g naked and throwing themselves on a table in crowded Starbucks, doesn't mean you have to.

If you can be worn down into cheating, you are a cheater and it's still you cheating.

How the fuck do men do anything if they can be worn down into piss poor behaviour? Is genuinely nothing their fault? Evil women, lurking to lead them astray?

They are adults. Not children

TwinsandTrifle · 12/09/2021 09:17

I do, it's called real world truth, rather than pretending on solely on MN that these people don't exist.

Chikapu · 12/09/2021 09:10

No. You're missing the point. As PP said, by this stage, they're desperate. Not for my man, for any man. They don't desire him in particular. It's just, "a man" finally. I find it really strange a few PP are pretending these women don't exist. They are pretty common

Wow, I have no words for that shitshow of a statement.

AgathaAllAlong · 12/09/2021 09:09

I'm also in the camp of if you need to keep him from seeing this woman to prevent an affair then he isn't the man for you. I wouldn't want to be with someone who is only with me because he's not had the chance for a few drinks with an ex from 30 years ago.

Think of it this way: in his mind she's this beautiful 20 year old with all these possibilities before them. Meeting her will dispel that image and replace it with the reality of now.

TwinsandTrifle · 12/09/2021 08:53

Even if not, it's pretty weird to think you're husband is just so undoubtedly sexy and irresistible than everyone is secretly pining over him

No. You're missing the point. As PP said, by this stage, they're desperate. Not for my man, for any man. They don't desire him in particular. It's just, "a man" finally. I find it really strange a few PP are pretending these women don't exist. They are pretty common.

And absolutely, the relentless pursuit and putting themselves on a plate, is deliberate and calculated. And should the man that's been targeted, ever, ever fall for it. Then they justify how they didn't do anything wrong, because "I'm not the one who broke my marriage vows"

Oh, do fuck off dear. Morals like that will be a big part of why you still remain single.

And just to clarify, of course he's done something wrong. But this is no "their eyes met across a crowded room" this is one person being selected then pursued by a desperate person. And desperate people know no bounds.

Chikapu · 12/09/2021 08:29

I hope I am wrong

No, you don't, you appear to be loving coming up with your little scenarios.

Hekatestorch · 12/09/2021 05:12

I know a number of middle-aged single women who are desperate for aman.Whojustify affairs by saying 'it isn't me who broke the marriage vows '.

Again, if the married man didn't want an affair, he could say no and cut her off if she started anything inappropriate.

An affair can't happen, here, unless the man always wants it.

The way some people describe single women (sad, desperate, dangerous, immoral) for just being single and the way men are being spoken about (helpless, can't help themselves if it's thrown at them, unable to say no and stick to their vows, poor poppets manipulated by scarring single women) is really really shocking.

DumplingsAndStew · 12/09/2021 01:17

Half the posters on here are fucking mentalists.

No-one even knows if the friend is single or not. She's probably more happily married than the OP and her husband. Even if not, it's pretty weird to think you're husband is just so undoubtedly sexy and irresistible than everyone is secretly pining over him, ready to make a move after 30 years.

I pit some of your husbands.

Cherryberrybonbon · 12/09/2021 00:33

I think you do have a right to say you don’t really want him to be friends with her if it makes you uncomfortable, it’s up to him if he decides to or not but you are allowed an opinion. Do you feel like this woman might be clutching at straws later in life and hoping to win him over?

faithfulbird20 · 12/09/2021 00:21

How would he feel if he was in your position?

I wouldn't feel comfortable at all and yes of course you do have say who he's mates with especially if they've dated before!

Branleuse · 11/09/2021 23:42

I think id be jealous

Hattie765 · 11/09/2021 23:34

@Ibizafun

I think I do have a right to decide who he’s friends with when it comes to single women he’s dated! Especially as he asked me how I felt. Can ask her to ours but it’s the prospect of friendship after I’m not sure I’m comfortable with
No you don't. If any of my friends told me their partner was trying to decide who they could be friends with I'd tell them to leave such a toxic relationship immediately. If you can't trust him to the point you need to ban him from seeing people you really need to examine whether this is the right relationship for you.
andweallsingalong · 11/09/2021 23:13

I voted Yabu because I think it's weird meeting just once. I'd say not at all or as a mutual friend....