Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU moving away from DP’s DD

236 replies

Dinodoodle · 11/09/2021 13:05

DP has been offered a new job which is an excellent opportunity for him, it’s a really good career move as well as paying an enormous amount more. The problem is that it’s based 300 miles away from DP’s DD. She’s 5, her parents split 3.5 years ago and DP and I have been together for 2.5 years. We have no other children and it’s very unlikely that we ever will.

We currently have DSD 1 night in the week and every other weekend, there’s also ad hoc other nights here and there when her mum has plans. DP and I have discussed how things could work if we were to move and so far the plan would be that he would travel back at least every 4 weeks (he’ll try and arrange it for every 3 though) and have her at his parents thur-mon. They both have bedrooms at theirs and DSD is very used to spending time there. Then she would come to us for the school holidays.

There is no doubt that taking the job will give DP the chance to provide more for his DD. He pays his ex well already (which he absolutely should) but this does mean that we are struggling to move forward with our lives. We private rent and are stuck in a tiny 1 bed flat, I sleep on the sofa when DSD stays and she sleeps in bed with DP. That obviously can’t go on for much longer. Moving will give us all more space, a proper garden, more money for activities, more money we can save for her, in future we’ll be able to buy a house that will eventually go to her and we can give her mum more for her day to day care.

If it comes to it I’m excited to go, I’ve always been a bit nomadic and enjoy adventure.

DP’s ex is going to go spare if/when he brings it up and I understand she has a right to be consulted and pissed off but are we being ridiculous to consider it? She has twice moved over an hour away for new relationships (that ended a short while after) and DP has just had to accept it and put in the extra effort to collect/drop off DD for access. It’s always him putting in the effort because ex doesn’t drive. She is an oddly controlling woman and kicks up a fuss over things that don’t even matter, so heaven knows how she’ll react to this. Example: she’s pregnant and we asked her the due date because we wanted to book a holiday and obviously don’t want to book in the weeks surrounding the birth as we expect to be needed to have DSD while she recovers/bonds in peace etc. Would she tell us? No. Cue incoming barrage about how it’s not our business and she doesn’t need our help etc etc. We’ve guessed and booked anyway but that’ll rear it’s head again.

Nothing is set, he is also in talks for a job much closer but we are genuinely torn. I’d hate to think we’re putting money over time with DSD but this is the real world and if you want things you have to go and get them.

OP posts:
Naunet · 11/09/2021 15:25

OP, what would you think if her mother announced she was moving 300 miles away so your DP would have to have DD full time from now on, and she’d come back to visit once a month. She doesn’t ask if you’re both ok with this new arrangement, just tells you what’s happening.

Would you think that was reasonable? Would you think she was a good mum? Would you be angry that she didn’t even ask you if you could both take on the extra childcare?

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 11/09/2021 15:23

I’m not sure the extra activities etc really will be extra given how little she will actually be there.
The benefits may suit you as a couple but his daughter will be the one who gets monthly visits only and no dad present in her day to day life for hobbies, school things etc.
You may find the other parent won’t accommodate the pattern he wants.

mocktail · 11/09/2021 15:21

I don't understand how he can even consider it.

ZenNudist · 11/09/2021 15:18

Surely a wind up. If he really could move that far from his dd he'd be showing himself up as a pretty awful human being. Being able to support her financially is an excuse. To be a father you need to actually see your child and the shitty arrangements proposed here about seeing every 3 weeks are woefully insufficient.

The decent thing to do is find a much closer job.

You sound really selfish supporting this. I hate SM bashing where its said "you know what you're getting into", but really when you attach yourself to a man with a child by another woman you are giving up adventure and nomadic wandering.

Dinodoodle · 11/09/2021 15:16

@SpaceshiptoMars

Is it a drive or can you fly? Mum may object to you grabbing all of the main holidays - you get the fun stuff, she gets the daily grind. You'd need to be pretty fair and generous with maintenance to cover extra childcare, or you'll make an enemy from the off. Not sure that 'buying the child back' with a house is a guarantee of success - gratitude is a glacially slow growing virtue! As long as you are aware that she might take the goodies and run - and can handle that - you could end up quite heartbroken if that happened.
If mum is unhappy with that then it needs to be looked at again. It’s just an idea at this stage. She’s with us for longer periods during school holidays normally anyway so mum has a longer break/holidays etc. As others have said it’ll probably get harder as she gets older and has friends and so on that she’d rather see.

I don’t expect DSD to care anything about house purchase etc now of course, im not a thinking of buying her back. Just about having more to offer long term.

OP posts:
DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 11/09/2021 15:12

@Rach888 you're seeing things with rose tinted glasses on. You were a child at the time. You had the best of both worlds because your Mum made it so. The fact you can't see that means she did a great job.

Would you be happy if you and your dp split and you had to enforce all the bedtimes, deal with all the illnesses, homework etc and he swooped in on the holidays for all the fun stuff? Really?

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 11/09/2021 15:08

[quote Rach888]@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken you are coming across very close minded. And what a sweeping statement to make about parents who move away from their children. My opinion is based on my actual life and experiences so I am more than entitled to it. My mother is a feminist and a very strong woman who has raised me to be the same - to say I am basing my argument on misogyny is so far removed from the truth it’s quite laughable. But you MUST be correct as you know me so well and cannot take ANY other opinions on board. I’m going out now so unfortunately cannot waste my time further on this.

P.s: not all fathers / men are evil ;)[/quote]
My ex moved a long way away when DS was 8. DS hasn't suffered for it but that's because I worked very hard to make sure he didn't. I spent a fortune and travelled thousands of miles (3 countries and back again in 36 hours on one memorable occasion) to facilitate their time together. I am also a feminist.
The reason we are calling this misogyny is because it all falls on the shoulders of the mother to fill in the gaps when men like my ex, your dad and the OP's partner fuck off miles away from their kids then men get absolved with comments like yours that you never suffered for it.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 11/09/2021 15:08

I have already said this is a shitty thing to do and I would say exactly the same if it was the mum moving with a child that far from the father. However there was a recent thread where someone wanted to do exactly that and whilst some posters thought it was awful there was a lot who suggested the mum should go for it and it was up to the dad to either travel or move if he wished to continue seeing his dc on a regular basis. Interesting to once again seeing the difference MN puts on things based on which parent it is.

BungleandGeorge · 11/09/2021 15:05

If you have a one bed flat why don’t you just put the daughter in the living room? She’s only young so it’s not a problem if that’s the only space you have. I’d much rather do that and have a proper relationship with her.
Once you have a child together I think you really do need to stay within reasonable distance of the other parent apart from in exceptional circumstances. I believe courts can stop RP from moving hundreds of miles away and I’m pretty sure they wouldn’t grant whatever suits your partner as he is choosing to move

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 11/09/2021 15:00

[quote Rach888]@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken you are coming across very close minded. And what a sweeping statement to make about parents who move away from their children. My opinion is based on my actual life and experiences so I am more than entitled to it. My mother is a feminist and a very strong woman who has raised me to be the same - to say I am basing my argument on misogyny is so far removed from the truth it’s quite laughable. But you MUST be correct as you know me so well and cannot take ANY other opinions on board. I’m going out now so unfortunately cannot waste my time further on this.

P.s: not all fathers / men are evil ;)[/quote]
You couldn’t imagine leaving your child. Think about why that is. What feelings do you have for them that this man clearly doesn’t?

AuntieStella · 11/09/2021 14:59

There must be something in between moving 300 miles and staying and living in a 1-bed flat

Exactly

he is also in talks for a job much closer

Good - that is the best outcome here.

300 miles is too far. Little and often is a better pattern

HalzTangz · 11/09/2021 14:57

Could he not take the job but fly there on a Monday, lodge and fly back on a Friday, at least for a few years until the child is more at an age to travel 300 miles EOW. I think it's unfair to cut her visits to one weekend a month, and unfair to expect to have her for every school holiday

saraclara · 11/09/2021 14:57

This is just terrible timing I'm afraid. For her dad to move so far away at the same time as she's displaced by a new baby, is about as bad as it gets for a five year old.

You think you have lovely plans for how he will spend time with her, but those plans depend on cooperation from her mum, and I would bet anything that she punishes you both for this decision, and makes contact as difficult as possible.

Rach888 · 11/09/2021 14:53

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken you are coming across very close minded. And what a sweeping statement to make about parents who move away from their children. My opinion is based on my actual life and experiences so I am more than entitled to it. My mother is a feminist and a very strong woman who has raised me to be the same - to say I am basing my argument on misogyny is so far removed from the truth it’s quite laughable. But you MUST be correct as you know me so well and cannot take ANY other opinions on board. I’m going out now so unfortunately cannot waste my time further on this.

P.s: not all fathers / men are evil ;)

LividLaVidaLoca · 11/09/2021 14:52

NRTFT but you are SO out of order to encourage this.

Cuddlemonsters · 11/09/2021 14:52

I wouldn’t move this far away. 300miles is too far. I’d keep looking for a better paid job closer to home. Money is important but so is time. There is always a balance to be had, but this is too extreme a swing.

Recessed · 11/09/2021 14:52

If he only has his DD one night a week and no other responsibilities he has ample time to progress his career in another direction - there's really no excuse here.

AdriannaP · 11/09/2021 14:51

@Clymene

Look for another job. You can't move 300 miles away from a 5 year old. I'm sorry his child is such a burden and impacting on his career. Most normal people wouldn't even apply for a job that far from their child.
100% this. So what if he earns more money. Do you think her childhood will be better by spending more time with her parent or having a fairly absent parent but lots more toys and clothes. Also long term how is visiting at his parents going to work. Do you expect them to house him and her for the next 13 years? Let’s say they sell or die where and when would he see his DD. All seems very selfish to me and very convenient how you told yourself it’s even better for her as dad will have more money. If I was the ex I would go ballistic too - basically she will have to do 85% of the parenting going forward.
JustLyra · 11/09/2021 14:51

If he does this he'd have to be prepared for his relationship with his daughter to change massively.

I know someone who is a four hour journey away from his son after allowing his ex to move back to her hometown when she was struggling massively with a family situation.

They have a super agreeable co-parenting relationship. The ex allows him to stay in her house every month (she goes to her Mum), she also facilitates Facetime most days and she gives him the pick of the school holidays so he always can get the time off.

Even with that level of working together it's difficult. He doesn't have that day-to-day hands on relationship with his daughter and he is always torn between regretting agreeing and knowing it was the right thing at that time.

Recessed · 11/09/2021 14:51

There's barely a mother in the land who would even consider taking a job that means they'd only see their children once a month.

I could never be attracted to a man who did this. Justify it all you like but It's the height of selfish. If he's smart/hardworking he'll find another way of earning more money. I think it's appalling personally but as so many useless men do it, I'm sure he'll convince himself it's perfectly fine.

Hulkynothunky · 11/09/2021 14:50

You sound like you are trying to justify this to yourself. I'm sorry but this is plain wrong. Father's in children's lives are just as important as mother's. Can you imagine the comments on here/in RL if her mum was moving so far away?

He will just have to find a better paid job closer to home. She's 5, it's too far.

I'm sorry if this sounds brutal but I don't think he should even be considering it.

AcrossthePond55 · 11/09/2021 14:50

I think the decision is up to DP, I'd stay out of it if I were OP.

But here's no way it's remotely realistic for his DD to travel 300 miles EOW. That's a 6-7 hour drive just for her, let alone 2 round trips for DP. So to provide continuity, DP will have to be willing/able to take off work early and EOW travel 600 miles (round trip) himself and, unless he has family to put him up, pay for a hotel for 2-3 nights in order to see his DD. And OP will have to deal with either being without him during that period or travel with him. That's going to get old real fast and is going to be pretty pricy. And if DP wants to change access to having DD for school holidays instead, he's going to face a fight (sounds like) with his ex. Now you're talking money for a court battle.

OP needs to factor all these extra expenses to the increase in wages for DP.

CrossUniStudent · 11/09/2021 14:50

When you have kids sometimes you have to make sacrifices and that often includes in your career until they're a bit older.

My dad moved 300 miles away when I was in my twenties. It's a 5 hr drive, we hardly see each other, covid didn't help and i resent the fact he didn't want to stay close enough to be a part of mine and my kids lives. So I dread to think how a 5 yo growing up would feel about it.

ejhhhhh · 11/09/2021 14:49

Sorry, that was a bit garbled, but you get the jist!

ejhhhhh · 11/09/2021 14:48

Yes he could put the effort it to make it work, and his DD may be fine, as has been the case for some PP. But it wasn't for me, and it could be a red flag. The OP has only been in a relationship with him for 8 months, maybe he is really a selfish arseholes and this behaviour is a snapshot of that? My mum always said she didn't realise he was horrible until she married and lived with him, despite knowing he'd already abandoned his children from his first marriage (he moved away from them and hardny say them, just as he did with us). Maybe if my mum had seen that as the indicator of character that it was, she'd have saved herself years of pain and a messy divorce? Leaving your kids it's always going mean the guy's a wrongun, but it can.