Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should parents contribute?

88 replies

shoppingismydownfall · 10/09/2021 20:44

I'm aware this may be a contraversial topic. I work in social care and see children brought into the care system from all backgrounds, from the extremely wealthy to extremely poor. I'm not debating the rights and wrongs of social workers here.

My Aibu is, if it costs the local authority on average £3,000 per week to look after that child, should parents be financially assessed to contribute towards their care?

OP posts:
DonatellaVersace · 10/09/2021 21:35

No, I think it would lead to more abuse happening (just better hidden) and far less people would admit they can’t cope and it would be at the detriment to the children.

stinkycheeseman · 10/09/2021 21:32

@Simonjt

No, the priority should be the welfare of the child, not wasting both time and money trying to get a few quid from birth parents.
Possibly yes, but in all honesty this🔝
ThinWomansBrain · 10/09/2021 21:32

in theory, yes - but I think more would be spent on assessing .administering chasing than would actually raised from the process

Hekatestorch · 10/09/2021 21:27

Forgot to say in an ideal world nowhere near as many kids would need this.

And we would be reaching all those that we could.

The pandemic and panic over vulnerable children, attending due to their home lives or potentially never turning up again showed how badly those children were being failed.

Ibizan · 10/09/2021 21:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Hekatestorch · 10/09/2021 21:25

To be fair, we can't get absent parents to pay after a split. Not sure we could enforce this and not CMS.

If a parent is a poor parent, even though they are wealthy (so its not poverty related issues) to the point the child is removed, would they pay this? How much would pursuing it cost?

And if we pursue those payments, through the courts with fines or prison time, why not CMS dodgers?

I also think it would make people who are genuinely trying their best, but simply can not care for their children, less likely to seek help.

Women in DV situations are already terrified of having their children removed. They would then be terrified of having their children removed and then having less money to get out of the situation.

In an ideal world, yes, I think they should. But its so complicated and fraught with problems it wouldn't work.

drpet49 · 10/09/2021 21:24

* Parents should be made to. You choose to have kids, if you choose then not to look after them, you should be made to pay as much as you can.*

^I agree

WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly · 10/09/2021 21:23

This is an abhorrent thread.

Kneesaregood · 10/09/2021 21:21

*parent is unable to cope, obv!

Kneesaregood · 10/09/2021 21:21

Children are usually in the care of a local authority because the state has removed them against the wishes of the parent. Even those where it has been done voluntarily, I've never come across it where it has been the outcome a parent actually wanted - it's usually a last resort, where a child is unable to cope with parenting the child (eg if a child is caught up in CCE/CSE, or where their behaviour is putting other children in the house at risk, child on parent abuse etc)

Charging parents after such an extreme state intervention seems pretty brutal tbh.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 10/09/2021 21:17

The system can do pretty much fuck all about absent parents not contributing to their kids, then there's the reductions for every tiny little thing, job changes, hiding money from self employment, having their partner work while they look after any other kids... it would be a nightmare to enforce.

How would it work with separated parents?

How would it work if one child was removed and there are others still with the parent/s.

Crumpetsandhoney · 10/09/2021 21:14

It's an interesting question. And may have interesting impacts. When we attach a price to something it can become more prevalent - taking kids out of school during holidays just pay the fine and do it. Would Rich people just outsource problem kids or do they do it already like the boarding schools in jilly Cooper novels

MissM2912 · 10/09/2021 21:09

Ex foster carer here. I don’t think it would be unreasonable to expect birth parents to contribute to child’s expenses- things like clothes, hair cuts, Christmas presents- even if just as a token gesture.

shoppingismydownfall · 10/09/2021 21:07

Good point @Milkshake54

OP posts:
shoppingismydownfall · 10/09/2021 21:07

Just for example, I was raised in care and my parents were very comfortable finacially. Why shouldn't they contribute?

OP posts:
sycamoresue · 10/09/2021 21:07

@BluebellsGreenbells

I’m questioning where the £3,000 needed is spent?
Really?
romdowa · 10/09/2021 21:06

Yes they should have to pay maintance to the state. Just like any non resident parent. Should be deducted from source of they refuse to pay.

Milkshake54 · 10/09/2021 21:06

If being removed because of safeguarding issues and against the parents wishes - no.

If the parent is ASKING for their child (usually teenager) to be taken into care because they do not wish to parents them anymore - yes!

shoppingismydownfall · 10/09/2021 21:05

For those of you missing the point drastically...in the 90s social care means assessed parents AFTER their children we in the care of the LA. So a looked after child, not CIN, not CP.

Why not? Doesn't impact safeguarding the child.

OP posts:
TrainspottingWelsh · 10/09/2021 21:04

No. The parents with the means to pay are also more likely to have the money and education to fight ss.
Unfortunately I didn't even hit any serious radars with ss, let alone have the luck to be taken into care because my parents were lovely established middle class, and therefore marvellous in every way. Nowadays they wouldn't get away with that shit so easily, but even so, if parents like mine thought they might be forced to pay to have their public image disgraced they'd have more reason to cover up their behaviour.

PlanDeRaccordement · 10/09/2021 21:03

It’s not just abused/neglected children taken into care for safeguarding, it is also severely disabled children where the parents cannot care for them. So, no I don’t think the parents should be means tested for help from social care.

Similar to how adult children are not means tested for elder social care of their parents.

Only the actual recipient of social care should be means tested, and then only if they are an adult.

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/09/2021 21:02

If you work in that area you’ll know the threshold for a child to be taken into care is eye wateringly high, with parents facing extreme levels of challenge - I don’t know of a child removed from parents who could afford to pay the local authority towards that child’s care.

IVFdreams2021 · 10/09/2021 21:02

£3,000 is 'cheap'
Some children are in residential homes for £7-9000 per week!

gogohm · 10/09/2021 21:02

Where appropriate yes! My dd had 3 friends at college who were in care because their parents threw them out for being gay, in my opinion the parents should be charged for the housing and support they received, every penny (all families concerned were middle to higher earners). But I suspect they are quite unusual, it's not that richer people are better parents, it's just we buy in help

Simonjt · 10/09/2021 21:01

No, the priority should be the welfare of the child, not wasting both time and money trying to get a few quid from birth parents.