Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU moving away from DP’s DD

236 replies

Dinodoodle · 11/09/2021 13:05

DP has been offered a new job which is an excellent opportunity for him, it’s a really good career move as well as paying an enormous amount more. The problem is that it’s based 300 miles away from DP’s DD. She’s 5, her parents split 3.5 years ago and DP and I have been together for 2.5 years. We have no other children and it’s very unlikely that we ever will.

We currently have DSD 1 night in the week and every other weekend, there’s also ad hoc other nights here and there when her mum has plans. DP and I have discussed how things could work if we were to move and so far the plan would be that he would travel back at least every 4 weeks (he’ll try and arrange it for every 3 though) and have her at his parents thur-mon. They both have bedrooms at theirs and DSD is very used to spending time there. Then she would come to us for the school holidays.

There is no doubt that taking the job will give DP the chance to provide more for his DD. He pays his ex well already (which he absolutely should) but this does mean that we are struggling to move forward with our lives. We private rent and are stuck in a tiny 1 bed flat, I sleep on the sofa when DSD stays and she sleeps in bed with DP. That obviously can’t go on for much longer. Moving will give us all more space, a proper garden, more money for activities, more money we can save for her, in future we’ll be able to buy a house that will eventually go to her and we can give her mum more for her day to day care.

If it comes to it I’m excited to go, I’ve always been a bit nomadic and enjoy adventure.

DP’s ex is going to go spare if/when he brings it up and I understand she has a right to be consulted and pissed off but are we being ridiculous to consider it? She has twice moved over an hour away for new relationships (that ended a short while after) and DP has just had to accept it and put in the extra effort to collect/drop off DD for access. It’s always him putting in the effort because ex doesn’t drive. She is an oddly controlling woman and kicks up a fuss over things that don’t even matter, so heaven knows how she’ll react to this. Example: she’s pregnant and we asked her the due date because we wanted to book a holiday and obviously don’t want to book in the weeks surrounding the birth as we expect to be needed to have DSD while she recovers/bonds in peace etc. Would she tell us? No. Cue incoming barrage about how it’s not our business and she doesn’t need our help etc etc. We’ve guessed and booked anyway but that’ll rear it’s head again.

Nothing is set, he is also in talks for a job much closer but we are genuinely torn. I’d hate to think we’re putting money over time with DSD but this is the real world and if you want things you have to go and get them.

OP posts:
C152 · 11/09/2021 18:52

This is very difficult, OP, but I'm afraid I agree with many other posters - it is unreasonable to move so far away from a child who is still so young. And whilst, yes, if you want something, you have to go and get it, I don't share the view that you put yourself before your child. (I know some people do, it's just not my choice.) I can fully appreciate the extra money would come in handy for all, but she won't be this little forever. If it were me, I would hang on in the lower paid job until my child was older, and look for another opportunity then.

The child's mum moving is really neither here nor there. Her decisions - whether they were poorly thought through or not - shouldn't factor into why your partner chooses to move (if he does).

itsgettingwierd · 11/09/2021 18:51

I'd say if it will help improve dd quality of life too then move.

But...... he needs to stick to EOW.

Whether he drives back Friday evening or flies or train or whatever he needs to keep to the contact. She's about to have a sibling and that can be hard for a child who's has 4 parents attention for a few years without 2 of them moving away at the same time.

Nayday · 11/09/2021 18:46

I think it's too far to really maintain a relationship. If you met a partner and hadn't moved in together and they moved this distance, this sort of distance would be a deal breaker for a relationship.
In the short term he'll see her but 300 miles (4-6 hours travel) isn't even really a distance that's easily doable in a weekend. For this to work he's going to need to be on good ground with his ex, and have excellent communication.

lobsteroll · 11/09/2021 18:44

I'd be questioning why he would be satisfied with only seeing his daughter once a month.

I think it's great on one hand that he wants to earn more to provide for her but not at the expense of spending time with her.

These next few years will pass in a flash and he'll never get this time again with her. It's honestly not worth it for a better job/house/holidays etc. Kids don't care about that stuff, even when they seem like they do and they are asking for this that and the other, deep down they would always choose time with their parents over anything else.

Chailatteplease · 11/09/2021 18:43

@TeetleTottle

I’m really surprised by the responses here. A typical arrangement of EOW is 4 days a month, and the OP is proposing Thur-Mon every 3-4 weeks which is still 4 days a month, plus part of the holidays.

I think typical arrangements are shocking and I'm amazed that women put up with it. If I split from my children's father he will be having them 50%.

On that basis he is totally unreasonable. Just because he is the non resident parent doesn't mean he gets to move 300miles away. He is still equally responsible.

Agreed. Fathers have 50% rights, they should also have 50% responsibility.
Doggiedementia · 11/09/2021 18:41

That’s a dick move.

I also notice one of the first things you said when you were describing what you did with the little girl was that you spent your money on her.

JustLyra · 11/09/2021 18:41

@PineappleMojito

I’ve definitely seen threads on here where a mum has wanted to move far away from an ex partner with the child and been better supported. So it seems for a lot (but not all) posters here, dads can’t move away, but mums can, even though the net effect of reduced contact with the father is the same, it matters more which parent made the decision to move. If mum wants to take the kid further away from dad, cool and not at all damaging. If dad wants to move further away from kid, not cool and very damaging. That’s kinda how I’ve seen it go down. Can’t say I’ve ever seen a thread where a non resident mum wanted to move further away, but that doesn’t mean they haven’t existed.
The only time I’ve ever seen anyone supported to move away from the other parent was when the other parent wasn’t involved anyway.

Even one thread when the Mum wanted to move away and the Dad saw the kid one Saturday a month had a lot of people bluntly pointing out that she should facilitate that Saturday by doing the travel.

If the mum was moving without the child they’d be lambasted way more than the OP’s DP is getting.

PineappleMojito · 11/09/2021 18:38

I’ve definitely seen threads on here where a mum has wanted to move far away from an ex partner with the child and been better supported. So it seems for a lot (but not all) posters here, dads can’t move away, but mums can, even though the net effect of reduced contact with the father is the same, it matters more which parent made the decision to move. If mum wants to take the kid further away from dad, cool and not at all damaging. If dad wants to move further away from kid, not cool and very damaging. That’s kinda how I’ve seen it go down. Can’t say I’ve ever seen a thread where a non resident mum wanted to move further away, but that doesn’t mean they haven’t existed.

Maskedstranger · 11/09/2021 18:36

@icedcoffees

It’s 25k more than he is on now and the position he’s worked for for 15 years! It is very difficult to just disregard that kind of money and to not even try to find a way that we could make it work.

Why doesn't he approach his boss and see if he can negotiate a pay rise?

Yes, 25k is a good amount of money but a 5yo child has no concept of that. She just wants her dad. And her dad can't move 300 miles away without dumping a good chunk of his responsibilities onto his ex.

Things like: doctors appointments, dentists appointments, sick days, sports days, school plays, the nativity place, INSET days, shopping for school shoes and uniforms, helping with homework, facilitating playdates and after school activities, doing the school run...

How can he do any of those things from 300 miles away?

Sadly, I doubt the dad does many of those things now, when he is local. Most non-resident dads don't, in fact most resident dads don't either. Angry
Dissimilitude · 11/09/2021 18:36

If the money is THAT much more, I'd do it, but only if I could afford to travel that 300 miles more frequently than once a month.

Plenty of people work in my industry spend half their time in London (which is a lot more than 300 miles away from where I am).

It's less the distance, it's the infrequency of coming back.

JustLyra · 11/09/2021 18:34

@Blueroses99

I’m really surprised by the responses here. A typical arrangement of EOW is 4 days a month, and the OP is proposing Thur-Mon every 3-4 weeks which is still 4 days a month, plus part of the holidays.

Sounds like a good opportunity and the DH doesn’t have to do it forever, it could be worth doing even for a year or two for the experience and to save the funds to buy a bigger place near the DD.

Expecting the DD to do a 600 mile round trip EOW would be madness but that isn’t being proposed as DH would do all the travelling.

Looks like there a few options OP, work through them and work out what’s best for your family. The distance does not need to damage the father-daughter relationship irreparably.

Typical arrangements are EOW and an evening in the week - which is what they currently do as well as ad hoc nights.

The proposal would completely change the regularity and closeness of the relationship. To not benefit of the child, hence the reactions.

It’s walking away from anything other than once a month contact.

ittakes2 · 11/09/2021 18:31

I think you will have to get the mum to agree with the change in care and it sounds unlikely don't you think?

TeetleTottle · 11/09/2021 18:29

I’m really surprised by the responses here. A typical arrangement of EOW is 4 days a month, and the OP is proposing Thur-Mon every 3-4 weeks which is still 4 days a month, plus part of the holidays.

I think typical arrangements are shocking and I'm amazed that women put up with it. If I split from my children's father he will be having them 50%.

On that basis he is totally unreasonable. Just because he is the non resident parent doesn't mean he gets to move 300miles away. He is still equally responsible.

Gazelda · 11/09/2021 18:29

It sounds like a great opportunity which will have many benefits for your DP, you and his DD in the future.

However, I'm afraid it's just not the right time.

She's 5
Her parents split when she was a toddler
She moved away with her DM moved twice and then moved back again
Her DF met a new partner
She's started school during a pandemic
There's a new sibling on the way
Relations between her parents aren't easy
I presume her DM has a new partner? Has she had any other BFs between the split from your DP?

That's too much for a child to experience without being affected. A 300mile move will not have a positive impact on her right now.

user1471442488 · 11/09/2021 18:27

Look, make your excuses and do what you clearly want to do.

If you can both live with the fact that he chose money over his child and that she’ll feel abandoned and let down then crack on. You can keep protesting but he’s a shit dad and you’re a selfish person. I love adventure ffs. Poor little girl…

Chailatteplease · 11/09/2021 18:26

It’s beyond selfish to even consider this. I can’t abide people who don’t put their children’s well-being first. You don’t just get to drop your responsibilities because of something you want to do. Disgusting.

Also, you’re wrong OP. People wouldn’t be shouting “you go girl” to the mother if she were proposing leaving her daughter for the majority of the month. You can’t begin to understand this, not being a parent yourself.

Blueroses99 · 11/09/2021 18:23

I’m really surprised by the responses here. A typical arrangement of EOW is 4 days a month, and the OP is proposing Thur-Mon every 3-4 weeks which is still 4 days a month, plus part of the holidays.

Sounds like a good opportunity and the DH doesn’t have to do it forever, it could be worth doing even for a year or two for the experience and to save the funds to buy a bigger place near the DD.

Expecting the DD to do a 600 mile round trip EOW would be madness but that isn’t being proposed as DH would do all the travelling.

Looks like there a few options OP, work through them and work out what’s best for your family. The distance does not need to damage the father-daughter relationship irreparably.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 11/09/2021 18:21

@Dinodoodle I think that probably helps the justification in your mind, my partner is in a similar situation where his parents divorced but he spent holidays with his Dad, they have a great relationship. Like I said I can't imagine it at all but that's based on my own upbringing.

But is your partner genuinely able to facilitate these monthly visits and holidays? Surely he is going to have to take a lot of unpaid leave so how does that effect the salary? Will his ex even agree to it as she then misses out on the 'fun' time?

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 11/09/2021 18:20

@Naunet

I do think you’d have had more support here if the gender was reversed tbh, sometimes on MN it feels like fathers can’t win

Really? You think a mother moving 300 miles away and seeing her children once a month, would get more support? I can’t imagine that to be honest.

I’d bet my life savings on those posters imagining that the mum would be taking the child with her. It won’t even occur to them the difference between a dad moving 300 miles away from their child and a mum moving 300 miles away with their child.

Because women are expected to do it all and be the default parent.

Ginger1982 · 11/09/2021 18:16

@icedcoffees

It’s 25k more than he is on now and the position he’s worked for for 15 years! It is very difficult to just disregard that kind of money and to not even try to find a way that we could make it work.

Why doesn't he approach his boss and see if he can negotiate a pay rise?

Yes, 25k is a good amount of money but a 5yo child has no concept of that. She just wants her dad. And her dad can't move 300 miles away without dumping a good chunk of his responsibilities onto his ex.

Things like: doctors appointments, dentists appointments, sick days, sports days, school plays, the nativity place, INSET days, shopping for school shoes and uniforms, helping with homework, facilitating playdates and after school activities, doing the school run...

How can he do any of those things from 300 miles away?

This ^
icedcoffees · 11/09/2021 18:13

It’s 25k more than he is on now and the position he’s worked for for 15 years! It is very difficult to just disregard that kind of money and to not even try to find a way that we could make it work.

Why doesn't he approach his boss and see if he can negotiate a pay rise?

Yes, 25k is a good amount of money but a 5yo child has no concept of that. She just wants her dad. And her dad can't move 300 miles away without dumping a good chunk of his responsibilities onto his ex.

Things like: doctors appointments, dentists appointments, sick days, sports days, school plays, the nativity place, INSET days, shopping for school shoes and uniforms, helping with homework, facilitating playdates and after school activities, doing the school run...

How can he do any of those things from 300 miles away?

BungleandGeorge · 11/09/2021 18:11

@Naunet

I do think you’d have had more support here if the gender was reversed tbh, sometimes on MN it feels like fathers can’t win

Really? You think a mother moving 300 miles away and seeing her children once a month, would get more support? I can’t imagine that to be honest.

I know what a joke, people would be much harsher on a mother moving 300 miles away from her child
Dinodoodle · 11/09/2021 18:09

@bogoffmda

That arrangement will last till you have children then DSD will be history and you will be on here - bemoaning Ex does not drive, you do not want him to go so soon aftr the birth, can DSD not come for two-three months whilst you bond as a new family, cost of petrol etc etc etc.

This has been on this forum so many times and no matter what way you put it - he is abandoning his child.

My EX moved 100 miles away - on a Friday in rush hour that could turn into a 3 hr trip down and 2 hr back for me to take them because he could not do it. So thethought of his EX - if she could - doing hald the travelling!!!!!

Ive already said we won’t be having kids, baring some kind of medical miracle. If children were an option for the future I don’t think we would consider moving because that is too much like running off to start a “new family” which is not what we want.
OP posts:
icedcoffees · 11/09/2021 18:06

[quote Suzi888]@icedcoffees you don’t know that. You don’t know her parents financial circumstances or anything about her life.
I’m the high earner in my HH, not DH. If he left, financially I’d be absolutely fine. 💪🏼 So would my child.[/quote]
I'm wasn't talking about finances though. I'm talking about time.

The PP couldn't have travelled via plane EOW without her mum facilitating it somehow - with airport runs and handing her over to the airline staff etc. Her dad also couldn't move hours away without her mum picking up the pieces at home.

esloquehay · 11/09/2021 18:01

300 miles? Jesus. My ex husband lives 160 miles away and only sees our twin 3.5 year olds once a month for 24 hours.
I do wonder how Mon-Thurs would work in the long term for DSD. It's next to no contact, but it's better than nothing, I guess? 🤷
If I were in your position, I'd want to move and take life forward! I wouldn't want to be held back by the existence of DSD.
But, the actual Dad? Of course he is happy to consider moving 300 miles away, as he does none of the grunt work and just gets to do the fun stuff, like all NRP without a 50/50 custody agreement.
Yeah, that move would really fuck with that little girl's head. But, you do what's best for you in the 'long term', as 5 year olds totally have the capacity to think ahead. 🙄