Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to allow ex to take dc on this holiday?

487 replies

MrsBede · 10/09/2021 23:20

They are 12 &14 and in the 7 years since we split he has never taken them on holiday alone, though they've been twice in the UK when his dm organised it. Now he's inherited a substantial sum and messaged me tonight asking if he could take them away in October half-term. I asked which dates (they have 2 weeks off) and he said all of it as he wants to go abroad.

Ds1 was sitting next to me at the time and immediately said no as he really doesn't want to miss any school if he had to isolate on return. I messaged back to that effect but I'm livid he would take them for the full two weeks. I have never taken them so that he hasn't had them at all in any one holiday and I think it's unacceptable. He has them one night a week and eow, but often cancels if he has a gig. Term time is full on and we need the holiday time to reconnect (I'm a teacher). Just why should he think he should have the full holiday?

The other thing that really annoys me is he goes to Italy to visit friends every autumn and many a time when they were younger this has put me in the shit with child care as he does it at short notice. He obviously just wants to take them there and it's two weeks as that's how long he wants to go for, It's not a touristy place, there's not a lot there and they don't know his friends. I just think it's an utterly selfish idea and he's not replied to my text, which has put me on edge and I know ds is also worried about having said no. Ds2 doesn't see why they couldn't go. AIBU to think he's a selfish prick?

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 11:06

@Getyourarseofffthequattro

I didn’t say she did all the childcare - clearly she didn’t when she was at work. But she did everything else.

There’s far more to SAHParenting than childminding, which to OP’s ex, includes leaving DS2 on his phone for hours.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 11:03

@KaycePollard

Ive been a SAHP for a stretch when my kids were small. But I didn’t refuse to return to work, have an affair, then have patchy work history of continually leaving and being let go from jobs, and failing to pay for my kids for 6 years.

This. People should read the Op’s posts. Her ex sounds like a self-centred workshy cadger.

Nobody is disputing that. But that doesn't mean it should be taken out on his children, nor does it mean money owed to him should not be paid.
KaycePollard · 12/09/2021 11:01

Ive been a SAHP for a stretch when my kids were small. But I didn’t refuse to return to work, have an affair, then have patchy work history of continually leaving and being let go from jobs, and failing to pay for my kids for 6 years.

This. People should read the Op’s posts. Her ex sounds like a self-centred workshy cadger.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 11:01

@MrsBede

The reason she has to pay him out is BECAUSE he was a sahp. The rest is irrelevant to the settlement.

No, the reason I had to pay him out was because we were married and the assets of the marriage had to be split. He got just under 50% because he didn't want the pension and my solicitor said the judge would have been okay with that because the children were mainly with me and they are the priority. He would have got that had he been working. Sahps aren't entitled to a windfall for that or to be supported after, though they are of course entitled to a portion of the assets. Sahps are expected to support themselves after the marriage unless the spouse was absolutely loaded or other extenuating circumstances, of which there were none in our case.

Yes, but sahps are entitled to earnings of the marriage. Which this is. I expect if you'd been SAHP you'd have expected to get it. And rightly so.
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 11:00

[quote TatianaBis]@Getyourarseofffthequattro

I’m well aware how settlements work for SAHP. Generally the SAHP can go for primary custody. But he didn’t. Because he wasn’t so much a SAHP by choice as couldn’t be arsed to get a job. He didn’t want to look after his kids FT.

OP did the graft of primary carer/domestic work while working FT.[/quote]
Again now can she have done child care when she wasn't physically there?

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 11:00

@MrsBede

but unless you raised it with cms at the time there is nothing you can do about it now.

I raised it about 4 years ago and they won't chase arrears. Sorry, but you're an apologist for shit fathers.

No, I'm not I just know how the CMS works. I know they won't chase arrears because my own mother is still owed money from when I was a child. I'm being realistic. Does it help you for people to lie and say yes you can definitely get this money? No. It doesn't. If you want to believe you can then fine but you simply won't get it.

I'm not saying it's right but it's true.

TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 11:00

@Getyourarseofffthequattro

I’m well aware how settlements work for SAHP. Generally the SAHP can go for primary custody. But he didn’t. Because he wasn’t so much a SAHP by choice as couldn’t be arsed to get a job. He didn’t want to look after his kids FT.

OP did the graft of primary carer/domestic work while working FT.

MrsBede · 12/09/2021 10:58

but unless you raised it with cms at the time there is nothing you can do about it now.

I raised it about 4 years ago and they won't chase arrears. Sorry, but you're an apologist for shit fathers.

OP posts:
MrsBede · 12/09/2021 10:56

The reason she has to pay him out is BECAUSE he was a sahp. The rest is irrelevant to the settlement.

No, the reason I had to pay him out was because we were married and the assets of the marriage had to be split. He got just under 50% because he didn't want the pension and my solicitor said the judge would have been okay with that because the children were mainly with me and they are the priority. He would have got that had he been working. Sahps aren't entitled to a windfall for that or to be supported after, though they are of course entitled to a portion of the assets. Sahps are expected to support themselves after the marriage unless the spouse was absolutely loaded or other extenuating circumstances, of which there were none in our case.

OP posts:
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 10:54

If a woman inherited 250k there is no way on god's green earth anyone would think that her ex no longer owed her money. None at all. We all know that. Because it's a seperate issue.

And yes, it would be great if he paid for uni but you cannot force him. And yes it's very crap he paid no maintenance but unless you raised it with cms at the time there is nothing you can do about it now.

You know he is shit. You're jealous he's come into money but you're for some reason expecting him to completely change? Why? People like that don't change. You're only torturing yourself.

MrsBede · 12/09/2021 10:51

Thanks for understanding what I'm saying 'TatianaBis* Flowers.

I'm getting a bit sick of the selective reading on here and saying if he was a woman it would be different is ridiculous. If a woman behaved exactly like him I'd say the same, but most don't. I've read threads on here about sahms wanting to leave and being anxious about how they will support their kids, squirreling money away etc. He merrily strolled out without a thought for that into a shared house where they couldn't stay. He had no desire whatsoever to be the rp. He did not give up work to be a sahp - for a while the p/t work that fitted in with it continued then he lost that and did nothing to replace it. When I had a year off to have ds2 he refused to work and focused instead on his band. We got into debt. When he left he did get quite a decent job but I didn't ask for any money as we were adjusting to being split and I didn't want to rock the boat. However, then the novelty wore off and he lost the job and employment has been sporadic ever since, He is not the typical sahp.

This 'if he was a woman' is tiresome and ignores a large portion of the facts. I don't think he owes me from when he was a sahp but it's disgusting that he made no effort to pay for the 6 years after that and I don't think anyone would condone a woman doing that either unless her husband had been abusive leaving her with mental health issues or something. That isn't the case here.

I worry all the time about paying for uni and if he would email me saying 'I've come into some money and am putting some aside for boys' uni' I would be absolutely delighted. He won't though and may well piss what he has up the wall by then and I will have to fund it myself then hand him over £10 k immediately after. But yeah, if he was a woman everyone would say that was fine.

HandScreen You are projecting.

OP posts:
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 10:49

@KaycePollard

Do you say that to divorced men who paid out sahms?

Did you miss the bit where the OP said that her supposedly SAHP ex husband considered HER to be the main carer and expected her to do most of the domestic labour of child care and housework even though she worked full time?

You’re getting a really hard time here @MrsBede maybe from women who think that anything a man does domestically deserves a standing ovation.

But your DC will see through their father’s selfish laziness.

And how did she do that if she was working ft? He cared for the children while she was working ft. Clearly a court agreed the settlement. Him coming into money now years later changes nothing.

I don't agree he deserves a standing ovation. I simply believe he should be treated in the same way as a female sahp for settlement purposes. That's all I'm saying.

KaycePollard · 12/09/2021 10:47

Do you say that to divorced men who paid out sahms?

Did you miss the bit where the OP said that her supposedly SAHP ex husband considered HER to be the main carer and expected her to do most of the domestic labour of child care and housework even though she worked full time?

You’re getting a really hard time here @MrsBede maybe from women who think that anything a man does domestically deserves a standing ovation.

But your DC will see through their father’s selfish laziness.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 10:47

@DelphiniumBlue

As his circumstances have changed so dramatically, might it be worth you taking legal advice to see if the agreement to pay him more when DS2 reaches 18 can be changed?
Doubtful. This is nothing to do with earnings of the marriage. Cheeky to even ask really.
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 10:46

@TatianaBis

He was a SAHP? Do you think SAHMs are workshy? Or just men?

Ive been a SAHP for a stretch when my kids were small. But I didn’t refuse to return to work, have an affair, then have patchy work history of continually leaving and being let go from jobs, and failing to pay for my kids for 6 years.

Perhaps you have low expectations but I expect parents to financially support their kids.

The reason she has to pay him out is BECAUSE he was a sahp. The rest is irrelevant to the settlement.

I don't have low expectations I just understand how settlements work when one parent doesn't work.

TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 10:33

@Feelingoktoday read the following posts Hmm

DelphiniumBlue · 12/09/2021 10:31

As his circumstances have changed so dramatically, might it be worth you taking legal advice to see if the agreement to pay him more when DS2 reaches 18 can be changed?

Feelingoktoday · 12/09/2021 10:30

@TatianaBis

Pay to get rid of?

I’d say that to anyone with a workshy self indulgent partner who didn’t pay their way with their kids.

Perhaps you condone not supporting kids you’ve brought into the world.

He was the SAHP. Hope you say that to the many women that give up work to look after the kids. I don’t usually defend men in life but I’ve never known a man to walk away from a marriage where the wife was a SAHP and pay just £10k to. “Get rid of”. Appalling use of language.
TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 10:27

He was a SAHP? Do you think SAHMs are workshy? Or just men?

Ive been a SAHP for a stretch when my kids were small. But I didn’t refuse to return to work, have an affair, then have patchy work history of continually leaving and being let go from jobs, and failing to pay for my kids for 6 years.

Perhaps you have low expectations but I expect parents to financially support their kids.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 10:14

@TatianaBis

Pay to get rid of?

I’d say that to anyone with a workshy self indulgent partner who didn’t pay their way with their kids.

Perhaps you condone not supporting kids you’ve brought into the world.

He was a SAHP? Do you think SAHMs are workshy? Or just men?

I don't condone not supporting children but being a stay at home parent is quite obviously NOT that.

Gross.

HandScreen · 12/09/2021 10:13

@MalFunkshun

I too am unclear why you’ve posted - you have already decided you’re NBU and seem to be using the thread to argue with your ex by proxy Confused

I just had lunch with my school friend today, where we reminisced about living as children with divorced mothers who were totally unable to put their feelings about their exes aside in front of us. We both had very fractured relationships with our fathers throughout our teenage years as a result. And we both felt a very heavy burden of needing to look after our mothers as a result. How did that manifest? By agreeing with them that our dads were a waste of space, that we didn’t want to spend time with them, that we’d much prefer to stay with our mums instead.

Be careful, OP. It’s highly unlikely that your boys haven’t picked up on your bitterness and aren’t feeling the pressure to look after you. The bitterness might be well founded, but that’s to do with YOUR relationship with him. It in no way gives you the right to influence THEIR relationship with him.

100% this
TatianaBis · 12/09/2021 10:13

Pay to get rid of?

I’d say that to anyone with a workshy self indulgent partner who didn’t pay their way with their kids.

Perhaps you condone not supporting kids you’ve brought into the world.

HandScreen · 12/09/2021 10:08

@MrsBede

you said that a kid had no valid passport....hence the abroad question

Yes, no valid one, in that he has an old one that I'm not renewing until travel abroad looks like a risk-free option.

Jesus. You are out of control.
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 10:07

You'd be perfectly happy still saving up the £10k for him, would you?

Er yes because I'd still owe him that! It's nothing to do with what he's now got. Why on earth do you think you shouldn't pay him back?

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 12/09/2021 10:06

@TatianaBis

I’m not sure why you’re getting such a hard time OP. It’s galling that someone you had to pay to get rid of, who declined to pay for his kids for 6 years comes into a windfall yet will never pay back what he owed and still may continue not to pay his way going forward.
Pay to get rid of?

Do you say that to divorced men who paid out sahms?

Somehow I bet you don't. The double standards on here are amazing.