Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why a person who claims they have done 'extensive research'...

154 replies

Newrunner29 · 11/09/2021 09:37

...belives they are as knowledgeable as someone who has dedicated their career and have the relevant professional qualifications in a subject? It really fustrates me and makes me concerned for future.
I see on the Internet all the time this 'extensive research' line and think, what makes u more knowledgeable and also the line could literally mean anything.

I found this twitter feed which is loosely linked, even when confronted this person continues to spead misinformation. i would love to know why?
I would say there is a level of arrogance to it to.

To wonder why a person who claims they have done 'extensive research'...
OP posts:
Clymene · 11/09/2021 10:17

@OrganicBagel

But you don’t need qualifications to do your own research. What a cop out! I don’t need qualifications to research car safety. I don’t need to run my own crash test dummy trials or be a qualified engineer. I need to read the “research” that has already been done and THAT is my research. That’s what most research is! I work in a Uni research centre where academics do research which mainly involves reading results of trials and other people’s research papers and making their own conclusions, or analysing data from other people’s studies They don’t run the trials themselves but it doesn’t make them not researchers! I have a degree in statistics and policy analysis. I my doesn’t make me more or less of a researcher than someone who studied medicine or politics. Research isn’t a particular science! Anyone can do research. It is gathering data and information and making conclusions.
Most people don't have degrees in statistics and analysis. Most people are unable to internet scientific data. Googling is not research.

While most people can do enough research to make a decision on the best car seat to choose, this is about deciding that you don't need a car seat because 'I've done my research'. And disagreeing with scientists on the basis that 'I've done my research' is where tinfoil hattery flourishes

Pedalpushers · 11/09/2021 10:15

@OrganicBagel

But you don’t need qualifications to do your own research. What a cop out! I don’t need qualifications to research car safety. I don’t need to run my own crash test dummy trials or be a qualified engineer. I need to read the “research” that has already been done and THAT is my research. That’s what most research is! I work in a Uni research centre where academics do research which mainly involves reading results of trials and other people’s research papers and making their own conclusions, or analysing data from other people’s studies They don’t run the trials themselves but it doesn’t make them not researchers! I have a degree in statistics and policy analysis. I my doesn’t make me more or less of a researcher than someone who studied medicine or politics. Research isn’t a particular science! Anyone can do research. It is gathering data and information and making conclusions.
Yes, but does the average person know where to find the studies, how to ensure they have collected all the information available, how to analyse the work to assess which ones should be included and which ones shouldn't, which ones have higher levels of evidence, which ones have correct statistical analysis, which ones are underpowered to draw conclusions from, etc etc?
SecretSpAD · 11/09/2021 10:15

@Cuddlyrottweiler

I wish more people did their own research and made their own decisions rather than just accepting what they're told as fact. I don't like how easily people accept what they're told and obey people they've been told are above them. I think we train people from a young age to not challenge authority and it worries me.
There's a difference between challenging authority and being so arrogant that you think that your 5 mins of googling means that you are more superior to the person with the medical degree, postgraduate qualifications and 30 years experience.

Yes I'm talking to you Mr X from 3pm yesterday.

Droite · 11/09/2021 10:14

@OrganicBagel

But you don’t need qualifications to do your own research. What a cop out! I don’t need qualifications to research car safety. I don’t need to run my own crash test dummy trials or be a qualified engineer. I need to read the “research” that has already been done and THAT is my research. That’s what most research is! I work in a Uni research centre where academics do research which mainly involves reading results of trials and other people’s research papers and making their own conclusions, or analysing data from other people’s studies They don’t run the trials themselves but it doesn’t make them not researchers! I have a degree in statistics and policy analysis. I my doesn’t make me more or less of a researcher than someone who studied medicine or politics. Research isn’t a particular science! Anyone can do research. It is gathering data and information and making conclusions.
The clue there lies in the fact that it is academics who are doing the research - i.e. people who already have qualifications in the relevant area who are able to pick out what is good evidence and what isn't.

The problem lies with people with no real understanding of the subject doing their research on the internet and being unable to pick out the rubbish from what is valid. And it becomes worse when they approach their "research" with a bias, so they automatically give more weight to anything which fits their own theories.

KittenKong · 11/09/2021 10:14

I love twitter sometimes...

And looking at twitter isn’t ‘research’ in any sense of the word...

Bewareoftheblob · 11/09/2021 10:13

@Newrunner29

'Just accepting what they're told as fact'
This is my point. Surely we need facts to be accepted! And not everyone who speaks are telling facts. They might believe they are but doesnt mean they are. And now with social media literacy anyone can say anything and claim it as fact, so dangerous!

Even among experts, opinions differ. What's wrong with being willing to think critically and engage with the debate? I'm not suggesting that the person in your image is a good example of that, but still.

Pedalpushers · 11/09/2021 10:12

Doing research is a skill that in itself takes years of training to master. It frightens me that people think googling is research.

LittleBearPad · 11/09/2021 10:11

Extensive research usually means ‘googling’ something.

It’s asinine not to accept facts. You can question the interpretation of facts but by definition facts are accurate.

Droite · 11/09/2021 10:11

See also legal advice on social media. Sometimes it's really scary how people are willing to advise others on the basis of no knowledge at all - if people followed the advice they could lose out on their rights or get into serious trouble.

OrganicBagel · 11/09/2021 10:10

But you don’t need qualifications to do your own research. What a cop out! I don’t need qualifications to research car safety. I don’t need to run my own crash test dummy trials or be a qualified engineer. I need to read the “research” that has already been done and THAT is my research. That’s what most research is! I work in a Uni research centre where academics do research which mainly involves reading results of trials and other people’s research papers and making their own conclusions, or analysing data from other people’s studies They don’t run the trials themselves but it doesn’t make them not researchers! I have a degree in statistics and policy analysis. I my doesn’t make me more or less of a researcher than someone who studied medicine or politics. Research isn’t a particular science! Anyone can do research. It is gathering data and information and making conclusions.

Ponoka7 · 11/09/2021 10:10

@VioletCharlotte, GPs are gatekeepers of services. You might know more than your GP, but won't know more than your consultant. It's the very top specialists that these people are arguing with.
All the 'do you know what's in the vaccine' statements really pissed me off. We don't know what's in most of our commonly used drugs, or previously some foods. When it's said by people who take recreational drugs and go for dodgy cosmetic treatments, it's even more ludicrous.

GammyLeg · 11/09/2021 10:08

I love that Twitter exchange!

The problem isn’t people blindly obeying. The problem is people being arrogant enough to accept their research on Twitter supersedes empirical scientific study.

Newrunner29 · 11/09/2021 10:06

*literally

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 11/09/2021 10:06

"I don't like how easily people accept what they're told and obey people they've been told are above them. "

It's not about being above someone, it's about qualifications, experience and knowledge. If any of us contracted HIV, we wouldn't ignore the consultant. Those same consultants and immunologists are developing treatments against Covid, why suddenly don't we trust them? Likewise vets, mortgage advisors etc, we go to them for good reason. Most people have never thought about health, infectious diseases and medication before. A tiny bit if proper research, critical thinking would point them in the right direction. Lots of people already wore masks all day long. None of them were suffering from respiratory diseases or dropping through a lack of oxygen.

MLMbotsno · 11/09/2021 10:06

@Cuddlyrottweiler

I wish more people did their own research and made their own decisions rather than just accepting what they're told as fact. I don't like how easily people accept what they're told and obey people they've been told are above them. I think we train people from a young age to not challenge authority and it worries me.
Do you actually mean real research or flicking through social media listening to dissenting opinions against virologist, epidemiologists, doctors etc. 🤔
VioletCharlotte · 11/09/2021 10:05

Sometimes (not necessarily in this case) a patient who has carries out extensive research on their condition may well know a lot more than their GP. Look at all the women who are give poor advice about the menopause. Carrying out research is a good thing.

Smalldogbigdog · 11/09/2021 10:05

@Cuddlyrottweiler

I wish more people did their own research and made their own decisions rather than just accepting what they're told as fact. I don't like how easily people accept what they're told and obey people they've been told are above them. I think we train people from a young age to not challenge authority and it worries me.
For a lot of people, it's not possible for them to do their own research. They aren't capable of understanding complex scientific literature as they don't have the background knowledge and understanding, their lack of scientific vocabulary means they would need to put in a significant amount of time to understand individual papers, where they would still lack the background knowledge to know how to critically analyse the paper, check for biases and poor experimental design, as well as where it fits into the general scientific consensus. The average person needs to read about scientific research in layman's terms, where inevitably it can be misinterpreted and misconstrued.
Newrunner29 · 11/09/2021 10:05

And its not aboit being above them, its about someone spending years and years in this field and the other person having no experience just what they have read on the Internet regardless of the actuatecy (bad spelling)

OP posts:
YvesEveEave · 11/09/2021 10:05

Him not her*

Flowerlane · 11/09/2021 10:03

@Cuddlyrottweiler

I wish more people did their own research and made their own decisions rather than just accepting what they're told as fact. I don't like how easily people accept what they're told and obey people they've been told are above them. I think we train people from a young age to not challenge authority and it worries me.
Spot on, I totally agree. 👏👏
MLMbotsno · 11/09/2021 10:03

@Briony123

Social media is not always the home of intelligent debate...
This.

Intelligent, knowledgeable, trained individuals do attempt to correct the rubbish they spout but the stupid continue spreading misinformation.
I don't understand why people follow or listen to people on tik tok, YouTube etc and yet ignore medical experts trained in that field. They have bought into the whole conspiracy shit and often so far down the rabbit hole, maybe poor mental health or low intelligence or something lacking (critical thinking skills)...

Newrunner29 · 11/09/2021 10:02

@Cuddlyrottweiler

I wish more people did their own research and made their own decisions rather than just accepting what they're told as fact. I don't like how easily people accept what they're told and obey people they've been told are above them. I think we train people from a young age to not challenge authority and it worries me.
'Just accepting what they're told as fact' This is my point. Surely we need facts to be accepted! And not everyone who speaks are telling facts. They might believe they are but doesnt mean they are. And now with social media literacy anyone can say anything and claim it as fact, so dangerous!
OP posts:
AgathaX · 11/09/2021 10:02

I think there's more far too much challenging of people who know far more, often those in authority because they've earned that right with their knowledge (although of not always!), by people who know bugger all on a subject but just like the sound of their own choices.

YvesEveEave · 11/09/2021 10:00

Tbf that person says their qualifications are too numerous to list...so I mean, there's a teeny chance they have two degrees, one being medicine and one being natural sciences with a heavy dose of virology and the human immune system, plus a masters in politics and governance with a focus on public health. Probably not though Grin

Why people think they know more than doctors when it comes to medicine is a complicated question. Occasionally they do! One of my siblings and both of my parents were doctors and nurses. The younger doctor always says people ask her for a diagnosis or a comment thinking he knows EVERYTHING and he always says to me that doctors are just human and not all knowing. They can do a lot, but clearly they aren't perfect.

Why people think they know more about the vaccine program / mask wearing and covid restriction in particular is a weird one. Because they aren't saying they know more than one doctor, (it's possible that a patient might know more about their own rare condition than one particular doctor for example). But these people are saying they know more than huge numbers of doctors, scientists and other experts. Also, I honestly think mental health is a factor or possible personality disorders. Narcissistic behaviour, (I know more than anyone else about this) or anxiety (I'm so scared of dying after vaccination).

Cuddlyrottweiler · 11/09/2021 09:57

I wish more people did their own research and made their own decisions rather than just accepting what they're told as fact. I don't like how easily people accept what they're told and obey people they've been told are above them. I think we train people from a young age to not challenge authority and it worries me.