Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should parents contribute?

88 replies

shoppingismydownfall · 10/09/2021 20:44

I'm aware this may be a contraversial topic. I work in social care and see children brought into the care system from all backgrounds, from the extremely wealthy to extremely poor. I'm not debating the rights and wrongs of social workers here.

My Aibu is, if it costs the local authority on average £3,000 per week to look after that child, should parents be financially assessed to contribute towards their care?

OP posts:
DontBeAHaterDear · 10/09/2021 22:21

I understand that children from all sorts of backgrounds enter the care system for all sorts of reasons but really, how many children of wealthy parents do? Not because wealthy parents equal better parents but because I’m just surprised it happens enough that you are starting a debate whether the parents should contribute.

As it goes, I’m not sure that they should. Only because it’s something that could easily be exploited. Like others have said, some parents have to give up care of their children through no fault of their own, sometimes for good but sometimes on a temporary basis. They shouldn’t be penalised for doing the right thing in those circumstances and charging them for the care could make it harder for them to regain custody of their children if that is the end goal as it would deplete their funds a lot.

More money needs to be pumped into social care but shaking down already vulnerable people for the cash isn’t the answer.

Bizawit · 10/09/2021 22:13

@Disfordarkchocolate

I think it would lead to more abuse as people tried to avoid paying.
This . You need to think of the actual real life consequences and the potential impact on vulnerable children.
DingleyDel · 10/09/2021 22:09

Obviously not. The state has made the decision to remove the children against the parents wishes (I assume in the vast majority of cases). I’ve never heard anyone suggest prison stays should be means tested and those who can afford it should contribute. It would be similar in my mind.

DancingQueen85 · 10/09/2021 22:06

This is not something I'd every thought of before and I can see that it would be extremely difficult to implement but in principle I think yes they should contribute. My DC best friend is in foster care and their biological father is well off and I absolutely think he should be made to pay towards his children's upbringing

Pixxie7 · 10/09/2021 22:06

I see your point but surely not many parents willingly give up their children so that should be the priority. If they can contribute they should either via attachment to salary or via their benefits. However it has to be realistic and not leave the parent destitute, the problem is when you start charging in some cases it causes more problems than it solved.
What is really needed is to look at the reasons that so many children end up in care, which although not an expert I would suspect that poverty has a lot to do with it.

TrainspottingWelsh · 10/09/2021 22:04

@Whydidimarryhim that reasoning is exactly why dc with parents like mine weren't ever investigated properly. At least now when they are reported it's not an acceptable practice to assume wealthy parents can't possibly be abusive and dismiss concerns out of hand, but unfortunately a large portion of society do share the same blinkered view so many aren't reported in the first place.
Some parents do just need support, others might have been fit to parent with earlier intervention. And money will help/ prevent those situations. Other parents are just cunts and money makes no difference to whether you're a cunt, it just provides a smokescreen.

HerRoyalRisesAgain · 10/09/2021 22:03

It would cost the government more money trying to enforcement it.
The priority should be the children and ensuring their needs are met, not chasing parents who can't or won't be able to help.

jmh740 · 10/09/2021 22:00

I worked in a residential home 15 years ago 3k a week would have been on the cheap side then

CiaoForNiao · 10/09/2021 21:59

I think it's an interesting idea, but I can't see it actually working in real life.

toocold54 · 10/09/2021 21:56

I must be naive - why are people who are wealthy have children removed?

I think there are less wealthy children in care just because they can pay for a nanny, boarding school etc but it definitely happens still.
They could be sexually abused, physically or mentally abused etc still which money doesn’t help. The parent could suffer with severe MH issues. I’ve known a couple of children in care because their parents have an abusive partner and they won’t leave them so the child is removed.

Rolopolo8 · 10/09/2021 21:56

It's not that easy. I've known of a boy with severe autism and learning disabilities that was just left at the hospital by his parents.. They claimed they couldn't cope with him and withdrew from him, they signed away their parental responsibility to the local authority also and he was housed in a unit in the hospital until a bed became available in a LD unit.
I can't judge as I obviously don't know how hard it is to look after a child with severe autism and learning disabilities as I've never encountered it, I can imagine it's very very hard and the parents must've been torn. In those instances, you couldn't expect parents to contribute if they purposely withdraw from their children. It's very, very sad.

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 10/09/2021 21:54

The law already allows for this - Children Act 1989, Schedule 2, Part 3. And for services to children in need.

1)Where a local authority are looking after a child (other than in the cases mentioned in sub-paragraph (7)) they shall consider whether they should recover contributions towards the child’s maintenance from any person liable to contribute (“a contributor").

(2)An authority may only recover contributions from a contributor if they consider it reasonable to do so.

(3)The persons liable to contribute are—

(a)where the child is under sixteen, each of his parents;

(b)where he has reached the age of sixteen, the child himself.

(4)A parent is not liable to contribute during any period when he is in receipt [F54 of universal credit (except in such circumstances as may be prescribed), ] of income support [F55under][F56Part VII of the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992,][F57 of any element of child tax credit other than the family element, of working tax credit][F58[F59, of an income-based jobseeker's allowance or of an income-related employment and support allowance]].

00100001 · 10/09/2021 21:54

@Whydidimarryhim

I must be naive - why are people who are wealthy have children removed? Im only used to hearing about deprivation and I link that to poverty and addiction issues - parents who have been traumatised themselves and therefore don’t know how to parent. I probably would have been placed in care but I was born in 1964 so the social services didn’t exist in the way they do now. My parents where on benefits. My father an abusive alcoholic. He had other priorities and social services would have struggled to get anything from him.
Because having a million pounds in your bank account, a 5 bed house in London, a yacht, go skiing in the Alps, send your child to the top independent schools and a holiday home in Antibes doesn't mean you can't abuse and/or neglect your child.
Iworkedhardforwhatihave · 10/09/2021 21:49

Because I would have thought the % of parents who can pay any significant amount towards the cost is minuscule?

toocold54 · 10/09/2021 21:49

I’m theory yes they should contribute but would it lead to parents who would usually ask for their child to go into care not asking for help and then things getting even worse.

00100001 · 10/09/2021 21:48

@drpet49

* Parents should be made to. You choose to have kids, if you choose then not to look after them, you should be made to pay as much as you can.*

^I agree

Not everyone chooses to have kids.
00100001 · 10/09/2021 21:47

@Iworkedhardforwhatihave

What % of children in care come from high earning families?
What does it matter?
x2boys · 10/09/2021 21:45

In what context, i have a disabled child, if his needs and education could only be met in secure residential school (as a friend of mine is going through with her child now) should i be assessed in these cases, putting your child into care is a very emotional decision and made in the childs best interests

Sunndown · 10/09/2021 21:43

This could lead to more child deaths, couldn't it?

Sleepyblueocean · 10/09/2021 21:43

Parents can be charged for some types of care arrangements. I am suprised you don't know that.

TaysteesGal · 10/09/2021 21:43

I'm a social worker - people commenting on this thread saying parents should pay clearly have no idea of the actual real circumstances of children coming into care and the cycles in place that lead to that happening.

Simonjt · 10/09/2021 21:42

@Whydidimarryhim

I must be naive - why are people who are wealthy have children removed? Im only used to hearing about deprivation and I link that to poverty and addiction issues - parents who have been traumatised themselves and therefore don’t know how to parent. I probably would have been placed in care but I was born in 1964 so the social services didn’t exist in the way they do now. My parents where on benefits. My father an abusive alcoholic. He had other priorities and social services would have struggled to get anything from him.
Being wealthy doesn’t mean its okay to abuse or neglect your child.
SunbathingDragon · 10/09/2021 21:40

@Whydidimarryhim

I must be naive - why are people who are wealthy have children removed? Im only used to hearing about deprivation and I link that to poverty and addiction issues - parents who have been traumatised themselves and therefore don’t know how to parent. I probably would have been placed in care but I was born in 1964 so the social services didn’t exist in the way they do now. My parents where on benefits. My father an abusive alcoholic. He had other priorities and social services would have struggled to get anything from him.
Abusive families or those with addictions or health conditions can be wealthy.
LizzieBet14 · 10/09/2021 21:36

The money that is being spent on my CIN children for the last 18 months is a total waste of tax payer's money...... 6 weekly meetings to hear that my DS still has 100% attendance, 100% punctuality, plenty of achievement points, no behaviour points, hands in all homework and represents the school at sports.
My DD still has ASD, anxiety, SPD and PDA and struggles to attend school......
Honestly, it's like they've started now so they'll have to 'see it through'....... they can't be seen to back down.
The stress it's caused is beyond belief. They couldn't care less. We've found no care in social care.....

Whydidimarryhim · 10/09/2021 21:36

I must be naive - why are people who are wealthy have children removed?
Im only used to hearing about deprivation and I link that to poverty and addiction issues - parents who have been traumatised themselves and therefore don’t know how to parent.
I probably would have been placed in care but I was born in 1964 so the social services didn’t exist in the way they do now.
My parents where on benefits. My father an abusive alcoholic. He had other priorities and social services would have struggled to get anything from him.